Latest news with #OrenEtzioni
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Health
- Yahoo
White House MAHA Report may have garbled science by using AI, experts say
Some of the citations that underpin the science in the White House's sweeping 'MAHA Report' appear to have been generated using artificial intelligence, resulting in numerous garbled scientific references and invented studies, AI experts said Thursday. Of the 522 footnotes to scientific research in an initial version of the report sent to The Washington Post, at least 37 appear multiple times, according to a review of the report by The Washington Post. Other citations include the wrong author, and several studies cited by the extensive health report do not exist at all, a fact first reported by the online news outlet NOTUS on Thursday morning. Subscribe to The Post Most newsletter for the most important and interesting stories from The Washington Post. Some references include 'oaicite' attached to URLs - a definitive sign that the research was collected using artificial intelligence. The presence of 'oaicite' is a marker indicating use of OpenAI, a U.S. artificial intelligence company. A common hallmark of AI chatbots, such as ChatGPT, is unusually repetitive content that does not sound human or is inaccurate -as well as the tendency to 'hallucinate' studies or answers that appear to make sense but are not real. AI technology can be used legitimately to quickly survey the research in a field. But Oren Etzioni, a professor emeritus at the University of Washington who studies AI, said he was shocked by the sloppiness in the MAHA Report. 'Frankly, that's shoddy work,' he said. 'We deserve better.' 'The MAHA Report: Making Our Children Healthy Again,' which addressed the root causes of America's lagging health outcomes, was written by a commission of Cabinet officials and government scientific leaders. It was led by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who has a history of misstating science, and written in response to an executive order from President Donald Trump. It blames exposure to environmental toxins, poor nutrition and increased screen time for a decline in Americans' life expectancy. One reference in the initial version of the report cited a study entitled 'Overprescribing of Oral Corticosteroids for Children With Asthma' to buttress the idea that children are over-medicated. But that study didn't appear to exist. There is a similar Pediatrics article from 2017 with the same first author but different co-authors. Later Thursday, that Pediatrics article was swapped in for the apparently nonexistent study in the version of the report available online. An article credited to U.S. News & World Report about children's recess and exercise time was initially cited twice to support claims of declining physical activity among U.S. children, once with only part of the link shown. It listed Mlynek, A. and Spiegel, S. as different authors. Neither referred to Kate Rix, who wrote the story. Neither Mlynek nor Spiegel appear to be actual reporters for the publication. As of Thursday evening, Rix had been swapped in as the author on one of the references in the version of the report available online. Nearly half of the 522 citations in the initial version of the report included links to articles or studies. But a Post analysis of all the report's references found that at least 21 of those links were dead. Former governor and current New York City mayoral front-runner Andrew Cuomo was caught up in controversy last month after a housing policy report he issued used ChatGPT and garbled a reference. Attorneys have faced sanctions for using nonexistent case citations created by ChatGPT in legal briefs. The garbled scientific citations betray subpar science and undermine the credibility of the report, said Georges C. Benjamin, executive director of the American Public Health Association. 'This is not an evidence-based report, and for all practical purposes, it should be junked at this point,' he said. 'It cannot be used for any policymaking. It cannot even be used for any serious discussion, because you can't believe what's in it.' When asked about the nonexistent citations at a news briefing Thursday, press secretary Karoline Leavitt said the White House has 'complete confidence in Secretary Kennedy and his team at HHS.' 'I understand there were some formatting issues with the MAHA Report that are being addressed, and the report will be updated, but it does not negate the substance of the report, which, as you know, is one of the most transformative health reports that has ever been released by the federal government, and is backed on good science that has never been recognized by the federal government,' Leavitt said. At some point between 1 and 2:30 p.m. Eastern on Thursday, the MAHA Report file was updated on the White House site to remove mentions of 'corrected hyperlinks' and one of the 'oaicite' markers. Another 'oaicite' marker, attached to a New York Times Wirecutter story about baby formula, was still present in the document until it was removed Thursday evening. The White House continued to update the report into the night. Department of Health and Human Services spokesman Andrew Nixon said that 'minor citation and formatting errors have been corrected, but the substance of the MAHA report remains the same - a historic and transformative assessment by the federal government to understand the chronic disease epidemic afflicting our nation's children.' 'Under President Trump and Secretary Kennedy, our federal government is no longer ignoring this crisis, and it's time for the media to also focus on what matters,' Nixon said. Kennedy has long vowed to use AI to make America's health care better and more efficient, recently stating in a congressional hearing that he had even seen an AI nurse prototype 'that could revolutionize health delivery in rural areas.' Peter Lurie, president of the nonprofit Center for Science in the Public Interest, said he was not surprised by the presence of possible AI markers in the report. Lurie said he had asked his own staff to look into it after noticing that the report linked to one of his organization's fact sheets but credited the Department of Agriculture and HHS as the authors. 'The idea that they would envelop themselves in the shroud of scientific excellence while producing a report that relies heavily on AI is just shockingly hypocritical,' said Lurie, who was a top Food and Drug Administration official in the Obama administration, where he wrote such government reports. There are many pitfalls in modern AI, which is 'happy to make up citations,' said Steven Piantadosi, a professor in psychology and neuroscience at the University of California at Berkeley. 'The problem with current AI is that it's not trustworthy, so it's just based on statistical associations and dependencies,' he said. 'It has no notion of ground truth, no notion of ... a rigorous logical or statistical argument. It has no notions of evidence and how strongly to weigh one kind of evidence versus another. ' The Post previously reported that the document stretched the boundaries of science with some of its conclusions. Several sections offer misleading representations of findings in scientific papers. Related Content Harvard celebrates graduation in the shadow of its fight with Trump Columbia protester Mahmoud Khalil's detention ruled likely unconstitutional Despite ceasefire, India and Pakistan are locked in a cultural cold war
Egypt Independent
16-02-2025
- Business
- Egypt Independent
The real reason behind the DeepSeek hype, according to AI experts
CNN — DeepSeek turned the tech world on its head last month – and for good reason, according to artificial intelligence experts, who say we're likely only seeing the beginning of the Chinese tech startup's influence on the AI field. DeepSeek grabbed headlines in late January with its R1 AI model, which the company says can roughly match the performance of Open AI's o1 model at a fraction of the cost. Tech stocks tumbled as DeepSeek briefly unseated ChatGPT to become the top app in Apple's App Store. The achievement pushed US tech behemoths to question America's standing in the AI race against China – and the billions of dollars behind those efforts. While Vice President JD Vance didn't mention DeepSeek or China by name in his remarks at the Artificial Intelligence Action Summit in Paris on Tuesday, he certainly emphasized how big of a priority it is for the United States to lead the sector. 'The United States of America is the leader in AI, and our administration plans to keep it that way,' he said, although he added that 'America wants to partner' with other countries. But it's not just DeepSeek's efficiency and power. The way DeepSeek R1 can reason and 'think' through answers to provide quality results, along with the company's decision to make key parts of its technology publicly available, will also push the field forward, experts say. While AI has long been used in tech products, it's reached a flashpoint over the last two years thanks to the rise of ChatGPT and other generative AI services that have reshaped the way people work, communicate and find information. It's made Wall Street darlings out of companies like chipmaker Nvidia and upended the trajectory of Silicon Valley giants. So any development that can help build more capable and efficient models is sure to be closely watched. 'This is definitely not hype,' said Oren Etzioni, former CEO of the Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence. 'But also, this is a very fast-moving world.' AI's TikTok moment Tech leaders have been quick to respond to DeepSeek's rise. Google DeepMind CEO Demis Hassabis called the hype around DeepSeek 'exaggerated , ' but also said its model as 'probably the best work I've seen come out of China,' according to CNBC. Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said on the company's quarterly earnings call in January that DeepSeek has some 'real innovations,' while Apple CEO Tim Cook said on the iPhone maker's earnings call that 'innovation that drives efficiency is a good thing.' But the attention hasn't all been positive. Semiconductor researcher SemiAnalysis cast doubt over DeepSeek's claims that it only cost $5.6 million to train. OpenAI told The Financial Times it found evidence that DeepSeek used the US company's models to train its own competitor. 'We are aware of and reviewing indications that DeepSeek may have inappropriately distilled our models, and will share information as we know more,' an OpenAI spokesperson said in a comment to CNN. DeepSeek could not immediately be reached for comment. And a pair of US lawmakers has already called for the app to be banned from government devices after security researchers highlighted its potential links to the Chinese government, as the Associated Press and ABC News reported. Similar concerns have been raised about the popular social media app TikTok, which must be sold to an American owner or risk being banned in the US. 'DeepSeek is the TikTok of (large language models),' Etzioni said. DeepSeek's deep impression on the tech world Tech giants are already thinking about how DeepSeek's technology can influence their products and services. 'What DeepSeek gave us was essentially the recipe in the form of a tech report, but they didn't give us the extra missing parts,' said Lewis Tunstall, a senior research scientist at Hugging Face, an AI platform that offers tools for developers. Tunstall is leading an effort at Hugging Face to fully open source DeepSeek's R1 model; while DeepSeek provided a research paper and the model's parameters, it didn't reveal the code or training data. Nadella said on Microsoft's earnings call that Windows Copilot+ PCs, or PCs built to a certain spec to support AI models, will be able to run AI models distilled from DeepSeek R1 locally. Mobile chipmaker Qualcomm said on Tuesday that models distilled from DeepSeek R1 were running on smartphones and PCs powered by its chips within a week. AI researchers, academics and developers are still exploring what DeepSeek means for the advancement of AI. DeepSeek's model isn't the only open-source one, nor is it the first to be able to reason over answers before responding; OpenAI's o1 model from last year can do that, too. What makes DeepSeek significant is the way it can reason and learn from other models, along with the fact that the AI community can see what's happening behind the scenes. Those who use the R1 model in DeepSeek's app can also see its 'thought' process as it answers questions. 'You can see the wheels turning inside the machine,' Durga Malladi, senior vice president and general manager for technology planning and edge solutions at Qualcomm, said to CNN. Tunstall thinks we may see a wave of new models that can reason like DeepSeek in the not-too-distant future. That could be critical as tech giants race to build AI agents, which Silicon Valley generally believes are the next evolution of the chatbot and how consumers will interact with devices – although that shift hasn't quite happened yet. Grok 3, the next iteration of the chatbot on the social media platform X, will have 'very powerful reasoning capabilities,' its owner, Elon Musk, said on Thursday in a video appearance during the World Governments Summit. For now, the AI community will keep tinkering with what DeepSeek has to offer. That is, until the next breakthrough comes along. 'I certainly predict that in the next 12 months, it'll be supplanted by something else,' said Etzioni. 'But it's a very real advance.'
CNN
14-02-2025
- Business
- CNN
The real hype behind DeepSeek, according to AI experts
DeepSeek turned the tech world on its head last month – and for good reason, according to artificial intelligence experts, who say we're likely only seeing the beginning of the Chinese tech startup's influence on the AI field. DeepSeek grabbed headlines in late January with its R1 AI model, which the company says can roughly match the performance of Open AI's o1 model at a fraction of the cost. Tech stocks tumbled as DeepSeek briefly unseated ChatGPT to become the top app in Apple's App Store. The achievement pushed US tech behemoths to question America's standing in the AI race against China – and the billions of dollars behind those efforts. While Vice President JD Vance didn't mention DeepSeek or China by name in his remarks at the Artificial Intelligence Action Summit in Paris on Tuesday, he certainly emphasized how big of a priority it is for the United States to lead the sector. 'The United States of America is the leader in AI, and our administration plans to keep it that way,' he said, although he added that 'America wants to partner' with other countries. But it's not just DeepSeek's efficiency and power. The way DeepSeek R1 can reason and 'think' through answers to provide quality results, along with the company's decision to make key parts of its technology publicly available, will also push the field forward, experts say. While AI has long been used in tech products, it's reached a flashpoint over the last two years thanks to the rise of ChatGPT and other generative AI services that have reshaped the way people work, communicate and find information. It's made Wall Street darlings out of companies like chipmaker Nvidia and upended the trajectory of Silicon Valley giants. So any development that can help build more capable and efficient models is sure to be closely watched. 'This is definitely not hype,' said Oren Etzioni, former CEO of the Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence. 'But also, this is a very fast-moving world.' Tech leaders have been quick to respond to DeepSeek's rise. Google DeepMind CEO Demis Hassabis called the hype around DeepSeek 'exaggerated,' but also said its model as 'probably the best work I've seen come out of China,' according to CNBC. Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said on the company's quarterly earnings call in January that DeepSeek has some 'real innovations,' while Apple CEO Tim Cook said on the iPhone maker's earnings call that 'innovation that drives efficiency is a good thing.' But the attention hasn't all been positive. Semiconductor researcher SemiAnalysis cast doubt over DeepSeek's claims that it only cost $5.6 million to train. OpenAI told The Financial Times it found evidence that DeepSeek used the US company's models to train its own competitor. 'We are aware of and reviewing indications that DeepSeek may have inappropriately distilled our models, and will share information as we know more,' an OpenAI spokesperson said in a comment to CNN. DeepSeek could not immediately be reached for comment. And a pair of US lawmakers has already called for the app to be banned from government devices after security researchers highlighted its potential links to the Chinese government, as the Associated Press and ABC News reported. Similar concerns have been raised about the popular social media app TikTok, which must be sold to an American owner or risk being banned in the US. 'DeepSeek is the TikTok of (large language models),' Etzioni said. Tech giants are already thinking about how DeepSeek's technology can influence their products and services. 'What DeepSeek gave us was essentially the recipe in the form of a tech report, but they didn't give us the extra missing parts,' said Lewis Tunstall, a senior research scientist at Hugging Face, an AI platform that offers tools for developers. Tunstall is leading an effort at Hugging Face to fully open source DeepSeek's R1 model; while DeepSeek provided a research paper and the model's parameters, it didn't reveal the code or training data. Nadella said on Microsoft's earnings call that Windows Copilot+ PCs, or PCs built to a certain spec to support AI models, will be able to run AI models distilled from DeepSeek R1 locally. Mobile chipmaker Qualcomm said on Tuesday that models distilled from DeepSeek R1 were running on smartphones and PCs powered by its chips within a week. AI researchers, academics and developers are still exploring what DeepSeek means for the advancement of AI. DeepSeek's model isn't the only open-source one, nor is it the first to be able to reason over answers before responding; OpenAI's o1 model from last year can do that, too. What makes DeepSeek significant is the way it can reason and learn from other models, along with the fact that the AI community can see what's happening behind the scenes. Those who use the R1 model in DeepSeek's app can also see its 'thought' process as it answers questions. 'You can see the wheels turning inside the machine,' Durga Malladi, senior vice president and general manager for technology planning and edge solutions at Qualcomm, said to CNN. Tunstall thinks we may see a wave of new models that can reason like DeepSeek in the not-too-distant future. That could be critical as tech giants race to build AI agents, which Silicon Valley generally believes are the next evolution of the chatbot and how consumers will interact with devices – although that shift hasn't quite happened yet. Grok 3, the next iteration of the chatbot on the social media platform X, will have 'very powerful reasoning capabilities,' its owner, Elon Musk, said on Thursday in a video appearance during the World Governments Summit. For now, the AI community will keep tinkering with what DeepSeek has to offer. That is, until the next breakthrough comes along. 'I certainly predict that in the next 12 months, it'll be supplanted by something else,' said Etzioni. 'But it's a very real advance.'
CNN
14-02-2025
- Business
- CNN
The real hype behind DeepSeek, according to AI experts
DeepSeek turned the tech world on its head last month – and for good reason, according to artificial intelligence experts, who say we're likely only seeing the beginning of the Chinese tech startup's influence on the AI field. DeepSeek grabbed headlines in late January with its R1 AI model, which the company says can roughly match the performance of Open AI's o1 model at a fraction of the cost. Tech stocks tumbled as DeepSeek briefly unseated ChatGPT to become the top app in Apple's App Store. The achievement pushed US tech behemoths to question America's standing in the AI race against China – and the billions of dollars behind those efforts. While Vice President JD Vance didn't mention DeepSeek or China by name in his remarks at the Artificial Intelligence Action Summit in Paris on Tuesday, he certainly emphasized how big of a priority it is for the United States to lead the sector. 'The United States of America is the leader in AI, and our administration plans to keep it that way,' he said, although he added that 'America wants to partner' with other countries. But it's not just DeepSeek's efficiency and power. The way DeepSeek R1 can reason and 'think' through answers to provide quality results, along with the company's decision to make key parts of its technology publicly available, will also push the field forward, experts say. While AI has long been used in tech products, it's reached a flashpoint over the last two years thanks to the rise of ChatGPT and other generative AI services that have reshaped the way people work, communicate and find information. It's made Wall Street darlings out of companies like chipmaker Nvidia and upended the trajectory of Silicon Valley giants. So any development that can help build more capable and efficient models is sure to be closely watched. 'This is definitely not hype,' said Oren Etzioni, former CEO of the Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence. 'But also, this is a very fast-moving world.' Tech leaders have been quick to respond to DeepSeek's rise. Google DeepMind CEO Demis Hassabis called the hype around DeepSeek 'exaggerated,' but also said its model as 'probably the best work I've seen come out of China,' according to CNBC. Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said on the company's quarterly earnings call in January that DeepSeek has some 'real innovations,' while Apple CEO Tim Cook said on the iPhone maker's earnings call that 'innovation that drives efficiency is a good thing.' But the attention hasn't all been positive. Semiconductor researcher SemiAnalysis cast doubt over DeepSeek's claims that it only cost $5.6 million to train. OpenAI told The Financial Times it found evidence that DeepSeek used the US company's models to train its own competitor. 'We are aware of and reviewing indications that DeepSeek may have inappropriately distilled our models, and will share information as we know more,' an OpenAI spokesperson said in a comment to CNN. DeepSeek could not immediately be reached for comment. And a pair of US lawmakers has already called for the app to be banned from government devices after security researchers highlighted its potential links to the Chinese government, as the Associated Press and ABC News reported. Similar concerns have been raised about the popular social media app TikTok, which must be sold to an American owner or risk being banned in the US. 'DeepSeek is the TikTok of (large language models),' Etzioni said. Tech giants are already thinking about how DeepSeek's technology can influence their products and services. 'What DeepSeek gave us was essentially the recipe in the form of a tech report, but they didn't give us the extra missing parts,' said Lewis Tunstall, a senior research scientist at Hugging Face, an AI platform that offers tools for developers. Tunstall is leading an effort at Hugging Face to fully open source DeepSeek's R1 model; while DeepSeek provided a research paper and the model's parameters, it didn't reveal the code or training data. Nadella said on Microsoft's earnings call that Windows Copilot+ PCs, or PCs built to a certain spec to support AI models, will be able to run AI models distilled from DeepSeek R1 locally. Mobile chipmaker Qualcomm said on Tuesday that models distilled from DeepSeek R1 were running on smartphones and PCs powered by its chips within a week. AI researchers, academics and developers are still exploring what DeepSeek means for the advancement of AI. DeepSeek's model isn't the only open-source one, nor is it the first to be able to reason over answers before responding; OpenAI's o1 model from last year can do that, too. What makes DeepSeek significant is the way it can reason and learn from other models, along with the fact that the AI community can see what's happening behind the scenes. Those who use the R1 model in DeepSeek's app can also see its 'thought' process as it answers questions. 'You can see the wheels turning inside the machine,' Durga Malladi, senior vice president and general manager for technology planning and edge solutions at Qualcomm, said to CNN. Tunstall thinks we may see a wave of new models that can reason like DeepSeek in the not-too-distant future. That could be critical as tech giants race to build AI agents, which Silicon Valley generally believes are the next evolution of the chatbot and how consumers will interact with devices – although that shift hasn't quite happened yet. Grok 3, the next iteration of the chatbot on the social media platform X, will have 'very powerful reasoning capabilities,' its owner, Elon Musk, said on Thursday in a video appearance during the World Governments Summit. For now, the AI community will keep tinkering with what DeepSeek has to offer. That is, until the next breakthrough comes along. 'I certainly predict that in the next 12 months, it'll be supplanted by something else,' said Etzioni. 'But it's a very real advance.'
CNN
14-02-2025
- Business
- CNN
The real hype behind DeepSeek, according to AI experts
DeepSeek turned the tech world on its head last month – and for good reason, according to artificial intelligence experts, who say we're likely only seeing the beginning of the Chinese tech startup's influence on the AI field. DeepSeek grabbed headlines in late January with its R1 AI model, which the company says can roughly match the performance of Open AI's o1 model at a fraction of the cost. Tech stocks tumbled as DeepSeek briefly unseated ChatGPT to become the top app in Apple's App Store. The achievement pushed US tech behemoths to question America's standing in the AI race against China – and the billions of dollars behind those efforts. While Vice President JD Vance didn't mention DeepSeek or China by name in his remarks at the Artificial Intelligence Action Summit in Paris on Tuesday, he certainly emphasized how big of a priority it is for the United States to lead the sector. 'The United States of America is the leader in AI, and our administration plans to keep it that way,' he said, although he added that 'America wants to partner' with other countries. But it's not just DeepSeek's efficiency and power. The way DeepSeek R1 can reason and 'think' through answers to provide quality results, along with the company's decision to make key parts of its technology publicly available, will also push the field forward, experts say. While AI has long been used in tech products, it's reached a flashpoint over the last two years thanks to the rise of ChatGPT and other generative AI services that have reshaped the way people work, communicate and find information. It's made Wall Street darlings out of companies like chipmaker Nvidia and upended the trajectory of Silicon Valley giants. So any development that can help build more capable and efficient models is sure to be closely watched. 'This is definitely not hype,' said Oren Etzioni, former CEO of the Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence. 'But also, this is a very fast-moving world.' Tech leaders have been quick to respond to DeepSeek's rise. Google DeepMind CEO Demis Hassabis called the hype around DeepSeek 'exaggerated,' but also said its model as 'probably the best work I've seen come out of China,' according to CNBC. Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said on the company's quarterly earnings call in January that DeepSeek has some 'real innovations,' while Apple CEO Tim Cook said on the iPhone maker's earnings call that 'innovation that drives efficiency is a good thing.' But the attention hasn't all been positive. Semiconductor researcher SemiAnalysis cast doubt over DeepSeek's claims that it only cost $5.6 million to train. OpenAI told The Financial Times it found evidence that DeepSeek used the US company's models to train its own competitor. 'We are aware of and reviewing indications that DeepSeek may have inappropriately distilled our models, and will share information as we know more,' an OpenAI spokesperson said in a comment to CNN. DeepSeek could not immediately be reached for comment. And a pair of US lawmakers has already called for the app to be banned from government devices after security researchers highlighted its potential links to the Chinese government, as the Associated Press and ABC News reported. Similar concerns have been raised about the popular social media app TikTok, which must be sold to an American owner or risk being banned in the US. 'DeepSeek is the TikTok of (large language models),' Etzioni said. Tech giants are already thinking about how DeepSeek's technology can influence their products and services. 'What DeepSeek gave us was essentially the recipe in the form of a tech report, but they didn't give us the extra missing parts,' said Lewis Tunstall, a senior research scientist at Hugging Face, an AI platform that offers tools for developers. Tunstall is leading an effort at Hugging Face to fully open source DeepSeek's R1 model; while DeepSeek provided a research paper and the model's parameters, it didn't reveal the code or training data. Nadella said on Microsoft's earnings call that Windows Copilot+ PCs, or PCs built to a certain spec to support AI models, will be able to run AI models distilled from DeepSeek R1 locally. Mobile chipmaker Qualcomm said on Tuesday that models distilled from DeepSeek R1 were running on smartphones and PCs powered by its chips within a week. AI researchers, academics and developers are still exploring what DeepSeek means for the advancement of AI. DeepSeek's model isn't the only open-source one, nor is it the first to be able to reason over answers before responding; OpenAI's o1 model from last year can do that, too. What makes DeepSeek significant is the way it can reason and learn from other models, along with the fact that the AI community can see what's happening behind the scenes. Those who use the R1 model in DeepSeek's app can also see its 'thought' process as it answers questions. 'You can see the wheels turning inside the machine,' Durga Malladi, senior vice president and general manager for technology planning and edge solutions at Qualcomm, said to CNN. Tunstall thinks we may see a wave of new models that can reason like DeepSeek in the not-too-distant future. That could be critical as tech giants race to build AI agents, which Silicon Valley generally believes are the next evolution of the chatbot and how consumers will interact with devices – although that shift hasn't quite happened yet. Grok 3, the next iteration of the chatbot on the social media platform X, will have 'very powerful reasoning capabilities,' its owner, Elon Musk, said on Thursday in a video appearance during the World Governments Summit. For now, the AI community will keep tinkering with what DeepSeek has to offer. That is, until the next breakthrough comes along. 'I certainly predict that in the next 12 months, it'll be supplanted by something else,' said Etzioni. 'But it's a very real advance.'
