Climate-friendly gas claims challenged in landmark ACCC greenwash case
As oil and gas companies talk up their initiatives to shift to less-polluting fuels of the future, the national consumer watchdog wants to draw a line in the sand limiting how far those claims can go.
On Thursday the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) launched a landmark lawsuit alleging millions of Australians were misled by a series of advertisements suggesting the gas that flows into household heaters and stovetops could be 'renewable' within a generation.
Gas distribution company Australian Gas Networks ran an advertising campaign called 'Love Gas' in 2022 and 2023, featuring a father and his young daughter using gas-powered appliances for cooking, heating and bathing.
The advertisement then fast-forwards in time to show the daughter, now an adult, engaging in the same activities.
'Some things will never change, but the flame we use will,' said the voiceover in the ad. 'It's becoming renewable.'
As the gradual switch to all-electric homes threatens to leave billions of dollars of gas pipeline infrastructure as stranded assets, the promise of cleaner fuels – such as gases made from organic waste or hydrogen – being blended with and one day replacing polluting methane gas used in homes and businesses has become one of the industry's main survival plans.
Loading
But renewable gases are not yet commonly used nor available to residential gas customers. The ACCC alleges Australian Gas Networks' advertising overstated the likelihood it could overcome 'significant technological and economic barriers' within the time frame it suggested.
'It is not currently possible to distribute renewable gas at scale and at an economically viable price, and throughout 2022 and 2023 it was highly uncertain whether, and if so, when, this would be possible,' ACCC chair Gina Cass-Gottlieb said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
5 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Labor faces critical 'negotiations' with the Trump Administration to avoid section 899 'revenge tax', WAM Global's lead portfolio manager Catriona Burns declares
Donald Trump's controversial 'revenge tax' will force Australia to bargain with the United States on major points of contention as Labor looks to protect the $4.2 trillion super pool and investment. Section 899 of Trump's 'big beautiful bill' will allow the US to force taxes on nations it believes unfairly treats US firms – such as tech giants Meta and Alphabet. This comes as Australia targets big tech through its media bargaining incentive, while the nation's Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme has also drawn the Trump Administration's ire. If the bill passes, Australians may be forced to pay upwards of 20 per cent more tax on US investments. WAM Global's lead portfolio manager Catriona Burns said the Albanese government will be forced to bargain with the US. 'We give up some of the penalties that we're potentially putting on the tech companies, for example, in exchange for walking back the penalties that would be put on Australia,' Ms Burns said on Business Now. 'There's absolutely negotiation that will still likely go on and we could come to a much more favourable resolution than what is being proposed at this point.' Treasurer Jim Chalmers on Wednesday told reporters he had discussed section 899 with US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and made Australia's case against the looming tax. "We do not want to see our investors and our funds unfairly treated or disadvantaged when it comes to developments out of the US Congress,' the Treasurer said. This comes as Prime Minister Anthony Albanese vowed to protect beef trade, the media bargaining code and the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme after Trump first revealed sweeping "Liberation Day" tariffs. Despite the threats to Australia's super industry and investment returns, Ms Burns argued that investing in the US may still be more beneficial if section 899 of the bill goes through considering the greater potential for returns. 'When you look at the companies, particularly in the tech space for example, that are in America, there (are) still some wonderful businesses to invest in,' she said. 'Some of the best businesses in the world are in the US, so even with this potentially capping the returns that you can generate out of investing in the US, it still may well be the best place to invest. 'Importantly, it may incentivise the companies that you invest in in the US to actually give more back to investors in the form of buybacks rather than dividends.' Many in Australia's $4.2 trillion superannuation system have expressed concerns about diminished returns if the legislation passes as hundreds of billions of dollars of members' funds is invested in the US. AMP's chief economist Shane Oliver earlier this month said section 899 of the bill, alongside other economic policies by the Trump Administration, 'called into question 'US exceptionalism' and its 'safe haven' status'. The Future Fund chair Greg Combet also expressed concerns about the bill where he argued the US was hurting itself by thwarting investment through section 899. 'Section 899 of the Bill will potentially and dramatically escalate tax rates for Australian institutional investors like the Future Fund,' Mr Combet said in a speech to the Committee for Economic Development of Australia earlier this month. 'In combination these policies and dynamics are making the US a more risky and uncertain investment destination.'
The Age
6 hours ago
- The Age
Climate-friendly gas claims challenged in landmark ACCC greenwash case
As oil and gas companies talk up their initiatives to shift to less-polluting fuels of the future, the national consumer watchdog wants to draw a line in the sand limiting how far those claims can go. On Thursday the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) launched a landmark lawsuit alleging millions of Australians were misled by a series of advertisements suggesting the gas that flows into household heaters and stovetops could be 'renewable' within a generation. Gas distribution company Australian Gas Networks ran an advertising campaign called 'Love Gas' in 2022 and 2023, featuring a father and his young daughter using gas-powered appliances for cooking, heating and bathing. The advertisement then fast-forwards in time to show the daughter, now an adult, engaging in the same activities. 'Some things will never change, but the flame we use will,' said the voiceover in the ad. 'It's becoming renewable.' As the gradual switch to all-electric homes threatens to leave billions of dollars of gas pipeline infrastructure as stranded assets, the promise of cleaner fuels – such as gases made from organic waste or hydrogen – being blended with and one day replacing polluting methane gas used in homes and businesses has become one of the industry's main survival plans. Loading But renewable gases are not yet commonly used nor available to residential gas customers. The ACCC alleges Australian Gas Networks' advertising overstated the likelihood it could overcome 'significant technological and economic barriers' within the time frame it suggested. 'It is not currently possible to distribute renewable gas at scale and at an economically viable price, and throughout 2022 and 2023 it was highly uncertain whether, and if so, when, this would be possible,' ACCC chair Gina Cass-Gottlieb said.
Sydney Morning Herald
6 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Climate-friendly gas claims challenged in landmark ACCC greenwash case
As oil and gas companies talk up their initiatives to shift to less-polluting fuels of the future, the national consumer watchdog wants to draw a line in the sand limiting how far those claims can go. On Thursday the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) launched a landmark lawsuit alleging millions of Australians were misled by a series of advertisements suggesting the gas that flows into household heaters and stovetops could be 'renewable' within a generation. Gas distribution company Australian Gas Networks ran an advertising campaign called 'Love Gas' in 2022 and 2023, featuring a father and his young daughter using gas-powered appliances for cooking, heating and bathing. The advertisement then fast-forwards in time to show the daughter, now an adult, engaging in the same activities. 'Some things will never change, but the flame we use will,' said the voiceover in the ad. 'It's becoming renewable.' As the gradual switch to all-electric homes threatens to leave billions of dollars of gas pipeline infrastructure as stranded assets, the promise of cleaner fuels – such as gases made from organic waste or hydrogen – being blended with and one day replacing polluting methane gas used in homes and businesses has become one of the industry's main survival plans. Loading But renewable gases are not yet commonly used nor available to residential gas customers. The ACCC alleges Australian Gas Networks' advertising overstated the likelihood it could overcome 'significant technological and economic barriers' within the time frame it suggested. 'It is not currently possible to distribute renewable gas at scale and at an economically viable price, and throughout 2022 and 2023 it was highly uncertain whether, and if so, when, this would be possible,' ACCC chair Gina Cass-Gottlieb said.
