Appeals court keeps order blocking Trump administration from indiscriminate immigration sweeps
AP —
A federal appeals court ruled Friday night to uphold a lower court's temporary order blocking the Trump administration from conducting indiscriminate immigration stops and arrests in Southern California.
A three-judge panel of the Ninth US Circuit Court of Appeals held a hearing Monday afternoon at which the federal government asked the court to overturn a temporary restraining order issued July 12 by Judge Maame E. Frimpong, arguing it hindered their enforcement of immigration law.
Immigrant advocacy groups filed suit last month accusing President Donald Trump's administration of systematically targeting brown-skinned people in Southern California during the administration's crackdown on illegal immigration. The lawsuit included three detained immigrants and two U.S. citizens as plaintiffs.
In her order, Frimpong said there was a 'mountain of evidence' that federal immigration enforcement tactics were violating the Constitution. She wrote the government cannot use factors such as apparent race or ethnicity, speaking Spanish or English with an accent, presence at a location such as a tow yard or car wash, or someone's occupation as the only basis for reasonable suspicion to detain someone.
The Los Angeles region has been a battleground with the Trump administration over its aggressive immigration strategy that spurred protests and the deployment of the National Guards and Marines for several weeks. Federal agents have rounded up immigrants without legal status to be in the U.S. from Home Depots, car washes, bus stops, and farms, many who have lived in the country for decades.
Among the plaintiffs is Los Angeles resident Brian Gavidia, who was shown in a video taken by a friend June 13 being seized by federal agents as he yells, 'I was born here in the states, East LA bro!'
They want to 'send us back to a world where a US citizen … can be grabbed, slammed against a fence and have his phone and ID taken from him just because he was working at a tow yard in a Latino neighborhood,' American Civil Liberties Union attorney Mohammad Tajsar told the court.
People attend a rally and march in Oxnard, California, on July 11 after around 200 people were detained by federal officers during a raid at a cannabis farm in nearby Camarillo.The federal government argued that it hadn't been given enough time to collect and present evidence in the lawsuit, given that it was filed shortly before the July 4 holiday and a hearing was held the following week.
'It's a very serious thing to say that multiple federal government agencies have a policy of violating the Constitution,' attorney Jacob Roth said.
He also argued that the lower court's order was too broad, and that immigrant advocates did not present enough evidence to prove that the government had an official policy of stopping people without reasonable suspicion.
He referred to the four factors of race, language, presence at a location, and occupation that were listed in the temporary restraining order, saying the court should not be able to ban the government from using them at all. He also argued that the order was unclear on what exactly is permissible under law.
'Legally, I think it's appropriate to use the factors for reasonable suspicion,' Roth said
The judges sharply questioned the government over their arguments.
'No one has suggested that you cannot consider these factors at all,' Judge Jennifer Sung said.
However, those factors alone only form a 'broad profile' and don't satisfy the reasonable suspicion standard to stop someone, she said.
Sung, a Biden appointee, said that in an area like Los Angeles, where Latinos make up as much as half the population, those factors 'cannot possibly weed out those who have undocumented status and those who have documented legal status.'
She also asked: 'What is the harm to being told not to do something that you claim you're already not doing?'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Egypt Independent
2 hours ago
- Egypt Independent
Trump administration sanctions major Iranian shipping network as it ramps up maximum pressure campaign
The Trump administration is targeting Iran's oil sales by sanctioning a vast shipping empire that is run by the son of a top political adviser to the country's Supreme Leader, ramping up pressure on Iran following the US strikes on Iran's nuclear sites last month. 'Today, Treasury is sanctioning more than 115 individuals, entities and vessels that make up a vast shipping empire controlled by Mohammed (Hossein) Shamkhani, the son of Ali Shamkhani, a top political advisor to the Supreme Leader,' Deputy Secretary of Treasury Michael Faulkender said. 'Hossein Shamkhani's network, which controls a significant portion of Iran's crude oil exports, has touch points around the world. It's a clear example of Iran's flagrant abuse of the international financial system, helping both the regime and Hossein Shamkhani himself generate billions of dollars.' US officials said the Hossein network enables global sales of Iranian and Russian crude oil most often sold to China and said the penalties are the most significant sanctions imposed on Iran in recent years. The move comes as President Donald Trump's special envoy Steve Witkoff has privately told people that pursuing Iran nuclear deal talks are no longer a short-term priority for the administration following the US strikes on Iran's nuclear sites, three sources familiar with the discussions said. Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the Trump administration will continue to impose a policy of maximum pressure on the Iranian regime 'until Iran accepts a deal that advances regional peace and stability and in which Iran forgoes all aspirations of a nuclear weapon.' 'Today's actions underscore our resolve to target those who enable Iran's illicit oil and petrochemical trade and to cut off the regime's means of funding its destabilizing activities,' Rubio said. Oil sale profits are a key source of revenue for the Iranian regime, which the Trump administration is seeking to drive down. At the beginning of the year the Iranians were exporting about 1.8 million barrels per day, and most recent US figures show that Iran is now exporting about 1.2 million barrels per day, a Treasury official said. During the height of the Trump administration's maximum pressure campaign during Trump's first term Iran was exporting hundreds of thousands of barrels a day, the official said. Following the US strikes on Iran's nuclear sites, the US worked actively behind the scenes through intermediaries to re-start nuclear talks with Iran, CNN reported. But those talks have never been rescheduled, and efforts to re-engage have been put on the back burner. 'They would like to talk. I'm in no rush to talk because we obliterated their site,' Trump said in July. In some conversations Witkoff has asserted that key infrastructure at the three sites targeted by US airstrikes was destroyed and it would take Iran ten years to be able to begin enriching uranium again, one of the sources said. That assessment from Trump's top envoy appears inconsistent with the Pentagon saying that intelligence indicated that the program itself had been setback 'one to two years.' CNN has reached out to Witkoff's office for comment. Different US officials have also given their counterparts different assessments as to how long it could take Iran to begin enriching again in the weeks since those US strikes last month, ranging between three and ten years, sources said.
Egypt Independent
3 hours ago
- Egypt Independent
Inside Laura Loomer's hunt for disloyalty in Trump's government — and where she's looking next
Laura Loomer, the controversial far-right activist with a direct line to President Donald Trump, has taken credit for a slew of recent high-profile administration firings. But she sounds more exasperated than triumphant. In an interview with CNN last week, the Trump confidante touted her role in ousting the country's chief vaccine regulator, a senior national security lawyer and a decorated cybersecurity expert tapped for a post at West Point. It was a remarkable display of influence for someone with no formal government experience and whose online antics once resulted in a ban by social media companies. She said it's not nearly enough — and she's grown frustrated with White House officials ignoring her offers to help vet candidates. 'If I have to do it on the outside because of internal resistance, then so be it,' Loomer said in a phone call. Armed with more than 1.7 million followers on X and Trump's cell phone number, Loomer has taken on the self-appointed role of 'loyalty enforcer,' scrutinizing the backgrounds of various administration officials for any inkling they once harbored doubts about the president. She then amplifies her findings online, keeping up the drumbeat until White House officials — many of whom see her overtures as doing more harm than good — can no longer ignore it. 'She's a loose cannon,' said one Trump adviser who shares that view and was granted anonymity to speak candidly. 'But she has a following. It is what it is.' Inside the administration, recent episodes have only reinforced the growing perception that Loomer, despite aides' best efforts to limit her access within the White House, is nevertheless finding increasing success in influencing its decision-making from the outside. Her influence underscores the persistent personnel challenges, internal conflicts and frequent dismissals that have come to define the Trump administration since he first stepped foot in the White House. Trump, who values loyalty above all else, publicly praised Loomer's efforts on Sunday, describing her as a 'patriot.' Loomer sees disloyal operatives scattered throughout the administration, Cabinet officials misleading the MAGA faithful and a president who has yet to deliver on promises of retribution from his campaign. 'I'm not blaming Trump, but people will probably start to blame Trump if he doesn't use these opportunities to fire some Cabinet members,' she said. In a statement to CNN, White House spokesman Kush Desai did not engage on Loomer specifically, but asserted Trump 'has assembled the best and brightest talent to put Americans and America First.' 'It is not only appropriate, but critical for the Administration to recruit the most qualified and experienced staffers who are totally aligned with President Trump's agenda to Make America Great Again,' Desai said. Next targets Attorney General Pam Bondi may sit at the top of her blacklist — Loomer has publicly called for her firing several times — but she's not alone. Loomer also has doubts about Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins, blaming her for Trump's softer tone of late toward undocumented farm workers. And Loomer has turned her sizable megaphone against people now working at the Department of Health and Human Services under Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a former Democrat whose alliance with Trump remains a source of her skepticism. Neither Bondi, Rollins nor Kennedy appear in immediate danger of becoming Loomer's next victims; Trump has expressed support for all three. Loomer said they have not reached out to her about her concerns, despite her ongoing efforts to dig up dirt on their hires. But one embattled Cabinet head has: Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. Loomer said she recently spoke with Hegseth, whom she's known for a decade, about her work finding disloyal employees within the Pentagon. Defense Department spokesman Sean Parnell confirmed the two spoke, telling CNN in a statement that Hegseth 'appreciates Laura Loomer's outside advocacy.' US Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth waits for the arrival of Indian Minister of External Affairs Subrahmanyam Jaishankar during an Honor Cordon at the Pentagon on July 1, in Arlington, Virginia.'Personnel is policy, and Laura has taken that motto to heart,' Parnell said, adding: 'Qualified individuals who love our country and support the Administration's priorities will continue to be integral to our efforts.' Loomer has presented three more targets to her audience: Miami Republican Rep. Carlos Gimenez, whom she sparred with online, US Ambassador to Turkey Tom Barrack, due to his sprawling overseas businesses; and Trump's nominee to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, David LaCerte, over his legal work for big banks. The anatomy of getting 'Loomered' The recent ouster of a top public health official served as a window into how she pushes to oust Trump administration officials — what has become known in Washington as getting 'Loomered.' On July 20, Loomer began a relentless campaign against Vinay Prasad, the head of the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research at the US Food and Drug Administration, over his handling of key drug approvals and a series of years-old tweets expressing support for Democratic politicians and policies, claiming it was proof he was a 'leftist saboteur.' Within hours of posting her research online, Loomer sent it to the White House, she told CNN. A week later, Loomer unearthed audio of Prasad from a 2021 podcast where he joked he had stabbed a voodoo doll of Trump, along with other disparaging remarks about the president. Loomer said she sent the clip to Sergio Gor, the director of White House personnel. Prasad has not disputed the authenticity of the audio. Loomer's posts ricocheted quickly among Trump allies and heightened scrutiny of Prasad inside the administration. On day 10 of her crusade, the White House decided it'd had enough. Loomer is seen on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC, on June 5. Greg Kahn/The New York Times/Redux White House chief of staff Susie Wiles told FDA Commissioner Marty Makary on Tuesday that he needed to let go of Prasad, his chief science officer and close confidant, putting an abrupt end to his tenure after less than three months, two people familiar with the matter said. Wiles and other top aides had determined that the Loomer-led campaign risked mushrooming into yet another distraction for the White House, those two people said. The sense was they needed to contain it before Trump faced the press after returning from a trip to Scotland. 'They knew that [Trump] was going to have to deal with this,' said one of the people familiar with the matter. 'So they made the decision to take him out.' The departure came over the objections of Makary and Kennedy, who had vehemently defended Prasad — a controversial figure in health circles handpicked for his willingness to overhaul the nation's vaccine protocols — to White House officials, lawmakers and other Trump allies in recent days, the two people familiar and a third person briefed on the matter said. The decision so significantly dismayed Kennedy and Makary that, even after Prasad's departure, they discussed enlisting Medicare and Medicaid chief Mehmet Oz — a longtime friend of Trump — to corner the president at a Wednesday health event and press him to reverse course, one of the people familiar with the matter said. But that plan was rendered moot once Prasad's ouster went public the night before. 'I understand the paranoia and the desire to root out bad people even if it involves taking out some good people,' one of the people familiar with the matter said. 'But it's just true: Laura Loomer fired the head drug regulator for the United States.' HHS spokesman Rich Danker said in a statement to CNN that 'the FDA informed the White House on Tuesday that Dr. Prasad had stepped down.' He did not respond to several questions seeking to verify the above details. Prasad could not be reached for comment. Other supporters of Prasad used their own online platforms to accuse Loomer of working in concert with the pharmaceutical industry and others who objected to FDA decisions he'd overseen on rare drugs. Loomer denied to CNN that she was working with Prasad's other detractors. She said her concerns about Prasad grew out of the FDA's decision earlier this year to approve a new Covid-19 vaccine manufactured by Novavax. (It later emerged that Prasad had objected to the FDA's decision and had overridden the agency's experts to recommend against the broad use of two other Covid-19 vaccines.) 'I don't trust anybody' Loomer's inflammatory rhetoric toward Muslims and promotion of conspiracy theories have made her a controversial figure in Trump's orbit for years, and his advisers have long attempted to minimize her interactions with the president. She has said aides repeatedly step in to block her when Trump has attempted to hire her over the years. A self-described investigative journalist, Loomer has also pushed for a White House press credential, to no avail. In this September 2024 photo, Laura Loomer arrives at Philadelphia International Airport on The Trump Organization's Boeing who runs a small team of researchers, argued she would be more effective if the White House let her oversee hiring from the inside. She said that lately she's become inundated with tips, including from within the administration, about certain staffers. She said she vets them all. 'Aren't they supposed to know these people are a problem before Susie has to waste her time dealing with this lack of vetting?' Loomer said. Prasad is just the latest of a growing collection of government officials to get 'Loomered.' In the administration's first six months, Loomer has claimed credit for helping spur the removal of several staffers at the White House and elsewhere in government, including a string of firings at the National Security Agency and on the National Security Council in early April that followed a phone call and an Oval Office meeting with Trump. Amid the fallout, national security adviser Michael Waltz, a regular target of Loomer's attacks, was pushed out of that position as well. Just days before Prasad's ouster, the NSA removed another top official, general counsel April Falcon Doss, after Loomer amplified a report criticizing Doss for previously working for the Senate Intelligence Committee's Democratic staff. On Wednesday, she celebrated after Trump's Army secretary ordered the US Military Academy at West Point to rescind its appointment of Biden-era cyber defense official Jen Easterly as a distinguished chair. Loomer had recently taken aim at Easterly on X, singling her out in a post that alleged without evidence that 'there are some serious moles' at the Department of Defense. Very few have demonstrated such unflinching loyalty to Trump as Loomer. With thousands of jobs to fill across Trump's administration, she concedes that some appointees will inevitably have what she considers checkered records, including past criticism of the president. Some of the most prominent figures in Trump's administration — Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, for example — were once harsh Trump detractors. She said the concerns she is raising about certain hires go beyond ideological disagreements. Rubio and Vance, she noted, have publicly made amends and earned back favor with Trump and his supporters. Still, that doesn't mean they're immune from future scrutiny. 'I don't trust anybody. I'm not friends with anybody,' Loomer said. 'That's why I have four dogs.'
Al-Ahram Weekly
4 hours ago
- Al-Ahram Weekly
Former Israeli security officials urge Trump to compel Netanyahu to end Gaza war - War on Gaza
A group of over 600 former Israeli security officials urged US President Donald Trump to compel Benjamin Netanyahu's government to end the war in Gaza, The Jerusalem Post reported. The group comprises former generals from the army and equivalents from Mossad, Shin Bet, the police, and the diplomatic corps. In an open letter shared later with the media on Monday, the group, known as Commanders for Israel's Security (CIS), asserted their professional judgment that Hamas no longer represents a strategic threat to Israel. Thereby, they urged Trump to "steer" Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu towards ending the war in Gaza. 'Stop the Gaza War! ... We urge you to end the Gaza war. You did it in Lebanon. Time to do it in Gaza as well," the CIS directly appealed to Trump. The group contends that Israel has already achieved its core military objectives. "The army has long accomplished the two objectives that could be achieved by force: dismantling Hamas' military formations and governance," it stated. They emphasized that the "third, and most important, can only be achieved through a deal: bringing all hostages home.' This is not the first time the CIS has pressed for a shift in the government's policy. However, their latest intervention underscores the escalating international pressure on Israel regarding its acts in Gaza and the humanitarian crisis there, particularly given Trump's recent criticisms of Israel for causing starvation in Gaza, as reported by The Jerusalem Post. 'It is our professional judgment that Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel. Chasing remaining senior Hamas operatives can be done later. Our hostages can't wait,' the group said. The former officials believe Trump's unique standing with the Israeli populace gives him significant leverage. 'Your credibility with the vast majority of Israelis augments your ability to steer Prime Minister Netanyahu and his government in the right direction: End the war, return the hostages, stop the suffering, and forge a regional-international coalition that helps the Palestinian Authority (once reformed) to offer Gazans and all Palestinians an alternative to Hamas,' the letter read. The CIS proposed that Israel must announce its acceptance of an end to the war in exchange for the return of all remaining captives, a consistent offer by Hamas since the war started. Additionally, they urged Israel to accept the proposed international framework of Egypt, the UAE, and Saudi Arabia, together with a reformed Palestinian Authority (PA), taking over the running of post-war Gaza. The CIS expressed hope that Trump will press Netanyahu to make such an offer despite the Israeli premier's repeated rejection of this position, trying to keep his hard-right coalition partners from toppling his government if he ends the war. According to JPOST, the CIS had successfully influenced the Biden administration's policy in the past, and previously, the Netanyahu government's policies. "At first this war was a just war, a defensive war, but when we achieved all military objectives, this war ceased to be a just war," said Ami Ayalon, former director of the Shin Bet security service. The war, nearing its 23rd month, "is leading the State of Israel to lose its security and identity," Ayalon warned in a video released to accompany the letter. On 18 March, the Netanyahu government unilaterally broke a ceasefire agreement brokered in January by Egypt, Qatar, and the United States, resuming its genocidal war on Gaza. The renewed assault has killed thousands and left scores of Palestinian civilians wounded. Israel violated the truce after insisting on extending the first phase of the agreement and refusing to enter the second phase, which included more substantive steps toward ending the war. In recent weeks, Israel has faced mounting international pressure over its genocidal campaign in Gaza and a continued blockade that has plunged the strip into mass starvation. Since the war began in October 2023, the Israeli army has killed more than 60,400 Palestinians. At least 1,400 of them were targeted near US- and Israeli-backed aid distribution centres. Israel's engineered famine has killed more than 170 Palestinians in Gaza, including 93 children, according to health authorities. Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link:
