AI-generated Pope sermons flood YouTube, TikTok
AI-generated videos and audios of Pope Leo XIV are populating rapidly online, racking up views as platforms struggle to police them.
An AFP investigation identified dozens of YouTube and TikTok pages that have been churning out AI-generated messages delivered in the pope's voice or otherwise attributed to him since he took charge of the Catholic Church last month.
The hundreds of fabricated sermons and speeches, in English and Spanish, underscore how easily hoaxes created using artificial intelligence can elude detection and dupe viewers.
"There's natural interest in what the new pope has to say, and people don't yet know his stance and style," said University of Washington professor emeritus Oren Etzioni, founder of TrueMedia.org, a nonprofit focused on fighting deepfakes.
"A perfect opportunity to sow mischief with AI-generated misinformation."
After AFP presented YouTube with 26 channels posting predominantly AI-generated pope content, the platform terminated 16 of them for violating its policies against spam, deceptive practices and scams, and another for violating YouTube's terms of service.
"We terminated several channels flagged to us by AFP for violating our Spam policies and Terms of Service," spokesperson Jack Malon said.
The company also booted an additional six pages from its partner program allowing creators to monetize their content.
TikTok similarly removed 11 accounts that AFP pointed out -- with over 1.3 million combined followers -- citing the platform's policies against impersonation, harmful misinformation and misleading AI-generated content of public figures.
- 'Chaotic uses' -
With names such as "Pope Leo XIV Vision," the social media pages portrayed the pontiff supposedly offering a flurry of warnings and lessons he never preached.
But disclaimers annotating their use of AI were often hard to find -- and sometimes nonexistent.
On YouTube, a label demarcating "altered or synthetic content" is required for material that makes someone appear to say something they did not. But such disclosures only show up toward the bottom of each video's click-to-open description.
A YouTube spokesperson said the company has since applied a more prominent label to some videos on the channels flagged by AFP that were not found to have violated the platform's guidelines.
TikTok also requires creators to label posts sharing realistic AI-generated content, though several pope-centric videos went unmarked.
A TikTok spokesperson said the company proactively removes policy-violating content and uses verified badges to signal authentic accounts.
Brian Patrick Green, director of technology ethics at Santa Clara University, said the moderation difficulties are the result of rapid AI developments inspiring "chaotic uses of the technology."
Many clips on the YouTube channels AFP identified amassed tens of thousands of views before being deactivated.
On TikTok, one Spanish-language video received 9.6 million views while claiming to show Leo preaching about the value of supportive women. Another, which carried an AI label but still fooled viewers, was watched some 32.9 million times.
No video on the pope's official Instagram page has more than 6 million views.
Experts say even seemingly harmless fakes can be problematic especially if used to farm engagement for accounts that might later sell their audiences or pivot to other misinformation.
The AI-generated sermons not only "corrode the pope's moral authority" and "make whatever he actually says less believable," Green said, but could be harnessed "to build up trust around your channel before having the pope say something outrageous or politically expedient."
The pope himself has also warned about the risks of AI, while Vatican News called out a deepfake that purported to show Leo praising Burkina Faso leader Ibrahim Traore, who seized power in a 2022 coup.
AFP also debunked clips depicting the pope, who holds American and Peruvian citizenships, criticizing US Vice President JD Vance and Peru's President Dina Boluarte.
"There's a real crisis here," Green said. "We're going to have to figure out some way to know whether things are real or fake."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
3 hours ago
- The Age
‘She just conjured electricity': Celebrating Divinyls legend Chrissy Amphlett
Before Madonna talked sex and sexuality on stage, a working-class girl on the other side of the globe was shocking audiences with her fierce and powerful performances. Chrissy Amphlett was unlike anything Australians had seen when she burst on the stage in 1980 as lead singer of Divinyls. Without her it's hard to imagine Amy Taylor from Amyl & the Sniffers, or Amphlett's fellow Geelong-born rocker Adalita. A new show opening next week called Amplified showcases the work of the late artist – Amphlett died from breast cancer in 2013, aged just 53 – as well as her extraordinary impact and legacy. Making the work has been a wonderful process, says Sheridan Harbridge, who stars in the show, and co-created it with acclaimed director Sarah Goodes and musical director Glenn Moorhouse (Hedwig and the Angry Inch). Trawling through YouTube and watching old performances by the Divinyls and Amphlett solo, Harbridge says there are hundreds of comments from people writing things such as 'I saw them at the Crystal Ballroom and it was the most amazing thing I've ever seen'. 'And then women saying, 'I'd never seen a woman act like that and I didn't know you could',' the actor-singer-writer says, adding that 'equally for men, they were watching something quite electric'. 'I spoke to someone who worked with her and they said, 'she just conjured electricity'.' Raised in a Pentecostal Christian family in Gippsland, Harbridge wasn't allowed to watch shows like The Simpsons and The Golden Girls, but thankfully her mum didn't know what Rage was, so that was where she first came across Amphlett.
Sydney Morning Herald
3 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
‘She just conjured electricity': Celebrating Divinyls legend Chrissy Amphlett
Before Madonna talked sex and sexuality on stage, a working-class girl on the other side of the globe was shocking audiences with her fierce and powerful performances. Chrissy Amphlett was unlike anything Australians had seen when she burst on the stage in 1980 as lead singer of Divinyls. Without her it's hard to imagine Amy Taylor from Amyl & the Sniffers, or Amphlett's fellow Geelong-born rocker Adalita. A new show opening next week called Amplified showcases the work of the late artist – Amphlett died from breast cancer in 2013, aged just 53 – as well as her extraordinary impact and legacy. Making the work has been a wonderful process, says Sheridan Harbridge, who stars in the show, and co-created it with acclaimed director Sarah Goodes and musical director Glenn Moorhouse (Hedwig and the Angry Inch). Trawling through YouTube and watching old performances by the Divinyls and Amphlett solo, Harbridge says there are hundreds of comments from people writing things such as 'I saw them at the Crystal Ballroom and it was the most amazing thing I've ever seen'. 'And then women saying, 'I'd never seen a woman act like that and I didn't know you could',' the actor-singer-writer says, adding that 'equally for men, they were watching something quite electric'. 'I spoke to someone who worked with her and they said, 'she just conjured electricity'.' Raised in a Pentecostal Christian family in Gippsland, Harbridge wasn't allowed to watch shows like The Simpsons and The Golden Girls, but thankfully her mum didn't know what Rage was, so that was where she first came across Amphlett.
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
The rise, fall and potential rise again of countercultural brand Dr Martens
When the Allied victory was announced in 1945, Germans took the streets in droves. Soldiers and civilians alike took to shops, museums and government buildings to loot, searching for Nazi memorabilia, money and food in the wake of their country's defeat. One man, Dr Klaus Maerten, declined to participate. Instead, he walked into a shoemaker and asked to buy some leather. For 60 years Dr Maerten's creation became a countercultural symbol. But in 2025, its latest financial forecast shows it could become victim of the very market forces its wearers aimed to subvert. Dr Klaus Maerten was a 25-year-old army doctor for Nazi Germany when he came up with the idea of an air-cushioned sole shoe to help him recover from a skiing injury. He used parts of a car tyre to cushion the inside of his army boots, and went on to sell his shoes primarily to German housewives over 40 to wear while gardening. By 1959, the business of Dr Martens was booming and an English family took notice. The Griggs family, who were established in the footwear business and locals of Wollaston in the English Midlands — came across the "air-cushioned soles" in a German magazine. They bought an exclusive licence to the shoe, made their own tweaks — including the distinctive yellow stitching — and aimed their new product at factory workers and miners for £2. But one young musician would later change their trajectory forever. Pete Townshend was a guitarist for a band named the Who when he walked into the Griggs family's West Midlands store. He bought a pair of 1460 boots, and later wore them on stage in 1967 as a symbol of his own working class pride. According to the brand, the boots exploded in popularity from there. The punk subculture was emerging and they adopted the boots as an "anti-fashion" statement, as did Elton John, the Clash and the Sex Pistols. However the boots' popularity also crossed over with many of the early British skinhead groups. Skinhead groups were also known to adhere to racist, homophobic and fascist ideologies, whereas the punk subculture was synonymous with movements advocating anarchism, anti-fascism, and communism. "Without any warning or intent, Dr Martens were suddenly picked up by early multicultural, ska-loving skinheads — who proudly championed British working class style," the brand said. The alarm bells for Dr Martens started sounding as early as 2020. Over the years it adapted to market pressure by moving some of its manufacturing to China, Vietnam, Laos and Thailand — countries that would keenly feel the sting of the COVID-19 pandemic. The brand issued its first profit warning in November 2022, although then-chief executive Kenny Wilson said he was confident the lead up to Christmas could help resolve their woes. "Going into the winter season, we see people buying more of our iconic boots," he said. But it was soon clear the brand was in for protracted pain. By November 2023, the company had issued its fourth profit warning as pre-tax profits fell by 55 per cent. Mr Wilson again put the falling figure down to market forces outside the brand's control, including the rising cost of living. "Virtually all of the big footwear and apparel brands have had difficult numbers," Mr Wilson said. A year later, Kenny Wilson was gone. He was replaced with Ije Nwokorie, who spent the next two years attempting to claw back some of the business's tumbling share price. In last year's financial report, Mr Nwokorie said he was steadily turning things around. "We have made good progress against our objective of turning around our USA performance," he said. "We continue to actively manage our costs and are on track to meet our inventory reduction target for [the 2025 financial year]. "The team and I are squarely focused on returning the business to sustainable and profitable growth." Six months later, Dr Martens shares fell to an all-time low. The US tariff announcement tanked the business's shares, which had begun to plateau following better sales in America and the Asia Pacific. On Friday, the company revealed the extent President Donald Trump's trade war, the cost of living, the prevalence of fast fashion brands and even the threat of climate change had impacted the brand. Its reported revenue for the 2024/25 financial year was £787.6 million ($1.64 billion), down from £877.1 million the year before. The report said while the £89.5 million loss was felt, it was actually in keeping with what the company had forecasted the year prior. The report said the drop was expected to happen due to "a challenging macroeconomic and consumer backdrop in several of our core markets". Despite anticipation profits would likely suffer in the US due to Mr Trump's tariffs against many countries in Asia, US sales increased. "While the USA is an important market for us, we are a truly global brand that is sold in more than 60 countries around the world," the report said. "We do however recognise that there is continued macroeconomic uncertainty and the full outcome of tariffs is still unknown, and we will monitor this closely through the year and take action as appropriate." The brand said it was also able to save about £25 million in costs, which would go toward a better result next year. As a result, it said it would not be increasing prices on its products. The report said while it was anticipating its first return to profit in years, the brand had to be cautious about predicting the next 12 months. "I am laser-focused on day-to-day execution, managing costs and maintaining our operational discipline while we navigate the current macroeconomic uncertainties," Mr Nwokorie said. "This, combined with the enduring demand for our products, the robustness of our operations, the strength of our cashflow generation and balance sheet and the expertise of our people, gives me confidence that we will deliver the sustainable, profitable growth that this brand is capable of."
