Former Seanad candidate wants full recount of agricultural panel vote, court hears
Seanad
election candidate wants a full recount of the recent agricultural panel vote in the interest of fairness and transparency, the High Court has heard.
Cllr Angela Feeney, a member of the
Labour Party's
central council and former head of Technological University Dublin's school of languages, law and social sciences, has
brought a High Court petition
challenging the conduct of vote counting for the agricultural panel.
Cllr Feeney, a councillor in Kildare, wants January's election result overturned and a recount ordered.
She was eliminated on the 23rd count by a margin of .116, or one-ninth, of a ballot, missing out on the final seat to Fine Gael's Maria Byrne.
READ MORE
Each valid Seanad ballot paper is deemed to have a value of 1,000 votes. The total valid poll for the 11-seat agricultural panel was 95,667 votes.
Cllr Feeney's case claims there should have been a full recount of the ballots, rather than simply a repeat of the 23rd count. She says her request for a full recount was denied by the returning officer.
On Tuesday, giving evidence at the hearing into her action, Cllr Feeney said she was asking the court to grant the recount in the interest of fairness and transparency. She added that the 'bigger issue' in the case is transparency and public faith in the electoral system.
Cllr Feeney said she was 'surprised' when counting at the count centre began at such a distance that candidates and their teams had no proper sight of the process. Counting continued at a distance of about 7ft away and did not lend itself to 'proper oversight' of the process, as one might expect at local or Dáil election count centres, she said.
Cross-examined by Catherine Donnelly, senior counsel for the returning officer, Cllr Feeney agreed other candidates vying for a seat on the agricultural panel were eliminated by similarly slim margins, less than the value of one ballot paper.
Cllr Feeney said because she was last to be eliminated, she had the potential to be elected. None of the other candidates missed out by virtue of a margin as fine as hers, she said.
Cllr Feeney agreed that her side had not identified any particular error in the count process. She said she believed the error was not allowing the full recount and the lack of transparency.
Ms Donnelly put to Cllr Feeney that the count was visible to candidates. The councillor said the visibility was not adequate.
Asked why she did not raise with the returning officer concerns around transparency when she first arrived at the count centre, Cllr Feeney said it did not seem she and her team had an opportunity to raise such concerns.
Conor Power, senior barrister for Ms Feeney, said the returning officer had discretion in granting a full recount but a number of factors must be considered in exercising that discretion.
In Cllr Feeney's case, those factors included the narrow margin of difference between her and the next candidate, the very small margin of difference on a number of previous counts and the possibility of human error during the count, Mr Power said.
The case continues before Mr Justice Mícheál O'Higgins.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
44 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Race for the Aras – who are the candidates vying to replace Michael D Higgins as the next President of Ireland
THE COUNTRY is set to head to the polls later this year to vote in the next President of Ireland. It comes as Advertisement 2 Michael D. Higgins was first elected President in 2011 Credit: Sportsfile - Subscription The beloved figure was originally inaugurated as president in 2011, and then re-elected in 2018. And as the country gets ready to bid President Higgins a fond farewell, all sights have turned to who will take his place. A While there is a country-wide vote, there are certain criteria a candidate has to meet before making the ballot. Advertisement READ MORE IN NEWS They must be an Irish citizen and 35 years of age or older. You must be nominated by at least 20 members of the Oireachtas, or at least four local authorities. However, former or retiring presidents can nominate themselves. If there is just one candidate nominated they will be elected without a vote, however, that is unlikely to happen this time around. Advertisement Most read in The Irish Sun Exclusive Exclusive INDEPENDENT CANDIDATE Independent TD Catherine Connolly has confirmed she will put herself forward for the presidency. And it is believed she will easily surpass the nomination criteria, meaning we are almost guaranteed to see her name on the ballot this year. Ireland fans blown away by Fiji's 'class gesture' to President Michael D. Higgins moments before rugby clash Brian Stanley, Charles Ward, and Seamus Healy, also independent TDs, have confirmed they will back Catherine's bid. LEFT LEANING CANDIDATE Left-leaning parties could row in behind Deputy Connolly as a combined left-wing contender. Advertisement Labour, who Connolly resigned from in 2007, has explored the prospect of running its own candidate and has opened a two-week consultation period. The Green Party said no decision has been made yet on who could be backed by the party in the election. However, party leader The Galway native has already got the support of the Social Democrats, People Before Profit, and several independents. Advertisement SINN FEIN Sinn Fein's But sources told The Irish Sun they do not believe that Mary Lou is seriously being considered for the party's nomination for the presidency as she still holds the desire to become Ireland's first female Taoiseach. However, deputy leader Pearse Doherty last week denied that floating her as a contender for the presidency was a media game to try to generate headlines. FIANNA FAIL Ex-Minister Mary Hanafin wants to become President of Ireland and last month threw her hat in the ring to become Fianna Fail's candidate. Advertisement She told However, the She could face competition from former And former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern openly flirted with the idea of running as president by not ruling out the prospect during several media interviews. Advertisement FINE GAEL Former EU Commissioner Mairead McGuinness will be in the Aras race. She has been nominated to contest the 2025 Presidential Election this year for In a letter sent to Fine Gael members this week, McGuinness said she expects the election campaign to be "full on." Tanaiste and Fine Gael leader Advertisement 2 Michael D Higgins will say goodbye to Aras an Uachtarain on November 11, 2025 Credit: Alamy
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Catherine Connolly launches presidential bid saying she wants to ‘empower people to find their own voices'
Independent TD Catherine Connolly has launched her bid to become president, saying 'we're at a critical state in our country' and she is standing to 'empower people to find their own voices'. The Galway West TD made the announcement outside Leinster House on Wednesday, flanked by politicians from the Social Democrats and People Before Profit as well as Independents who are set to nominate her to appear on the ballot paper. During a press conference she spoke about her vision for the presidency, defended her record including a trip she took to Syria during dictator Bashar al-Assad's time in power and spoke about her nomination of journalist Gemma O'Doherty for president in 2018. Announcing her election bid, Ms Connolly said: 'I do so with the deep conviction that together, we can make this country better, and that we can make this country live up to its name, the Republic, and show that there is a different way.' READ MORE She said: 'We're at a critical state in our country', and added she was standing 'to enable people, to empower people to find their own voices, to stand up and be counted, to say there is a different way'. Ms Connolly said: 'We must deal with climate change. We must be a voice for peace. We have to stop the normalisation of war and violence. We have to stop the normalisation of homelessness. We have to say that these problems are not inevitable.' She added: 'They are man-made, policy driven, and we can have a different type of country and a different type of world. 'That is what motivates me'. Syria trip Since it emerged last week that she would be throwing her hat in the ring, a trip she took to Syria in 2018 along with then-TDs Clare Daly , Mick Wallace and Maureen O'Sullivan has resurfaced. At the time, al-Assad was still in office and engaged in a brutal civil war. Asked about the visit, she said she funded the trip herself, its purpose was 'fact-finding' with fellow TDs and activists and she 'met no member of government'. She said she visited a refugee camp outside Damascus and 'saw firsthand the destruction of a whole city', adding: 'I mean, my idea, up to then, of a refugee camp wasn't up to scratch really.' Ms Connolly said they were shown around by Palestinians and 'we stayed with them all of the time'. They travelled to Aleppo and met the Chamber of Commerce and also had a meeting with Unicef as well as visiting a convent. Catherine Connolly launching her presidential bid outside the Dáil on Wednesday. Photograph: Alan Betson Catherine Connolly answering questions from members of the media outside the Dáil on Wednesday. Photograph: Alan Betson Catherine Connolly with supporters as she launches her presidential bid outside the Dáil on Wednesday. Photograph: Alan Betson 'On no occasion had I anything to do with the government, nor did I ever utter one word of support for Assad,' she said. Presidential salary The salary for the presidency is approximately €350,000 and the current office-holder Michael D Higgins has waived a portion of it as well as Oireachtas pensions over the course of his two terms. Ms Connolly said she will 'look at the salary' and is 'open to ideas on that' adding: 'I'm certainly going to use it for the common good.' She said she would discuss it with her team and set out how she would use the salary 'in due course'. Northern Ireland On her position in relation to Northern Ireland she said: 'I think we're going to have United Ireland very soon' but it would not be 'immediate'. She said the Belfast Agreement 'has set the framework for that. Tremendous work has been done on the ground, with cross-Border bodies, and I look forward to the day when we have a United Ireland.' Ms Connolly added: 'There must be consent. I absolutely value the diversity, and we must value the different backgrounds in Northern Ireland.' Ms Connolly was among a number of Oireachtas members that indicated they would support Ms O'Doherty's bid to get on the presidential election ballot paper in 2018. Ms O' Doherty was unsuccessful in her attempt to win enough nominations to run and she subsequently became involved in far-right and anti-immigration activism. Ms Connolly said she does not regret making the nomination in 2018 saying Ms O'Doherty 'had done some good work as an investigative journalist.' She added: 'I didn't know her personally, but I knew her role, and I gave her a nomination when the time came. That didn't mean I was supporting her.' Ms Connolly said: 'Do I regret what's happened to the relation to her? Absolutely. Do I support her in any way? Not at all.' Political style Asked about a perception that she has a combative political style, Ms Connolly said she disputed that and said she would 'rephrase' it, adding: 'I think I've been very straight, honest and direct. I think I'm a very hard worker.' 'If as a society we don't value hard work and straight and blunt talking without any spin, then we're in trouble. 'I don't think I've set out to stir things or to be that type of politician.' She pointed to her time as Leas Cheann Comhairle in the last Dáil, saying: 'I've shown that I've been fair, that I'm able to put aside my strong opinion and function as a Leas Cheann Comhairle.' She said: 'I'm a democrat to my fingertips.' Earlier, she told RTÉ Raidió na Gaeltachta's Adhmhaidin programme that she did not make the decision to contest the election overnight and was doubtful enough about the move, but was convinced by correspondence she got from people asking her to run. 'I was taken aback by the support I received, I wasn't expecting that level of support from people across the country, in English and Irish,' she said speaking in Irish. McGuinness nomination On Tuesday, Fine Gael's Mairead McGuinness became the first official nominee in the presidential race to replace Michael D Higgins after his term comes to an end in the autumn. Ms McGuinness, who was a TV presenter and farming journalist before becoming an MEP and EU commissioner, is the nominee to become Fine Gael's presidential candidate. [ Profile: The outspoken left-wing campaigner running for president Opens in new window ] The election to succeed Mr Higgins is set to take place in late October or early November. Prospective candidates need the support of 20 Oireachtas members to get on the ballot paper. Fianna Fáil has not clarified if it will run a candidate and is to make a decision in the early autumn. Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald has also refused to rule herself out of the running. Connolly profile Ms Connolly has received the backing of the Social Democrats and People Before Profit, with the Labour Party 'very seriously' consider backing her. Ms Connolly worked as a barrister and a clinical psychologist before becoming a councillor for 17 years and spending a term as Galway mayor until 2005. She resigned from the Labour Party in 2006 after being turned down to be a running mate of then incumbent TD Mr Higgins. She was first elected to the Dáil as an independent candidate for Galway West in 2016. - Additional reporting PA
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
United Ireland coming ‘very soon', says Catherine Connolly as she launches Presidency campaign with bid to woo Sinn Féin
The Independent Galway TD has promised not to take her full salary as she launched her campaign as a Left candidate Catherine Connolly has launched her Independent campaign for the Presidency, promising not to take her full salary - but looking forward to a United Ireland "very soon". Ms Connolly defended a trip to Syria with Mick Wallace, Clare Daly and Maureen O'Sullivan when dictator Bashir al-Assad was in power, and said she was "right at the time" when she previously backed controversial journalist Gemma O'Doherty for a Presidential run. The Galway West Independent rejected the idea that she was the "continuity candidate" after 14 years of Michael D Higgins, for whom she wanted to be a running mate. She left the Labour Party when that bid was rejected, saying it had lost its soul – but refused to answer questions about taking its money for her campaign, which she believes will cost between €500,000 and €1 million. Ms Connolly, a former leas cheann comhairle, became emotional when she recalled seeing Catholic refugees from Northern Ireland arrive in Galway in the late summer of 1969. 'I think Northern Ireland is extremely important. I think we're going to have united Ireland very soon," Ms Connolly said in response to a suggestion from the Irish Independent that she had been described as a republican socialist. "I think the Good Friday Agreement has set the framework for that," she said, adding that she would welcome the backing of Sinn Féin. "I think tremendous work has been done on the ground with cross-border bodies, and I look forward to the day when we have a united Ireland," Ms Connolly said. But she added: "I absolutely value the diversity, and we must value the different backgrounds in Northern Ireland." Asked whether there was any difference between her position and that of Sinn Féin, she said: "I can tell you my position. You're left to kind to compare and contrast that, which will fail. "But I grew up in Galway and witnessed the refugees coming to Galway. I was young at the time, and they came down, and they were put up in various colleges – and I witnessed their terror, their upset, and their utter desire for peace,' she said. ADVERTISEMENT So far the only other confirmed candidate is former MEP Mairéad McGuinness, who will run for Fine Gael. Neither Fianna Fáil nor Sinn Féin have decided whether they will run a candidate, while Labour is currently deciding whether to back Ms Connolly after she met the party earlier this week. Ms Connolly said she was "fully ready now for the campaign", adding: "We don't have a huge, big machine, and I think we have conviction." So far backed by Independents and the Social Democrats, she said: "We believe in what we're doing, and I think we are happy to put forward that vision." Social Democratic support had "come from the ground up, and I understand it's similar with People Before Profit", Ms Connolly said. She said she was going to discuss the Presidential salary with her team – "There are lots of decisions to make here about the campaign and how I use the salary is one of those.' "All I can say at this point is I have stood as a woman who speaks bluntly and who speaks as honestly as I can." She was asked about the war in Ukraine, and said the Russian invasion was "wrong, illegal and unacceptable", adding "we need to find a voice for diplomacy. We need to get peace." She added, however: "I think could have been prevented beforehand. What they've done is utterly wrong. It's just inexcusable. But I think we could have worked before that in terms of diplomacy." She said her clapping for a live video address by Volodomyr Zelensky to the Dáil had been scrutinised, and how long it had lasted. "I stood and I clapped, and the level of interest from certain quarters in the media was that I didn't clap long enough and I didn't clap hard enough," she said. "I was nauseous at the war. I would have stood in silence." She refused to comment on rival contender Ms McGuinness, except to say: "My views on the Fine Gael party are well-known.' Standing outside Leinster House, Ms Connolly added: "I'm going to be presenting myself as a credible candidate for the Presidency with my views, with my track record, and my work ethic. "That's what I will be presenting before the people, and I would hope the people would respond to that."
