Kildare data centre plan faces fresh objections
,
An Taisce
and Friends of the Irish Environment (FIE) have called on Kildare County Council to refuse planning permission for a €3 billion data centre due mainly to the increased greenhouse gas emissions it will produce.
In August of last year, multimillionaire engineering entrepreneur and co-owner of Monaghan-based forklift manufacturer, Combilift, Robert Moffett through his Herbata Ltd vehicle, lodged plans for the six data centre campus for a site next to the M7 motorway and business park at Naas, Co Kildare
In October, the council stalled the plan after stating that the projected CO2 emissions from the data centre campus on lands is 'excessive' for one development.
In June, Herbata lodged extensive further information on the scheme in response to the concerns pointing out that the data centre will not be reliant upon the existing electricity generation and will get 50 per cent of its power from renewables.
READ MORE
Consultants for the applicants, RPS stated that the utilisation of Combined Cycle Gas Turbines (CCGT) would result in a consequent reduction of 552,000 tonnes in greenhouse gas emissions
However, in new submissions ahead of a council planning decision this week, Friends of the Earth Ireland, An Taisce and FIE call on the Council to reject the plan while County Kildare Chamber has urged the planning authority to grant permission
On behalf of FIE, Tony Lowes highlighted the data centres' projected high greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and incompatibility with Ireland's climate obligations
He states that the development 'could emit nearly one million tonnes of CO₂ equivalent per year. Over five years, this would account for almost a quarter of Ireland's electricity sector carbon budget—posing a major adverse impact on national emissions targets'.
On behalf of Friends of the Earth Ireland, campaigns director Jerry Mac Evilly said 'the central message of this submission is that the applicant has not clearly or sufficiently addressed significant emissions impacts of the six gas-powered data centres. We therefore call for the application to be rejected'.
On behalf of An Taisce, senior planning and environmental policy officer, Phoebe Duvall has told the council that to grant permission 'would be in contravention of Ireland's legally binding emissions reduction obligations and contrary to the national climate objective'.
In a submission on behalf of County Kildare Chamber, its ceo, Sinead Ronan has told the council that 'this proposal presents a forward-looking opportunity to enhance the local economy, support employment and position Kildare as a leader in sustainable digital infrastructure. The project also has a clear alignment to planning policy, climate goals and heritage protection'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on Ireland's economic position: not as good as it looks
The decision by The Economist magazine to exclude Ireland from its annual ranking of the world's richest countries is not the first time comparisons of this kind have sidelined the State's economy, Even official EU statistics now sometimes leave out Ireland, particularly when looking at trends in trade. And private sector analysts often exclude Ireland when looking at Europe-wide indicators. Should we be upset? Not really. The problem, as the Economist puts it, is that Ireland's economic data is 'polluted by tax arbitrage.' Multinationals organise their tax affairs to declare as much profit as possible in Ireland, helped by accountants who are , as the magazine said , 'as versed in the arts of surreal creativity as James Joyce.' Ireland argues, with some justification, that these companies have ' substance' here – in other words they employ people and produce goods or services from Ireland. However, the extent of the profit declared here is well in excess of what would be justified by this activity. And so, on a range of estimates, as much as half of Ireland's corporate tax take may be 'windfall' – not directly related to activity here – and our Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is very significantly inflated. Does this matter? It complicates analysis of Ireland's economy and more meaningful assessments now use other modified aggregates. Had the Economist included Ireland in its list of GDP per head, it would have been somewhere in the top half dozen countries. A more realistic measure would put Ireland in the middle of the European pack. READ MORE Unfortunately, Ireland's out-of-kilter data has created another problem. It has put the State in the spotlight internationally, including in the White House, where there has been focus on Ireland's trade surplus with the US, due almost entirely to pharma exports. The Irish GDP and trade figures may not reflect the scale of real activity here, but they do show major pharma production in Ireland for the US market and the impact of the associated aggressive tax planning. In that way, Ireland's mangled figures do still tell a real story.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Protesters call on Central Bank not to renew Israel bonds
Protesters have urged the Central Bank of Ireland not to proceed with the approval for the sale of Israel bonds in advance of an upcoming renewal date. About 100 demonstrators gathered outside the Central Bank in Dublin on Tuesday to demand an end to the authority's role in approving Israel bonds for sale in the EU, for the Government to include services in the Occupied Territories Bill and to pass that legislation. The bank is the designated authority in relation to the sale of Israel bonds in the EU, and has determined the securities meet the standards of the union's prospectus regulations. Israel bonds have been advertised as supporting the country's economy and, more recently, websites promoting the securities emphasise their role in supporting Israel's military operations in Gaza. READ MORE Protesters and Opposition parties have called for legislation that would give Ireland the power to refuse the sale of Israeli 'war bonds' over human rights concerns. They say the bonds are intended to fund the war in Gaza, while Ireland has an obligation under the Genocide Convention to use all means likely to have a deterrent effect on those suspected of preparing genocide. The Central Bank has said regulations require it to approve prospectuses that meet standards of completeness, consistency and comprehensibility. The Israel bond prospectus is up for renewal on September 2nd. The Oireachtas Joint Committee on Finance has recommended that the bank carry out an immediate review before renewing approval of the bonds. David Landy of Jews for Palestine and Academics for Palestine outside the Central Bank in Dublin. Photograph: Niall Carson/PA Wire Meanwhile, Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon has launched legal proceedings against the Central Bank over claims that investors in Israeli bonds could be legally complicit in genocide in Gaza. It is alleged that the Central Bank's failure to ban the marketing, distribution and sale of Israel bonds exposes investors to risks that have not been disclosed to them. [ Lobby other EU countries to allow Irish Central Bank to drop Israeli war bonds, TDs recommend Opens in new window ] Ireland-Palestine Solidarity Campaign chairwoman Zoe Lawlor said: 'The Government has to end the direct involvement of the Central Bank in apartheid Israel's sale of genocide-funding bonds. 'The Central Bank is an organ of this State, and its complicity in genocide makes Ireland complicit.' David Landy of Jews for Palestine, and Academics for Palestine, said: 'We are asking the Central Bank to do the absolute minimum required of it under law – to end the sale of Israeli war bonds, to finally end this direct Irish participation in Israeli genocide.' Sinn Féin's foreign affairs spokesman said the Irish Government 'must use every lever at its disposal' to show leadership on Gaza. Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire said: 'Clearly, ending the facilitation of Israeli war bonds is one of those.' He added: 'The people of Gaza and of Palestine need us to act.'
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘We are sleeping in cars and serial couch-surfing': Dublin students appeal to homeowners to rent out rooms
On a busy summer morning, Dublin commuters were being approached by eager students' union officers in a 'last-ditch effort to get some rooms' for incoming college goers. 'We have people who sleep in cars and serial couch surfers,' said University College Dublin (UCD) students' union president Michael Roche, who was on the canvass at St Stephen's Green. – In recent weeks, he said, there has been an influx of queries from concerned students and parents about housing for the year ahead. 'For international students and first years who are quite new to Dublin's rental market, there can also be exploitative situations or scams where people just don't have the knowledge of the market that returning students do,' Mr Roche said. READ MORE Recent figures showed UCD has the State's most expensive on-campus rooms . Mr Roche said that situation has left 'a lot of people locked out' in their search for accommodation. An en-suite room in village three on the college's Belfield campus costs €11,888 for the academic year. The cheapest on-campus option at UCD is a shared bedroom in village one at €5,722. UCD students' union has joined forces with the Dún Laoghaire Institute of Art Design and Technology (IADT) for a digs drive aimed at addressing the 'chronic shortage of rental accommodation' in the capital. Emilia O'Hagan, UCD welfare officer, was among the students' union officers urging people to consider accommodation tax-breaks. Photograph: Tommy Clancy [ Where will vital student housing come from? Opens in new window ] Commuters passing St Stephen's Green Luas station from 7am on Tuesday were handed flyers encouraging them to avail of the Revenue Commissioners' rent-a-room relief scheme that allows homeowners earn up to €14,000 tax-free for letting out a spare room in their home. The student representatives were due to gather again on Tuesday evening at bus and Luas stops around the city to push their appeal. UCD students' union campaign and engagement officer Hazen E Griffin has experience of the challenges of finding accommodation as an international student in Dublin. Arriving from the US, Mr Griffin said he was shocked at the housing crisis in Ireland and spent the summer couch-surfing while struggling to find a place to live for the upcoming academic year. It had taken a 'serious' toll on his mental health, he said. 'This is the experience of countless students,' Mr Griffin said. 'This is a last-ditch effort to get some rooms for students who are coming in the next two weeks to study at Irish universities.' Welfare officer Emilia O'Hagan, from Co Down, lived and worked 'upwards of 50 hours a week' in a Dublin boarding school during second year when no other accommodation options were available. 'Looking back, that was a really messed up situation for someone in their second year of college,' she said. 'I was only 19 and basically mothering over 30 children. I was on call all night ... any social life was out the window.' The digs drive 'is quite personal to me', she said, describing how she failed exams due to the demands of her work and living arrangement. Shreyansh Jagtap from Mumbai, India, said living in digs has positively transformed his college experience. Mr Jagtap lives with a family in Ongar, west Dublin, who have rented a room to him for €600 a month for the last year. 'They have kids, so it's like a family for me here. It's giving mental support plus a good space,' he said. One 'perk' of the digs arrangement, he said, has been the home-cooked meals included in the rent. Now the students' union's graduate officer, Mr Jagtap said he has seen how renting in Dublin was '10 times harder' than in Mumbai. 'Mumbai is also expensive, but not this much,' he said.
