logo
Europe's cross-border caravan commuters: How an army of French workers camp on Swiss border and cross daily into prosperous Alpine neighbour to earn higher salaries

Europe's cross-border caravan commuters: How an army of French workers camp on Swiss border and cross daily into prosperous Alpine neighbour to earn higher salaries

Daily Mail​08-07-2025
French workers are increasingly leaving behind their lives to stay in a caravan on the border and commute into neighbouring countries for more gainful employment.
Communes on the country's eastern frontier are now said to be filling up with citizens eyeing work in richer countries - while still enjoying the lower cost of living at home.
Employees can receive twice their French salary or more while working in Switzerland, and then return home for cheaper bills, groceries and fuel.
This year, France recorded more than 230,000 people crossing the border into Switzerland alone - more than double the 99,500 noted 20 years ago.
Cross-border work may be protected by law, but the scale now threatens to overwhelm the French welfare system and strain tiny frontier communities.
Roger Belot, the mayor of the Alpine village of Les Fourgs, told The Sunday Times that these workers have transformed the commune.
The community of 1,500 faces housing shortages, longer queues at food banks and a lack of staff in key industries as workers arrive and immediately look east.
Over the winter, the outlet reports, a car park serving tourists was filled with caravans and trucks, much to the chagrin of locals dependent on the ski trade.
Mr Belot said that he was now having to use village money to accommodate cross-border workers in a formal campsite where he can, at least, charge for access to water, electricity and waste disposal.
While these workers do face a stripped-back life living out of vans in potentially hostile territory, the financial benefits are clear.
France is battling an unemployment rate of 7.4 per cent and the median salary is approximately €2,735 (£2,355) net per month in the private sector, according to the latest INSEE data.
In Switzerland, the median gross monthly salary for full-time employees was CHF 6,788 (£6,249) in 2022, the most recent data from the Swiss Federal Statistical Office.
Put differently, the €400 (£344) Mr Belot hopes to charge for staying in the campsite is around 15 per cent of the median French wage. It is 5.5 per cent of the median Swiss.
Les Fourgs is not unique. In Pontarlier, near the Swiss border, 30 per cent of the 18,000 inhabitants are cross-border workers, 24 heures reports.
Locals complain that Swiss wages are massively driving up property prices on the French side of the border - up to levels comparable with Paris.
This trend is felt most in France, but exists in Italy, Germany and Austria, too. In total, some 405,000 people crossed borders to work in Switzerland in the first quarter of 2025. 234,000 were French.
France has, until recently, guaranteed certain protections to these workers.
Should a cross-border worker from France lose their well-paying job in Switzerland, they will be cushioned by the French state, which pays out benefits based on prior salary.
According to The Times, the French state is losing €800 million every year to such workers who lose their jobs.
Efforts are being taken to redress this. In March, a new decree aimed at cross-border workers introduced 'major changes' to compensation.
Before April 1, a cross-border worker who lost their job in Switzerland could refer to his Swiss salary to determine claims in France.
Now, it has to be defined in line with French expectations.
Nonetheless, there are now some 500,000 'frontaliers' living and working between France and its neighbours as more and more cotton on.
Social media is now awash with anonymous users gently probing how they might go about finding work over the border while continuing to live in France.
On Facebook last week, one French member of a Swiss expats group said they had a 'stable and comfortable' remote IT job based in France, but hoped to 'experience the Swiss professional environment' while continuing to live in France near the border.
They asked what kind of salary they should aim for in an IT support role while living on the French side with two young children.
'Anything above 80k CHF [£73,639] gross/year is a good salary, [especially] if you're living in France,' another anonymous user replied.
Glassdoor estimates that even working in Paris, an IT support worker can only expect a salary of around €40,500 (£34,859).
Once folded into the Swiss tax system, they can expect to pay significantly lass tax than they would in France.
Then, after a short commute home, they can pay a fraction of what they would have spent in Switzerland for dinner, utilities or a night on the town.
Curiosity around cross-border benefits has spawned blogs, travel pages and official websites dedicated to answering questions on the topic.
Associations for cross-border workers have also banded together to form the 'European Confederation of Cross-Border Workers', in part to create a legal unit to defend those subject to the new rules on benefits.
Working within the EU is, for France, slightly more straightforward. Citizens are able to move to and reside in other member countries, thanks to the right to free movement.
This means a French worker can cross the border into Germany or Belgium and live for up to three months without any requirements other than a valid identity card or passport.
To stay longer, they may be asked to meet certain conditions, like proof of study or work.
Switzerland is not a member of the EU, but French workers can work across the border with a G permit, a Swiss document that their employer applies for.
Working in Switzerland and living in France has been legal since 1983, thanks to a bilateral agreement between the two countries.
There are certain conditions; cross-border workers must return to France at least once a week, for example.
After 12 years of recognised status, cross-border workers may be eligible for Swiss nationality, while also retaining their French nationality.
Switzerland voted against joining the European Economic Area (EEA) in 1992, but separately does also allow EU citizens to live and work in Switzerland under a free movement agreement.
Switzerland, with an ageing population of just nine million, stands to gain from the system. But the influx of French workers has been met with some resistance.
Long-time beneficiaries of the system told the Sunday Times that newcomers were giving them a bad name.
And the increased supply of workers is believed to be lowering wages for available jobs in Switzerland.
Some Swiss have also started limiting access to amenities for the French.
Last week, French media picked up on reports a popular pool would limit use to Swiss nationals and holders of a valid settlement permit or work permit.
Cross-border workers may be able to enjoy the benefits for now. But on both sides of the frontier, perceptions are changing in response to the scale of the movement.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

French consumer inflation confirmed at 0.9% in July
French consumer inflation confirmed at 0.9% in July

Reuters

timean hour ago

  • Reuters

French consumer inflation confirmed at 0.9% in July

Aug 14 (Reuters) - Consumer price inflation in France was stable in July and met analysts' expectations and the preliminary reading, statistics office INSEE said on Thursday. France's harmonized inflation rate, adjusted for comparison with other euro zone countries, was +0.9% year-on-year in July, INSEE said. A poll of 17 analysts surveyed by Reuters had on average expected the +0.9% rate for EU-harmonised inflation. INSEE reported the same figure in its preliminary reading. The consumer inflation rate was also at +0.9% year-on-year in June.

‘We are Nicolas': inside France's middle-class revolt worrying Macron
‘We are Nicolas': inside France's middle-class revolt worrying Macron

Times

time11 hours ago

  • Times

‘We are Nicolas': inside France's middle-class revolt worrying Macron

Nicolas, a thirtysomething professional, sits in his tiny Paris flat with his head in his hands. Despite a degree and a job with a big brand company, he and his wife Julie are barely managing after the state takes its huge cut from their pay. More than 500,000 people have tweeted sympathy with the young manager since his plight went public. Ministers and MPs have offered support and he is worrying President Macron's staff. All of which is remarkable given that Nicolas does not exist. He is the fictional embodiment, a ­viral meme, of the frustration of a generation of white urban middle-class millennials who feel they are being milked to pay for the French benefits system and for boomers living it up on state pensions. His name is one that peaked in popularity with middle-class parents in 1980. The slogan 'C'est Nicolas qui paie' (Nicolas foots the bill), which emerged in 2020, has taken off this year, channelling anger in a section of the electorate that was the heart of initial support for Macron's centrist En Marche party, now called Renaissance. Targets for Nicolas's ire include Bernard and Chantal, generational names for 70-year-olds who are depicted sailing the oceans on cruises, thanks to pensions that this year gave retired recipients higher incomes than average full-time workers. Also in his sights is ­Karim, the Muslim-African immigrant whose life is supposedly financed by ­Nicolas. Tax rises promised by François Bayrou, prime minister of France's minority government, have boosted the Nicolas phenomenon, drawing in conservative politicians. Bruno Retailleau, leader of the centre-right Republicans and the interior minister, warned that if Bayrou fails to change the budget: 'It's Nicolas who'll pay'. Jonas Haddad, 37, the vice-president of the Normandy region and spokesman for the Republicans, praised what he called 'the rallying call for a generation that is being fleeced'. He said: 'I'm hearing a lot of young French people wondering if it is worth staying in France.' Aides of Macron, who opposes Bayrou's planned tax rises, say they are keeping a close eye on the movement. The Élysée Palace agrees with the claim that the middle class is being taxed too much, a staff member said. The government is more worried about a brewing revolt, also born on social media, of a potentially more violent type. Under the slogan 'Bloquons tout' (Let's block everything), a movement echoing the 2018 gilets jaunes (yellow vests) uprising is calling for the country to be brought to its knees on September 10. Drawing from the radical left and hard right, it is calling for civil disobedience and mass protest. It is being ­closely watched by the police intelligence service. The Nicolas trend has been propelled by an X account, NicolasQuiPaie, which has relayed humorous memes around the long-suffering millennial. The anonymous creator of the ­account, which has more than 70,000 followers, has insisted that he is not political. However, he has voiced admiration for Javier Milei, the libertarian ­Argentine president. He has distanced ­Nicolas from the gilets jaunes. He told Le Figaro: 'We must make the country understand that the ­country cannot stay afloat without the people who are at work. The political leaders have to have the courage to teach the other social classes that they need us.' Nicolas is being depicted on the left as a vehicle for populist and hard-right politics. Gaspard Gantzer, a former advisor to François Hollande, the former Socialist president, said: 'This Nicolas character, who comes over so simple and typical, is in reality a Trojan horse. He is circulating ­reactionary identity politics, which claim that only productive people have the right to have an opinion.' Analysts see the Nicolas phenomenon and the angrier 'block everything' movement as a symptom of the breakdown of the political system, witnessed by the collapse of the old ­established parties and the emergence of two big blocs on the hard left and populist right that ­jointly enjoy support from well over half the public. Jérôme Fourquet, director of opinion for Ifop polling, said: 'Each in its way translates the deep anger which is burning in whole swathes of society.' • In the new age of French chaos, hard right and left call the shots Nicolas comes mainly from right-wing frustration over taxes and excessive benefits, while the 'block everything' is a replay of the yellow vests, he told Le Point magazine. 'They are two slogans that have no party or trade union but which are fed by the same ­exasperation.' The Nicolas phrase is a new take on an old expression, recently used by ­Macron: 'C'est bibi qui paie'. ­Bibi refers to oneself so it means: 'I'm the one who pays'.

Macron's plea to his countrymen to work harder has backfired
Macron's plea to his countrymen to work harder has backfired

Times

time12 hours ago

  • Times

Macron's plea to his countrymen to work harder has backfired

Every August, it is traditional in Britain for a politician to be mercilessly criticised for going on holiday (especially somewhere foreign and sunny and fun) rather than toiling away in Whitehall. In France, the precise opposite holds. The French premier, François Bayrou, has very publicly remained at his desk in Paris this month. He was hoping his example might encourage his compatriots to cut back their downtime, given the magnitude of their nation's debt crisis. Instead, M. Bayrou has been roundly, sincerely and angrily mocked for neglecting to take it easy on the beach. Friday marks the high (or low, from M. Bayrou's perspective) point of the annual French summer shutdown, la torpeur estivale, when 40 per cent of businesses close and the workforce disappears to the coast and countryside for three or four weeks to recharge its batteries. This weekend, an astounding 55 per cent of the French population will be away from home, most of them in their mother country. La rentrée, the big return to work, is still a fortnight away. Much, rightly, is made of the UK's looming fiscal crisis, as the national debt to GDP ratio stands at about 96 per cent. The equivalent figure for France is 113 per cent. So M. Bayrou is of course correct in exhorting his countrymen to knuckle down, nice weather notwithstanding. Bonne chance avec ça! The odds are stacked against him. • How the French have clung on to their August holiday shutdown The French enjoy a minimum of 25 days paid holiday a year, plus 11 national bank holidays and some extra local ones, plus the 'right to disconnect' and not work out of hours, plus the chance to accrue even more days off (the so-called réduction du temps de travail) if they exceed the mandated 35 hours work a week. As the virulent protests against raising the retirement age from 62 to 64 showed, these privileges, unaffordable as they may be, will not be surrendered lightly.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store