US added to international watchlist for rapid decline in civic freedoms

The Guardian

10-03-2025

The United States has been added to the Civicus Monitor Watchlist, which identifies countries that the global civil rights watchdog believes are currently experiencing a rapid decline in civic freedoms.
Civicus, an international non-profit organization dedicated to 'strengthening citizen action and civil society around the world', announced the inclusion of the US on the non-profit's first watchlist of 2025 on Monday, alongside the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Italy, Pakistan and Serbia.
The watchlist is part of the Civicus Monitor, which tracks developments in civic freedoms across 198 countries. Other countries that have previously been featured on the watchlist in recent years include Zimbabwe, Argentina, El Salvador and the United Arab Emirates.
Mandeep Tiwana, co-secretary general of Civicus, said that the watchlist 'looks at countries where we remain concerned about deteriorating civic space conditions, in relation to freedoms of peaceful assembly, association and expression'.
The selection process, the website states, incorporates insights and data from Civicus's global network of research partners and data.
The decision to add the US to the first 2025 watchlist was made in response to what the group described as the 'Trump administration's assault on democratic norms and global cooperation'.
In the news release announcing the US's addition, the organization cited recent actions taken by the Trump administration that they argue will likely 'severely impact constitutional freedoms of peaceful assembly, expression, and association'.
The group cited several of the administration's actions such as the mass termination of federal employees, the appointment of Trump loyalists in key government positions, the withdrawal from international efforts such as the World Health Organization and the UN Human Rights Council, the freezing of federal and foreign aid and the attempted dismantling of USAid.
The organization warned that these decisions 'will likely impact civic freedoms and reverse hard-won human rights gains around the world'.
The group also pointed to the administration's crackdown on pro-Palestinian protesters, and the Trump administration's unprecedented decision to control media access to presidential briefings, among others.
Civicus described Trump's actions since taking office as an 'unparalleled attack on the rule of law' not seen 'since the days of McCarthyism in the twentieth century', stating that these moves erode the checks and balances essential to democracy.
'Restrictive executive orders, unjustifiable institutional cutbacks, and intimidation tactics through threatening pronouncements by senior officials in the administration are creating an atmosphere to chill democratic dissent, a cherished American ideal,' Tiwana said.
In addition to the watchlist, the Civicus Monitor classifies the state of civic space in countries using five ratings: open, narrowed, obstructed, repressed and closed.
Currently, the US has a 'narrowed' rating, which it also had during the Biden administration, meaning that while citizens can exercise their civic freedom, such as rights to association, peaceful assembly and expression, occasional violations occur.
For part of Trump's first term, Tiwana said, the US had been categorized as 'obstructed', due to the administration's response to the Black Lives Matter protests and restrictive state laws that were enacted limiting the rights of environmental justice protesters, and other actions.
Sign up to Headlines US
Get the most important US headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning
after newsletter promotion
Under Joe Biden, the classification went back to 'narrowed', Tiwana, said, but as of Monday, the US has been placed on the watchlist as the group says it sees 'significant deterioration' in civic freedoms occurring.
Tiwana noted that the US is again seemingly headed toward the 'obstructed' category.
While the Trump administration often say they support fundamental freedoms and individual rights, like free speech, Tiwana believes that the administration seem 'to be wanting to support these only for people who they see as agreeing with them'.
Historically, Tiwana said, the US has been 'considered the beacon of democracy and defense of fundamental freedoms'.
'It was an important pillar of US foreign policy, even though it was imperfect, both domestically and how the US promoted it abroad,' he added.
But Tiwana believes that the recent actions and statements made by this US administration could empower authoritarian regimes around the world, undermine constitutional principles, and embolden those who 'want to accumulate power and increase their wealth and their ability to stay in power for as long as possible'.
Tiwana says that he and the organization want to draw attention to the fact that those in power in the US are, in his view, engaging in a 'zero-sum politics game' that is eroding 'constitutional principles and frankly, engaging in, anti American behavior'.
'We urge the United States to uphold the rule of law and respect constitutional and international human rights norms,' said Tiwana.