Oppn hails SC order on draft roll, EC cites Aadhaar validity
Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge said the campaign by millions of aware citizens, the Congress, and Rahul Gandhi has achieved its first success through the intervention of the Supreme Court. '…During SIR in Bihar, according to the ECI, the data of the 65 lakh (6.5 million) people who were excluded from the voter list will now have to be made public by the ECI, which will increase transparency,' Kharge said in a post in Hindi on X, welcoming the decision of the top court in the public interest.
Congress general secretary KC Venugopal said the Supreme Court's ruling is a 'massive victory for democracy', and a huge message for the 'vote chors (thieves)' who tried to use the SIR to distort the electoral process in Bihar. His party colleague Jairam Ramesh said the top court verdict on Bihar SIR issue is 'a beacon of hope'. He added that the Supreme Court has just upheld the Constitution of India in a 'categorical, convincing, and courageous manner'.
Tejashwi Yadav, the leader of RJD, an ally of Congress, said the interim order of the SC over SIR in Bihar has 'exposed the BJP, its allies and their nefarious design to disenfranchise people'. 'Our fight will continue and we will keep an eye on officials involved in the SIR exercise,' he told reporters.
Reacting to the development, the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) said the Congress tried every 'trick and deceit' to stop SIR exercise in Bihar but it had to face disappointment in the Supreme Court. 'Now, in sheer desperation, Congress is clutching at non-issues and parading them as 'moral victories',' BJP chief JP Nadda said in a post on X.
The fact remains that all their canards are being rejected, exposed, and defeated one by one, Nadda, who is also the Union health minister, said. 'Congress has yet again lost the case and lost the plot,' he added.
Responding to the court order, ECI said it was 'already accepting Aadhaar card as proof,' sharing a photograph of the enumeration form used during the SIR. 'List of deceased, voter at two places and permanently shifted is being shared with political parties since July 20, 2025,' it said.
The poll panel added that it will give 'further facility to citizens at large' by adding a list of 'non-included voters with reasons' to Bihar's draft electoral roll.
Speaking on the matter, former Lok Sabha secretary PDT Achary said there was 'no reason for the EC to not publish the list of deleted electors along with reasons for deletion publicly.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
26 minutes ago
- News18
Who Is Gurkirat Dang? Does He Have 4 Voter IDs? How's He Linked To Rahul Gandhi's Vote Theft Row?
Last Updated: EC SIR vote theft row: During his presentation, Rahul Gandhi had cited the example of Gurkirat Singh Dang, who he claimed had voted four times in Delhi. Dang has refuted the claims Rahul Gandhi, Congress leader and leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, recently began what he called a campaign against alleged 'vote theft" or 'vote chori". During his presentation to back his claims against the Election Commission (EC) and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), Gandhi cited the example of one Gurkirat Singh Dang, who he claimed had four voter IDs and had voted four times in Delhi. Dang has now come forward, refuting the claims and stirring another political row. The opposition, led by the Congress, has been protesting against the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in poll-bound Bihar. Gandhi at a press meet on August 7 alleged irregularities in the electoral rolls of the recently held polls, saying the poll body was working in collusion with the ruling BJP to destroy the election system in India. The Election Commission has rejected these claims, insisting that the revision exercise was carried out transparently. Among Gandhi's examples of alleged voter list manipulation was the case of Dang. 'Here is a duplicate voter. There are 11,965 voters of this type. This is a gentleman called Gurkirat Singh Dang. Gurkira Singh Dang appears once, twice, three times, four times in four different polling booths in the constituency. The same name, the same address, the same person for different polling booths. And this is not just one person; this is thousands of people in one assembly," said Gandhi. What did Gurkirat Singh Dang say? Does he have four voter IDs? The first to respond to Gandhi's claims was his Dang's sister, Kanandeep Kaur Dang: 'This is my brother, Gurkirat Singh Dang. Rahul Gandhi preaches about our constitutional rights, yet bends laws when it suits him. During his presentation, our privacy was breached, the media circus outside our home was invasive. The hypocrisy is glaring. Hear the truth." This is my brother, Gurkirat Singh Dang. Rahul Gandhi preaches about our constitutional rights, yet bends laws when it suits him. During his presentation, our privacy was breached, the media circus outside our home was invasive. The hypocrisy is glaring. Hear the truth.— Kanandeep Kaur Dang (@Dangkanandeep) August 12, 2025 She then posted a video of Dang explaining why he got the four IDs and how he does not have them now. 'I challenge Rahul Gandhi to prove that I voted 4 times. Due to rejection issues, four IDs were mistakenly created, but I had applied for their cancellation as per the rules and regulations of the poll body," he said in the video. 'My family is being harassed," Dang claimed, adding, 'I will take legal action against YouTube creators for defaming me". How Dang's response stirred a political row The BJP criticised the Congress for 'lying" to the country with alleged false claims. 'Gurkirat Singh Dang, whom Rahul Gandhi had singled out during his presentation on so-called Vote Chori, has hit back, calling him a bad loser and demanding that he produce proof to substantiate the allegation that he voted multiple times," said BJP IT cell chief Amit Malviya in an X post. Gurkirat Singh Dang, whom Rahul Gandhi had singled out during his presentation on so-called Vote Chori, has hit back, calling him a bad loser and demanding that he produce proof to substantiate the allegation that he voted multiple times. This isn't the first time—every claim… — Amit Malviya (@amitmalviya) August 17, 2025 top videos View all 'This isn't the first time—every claim Rahul Gandhi has made has collapsed under scrutiny. Rahul Gandhi is an industrial-scale LIAR," he added in his post. The Election Commission of India has been asking Gandhi to either sign a formal declaration for his claims or apologise to the nation. Gandhi, however, has refused to do so claiming that he is citing the EC's data. view comments Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: August 17, 2025, 13:13 IST News india Who Is Gurkirat Dang? Does He Have 4 Voter IDs? How's He Linked To Rahul Gandhi's Vote Theft Row? Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Time of India
28 minutes ago
- Time of India
Vote theft row: Congress MP Manish Tewari cites ‘trust deficit' with Election Commission; Akhilesh Yadav presses for reforms
Congress MP Manish Tewari cites 'trust deficit' with Election Commission; Akhilesh Yadav presses for reforms (Picture credit: PTI, ANI) NEW DELHI: The Election Commission of India (ECI) is facing mounting criticism from opposition parties, with Congress MP Manish Tewari and Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav both questioning the poll body's credibility in light of allegations over voter list manipulation. As per news agency ANI, Tewari said the Commission was struggling with a 'trust deficit,' arguing that it carried 'very little conviction' and 'almost zero credibility' among political circles and the wider public. Objecting to the current system of appointments for the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners, he stressed that the executive's 'veto' in the process was undermining confidence. 'As long as the executive veto remains with regard to the appointment of the Commissioners of the EC, no matter how many press conferences the EC does it will not matter even one bit whatsoever,' he wrote on X. He further urged the poll body to 'correct the widely held perception that it is an extension counter of the Union Government,' warning that it had acquired a negative label similar to 'Godi Media,' which, he said, was harmful for Indian democracy. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The 5 Books Warren Buffett Recommends You To Read in 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo Meanwhile, Samajwadi Party's leader Akhilesh Yadav also targeted the Commission, saying it needed 'not just reform but an inevitable fundamental transformation.' In a post shared on X, Yadav stated, 'The historic responsibility of saving democracy rests on their shoulders. It is understood that they are under various kinds of undesirable pressures, but they should not think they are alone. When the Election Commission starts walking on the right path, the support of millions of Indians will become its protective shield. The public and public trust naturally align with those who walk the path of truth. ' He added that even one 'courageous step' by the Commission could safeguard the future of generations. Yadav's comments came as opposition parties raised objections to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter rolls in Bihar. Congress leader Rahul Gandhi had earlier alleged voter list manipulation and produced what he called 'proof' at a press conference. The Commission, in response, has asked Gandhi to provide a signed affidavit and submit the evidence formally for investigation. RJD leader Tejashwi Yadav also joined the criticism, accusing the Bharatiya Janata Party of 'misusing Constitutional agencies' and attempting to 'destroy democracy and the Constitution.' He vowed to resist any effort to deny people their voting rights, saying, 'We will fight wherever we want and we will not let our rights be erased.' The Election Commission, however, defended its procedures, stating that errors in electoral rolls should be raised during the 'Claims and Objections' period. According to the Commission, digital and physical copies of the final roll are shared with recognised political parties and candidates to ensure scrutiny at the right time. 'Had these issues been raised at the right time through the right channels, it would have enabled the concerned SDM EROs to correct the mistakes, if genuine, before those elections,' the EC said in its release.
The Hindu
42 minutes ago
- The Hindu
'Planting food, not violence or hate': Brazil's Lula razzes Donald Trump over tariff-hit grapes
Brazil President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva said on Saturday (August 17, 2025) he hopes U.S. President Donald Trump can come and get to know the real Brazil, as the South American powerhouse reels from Washington's 50% tariffs. In a video taken while he planted grapes — one of the tariff-hit goods — Brazil's leftist leader addressed Mr. Trump. Brazil's Lula says proposal to regulate social media platforms is ready "I hope you can visit someday so we can talk and you can get to know the true Brazil, the Brazil of people who love samba, carnival, soccer, the United States, China, Russia, Uruguay, and Venezuela. We love everyone," Mr. Lula said. The tariffs imposed on Brazil are among the steepest to hit a U.S. trading partner. And unlike with other countries, the measures against Brazil have been framed in openly political terms, with the Republican President justifying the move by alleging Brasilia is conducting a "witch hunt" against his ally, former President Jair Bolsonaro. Mr. Bolsonaro is being tried for an alleged coup attempt against Lula in 2022, and the United States recently sanctioned the judge in the case, along with seven other Supreme Court magistrates. Mr. Lula has backed the Supreme Court and promises to defend "the sovereignty of the Brazilian people." His administration has also vowed to combat Mr. Trump's tariffs, including by lodging an appeal if necessary. India, Brazil partnership relevant to the entire world: PM Modi The levies, which affect several key exports from the largest economy in Latin America, sweep aside centuries-old trade ties and a surplus that Brasilia put at $284 million last year. In his message on X, Mr. Lula said he was giving an example of "planting food, and not planting violence, or planting hate." "I hope that someday we can talk, President Trump, so you can learn about the quality of the Brazilian people," he adds.
