Minns says Folbigg ‘free' to sue his government if $2m not enough for 20 years in jail for wrongful convictions
Chris Minns is facing bipartisan condemnation and a possible inquiry into what has been described as an 'insulting' compensation payout for Folbigg.
Folbigg, once referred to as among Australia's worst serial killers, was convicted in 2003 and ordered to serve a minimum 25-year sentence for the suffocation murders of three of her children and manslaughter of a fourth.
Her name was cleared and convictions quashed in 2023 by the appeals court just months after she was granted an unconditional pardon and released from prison.
On Friday morning, the Greens MP Sue Higginson wrote to the Minns to formally request the government 'review the decision to offer such an unjust and inadequate payment' to Folbigg.
'It's not too late for Chris Minns to do the right thing, meet with Kathleen, and offer her just and fair compensation for the injury that has been done to her as a result of a failure by the NSW justice system,' Higginson said.
'If he doesn't do this I will move to establish an inquiry to examine how this decision was reached. Kathleen and all people with an interest in justice deserve to understand how this has gone so wrong.'
The Nationals MP Wes Fang said a public inquiry into the compensation figure should not be delayed.
'The state took away Kathleen's life, her liberty, even her home, for 20 years,' Fang said. '[The state attorney-general] Michael Daley had the ability to give her a small amount of dignity back, to try and enjoy her next 20 years.'
The opposition leader, Mark Speakman, said the figure was 'unfair and too low' but stopped short of calling for a formal inquiry on Friday morning.
Minns said $2m was the most the government could allocate to Folbigg 'without pulling it away from other important programs'.
The premier said other higher compensation payments to wrongly accused people had occurred after they initiated legal action against governments.
'[Folbigg's] lawyer is free to take the NSW government to court, to sue the NSW government and we would deal with it in those circumstances,' Minns said.
Folbigg's lawyer, Rhanee Rego, was contacted for comment. It is not known whether further legal action is being considered.
Emma Cunliffe, who was one of the first lawyers to argue Folbigg was innocent, said the $2m figure was 'inadequate' when compared to the money provided to other wrongfully convicted Australians.
In 2019, David Eastman was paid $7m by the ACT government after spending 19 years in prison. Lindy Chamberlain was paid $1.5m for 3.5 years in prison three decades ago.
'Fair compensation would offer parity with past awards,' Cuncliffe said. 'It would allow Kathleen Folbigg sufficient resources to live out her years in peace and comfort and hopefully to access the supports and services that will allow her to heal.'
Cuncliffe, now a professor at the University of British Columbia, said it was common for government to made 'a lowball offer of compensation' only for it to be revised in the face of public pressure.
One of Kathleen's closest friends, Tracy Chapman, who has supported her for more than two decades, described the compensation figure as 'insulting'.
'It's a failure of empathy,' Chapman said. 'It's a failure of accountability.'
Chapman said there appeared to be no formal process of appeal and that the government's compensation offer was described as 'non-negotiable'.
'This is the shocking thing,' Chapman said. 'There is no process. There is no system here. They don't have to do anything.
'The letter of compensation was insulting. It said we did extensive research and this is the figure we came up with and this is not negotiable, it's a final offer.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Marles insists Australia ‘not supplying weapons to Israel' but critics argue ‘parts of weapons are weapons'
The federal government won't follow Germany and introduce new export restrictions to pressure Israel, with the defence minister, Richard Marles, insisting no weapons are being sent from Australia to aid the killing in Gaza. Marles, the acting prime minister, said on Sunday that Australia was not exporting any weapons for use by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), a contested claim rejected by human rights campaigners and the Greens. 'Let's be clear: we don't supply weapons to Israel,' Marles told ABC TV. 'We've seen a lot of misinformation in relation to what Australia is doing here. The fundamental point is that we are not supplying weapons to Israel, and there is no step that we could take, equivalent to that of Germany, which would have any impact in relation to that.' The comments follow Germany's decision last week to halt exports of military equipment that could be used in Gaza. The chancellor, Friedrich Merz, announced the decision on Friday, in response to Benjamin Netanyahu's plans to dramatically expand Israel's Gaza operations, a move condemned by the international community. Marles was asked about Australia exporting armoured steel and, separately, parts for F-35 fighter jets, which Israel previously conceded were used in operations in Gaza. 'We're an F-35 country and we have been that for a couple of decades. That is a multi-lateral arrangement with supply chains that are organised by Lockheed Martin in the United States and have multiple suppliers in respect of all of those supply chains.' David Shoebridge, the Greens' spokesperson on foreign affairs, labelled Labor's statements meaningless. 'Australia is a key part of the F-35 fighter jet program. We are the only place in the world that makes parts like the bomb bay doors and we operate as one of the few regional distribution hubs. 'Two years of hollow talking points from the Albanese government aren't washing with the public any more as we watch a genocide in real time.' Shoebridge argued that, under international law, component parts were considered weapons. 'Watching the defence minister, Richard Marles, refuse to answer basic questions about Australia's export of weapons parts and defence material to Israel is excruciating,' he said in a statement. 'The Australian public knows that the Albanese government is permitting the export of armoured steel, F-35 weapons parts and other critical materials to Israel and wants it to stop.' Shoebridge said if the Albanese government stopped the export of F-35 parts to Israel, their fleet would, in time, be grounded. 'The fact Albanese is choosing not to do that makes us complicit,' he said. Donald Rothwell, a professor of international law at the Australian National University, said Australian exports of component weapon parts to the IDF were 'contributing to the Israeli military campaign in Gaza'. 'Part of the difficulty is that there can be so many component parts of weapons. Some component parts may have been exported to Israel for civilian use but then utilised for weapons,' he said on Sunday. 'The clearer position that Australia could take is that if it diplomatically, legally and politically objects to Israel's occupation of Gaza, then all exports could be suspended for the time being. That would be the clearest way of ensuring that no Australian exports contribute to the Israeli military effort in Gaza.' Rothwell said he 'would not be as decisive as Senator Shoebridge as to his interpretation of international law'. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion Guardian Australia reported in November that Australia had amended or lapsed at least 16 defence-related export permits to Israel. A spokesperson said all of the permits were approved before the 7 October terror attacks by Hamas and none related to weapons or ammunition. The ABC reported in April that a remote weapon system designed and built by an Australian company was one of dozens of counter-drone technologies tested by Israel this year. The Australian Centre for International Justice, a non-profit legal centre, is among organisations questioning the government's claims on military exports. The prime minister, Anthony Albanese, said Australia had appropriate sanctions in place against members of Israel's war cabinet and would not publicly discuss other considerations. 'What we need to do here is to have very clear statements and actions by the Australian government that make a difference, rather than respond to a slogan on a protest,' he said during a visit to New Zealand. Albanese said the government wanted hostages held by Hamas released and for urgent aid to stop the 'humanitarian catastrophe' unfolding in Gaza. Australia's opposition home affairs spokesman, Andrew Hastie, told Sky that Netanyahu's plan to control Gaza City was 'a very risky proposition' and could add to the humanitarian crisis. 'It would be incredibly difficult for IDF troops to move through and clear. All the advantage would be with Hamas defenders and anyone else who would stand and fight.' The foreign minister, Penny Wong, joined Germany, Italy, New Zealand and the UK in a joint statement on Saturday, stating Israel's plan would make an already perilous situation worse and risked breaching international law. London's high court ruled a month ago that Britain's decision to allow the export of F-35 fighter jet components to Israel, despite accepting they could be used in breach of international humanitarian law in Gaza, was lawful.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Inside the deadly Chinese school trip to Australia that ended in tragedy - as girl, 13, faces murder charge for allegedly stabbing her 14-year-old roommate to death
Part of a Chinese school exchange trip has been abandoned after one of the girl students was allegedly stabbed to death by another at a suburban Australian home. A 13-year-old girl accused of murdering her friend, 14, remains in custody while her parents are expected to fly in from their home in China to speak to detectives. They were part of a group of 15 Chinese students on an exchange trip from schools in China associated with the Newcastle Waldorf School in the NSW Hunter region. The two teenagers had been staying with hosts Steve Moloney and Tracey Taylor at their home in Edgeworth, Newcastle. The couple had gone to bed on Monday evening when they allegedly heard a commotion and discovered the 14-year-old fatally wounded. Police arrested the 13-year-old at the scene. The Newcastle Waldorf School this week held a candlelit ceremony but classmates revealed the other Chinese students on the trip were too traumatised to attend. They have not been seen since the tragedy unfolded, one student revealed. 'There are around 15 of them, across a few year groups, but none of them came back to school again,' they told the Daily Mail. 'Some had made good friends here, but I don't think we will see them again before they leave on Saturday. 'We sang, lit candles and laid flowers to remember the girl who lost her life. 'The school has offered counselling to us and we have been making cards for the other students who came with them.' It is believed the alleged victim and her alleged killer did not know each other before making the trip to Australia on the study program. 'Most of the kids met for the first time at the airport in China,' said the student. 'But they had ten hours together before arriving in Australia and saw each other every day, so the news was really shocking to all of them.' The Newcastle school's co-principals, Peter Muddle and Tracey Ashton, said they had arranged extra counselling to support everyone through this very difficult time. 'We are deeply shocked and saddened by the tragic incident involving two visiting Chinese students who have been in Australia since last week as part of a tour group,' they said in a joint statement. 'Our priority has been to ensure care and professional support is in place for our school community, as well as for the visiting students and their carers who find themselves dealing with grief far away from their families.' They also confirmed the teenagers' host couple were not affiliated with the school. 'The tragedy occurred at a residence where both students were billeted,' the statement continued. 'Although the host family is not connected with our school, we are thinking of them as they too must cope with this ordeal.' It's understood the group were from various Waldorf schools across China and are scheduled to leave Newcastle on Saturday before spending a further week in Australia. A Waldorf or Steiner school is based on the educational philosophy of German Rudolf Steiner, which emphasises a holistic approach to education. The school focuses on intellectual, emotional, physical, and spiritual development rather than just academic performance. The program is held by Beijing-based tour agency Depu and run by Italian Amerigo Sivelli. The tour in Australia is the second this year, with another group of students enjoying the same three-week itinerary in April. After the planned two weeks in Newcastle, the students were due to visit more of Australia before returning home. 'After a marvellous time at the Newcastle Waldorf School, we took our Chinese students travelling to Sydney and Melbourne,' the company posted to Facebook in April alongside images of the trip. 'We focused on the relationship between First Nations People (Aboriginal people) and Western colonisation in Australian art as well as on nature connection activities. 'Opening up to new questions makes us more vulnerable and fragile, but it's also a courageous step towards our future.' It is not known if the remaining tour - which is understood to include a tour of the Great Ocean Road in Victoria - is going ahead. Strike Force Aggnes has been established and an investigation is underway with the assistance of the State Crime Command's Homicide Squad. The 13-year-old has been charged with murder and remains in custody after appearing before a Children's Court on Wednesday. The court heard that the 13-year-old was travelling with an 'extraordinary,' amount of medication. Daily Mail contacted the program organisers, who said they were 'too busy' to comment on the death of the child.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Cuddles, cuppas and chemistry: Albanese and Luxon downplay divisions in times of global turmoil
Australian prime minister Anthony Albanese and his New Zealand counterpart, Christopher Luxon, made multiple references to the freezing Queenstown climate during their annual meet-up but the mood was far from frosty. As the evening light dipped behind the jagged peaks surrounding a billionaire's bunker-like facility where the leaders held their bilateral talks at the weekend, Luxon quipped that the outdoor press conference was the coldest he had ever done and it was time for a cup of hot chocolate. Albanese, however, had other ideas. 'We're going in for a cuddle,' he said, giving Luxon a good pat on the back – a reference, perhaps, to their much-talked about embrace earlier in the day. It is the pair's second annual meeting, following Luxon's visit to Canberra last year but the leaders' relationship precedes their time in office, having first met when Luxon was the chief executive of Air New Zealand, and Albanese was Australia's transport minister. 'We've been friends for a long time,' Albanese said. 'We're probably the two leaders of nations that can sit down and talk aviation like two nerds and bore everyone else around the international forums.' Australia is New Zealand's only formal ally and the two countries have a long and close friendship, often walking in lock-step over global issues, defence and trade. However, their meeting came as record numbers of New Zealanders are leaving for Australia in search of better opportunities, while Australia continues to deport people with criminal convictions back to New Zealand under its contentious 501 deportation policy. Those issues – particularly the latter – have been a long-running thorn in the side of the trans-Tasman relationship, but were downplayed by the leaders who chose to focus their attention on being trusted friends, amid major geopolitical upheaval. 'At a time of global uncertainty this bond has never been more important,' Albanese said. Luxon, too, pointed to the certainty and predictability of the trans-Tasman alliance, and 'the knowledge that we have one another's backs'. Commitments to strengthen that bond included cooperating on growing each country's economy, cutting regulatory tape to streamline trans-Tasman business and working closely on defence. The prime ministers also stood together on international issues, including on Israel's latest plans for Gaza, China's expansion in the Pacific and US tariffs. On Saturday, the foreign ministers of both countries – alongside Germany, Italy and the UK – released a joint statement condemning Israel's plan to take over Gaza City. Last month, New Zealand and Australia cosigned the New York Call – a declaration indicating the possible recognition of Palestinian statehood. Neither Luxon nor Albanese would confirm when a declaration of statehood might happen but said Israel's latest plans were 'wrong' and urged the country to rethink its agenda. Both leaders also rejected the idea that possible trade retaliation from the US president, Donald Trump, over recognising Palestinian statehood would affect their positions. Australian goods imported into the US have attracted Trump's baseline 10% tariff, while last week, New Zealand was hit with a surprise 15% tariff. 'We make our own assessments in … our own economic and our security interests,' Luxon said, to which Albanese said: 'Australia has exactly the same position.' Regarding China – the largest trading partner of both countries – the leaders said followed pretty much the same playbook: cooperate where they can and disagree where they must. On a icy Sunday morning in Arrowtown, the prime minsters laid a wreath in remembrance of fallen Anzac soldiers before embarking on a helicopter ride over the region's mountains and glaciers. After another set of goodbye hugs at Queenstown airport, Albanese boarded his 737-8 Boeing business jet just after midday. Following his departure, Luxon told media the pair shared 'good chemistry', and that having a peer support group of other leaders was 'really important'. Asked whether Albanese was 'trolling' him by sporting the yellow scarf of the Wallabies – Australia's national rugby team – Luxon said 'he probably was a bit, yeah'. 'He was probably trolling me a bit with that plane there too but I'll just leave that for another day,' Luxon said, hinting at New Zealand's beleaguered defence force fleet. Some trans-Tasman rivalries will never freeze over.
