‘Noise sensitive' woman loses battle with sisters to keep mum's £420k home for her 'emotional support' dogs
Sharon Duggan claimed the home in Crawley, West Sussex, for herself after mum Agnes passed away in 2018.
4
4
The "hyper-vigilant and sound sensitive" alternative therapist said she needed the house for her therapeutic rescue dogs.
Sharon took her sisters to court after they tried to claim their share in the home, which was left to all three daughters.
Sibling Brenda, who was supported by third sister Ann, fought the case and won after a judge threw out Sharon's claim.
Sharon had used the 1975 Inheritance Act to argue she deserved "reasonable provision" above her one-third share of her mum's money.
She claimed her special sensitivity and medical ailments, which include dyslexia, fibromyalgia, depression, anxiety, insomnia, PTSD, Adjustment Disorder and long Covid, meant she should get at least a life interest in the property.
But while the judge accepted that Sharon has "particular issues," he concluded a flat could not be ruled out as "suitable" accommodation for her.
Central London County Court heard most of Agnes' estate was tied up in her house, where Sharon had lived and cared for her during her final dementia-stricken years.
After Agnes died, the three sisters ended up in court when Sharon refused to move out - citing her acute physical and emotional needs and the plight of her two rescue dogs.
She insisted her problems far outweighed those of her sisters and argued she had "sacrificed" her career to move in and help out her mum in 2014.
Sharon also claimed Agnes was planning to change her will to ensure the house was left to her.
She told the court she spent £30,000 of her own money on funding Agnes' hefty vet bills for her beloved Jack Russell/Chihuahua cross, Lady.
In her written arguments to the court, Sharon insisted that "psychologically she could not cope with living in a flat again".
Her barrister said: "She is anxious that neighbours may cause disturbances and impact upon her ability to sleep.
"She now has two rescue dogs, which help with her mental and emotional well-being, but which makes finding suitable alternative accommodation difficult.
"The claimant maintains that moving from the property would affect her mental health greatly and that having to move into rented or temporary accommodation would further affect her health negatively."
Sharon said she wanted the house transferred to her outright or the right to a life interest.
She also alternatively suggest an order allowing her to buy her mum's old property for a small sum, which would be raised with a mortgage.
But Brenda insisted that Sharon and her pets would be fine in a flat.
Judge Alan Johns said he was "satisfied" there was no promise that the house would go to Sharon alone.
He added: "Given the circumstances in which Sharon occupied the property with Agnes, there's no moral claim strong enough to deprive her sisters of their share of this modest estate."
The ruling means the sisters are each due a third of their mum's estate - although Sharon's share could be wiped out by the court bills for the trial.
4
4
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
28 minutes ago
- BBC News
'Magical' event for Bridgwater boy, four, with rare condition
The mother of a four-year-old boy with a rare genetic disorder has described her shock at the community response to an event designed to make him feel "special". Motorbikes, fire engines, police cars and tractors are among the vehicles set to take part in a drive past for Louie, from Bridgwater, later. He is just one of 100 people diagnosed with XIAP deficiency, which can cause a number of complications including an increased risk of developing infections. His mum Shannon, 29, has organised the event ahead of her family having to isolate in preparation for Louie's second bone marrow transplant this autumn. "Never in a million years did I think it would go this crazy, but it just goes to show [there are] strangers all pulling together to make little boys' day," she said. XIAP deficiency largely affects males due to the genetic mutation affecting the X chromosome and Louie was just four months old when he began to display symptoms of the condition, including a was initially suspected that he had cancer after he was blue-lighted to Bristol Children's Hospital from Musgrove Park in Taunton, Somerset. But after extensive investigations, specialists diagnosed him with the rare genetic condition and he was transferred to the care of Great Ormond Street Hospital in London. It was there that he underwent his first bone marrow transplant in August 2023 which, Shannon said, "didn't go very well" and led to Louie developing a brain infection."He lost all mobility, all speech," she said. "He had to relearn to walk, talk - everything again. He's still delayed globally and he struggles with speech now." Louie faces another bone marrow transplant in October - this time with an increased risk of a similar infection despite being closely monitored. "We've got to keep Louis [isolated] throughout September [...] because obviously they don't want him to go in with any type of infection on board," Shannon this in mind, around three weeks ago she said she had the "wild idea" of setting up a "ride-in" event for Louie and his two older brothers Oscar, 12, and Jenson, eight, whose childhoods have been heavily impacted by what Louie has been through. "I wanted to do something special for all three boys because they've all had a tough ride the past few years and they all know what's to come in October," Shannon said. "With Louis obviously being immune compromised we can't really do much as a family," she added. "He's not allowed to go to busy [places] like theme parks, soft plays, literally anything. "He's mainly been around like family kids and family so just for the two older boys [...] just to have that special day and just to feel a bit normal maybe, to have a bit of a childhood and just included - I think it will just be magical for them all." Vehicles of all sizes and shapes, from classic cars to diggers, have been invited to take part in the event, which will set off from Morganians Rugby Club, along the Kingsdown Estate and finishing at Stogursey Village Hall. With hundreds of people sharing her Facebook post and offers of attendance from the fire service and police, Shannon said the response "means everything". "I'm definitely going to be overwhelmed with emotions and the kindness of people," she added.
BBC News
28 minutes ago
- BBC News
Trawden: 'Our farms are under siege from criminal gangs'
Organised crimes gangs including sheep rustlers and burglars are targeting farmers who have described "living in fear" of a new rural crime Jackson said he had suffered repeated break-ins at his farm in Trawden, Lancashire, with burglars trying to steal quad bikes worth £12,000 as well as his sheep - which can fetch £200 each on the black farmers have told the BBC about joyriders high on drugs driving off in their tractors and pigs being killed with Lancashire Police officer described how organised crime gangs "scope out" farms before stealing from them while sheep have been "slaughtered" at the side of the road. Trawden recently made headlines around world for its kindness - thanks to its residents taking volunteering to the next level - but farmers on its outskirts have said there is a darker side to the Jackson said: "It's a beautiful place but some farmers now live in fear of criminals."We know organised crime is behind it."We've had to increase security with CCTV cameras as we've had several attempted break-ins as they tried to get to the quad bikes." The 38-year-old continued: "They try and rip tiles off the sheds so they can see what's inside."It's worse in bad weather as they know they won't be heard in the wind."There's also quite a bit of sheep rustling. They can get £200 for them on the black market."Crime seems to be getting worse and the police don't seem to be able to do much about it." Dairy farmer Stephanie Gregory, who keeps about 180 cows, has had three Land Rovers and two quad bikes stolen from her 49-year-old said: "It's pretty isolated up here and sometimes when you're out in the dark, you do worry who's watching you."We've had quite a bit stolen and one of our workers came across someone joyriding one of our tractors at night in a field."His eyes were glazed over like he was on drugs and he was going round in circles."Some pigs were also shot dead with crossbows on another farm but thankfully our animals have been kept safe." Walking his dog through the village, leisure centre lifeguard Leighton Wainman, 22, said: "There's not much crime in the village itself as it's pretty quiet."But I know there's problems in the hills."We all heard about the farmer who got nicked. He'd had break-ins at his farm." Last October, a 52-year-old farmer in Trawden took the law into his own hands on his land, tying up two people he accused of drove them four miles to Colne police station but was then arrested for false imprisonment and assault. The farmer was released and the case remains under Jackson said: "I think there might be more incidents of people taking the law into their own hands."Sgt Kevin Day, whose team patrols the area, said criminals from Burnley and Yorkshire have targeted farms to steal items including quad bikes and expensive said: "We know a lot of criminals are travelling into the area and scope out farms."A lot of these guys are using cloned vehicles and they know how to dress to look anonymous."It can be a challenge, but one we rise to every day. We have arrested people who have stolen quad bikes and farm machinery."Farmers do need to report crime as under-reporting is massive in the area."Sgt Day said the effects of sheep rustling were also "huge" for farmers. The officer added: "Sheep can be taken for different reasons."Occasionally we have high numbers taken from a flock that might go into the illegal food market."We have had individual sheep slaughtered and butchered to a very high standard at the side of the road." Listen to the best of BBC Radio Lancashire on Sounds and follow BBC Lancashire on Facebook, X and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
Western Telegraph
29 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Mounjaro prices double as weight loss jab popularity soars
US-based Eli Lilly says a 5mg dose will nearly double from £92 to £180 from September 1, while a 15mg pen will rise from £122 to £330. A Lilly spokesperson said: 'Following a review, Lilly will increase the UK list price for Mounjaro (tirzepatide) from 1 September to address pricing inconsistencies compared to other developed countries, including in Europe. We have reached an agreement with the NHS to ensure continued supply and patient access." The statement continues: 'While Lilly does not determine the prices that private healthcare providers set, we are working with them to maintain patient access. The UK was one of the first countries where Lilly launched Mounjaro, and our priority was to bring it to patients as quickly as possible during a time of limited supply of GLP-1 RA treatments for type 2 diabetes. 'At launch, Lilly agreed to a UK list price that is significantly below the European average to prevent delays in NHS availability." More than 1.5 million people in the UK are believed to be using weight-loss medication each month, with most buying the jabs from private pharmacies. Mounjaro users report surprising side effect - pharmacists share their tips — Bucks Free Press (@bucksfreepress) August 8, 2025 This comes as the Government has joined forces with Eli Lilly in a bid to tackle obesity. The move could see patients accessing care at pharmacies or by using online platforms. The £85 million programme from Eli Lilly and the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) has been designed to look at how obese patients can access weight management care more easily. This includes through community services, in pharmacies and online. Using these tools, eligible patients could be treated 'in a matter of months', according to Health Secretary Wes Streeting. Under the agreement, the Government will contribute up to £50 million in UK-wide investment. Meanwhile, Eli Lilly will back the programme with £35 million, and NHS organisations will be able to apply for a share of the funding. Recommended reading: Mounjaro warning as pens ruined by heatwave temperatures This comes as users are risking having to throw away perfectly good Mounjaro pens as they have overheated in the recent heatwave. Improper storage of Ozempic, Wegovy and Mounjaro during a heatwave could destroy the active ingredient in these jabs, potentially wiping out their effects entirely, even if the medication looks completely normal. 'We recommend treating your weight-loss pen the same way you'd treat insulin or any critical medication,' says Danielle Brightman, Clinical Director at Numan. 'When in doubt, don't risk it. Speak to a healthcare professional and arrange a replacement.' 8 tips to protect Mounjaro and other weight-loss injections during hot weather Use a medical-grade cool bag. Transport your pen in a proper, insulated container designed for sensitive medications. Don't use improvised ice packs that might freeze the pen by accident. Never leave your pen in hot places. Even 10 minutes in a parked car or on a sunny kitchen counter could expose it to damaging heat if out of its delivery packaging or unrefrigerated. Always check the environment before setting it down. Store below 30°C once in use. Once opened and if not refrigerated, keep your pen in a shaded, ventilated area, away from heat sources, windows, and radiators. If you live in a flat or home without air conditioning, keep the pen in a bedroom or hallway that doesn't heat up from direct sun. Avoid storing near exterior walls if the property retains heat. Follow the usage timeline carefully. The storage instructions between medications. Wegovy after first use can last 6 weeks below 30 degrees then needs to be disposed of, whereas Mounjaro has a shorter time of 30 days below 30 degrees before needing to be disposed of. Stick to that timeframe, and if you're unsure whether it's still safe, consult your provider. Use a fridge thermometer at home. Fridge temperatures can fluctuate, especially in older models or over-packed shelves. A simple digital fridge thermometer can help ensure your pen is always stored between 2–8°C before first use. Planning to travel? Use airline-friendly cooling cases. If you're flying or taking long journeys, consider TSA-approved insulated medication pouches with cooling gel packs. Always store the pen in carry-on luggage, not checked baggage, as cargo holds can get hot or cold. Set storage reminders on your phone. If you're prone to forgetting where you left your pen, set daily reminders to check if it's stored properly, especially during heatwaves or while travelling. Don't store near appliances or steam sources. Keep pens away from kettles, toasters, ovens, dishwashers, and anywhere that might experience sudden heat or humidity, especially in small kitchens or shared spaces. Injections like Ozempic, Wegovy, and Mounjaro are now widely used across the UK for appetite control and sustainable weight management. But despite their growing popularity and increasing availability now through the NHS, most patients don't realise the strict temperature guidelines that must be followed to keep these drugs effective. 'We speak to patients every day who are using GLP-1s for the first time,' says Danielle. 'With temperatures set to soar again this summer, it's crucial we raise awareness about safe medication storage. Heat damage isn't always obvious, but it can have a huge impact on effectiveness and safety."
