Terror hoaxster freed despite Ontario hospital's view he poses a 'significant threat'

National Post

12 hours ago

Article content
'On Dec. 19, 2016, while Mr. Clements was in remand custody, a terrorist attack occurred in Berlin causing 12 deaths and dozens of injuries (approximately 50),' said the review board decision.
Article content
'A search of Mr. Clements phone and email account on the same day did not show any evidence of foreign communications that would indicate knowledge of the terrorist attack in Berlin.'
Article content
When Mounties interviewed him three days later, Clements 'advised that a 'higher power' had told him about the attacks. He endorsed hearing voices that only he could hear. Both Jesus Christ and the devil spoke to him. He heard the voices first approximately one week before he contacted the consulate,' said the decision.
Article content
The decision notes his 'current diagnosis is schizophrenia spectrum disorder.'
Article content
The psychiatrist who treated Clements just before last month's hearing pointed to a hospital report that referred to his 'history of violence' as well as the seriousness of the terrorism hoax. 'He noted that Mr. Clements 'likely' suffers from a major mental disorder but the diagnosis has not yet been clarified. He advises that Mr. Clements has no insight into the need for treatment for future risk of violence although on a day-to-day basis he does well.'
Article content
A former director of the Rivercity Vineyard Church and Community Centre in Sarnia, which runs a shelter, indicated Clements had been actively involved there as both a volunteer and in a paid position for years. She 'described no mental health or management concerns whatsoever concerning Mr. Clements. To the contrary, she described him as an 'amazing worker' with a 'great heart.''
Article content
She called Clements a 'puppy dog,' explaining that that he 'has been stable for the entirety of the time he has been at the shelter. He has his own private room and there is no limit on how long he may occupy that room so long as he continues to help at the shelter.'
Article content
The review board heard that since he was arrested and hospitalized in April, Clements 'has been pleasant and sociable with staff and peers. His thoughts were clear and organized' and his 'behaviour was not 'obviously bizarre.''
Article content
Clements testified that 'since no one contacted him after the board hearing in April 2022 he thought the matter was concluded,' said the decision, which notes he then went to Halifax for more than a year before returning to Sarnia.
Article content
The review board didn't buy his story about not knowing he had been ordered detained by the hospital. 'The only reasonable inference to be drawn is that Mr. Clements was aware of the disposition but was refusing to be bound by it.'
Article content
It examined Clements' 'serious history of mental health and substance abuse issues, his lengthy criminal record, including assault, break and enter, and failures to comply, his (previously) paranoid and aggressive behaviour while in detention at the respondent facility, his resistance to treatment, including medications, his moderate to high risk scores on risk assessment tests, his breach of hospital rules, including attempting to abscond, and his lack of insight into the index offence, his condition and his need for treatment.'
Article content
It also accepted his psychiatrist's opinion that Clements 'posed a significant threat to public safety based on these factors.'
Article content
But board members had 'serious concerns' about the conclusion that Clements has a 'history of violence.'
Article content
'Although there is no doubt that the index offence was extremely serious with a potential for at a minimum serious psychological harm to individuals, there is little outside of that to support a finding that Mr. Clements has a 'history of violence' which significantly undermines the opinion of the hospital with respect to significant threat.'
Article content