If Dave Chappelle is a genius, why does his comedy punch down on trans people?
A friend recently invited me to a Dave Chappelle performance in Yellow Springs, about an hour north of Cincinnati. I passed. I didn't know what his routine would be, but I knew what I didn't want to hear.
Chappelle is a masterful storyteller and one of the most talented comedians of our time. But his comedy increasingly leaves me uneasy − not because it's edgy, but because it too often reinforces the very prejudices it claims to poke fun at.
I first felt this discomfort when Chappelle made a name for himself joking about Black people in ways that gave license to racists. I watched White audience members laugh a little too hard at sketches that, while brilliantly crafted, seemed to permit them to enjoy stereotypes they weren't supposed to say out loud.
Chappelle himself later acknowledged this dynamic, and even walked away from a $50 million deal and his hit show on Comedy Central, "Chappelle's Show," when he saw people laughing with the characters instead of at the racism.
But in his recent stand-up, Chappelle has shifted his focus toward the LGBTQ+ community, especially transgender people, and I feel that same uneasiness again. Once more, I see people who likely hold deep biases laughing with a sense of vindication. "If Dave Chappelle can say it," they think, "so can I."
Opinion: Don't take Dave Chappelle down. Lift transgender voices up.
When the joke punches down, the harm hits hard
This isn't about being offended. It's about what comedy does. The best comedy punches up − it challenges power, exposes hypocrisy and speaks truth. But when it punches down, it can legitimize cruelty and reinforce systems of exclusion.
Opinion: Pride reminded me capitalism can't save us from Trump. Only we can do that.
Chappelle insists he's just telling the truth. But truth without compassion can sound a lot like contempt. When that contempt is aimed at groups already struggling to be seen and heard, it becomes more than a joke. It becomes part of the problem.
So no, I won't attend the show. I admire Chappelle's genius. But I can't pretend not to see the cost of his notoriety, especially when it's borne by the people who are already fighting to be treated with dignity.
We should all ask ourselves: When we laugh, who's hurting?
Dennis Doyle lives in Anderson Township and is a member of the Board of Contributors at the Cincinnati Enquirer, where this column originally appeared.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
‘South Park' Lives: Paramount Inks New Deal With Creators, Library Moving to Paramount+
South Park has been saved. Just hours before the Comedy Central show's season 27 premiere on July 23 (a premiere that had already been pushed back due to the uncertainty of a new deal), Paramount and Park County, the venture creators Matt Stone and Trey Parker run and which produces the show, have reached a new deal. More from The Hollywood Reporter Skydance Tells FCC It Will Create CBS News Ombudsman, Eliminate DEI at Paramount Trump's Side Deal With "New Owners" of Paramount May Hint at FCC Concessions Paramount Execs Tell Staff That Africa Offices and Channels May Close Amid Strategy Review (Exclusive) The agreement means that South Park's new season will debut as scheduled. The deal runs for five years and encompasses 50 new episodes of the show to debut on Comedy Central. In addition, the companies have inked an expansive new streaming partnership (via their joint venture South Park Digital Studios) that will bring South Park's library to Paramount+ in both the United States, where HBO Max has held the rights for years, and globally. New episodes will also stream on Paramount+ in the U.S. the day after they air on Comedy Central under the pact. A source pegged the value of the deal at about $1.5 billion. 'Trey and I and the whole South Park crew are grateful for this extension and this deal. We want to thank [Paramount co-CEO and president of Showtime/MTV Entertainment] Chris McCarthy and [COO] Keyes Hill-Edgar for years of great partnership and are looking forward to continuing to make South Park for the next five years,' said Stone. Added Parker, 'We are grateful for this opportunity and deeply honored by the trust placed in us. This is about more than a contract — it's about our commitment to this organization, our teammates, and our fans. We're focused on building something special and doing whatever it takes to bring championships to this city.' Streaming deals for the show expired on June 23, forcing an extension of a domestic deal with Warner Bros. Discovery to keep it on HBO Max for now. Earlier this month, Paramount+'s international license to stream episodes of the long-running animated series expired, which led to the streamer pulling the series from its global service. Park County has an unusual arrangement with Paramount, with the production company receiving about 50 percent of all streaming revenue, even as Paramount retains ownership of the show. 'Matt and Trey are singular, creative forces whose fearless humor and boundary pushing storytelling have made South Park one of the most beloved and enduring series ever — more popular today than at any point in its history, and one of the most valuable TV franchises in the world,' said McCarthy. 'They are exceptional talents and trusted partners. We're thrilled that Comedy Central and now Paramount+ globally will be the home to South Park for years to come and our thanks to the Skydance team for their vital partnership in making this happen.' The deal also comes after a heated but quiet behind-the-scenes legal dispute between Park County, Paramount Global, and Skydance, which is set to assume control of Paramount in the coming weeks. It was a dispute that had some sources concerned about the show's future. Parker and Stone were seeking an extension of their current first-look deal with the company, which a source pegged at being worth about $150 million per year during its six-year term. That agreement had a couple of years left, but the creators were seeking an early extension that could coincide with a streaming agreement. However, Skydance leadership, including CEO David Ellison and incoming president Jeff Shell, had approval rights on any deals that met a certain threshold, and the Park County deal fit that bill. Earlier this month, The Hollywood Reporter learned that Park County believed it had struck a basic framework with Paramount on a new 10-year, $3 billion deal, roughly three times the value of their last agreement. Skydance, however, was reluctant to sign off a deal that long, fearing how the streaming market could change by then. At $1.5 billion, the new deal would be worth about $300 million per year, albeit with the shorter time frame that Skydance had been pushing for. While $1.5 billion is an extraordinarily high number for what amounts to 50 episodes of TV, a source said that the overall deal also functioned as an advance on the streaming revenue, helping to explain the cost. When the talks were most heated, Parker and Stone brought on Bryan Freedman, a prominent lawyer and bulldog negotiator known for aggressive legal maneuvering, underscoring how the dispute had escalated. 'This merger is a shitshow and it's fucking up South Park. We are at the studio working on new episodes and we hope the fans get to see them somehow,'' Parker and Stone wrote in a social media post on July 2, after Comedy Central announced that the season 27 premiere had been pushed by a few weeks. In a precursor to the legal dispute, Park County threatened legal action against Shell for allegedly urging Netflix and Warner Bros. Discovery to modify certain terms of their offers for the show in a 'manner calculated to benefit Paramount at the expense' of the company. It pointed to Shell urging WBD to give Paramount+ an exclusive 12-month window for new episodes of the show and to shorten the term of the deal from 10 to five years, which could worsen the studio's bid for the series. Best of The Hollywood Reporter 'The Studio': 30 Famous Faces Who Play (a Version of) Themselves in the Hollywood-Based Series 22 of the Most Shocking Character Deaths in Television History A 'Star Wars' Timeline: All the Movies and TV Shows in the Franchise Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
‘South Park' Creators Reveal Network Battle Over Premiere's Trump Penis as They Joke: 'We're Terribly Sorry'
South Park creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone had a lot to say when they took the stage at San Diego Comic-Con following a recent stretch that has seen plenty of headlines about the long-running Comedy Central animated series. Parker and Stone addressed the Hall H crowd Thursday as part of a panel promoting the network's adult animation programming, alongside Beavis and Butt-Head creator Mike Judge and Digman! co-creator Andy Samberg. At the start of the panel, moderator Josh Horowitz addressed the elephant in the room by asking the South Park creators if they had been following the noisy reaction to the show's season 27 premiere that aired Wednesday and included an unflattering depiction of President Donald Trump. More from The Hollywood Reporter 'Rick and Morty' Spinoff 'President Curtis' a Go at Adult Swim 'The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon' Renewed for Fourth and Final Season at AMC "James Fraser Dies" in First 'Outlander' Season 8 Footage Parker had a succinct response, saying jokingly with a straight face, 'We're terribly sorry.' That was the extent of the reply, although there would be more to come about the episode. A more direct reference to Trump came when the South Park creators were asked how they originally connected decades ago. 'For me and Trey, we met over Monty Python,' Stone said. 'In this day, when PBS is getting their funding cut, that's how I found Monty Python.' The comment, which comes as Trump has signed a bill cutting federal funding to public broadcasting, earned cheers from the crowd. Parker said that the show's team still finds the creative process to be as thrilling as ever. 'We were at South Park this morning trying to figure out what next week's show is going to be,' he admitted. He pointed out that, even for this week's season 27 premiere, the show's team just recently finalized the episode's story. 'Just three days ago, we were going, 'I don't know if people are going to like this,'' Parker said. He added that he and Stone were reading news headlines and said to each other, 'Let's put that in there.' As the conversation went on, discussion turned to notes from higher-ups, and Horowitz asked if there were concerns about the season 27 premiere. Parker referenced the episode showing Trump's penis when he shared feedback from network brass: 'They were like, 'We're gonna blur the penis,' and we're like, 'No, you're not gonna blur the penis.'' Stone said that the show's team agreed to add eyes to the penis: 'Then it's a character.' As far as his initial inspiration for Beavis and Butt-Head, Judge recalled doing an impression at school of a classmate who was smitten with an attractive teacher. 'I started imitating in the back of the class, and it just caught on,' Judge said. 'I was just trying to draw him, and it turned into something else.' He then added of his former friend, 'He's a nuclear engineer now, so he's nothing like Beavis.' Samberg recalled his Lonely Island sketches for Saturday Night Live being among the first viral YouTube clips, particularly 'Lazy Sunday' from 2006. 'SNL used to do the same characters over and over and over again because there was no place to rewatch it,' he said. 'YouTube became something that people found out about the day after the Narnia one, and we had really good timing with it.' Judge recalled getting a kick out of SNL's 2024 viral Beavis and Butt-Head-inspired sketch that starred Ryan Gosling and Mikey Day. 'That was pretty cool,' Judge said. 'That had me laughing.' When the panelists were asked whether they get recognized in public, Stone quipped that his fans are mostly men: 'I'm older now, but it wasn't that great to be recognized by just guys.' Parker and Stone had been in a tense dispute with Paramount and future owners Skydance regarding the show's streaming rights. On Wednesday, Paramount announced a new five-year deal with Parker and Stone's production company, Park County, for a reported $1.5 billion. It will bring South Park to Paramount+ in the U.S. for the first time ever and see the show produce 10 episodes per year. The Hollywood Reporter reported earlier this month that Park County believed it was set to finalize a 10-year, $3 billion deal with Paramount but that Skydance balked at approving a deal of that length, given uncertainty with the streaming market. Amid the dispute, Parker and Stone enlisted notable lawyer Bryan Freedman to help with negotiations. Comedy Central announced earlier this month that the season 27 premiere, which would mark the show's first new episode in more than two years, had been delayed as the show's deal remained in limbo. Parker and Stone wrote in a fiery social media post at the time, 'This merger is a shitshow and it's fucking up South Park. We are at the studio working on new episodes and we hope the fans get to see them somehow.' South Park's season 27 premiere finally aired Wednesday on Comedy Central and includes a cartoon depiction of Trump, with one scene showing him nude while in bed with Satan. Satan brings up rumors about Trump's name appearing on the documents related to the Jeffrey Epstein case. The episode also references CBS' recent cancellation of The Late Show With Stephen Colbert, which has spurred speculation about the axing being politically motivated ahead of the Paramount merger, mirroring debate surrounding Paramount's 60 Minutes settlement with Trump. During the season 27 premiere, a representation of Jesus Christ warned South Park residents to take Trump seriously. In a statement issued earlier Thursday about the episode, White House Assistant Press Secretary Taylor Rogers said in part, 'This show hasn't been relevant for over 20 years and is hanging on by a thread with uninspired ideas in a desperate attempt for attention.' On Thursday, the Federal Communications Commission cleared the way for David Ellison's Skydance to acquire Paramount Global in an $8 billion deal. Following the FCC's approval, Skydance can soon complete its acquisition of Paramount, putting Ellison in charge of the owner of Comedy Central, CBS and other media properties. Best of The Hollywood Reporter 'The Studio': 30 Famous Faces Who Play (a Version of) Themselves in the Hollywood-Based Series 22 of the Most Shocking Character Deaths in Television History A 'Star Wars' Timeline: All the Movies and TV Shows in the Franchise
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Beavis And Butt-Head are solid-gold idiots in new Comedy Central trailer
We have to imagine there's something very freeing about writing Beavis and Butt-Head, two characters who, by their base natures, are free of pressures to evolve, mature, or otherwise grow. The duo's revival series—which has been absent from screens for a couple of years now as it makes the jump from Paramount+ to Comedy Central—has made a massive asset of that lack of mutability, even as it's expanded out the show's world a bit, focusing episodes on 'Old' and 'Smart' version of the characters, as well as the classic teenage pairing. All of which is still pretty clearly in play in the new trailer for the show's third/eleventh season, which debuted ahead of its Comic-Con panel this afternoon. We get at least one high-profile cameo, as Metallica shows up for what looks like a plotline about Beavis and Butt-Head becoming really rich—and getting gold bars chucked at them for their trouble. But really, the vibe here is centered on a familiar brand of mayhem. Tasings, deliberate weight gain, a whole lot of burning shit: None of it necessarily seems massively surprising, or inventive but, again, that's not really what Beavis And Butt-Head is for. The important thing is that Mike Judge and his fellow writers and animators haven't caught any pesky cases of maturity since the last time they returned to these characters, allowing the show to fulfil its very specific ecological niche. The new season of Beavis And Butt-Head is set to make its Comedy Central debut on Wednesday, September 3. More from A.V. Club The biggest news (so far) from San Diego Comic-Con 2025 What's on TV this week—Chief Of War and Eyes Of Wakanda R.I.P. Tom Lehrer, mathematician and musical satirist Solve the daily Crossword
