logo
How thousands of teaching positions in a German state were lost to administrative error

How thousands of teaching positions in a German state were lost to administrative error

Local Germany4 days ago
More than 1,400 teaching positions in Baden-Württemberg have gone unfilled for years.
According to a joint statement by the state's Ministry of Education and the Ministry of Finance, the problem began in 2005 with programming errors at the education administration department – and was only spotted a week ago when the personnel software was updated.
Neither the Ministry of Finance nor the Ministry of Education can explain why the mistake went unnoticed for so many years.
What do we know so far?
In 2005, Baden-Württemberg's education authorities migrated to a new personnel management system known as DIPSY (
Dialogisiertes, personalisiertes Personalverwaltungssystem
).
According to a
press release
from the state's Ministry of Education, a programming error occurred during the data transfer, meaning that teaching positions which should have been marked as vacant were incorrectly logged as occupied.
READ ALSO:
How German schools are including more and more AI
The error remained hidden for 20 years due to a mix of system complexity, procedural blind spots, and an absence of cross-checking controls. After the 2005 transition, the system simply rolled the flawed numbers forward annually, with no full recalculation or verification.
Periodic payroll and staffing reviews, as well as internal audits, all failed to spot the growing discrepancy.
Advertisement
Estimates suggest that 'phantom' jobs accumulated at a rate of approximately 80–100 positions per year, according to reporting by
Bild
.
The scandal was finally uncovered when the state's education administration updated its personnel software.
During routine recalculations using a new program this month, officials realized that 1,440 teaching positions, purportedly filled for nearly two decades, were actually vacant.
What was the effect?
Baden-Württemberg's Finance Ministry claims no direct financial damage occurred as the salaries earmarked for the 'phantom' teachers were never paid.
Opposition politicians and
teachers' unions
are disputing this assertion, arguing that the long-term costs in educational outcomes – for pupils attending schools which weren't adequately staffed – may be significant.
READ ALSO:
Backlash after German minister suggests cap on immigrant students in schools
In addition, many newly qualified teachers across the state struggled to secure permanent jobs, while existing staff took on additional duties to cover shortages.
Unions argue that the chronic lack of personnel led to missing lessons, cancelled classes, and limited support for vulnerable pupils, including those at special education and counselling centres.
'For years, teachers have had to juggle to ensure compulsory lessons, and for years, children and young people have been sent home early because lessons have been cancelled and cannot be replaced,' reads a press release issued by the GEW teachers' union.
Advertisement
Schools for special educational needs, primary schools, and secondary moderns are believed to have suffered most.
Who
is
responsible?
The programming error first occurred in 2005, under then-CDU Education Minister Annette Schavan, but a succession of governments, ministers from multiple parties, and senior officials all failed to notice or correct the problem.
A working group has now been established to clarify causes, accountability, and enact prevention measures to make sure nothing similar happens again.
In addition, Baden-Württemberg's government has pledged to fill all 1,440 positions as soon as possible – with priority for special needs, primary, and non-gymnasium secondary schools.
Teachers' unions are insisting that all unspent funds should be redirected into schools to address the education deficit, with swift hires before the new school year begins.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Taliban to send envoys to Germany to work on deportations
Taliban to send envoys to Germany to work on deportations

Local Germany

time2 hours ago

  • Local Germany

Taliban to send envoys to Germany to work on deportations

The flight on Friday was the second from Germany since expulsions to Afghanistan were resumed last year. Germany does not recognise the Taliban authorities in Afghanistan but does have "technical contacts" on the deportations, which have been facilitated by Qatar. Government spokesman Stefan Kornelius said that during the exchanges "it has been agreed that two representatives of the Afghan administration will be incorporated" into Afghanistan's missions in Germany. According to the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (FAZ) daily, the two envoys will work at the Afghan embassy in Berlin and at the country's consulate in the western city of Bonn. The Taliban authorities demanded this step in return for making last Friday's flight possible, the paper reported. The FAZ said that the names of the envoys had been sent to Berlin and that they had already worked in consular services and were not considered extremists. Germany stopped deportations to Afghanistan and closed its embassy in Kabul following the Taliban movement's return to power in 2021. READ ALSO: Germany presses ahead with deportations to Afghanistan However in 2024 the last German government resumed expulsions with a flight in August carrying 28 Afghans. Current chancellor Friedrich Merz has vowed to continue deportations, having made a tougher line on immigration a key campaign theme in February's general election. Kornelius said that further flights were in the offing. Advertisement "The government has committed to systematic expulsions of those convicted of crimes and this will not be accomplished with just one flight," he said.

Germany updates: Companies pledge €631 billion investment – DW – 07/21/2025
Germany updates: Companies pledge €631 billion investment – DW – 07/21/2025

DW

time3 hours ago

  • DW

Germany updates: Companies pledge €631 billion investment – DW – 07/21/2025

The "Made for Germany" alliance has pledged investments totalling €631 billion over the next three years. Friedrich Merz met with top executives in Berlin in a bid to breathe life into the German economy. DW has more. An alliance of top German companies pledged to invest at least €631 billion ($733 billion) in Germany over the next three years. Chancellor Friedrich Merz met with executives from top German firms on Monday, hoping to rally fresh investment after two years of recession. While the government has approved billions in tax relief and a €500-billion ($580 billion) fund for infrastructure and climate, Berlin says public money alone won't be alliance of German companies, numbering in the dozens, pledged to invest at least €631 billion ($733 billion) in Germany over the next three years. "The investments by the initiative are a very powerful signal that we are now experiencing a shift in sentiment and consolidating it," German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said. "The message ... is very clear: Germany is back. It's worth investing in Germany again. We are not a location of the past, but a location of the present and above all the future," he added. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said that large public investments could be boosted significantly private funding. 'We want to leverage this potential and thus trigger further growth effects," Merz said after meeting with representatives of the "Made for Germany" initiative at the Chancellery in Berlin. The new government has launched a program to spur on investment and establish a €500 billion fund to splash on German infrastructure over the next 12 years. It has also pledged to cut bureaucratic red tape and speed up digitization. The initiative is being led by executives from Germany's blue-chip companies, including lender Deutsche Bank and industrial group Siemens. A summer interview with Alice Weidel, the leader of the far-right party Alternative for Germany (AfD), was severely disrupted by protesters on Sunday. Members of her party have called for a repeat. Watch what happened here: There has been a continued decline in the number of people employed in Germany's metal and electrical industry, according to the employers' association Gesamtmetall. The association said that since the beginning of 2025, there had been around 60,000 job losses. Basing its findings on a survey of companies, the association said that the number of employees in May was 2.5% lower than compared to the same period the year before. While Germany's new government has taken some measures to relieve the situation, Gesamtmetall's managing director Oliver Zander higlighted a reduction in the electricity tax and the immediate investment program as outstanding issues. "The speed at which the decline in employment in the metal and electrical industry continues shows, however, that the federal government has no time for breathers," Zander said. The next heat wave has been forecast in Germany. How is a country known for its lack of air conditioning preparing? Read the full story about Germany's preparations for heat waves. Researchers say a far-right social media campaign — that painted a respected law professor as extremist — caused the suspension of the election of judges to Germany's highest court. Read the full story on the controversial failure to elect a judge to Germany's top court. Once famed for never being late, German trains almost never run on time anymore. Deutsche Bahn has launched a refurbishment program that is likely to last at least a decade, and the costs and criticism are increasing. Read the full story on increasing delays on Germany's rail network. Germany's bond market calmed slightly on Monday after weeks of rising long-term interest rates. Investors are now waiting for new economic data from the Eurozone and a key decision from the European Central Bank (ECB). A bond yield is the return investors get for lending money to the government by buying its bonds. When bond prices go up, yields go down — so falling yields often reflect expectations of slower growth or lower interest rates. Economists believe the ECB will keep interest rates steady for now, but might cut them again as early as September. Some analysts think this week's Eurozone business activity data could show little change, partly due to global trade worries and a strong euro. That could make German government bonds more attractive, pushing their prices up and yields down. Senior representatives from around 50 countries are reconvening for another meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group. The virtual session is set to begin with opening statements from German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius, UK Defense Secretary John Healey, and Ukrainian Prime Minister Denys Shmyhal. The Ukraine Defense Contact Group was first launched on April 26, 2022, at the US air base in Ramstein, Germany — leading to the term "Ramstein format." US President Donald Trump's turnaround on military aid for Ukaine is likely to be the main topic of discussion, as NATO allies work to facilitate the weapons delivery. Survivors of abuse within the Catholic Church are urging the Vatican to take action against Cologne Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki, following years of controversy and a newly closed investigation. The plaintiffs accuse Woelki of shielding perpetrators and retraumatizing victims through his handling of abuse cases in the archdiocese. The complaint, submitted by all 12 members of the survivors' advisory board at the German Bishops' Conference, was drafted by physician and board member Katharina Siepmann. "The affected often experience the cardinal's behavior as offensive," said Siepmann, who suffered three years of severe abuse as a child and has served on the board since early this year. The body was established in 2022 to represent victims and advise the Church. The group's formal complaint against Woelki refers to alleged breaches of church law, not state law. "We ultimately hope that officials in Rome — and the pope himself — will view the cardinal's behavior as unacceptable and intervene," Siepmann told German broadcaster WDR. In May, Cologne prosecutors announced that Woelki would not face perjury charges in connection with his sworn statements about when he learned of abuse allegations in his archdiocese. The archbishop had been under investigation for more than two years. Woelki, who remains a cardinal and Archbishop of Cologne, took part in the conclave that chose Pope Leo XIV. The small town of Bohmte near the city of Osnabrück in the northwestern state of Lower Saxony was the scene of a spectacular accident that left two people seriously injured, including a seven-year-old boy. For as yet unknown reasons, local police reported, a car appears to have come off the road at high speed before colliding with a parked vehicle and crashing through a hedge. It then landed on a trampoline, hitting and injuring the child who was playing on it, and bounced into the attic of a barn. Read the full story about the car that crashed into a trampoline in northern Germany. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz is set to meet top executives from major German firms on Monday in a bid to restore investor confidence and revive the struggling economy. Representatives from around 30 companies — including Siemens and Deutsche Bank — are expected to attend the talks in Berlin, according to sources cited by DPA. More than a dozen firms listed on the DAX, Germany's main stock index, are among those invited. The meeting will focus on the "Made for Germany" initiative, launched by Siemens and Deutsche Bank, which aims to strengthen the country's investment climate. Participating firms are expected to outline upcoming projects and signal readiness to commit fresh capital. After two years of recession and amid a bleak outlook for 2025, Merz is urging companies to ramp up domestic investment. His government, which took office in May, has approved multi-billion-euro tax relief packages to stimulate growth. A government spokesperson last week pointed to the recently passed €500 billion (over $580 billion) infrastructure and climate fund, saying public investment will lead the way — but private sector participation is essential. Once Europe's growth engine, the German economy has been hit hard by inflation, energy price shocks, and mounting global competition in the wake of the pandemic and the war in Ukraine. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video from the DW newsroom, overlooking the Rhine River in Bonn — the former capital of West Germany. You join us as Chancellor Friedrich Merz gets ready to woo some of Germany's biggest business bosses to help get the sluggish economy back on its feet. Top names like Siemens and Deutsche Bank are expected talks in Berlin, along with more than a dozen other DAX-listed giants. About 30 firms are set to join what's being billed as a major push to rebuild investor confidence in the country's economic future. Merz is under pressure after two back-to-back years of recession and little sign that 2025 will turn things around. Follow along for the latest on what Germany is talking about on Monday, July 21.

Germany updates: Merz seeks to win over investors – DW – 07/21/2025
Germany updates: Merz seeks to win over investors – DW – 07/21/2025

DW

time7 hours ago

  • DW

Germany updates: Merz seeks to win over investors – DW – 07/21/2025

Chancellor Merz is meeting top executives in Berlin to urge bosses to invest and breathe life into a floundering economy. Follow DW for more. Chancellor Friedrich Merz is welcoming executives from top German firms on Monday, hoping to rally fresh investment after two years of recession. Around 30 companies — including big hitters like Siemens and Deutsche Bank — are expected to present projects under the "Made for Germany" push to restore confidence in the economy. While the government has approved billions in tax relief and a €500-billion ($580 billion) fund for infrastructure and climate, Berlin says public money alone won't be famed for never being late, German trains almost never run on time anymore. Deutsche Bahn has launched a refurbishment program that is likely to last at least a decade, and the costs and criticism are increasing. Read the full story on increasing delays on Germany's rail network. Germany's bond market calmed slightly on Monday after weeks of rising long-term interest rates. Investors are now waiting for new economic data from the Eurozone and a key decision from the European Central Bank (ECB). A bond yield is the return investors get for lending money to the government by buying its bonds. When bond prices go up, yields go down — so falling yields often reflect expectations of slower growth or lower interest rates. Economists believe the ECB will keep interest rates steady for now, but might cut them again as early as September. Some analysts think this week's Eurozone business activity data could show little change, partly due to global trade worries and a strong euro. That could make German government bonds more attractive, pushing their prices up and yields down. Senior representatives from around 50 countries are reconvening for another meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group. The virtual session is set to begin with opening statements from German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius, UK Defense Secretary John Healey, and Ukrainian Prime Minister Denys Shmyhal. The Ukraine Defense Contact Group was first launched on April 26, 2022, at the US air base in Ramstein, Germany — leading to the term "Ramstein format." US President Donald Trump's turnaround on military aid for Ukaine is likely to be the main topic of discussion, as NATO allies work to facilitate the weapons delivery. Survivors of abuse within the Catholic Church are urging the Vatican to take action against Cologne Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki, following years of controversy and a newly closed investigation. The plaintiffs accuse Woelki of shielding perpetrators and retraumatizing victims through his handling of abuse cases in the archdiocese. The complaint, submitted by all 12 members of the survivors' advisory board at the German Bishops' Conference, was drafted by physician and board member Katharina Siepmann. "The affected often experience the cardinal's behavior as offensive," said Siepmann, who suffered three years of severe abuse as a child and has served on the board since early this year. The body was established in 2022 to represent victims and advise the Church. The group's formal complaint against Woelki refers to alleged breaches of church law, not state law. "We ultimately hope that officials in Rome — and the pope himself — will view the cardinal's behavior as unacceptable and intervene," Siepmann told German broadcaster WDR. In May, Cologne prosecutors announced that Woelki would not face perjury charges in connection with his sworn statements about when he learned of abuse allegations in his archdiocese. The archbishop had been under investigation for more than two years. Woelki, who remains a cardinal and Archbishop of Cologne, took part in the conclave that chose Pope Leo XIV. The small town of Bohmte near the city of Osnabrück in the northwestern state of Lower Saxony was the scene of a spectacular accident that left two people seriously injured, including a seven-year-old boy. For as yet unknown reasons, local police reported, a car appears to have come off the road at high speed before colliding with a parked vehicle and crashing through a hedge. It then landed on a trampoline, hitting and injuring the child who was playing on it, and bounced into the attic of a barn. Read the full story about the car that crashed into a trampoline in northern Germany. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz is set to meet top executives from major German firms on Monday in a bid to restore investor confidence and revive the struggling economy. Representatives from around 30 companies — including Siemens and Deutsche Bank — are expected to attend the talks in Berlin, according to sources cited by DPA. More than a dozen firms listed on the DAX, Germany's main stock index, are among those invited. The meeting will focus on the "Made for Germany" initiative, launched by Siemens and Deutsche Bank, which aims to strengthen the country's investment climate. Participating firms are expected to outline upcoming projects and signal readiness to commit fresh capital. After two years of recession and amid a bleak outlook for 2025, Merz is urging companies to ramp up domestic investment. His government, which took office in May, has approved multi-billion-euro tax relief packages to stimulate growth. A government spokesperson last week pointed to the recently passed €500 billion (over $580 billion) infrastructure and climate fund, saying public investment will lead the way — but private sector participation is essential. Once Europe's growth engine, the German economy has been hit hard by inflation, energy price shocks, and mounting global competition in the wake of the pandemic and the war in Ukraine. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video from the DW newsroom, overlooking the Rhine River in Bonn — the former capital of West Germany. You join us as Chancellor Friedrich Merz gets ready to woo some of Germany's biggest business bosses to help get the sluggish economy back on its feet. Top names like Siemens and Deutsche Bank are expected talks in Berlin, along with more than a dozen other DAX-listed giants. About 30 firms are set to join what's being billed as a major push to rebuild investor confidence in the country's economic future. Merz is under pressure after two back-to-back years of recession and little sign that 2025 will turn things around. Follow along for the latest on what Germany is talking about on Monday, July 21.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store