AgriSA and community leaders warn of economic fallout from tobacco legislation
In its parliamentary submission, AgriSA said the bill, in its current form, neglects to consider the broader implications on agricultural livelihoods. It said tobacco farming remained a vital income source for thousands of rural households, especially in provinces where alternative crops were not economically viable.
'We feel that good legislation is necessary to avoid harmful consequences that might not be foreseen in terms of the present bill. Our emphasis is on fixing what is wrong before we progress to further statutory requirements, the consequences of which have not been fully explored.
'We don't have a vested interest in smoking. We have a vested interest in a constructively regulated, purposeful, evidence-based bill that doesn't create the unforeseen consequence whereby we're supporting illegality through regulation, which is not appropriate to achieve the objective we all want to see achieved,' said AgriSA's Janse Rabie.
Rabie said tobacco production dropped by about 50% in five years.
'Why? Because illicit trade has eaten their market away. That's the bottom line and farmers ask the honest question to government: why has government allowed our market to be eaten away by illicit trade?
'If you want to really address the harm, you need to properly legislate the ability to enforce. We absolutely need to make sure that what is in place is properly enforced and that we don't carry on a system that is not working and is allowing for additional illegality to take place.'
Nedlac Community Trust CEO Nhlanhla Ndlovu said the issue of the Tobacco Bill was 'misguided from the point of view of not quantifying the impact to producers like farmers, with potential significant implications for the farmers, workers and communities they support'.
'It looks like there's an economic impact that will result in an inability, among affected farmers and communities, to make an income, but there's no viable replacement programme. You are taking away livelihoods in a context where crime stats are showing an increase across the board.'
ActionSA MP and harm reduction advocate Dr Kgosi Letlape added his voice, saying the bill seemed to condemn adult smokers to death while 'concentrating solely on issues of youth uptake, which are important, but the deaths don't come from the youth'.
He was also concerned about the impact on agriculture in SA. 'Should our agricultural sector be looking beyond our borders to progressive markets where their products could be used for less harmful sources of nicotine?
'My fear is not that the industry will die, it'll just be driven into the wrong hands.'
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
an hour ago
- The Herald
Paterson High gets R250,000 boost to improve infrastructure
Paterson High School has received a major boost to its centenary celebrations with a R250,000 donation from automotive battery manufacturer Auto-X, aimed at improving infrastructure, safety and energy resilience. The contribution includes the installation of inverters to keep the Schauderville school operational during power outages, as well as refurbishments such as painting and fitting burglar bars to enhance security. Auto-X, based in the Neave/Korsten cluster, is a member of the Nelson Mandela Bay Business Chamber. Manufacturing and technical executive Kelvin Naidoo, who also serves as the chamber's president, said the initiative honoured the school's legacy while investing in the future of local pupils. 'Access to stable electricity and a safe, dignified learning environment are critical to unlocking the full potential of learners,' Naidoo said. The Neave/Korsten cluster, one of 11 geographic clusters under the chamber, has previously worked with the school on community projects, including a competition that resulted in new waste bins for the neighbourhood. Cluster chair Keith Prinsloo said the donation reflected the kind of leadership the group promoted. 'While our mission is to attract and retain investment, we are equally proud to support initiatives that deliver tangible community benefits,' Prinsloo said. The chamber's cluster model focuses on inclusive economic development, with members encouraged to invest in projects that make a lasting social impact alongside economic growth. The Herald
The Herald
an hour ago
- The Herald
Nelson Mandela Bay civil society group calls for conference to avert economic crisis in metro
The Civil Society Coalition of Nelson Mandela Bay has urged Eastern Cape premier Oscar Mabuyane and the presidency to urgently organise a rescue conference to discuss how an economic collapse can be averted in the metro. This follows the imminent closure of the Goodyear plant in Kariega, US tariffs that threaten the industrial economy, and political instability at City Hall which has led to chronic service delivery failures. On Monday, the coalition stated that a new social compact was needed to consolidate the input generated by civil society, which would be binding across all levels of government. 'We need a proactive economic and industrialisation strategy that broadens the value chains that underpin our economy and builds on the metro's existing human and natural assets. 'This metro cannot afford to lose another industrial anchor, more so that we are already advised of others that are in line to potentially close,' the statement said. According to the coalition, the US tariffs pose a danger to the industrial economy of the Bay and have placed thousands of jobs at risk. The new 30% tariff rate kicked in August after a trade deal could not be reached. 'The tariffs will also serve to have a domino effect on other industries, as we seek new markets in competition with other countries similarly impacted. 'Any disruption to trade relations with the US will have a devastating ripple effect across supply chains, communities and households already battling high levels of poverty and unemployment.' It said the impact of the closure of Goodyear stretched far beyond the employees of the plant, but would affect small businesses and surrounding sectors. 'This signals a deepening social and economic crisis,' the statement said. Goodyear announced in June that 907 jobs were on the line when it winds down its manufacturing operations in the country. The group has also hit out against political governance in the city. 'The direct consequence of the misgovernance and mismanagement on the political and economic front, social depravation and decline , specifically in the form of murder, syndicated theft of infrastructure, substance abuse, interpersonal abuse, and neighbourhood gangs, plague the people of our metro. 'We are counted among the top-ranking murder cities in the world. 'It is a crisis our leadership seem to blind themselves to and we call for a sense of urgency among the non-state formations, working with a willing government at all levels,' the coalition said. It has called on the government to take the necessary action to enable a sustainable economy by securing a low-carbon and stable electricity supply to the metro. This, they said, could be done by bringing in industrial and trade policy certainty for green hydrogen, electric vehicles, grid supply, wheeling of renewable energy, manganese exportation and beneficiation of raw minerals. Other suggestions included leveraging the national public employment programmes to aid cleanup, tourism and community safety, and returning the ports to optimal functionality. The Herald
The Herald
an hour ago
- The Herald
IDT board committed to transparency amid ongoing investigations
The board of the Independent Development Trust says it is committed to transparency and accounting amid ongoing investigations at the state agency responsible for implementing social infrastructure programmes. The board said it was treating all matters before it with the serious urgency it deserved and had launched a number of concurrent processes to bring stability to the organisation. Over the past week, the board said it held lengthy meetings to address these matters, including the PwC forensic investigation into the oxygen plant tender, the circulating video containing allegations of bribery by suspended IDT CEO Tebogo Malaka and the organisation's spokesperson, Malaka's suspension and concerns relating to a number of tenders and supply chain processes linked to them. 'While sensitive investigations are under way, the board is taking all necessary steps to safeguard public funds, protect projects that deliver social infrastructure for underserved communities, as well as poverty alleviation projects like the extended public works programme.' The board said it was fulfilling its legal mandate by acting on substantial information, following all applicable laws . 'Once in a position to do so, the board will provide the public with a detailed briefing on the actions taken and the findings of its investigation. The board is fully aware that restoring trust in the organisation requires openly sharing the measures implemented to strengthen governance and protect public funds.' The board said it was committed to doing so at the earliest possible stage without compromising any ongoing criminal investigations. Malaka and her spokesperson, Phasha Makgolane, are alleged to have offered Daily Maverick journalist Pieter-Louis Myburgh R60,000 to drop a story he was working on relating to Malaka's business affairs, including how she was funding the construction of her multimillion-rand home at Waterfall Country Estate in Midrand. TimesLIVE
