Promoter's Caution could add random layer of chaos in NASCAR All-Star Race

San Francisco Chronicle​

17-05-2025

The fate of the NASCAR All-Star Race largely rests on the whims of Marcus Smith, who is giving few hints about how he'll deploy a new 'Promoter's Caution.'
It's the latest goofy gimmick in an event defined by annual format changes designed to goose the competition in the name of fender-banging fireworks. At a randomly selected point Sunday night during the first 220 of 250 laps at North Wilkesboro Speedway, a yellow flag will fly and possibly wipe out a big lead while bunching the field for a race-altering restart.
The decision on when to throw the yellow rests solely with Smith, the president and CEO of Speedway Motorsports, which owns the 0.625-mile track in North Wilkesboro, North Carolina.
'I'll have a very special mystery guest with a little All-Star Race history of his own to help me out when it's time to drop the yellow,' Smith said. 'Hopefully, we'll create a little chaos for the teams and some fun for the fans at the same time.'
It's an attempt to restore some luster to the All-Star Race, which has lost touch with its no-holds-barred origins. The past two events at North Wilkesboro produced runaway victories for Kyle Larson and Joey Logano, who led 199 of 200 laps in 2024.
The most memorable event last year came after the race when Ricky Stenhouse Jr. and Kyle Busch engaged in fisticuffs after tangling for a midpack position. It was a far cry from the furious last-lap battles that once sent an All-Star Race winner to the emergency room (Davey Allison suffered a concussion in 1992 after crashing from contact with Kyle Petty at the checkered flag).
The Promoter's Caution won't guarantee a slam-bang ending, but it's in the vein of an exhibition race with $1 million but no points at stake. While other pro sports have struggled to keep all-star events relevant, Cup Series drivers pride themselves on competing as hard as they would in a race with championship implications — and sometimes harder.
'The All Star Race is not just another race,' Joe Gibbs Racing's Christopher Bell said. 'Everybody is more aggressive than a normal Sunday Cup race. Everyone has that win it or wear it attitude, and it races differently because of that.'
A sense of resignation from the All-Star Race's annual format overhauls also makes it easier to accept the inanity of a random yellow.
'I have a hard enough time keeping up with all of the different format stuff,' Team Penske's Austin Cindric said. 'It doesn't really bother me that much that we're going to have a Promoter's Caution because, unless I'm the caution, I can't control it in any way. It's just the racing gods, but maybe they're on earth this time.'
Though its timing could cost him a win, Logano is fine with the Promoter's Caution because 'the All-Star Race presents the opportunity to try things outside of the box.
'I don't think we should have a Promoter's Caution in points-paying events,' he said. 'But in this case, we do something different. It's something everyone can talk about. And I just don't know what they're going to do. Are they going to put Marcus in the flag stand, and he's just going to throw a yellow flag?'
The son of late NASCAR Hall of Famer Bruton Smith, who once lobbied for random yellows as the most bombastic promoter in Cup history, is coy about how the Promoter's Caution will be unveiled.
'I've had no shortage of NASCAR experts from inside and outside of the garage giving me advice on what to do,' Marcus Smith said. 'I've got a couple of scenarios in mind depending on what's happening with the race. Or I could just go spur of the moment with my gut.'
Odds and ends
Christopher Bell (+350) is the BetMGM Sportsbook favorite, followed by pole-sitter Brad Keselowski (+600), Logano (+650), two-time defending Daytona 500 winner William Byron (+700) and Denny Hamlin (+800). Kyle Larson, who will start last after missing practice and qualifying while attempting to make the Indy 500, is listed at +1000. … After sitting essentially dormant for more than 35 years, North Wilkesboro Speedway is playing host to its third consecutive All-Star Race since a $20 million makeover. Keselowski wants to move a points race from Charlotte Motor Speedway's 'Roval' layout to North Wilkesboro Speedway and shift the All-Star Race back to Charlotte's 1.5-mile oval (the host from 1987-2019). 'This needs to be a points racetrack,' Keselowski said of North Wilkesboro. 'I'm very strong about the Roval has got to go.'
___