logo
‘Noise sensitive' woman loses battle with sisters to keep mum's £420k home for her 'emotional support' dogs

‘Noise sensitive' woman loses battle with sisters to keep mum's £420k home for her 'emotional support' dogs

The Sun7 days ago

A WOMAN has lost a court fight with her sisters to keep their mum's £420,000 home for her "emotional support" dogs.
Sharon Duggan claimed the home in Crawley, West Sussex, for herself after mum Agnes passed away in 2018.
4
4
The "hyper-vigilant and sound sensitive" alternative therapist said she needed the house for her therapeutic rescue dogs.
Sharon took her sisters to court after they tried to claim their share in the home, which was left to all three daughters.
Sibling Brenda, who was supported by third sister Ann, fought the case and won after a judge threw out Sharon's claim.
Sharon had used the 1975 Inheritance Act to argue she deserved "reasonable provision" above her one-third share of her mum's money.
She claimed her special sensitivity and medical ailments, which include dyslexia, fibromyalgia, depression, anxiety, insomnia, PTSD, Adjustment Disorder and long Covid, meant she should get at least a life interest in the property.
But while the judge accepted that Sharon has "particular issues," he concluded a flat could not be ruled out as "suitable" accommodation for her.
Central London County Court heard most of Agnes' estate was tied up in her house, where Sharon had lived and cared for her during her final dementia-stricken years.
After Agnes died, the three sisters ended up in court when Sharon refused to move out - citing her acute physical and emotional needs and the plight of her two rescue dogs.
She insisted her problems far outweighed those of her sisters and argued she had "sacrificed" her career to move in and help out her mum in 2014.
Sharon also claimed Agnes was planning to change her will to ensure the house was left to her.
She told the court she spent £30,000 of her own money on funding Agnes' hefty vet bills for her beloved Jack Russell/Chihuahua cross, Lady.
In her written arguments to the court, Sharon insisted that "psychologically she could not cope with living in a flat again".
Her barrister said: "She is anxious that neighbours may cause disturbances and impact upon her ability to sleep.
"She now has two rescue dogs, which help with her mental and emotional well-being, but which makes finding suitable alternative accommodation difficult.
"The claimant maintains that moving from the property would affect her mental health greatly and that having to move into rented or temporary accommodation would further affect her health negatively."
Sharon said she wanted the house transferred to her outright or the right to a life interest.
She also alternatively suggest an order allowing her to buy her mum's old property for a small sum, which would be raised with a mortgage.
But Brenda insisted that Sharon and her pets would be fine in a flat.
Judge Alan Johns said he was "satisfied" there was no promise that the house would go to Sharon alone.
He added: "Given the circumstances in which Sharon occupied the property with Agnes, there's no moral claim strong enough to deprive her sisters of their share of this modest estate."
The ruling means the sisters are each due a third of their mum's estate - although Sharon's share could be wiped out by the court bills for the trial.
4
4

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Good Morning Britain's Kate Garraway rushed to hospital on Dr Hilary's orders after 'searing chest pain and vomiting' sparked heart attack fears
Good Morning Britain's Kate Garraway rushed to hospital on Dr Hilary's orders after 'searing chest pain and vomiting' sparked heart attack fears

Daily Mail​

time41 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Good Morning Britain's Kate Garraway rushed to hospital on Dr Hilary's orders after 'searing chest pain and vomiting' sparked heart attack fears

Good Morning Britain 's Kate Garraway was once rushed to hospital on Dr Hilary's orders over heart attack fears. The TV presenter and broadcaster, 58, opened up about the concerning moment that happened in the midst of caring for her late husband Derek. She revealed in The Sun how she 'woke up with searing chest pain' one morning on the way to work on ITV 's Good Morning Britain. 'I could barely move, but I forced myself into the car. On the way in, I threw up,' she said. Kate added: 'By the time I arrived at the studio, something was clearly wrong. Dr Hilary told the producers to call an ambulance.' From A-list scandals and red carpet mishaps to exclusive pictures and viral moments, subscribe to the DailyMail's new Showbiz newsletter to stay in the loop. Dr Hilary Jones is a well-known TV doctor and resident GP on the daily news programme. When Kate arrived at the hospital, medics were concerned she might be suffering from a heart attack. 'Instead of going on air, I was in hospital, wired to machines, with doctors fearing a heart attack,' the presenter revealed. She was instead diagnosed with a 'heart event' which was put down to the prolonged toll the 24 hour care she provided for her late husband had on her own body. Kate revealed there were 'other signs' of the stress she was experiencing too including 'missed appointments' and her autoimmune thyroid condition worsening. Derek died at the age of 56 in January 2024 following a four-year battle with long Covid. He was diagnosed with coronavirus as Britain moved towards its first national lockdown during the first weeks of the pandemic. The virus ravaged his body and left him in a life-threatening condition, with doctors putting him in a medically induced coma and on a ventilator during his 13-month stay in hospital. She was instead diagnosed with a 'heart event' which was put down to the prolonged toll the 24 hour care she provided for her late husband had on her own body Kate recalled being taken to hospital in her book, The Strength Of Love, in 2023. She said: 'There was a searing pain in my chest — as though someone had punched their fist through my breastbone, snatched hold of my heart and squeezed. 'The pain was sharp and excruciating. Then I realised that it wasn't a sudden onset of pain. It had been there all the time. My temporary paralysis had ­distracted me. 'Then came the thought, "Oh God, was I having a heart attack?". But why was my body reacting like this? 'Could I be so desperate to help Derek that I'd started having ­sympathy pains?' She then threw up on the way to work and was taken to A&E when she arrived at the studios. After conducting tests a cardiologist ruled out a heart attack as a possible cause before doctor let her go home. She also told how she burst into tears when the doctor recognised her and said she was an inspiration, before telling him: 'I'm not doing any good for ­anybody.' Kate has been busy juggling a hectic work schedule, as the true extent of her debts are revealed. She has openly discussed how she has been left with debts between £500,000 and £800,000 after caring for her late husband Derek. As well as tackling debts related to the £16,000 a month costs for his care, a new liquidator's report has revealed the large tax costs that are yet to be paid by Derek's now-defunct psychotherapeutic company Astra Aspera. The company, which was jointly controlled by Kate, went bust owing hundreds of thousands of pounds to creditors, including a large bill to HMRC. Kate has been busy promoting her various work projects as her debts loom over her but it's not the first time the broadcaster has had to deal with financial woes. In 2012, two other firms jointly controlled by Derek and Kate went bust. Fulfill Media Ltd had debts totalling £922,807, which included £88,486 owed to HMRC, £90,882 to trade creditors, and £462,808 in 'third party loans'. At the same time, Countrymouse Media Ltd, was liquidated owing £189,121, which included £98,944 to the taxman and £48,000 on an overdrawn directors loan account. Derek and Kate were both personally owed £24,000 each by the business. In January 2024, it was reported that Kate may have to sell the home to repay her current debts with one source saying: 'It has cost hundreds of thousands of pounds to look after Derek and do everything she could to get him better but it's left her struggling.' But hard-working Kate has been on a self-promotion blitz amid her latest financial woes. Alongside her regular GMB work, the star plugged her Smooth Radio show this week, revealing she was 'chuffed' that the lunchtime show now reached 2.8million listeners. She has also been teasing her signing in perhaps one of the most anticipated TV shows of year - Celebrity Traitors. Along with the likes of Stephen Fry, Alan Carr and Jonathan Ross Kate headed to Scotland a few weeks ago to film the spin off of the smash hit BBC series. Meanwhile, in February she was announced as the host of a new Dubai-set podcast and YouTube series - DXB Unheard. Each of the eight episodes, which are released weekly, feature interviews with Emiratis and Dubai residents 'who have left an indelible mark on the city.' She filmed the series last year and has admitted that she found it 'interesting' to learn about how people lived their lives at a time when she was contemplating her future plans. Kate previously revealed that Derek's £16,000-a-month care costs eclipsed her GMB salary, admitting in a 2023 interview that she couldn't even afford to have the heating on in October. Speaking before her husband's death, Kate said: 'Derek's care costs more than my salary from ITV and that is before you pay for a mortgage, before you pay any household bills, before you pay for anything for the kids, so we are at a crunch point. 'I am in debt. I can't earn enough money to cover my debt because I am managing Derek's care and I can't even use the money I do have to support Derek's recovery, because it's going on the basics all the time.'

‘Take back the small moments and replenish your mind'
‘Take back the small moments and replenish your mind'

Telegraph

timean hour ago

  • Telegraph

‘Take back the small moments and replenish your mind'

Making the most of every waking moment is an intrinsic part of the expert advice Dr Julie Smith shares in her bestselling books and online, and it's a theme that is also at the heart of Anita Rani's new podcast, Bright Ideas with Anita Rani, in partnership with EE. Dr Smith, a clinical psychologist-turned-online educator with over 7 million subscribers, as well as author of the instant bestseller Open When, has spent years honing her expertise when it comes to mental wellbeing. One of her tips for cultivating everyday moments of joy is that happiness can be as simple as being outside in nature or playing board games with family: 'Ritual helps you slow down for a minute, as does just focusing on enjoying it,' she says. This is especially important when the urge to doomscroll through a feed full of negativity can drag us down. She tells Anita that we need to realise our limitations and reclaim the control that has over our lives: 'There's a lot we can't control but we can learn to tolerate what we can't change. You could absorb negativity non-stop but instead aim to turn suffering and uncertainty into something that matters.' She also provides Anita with some essential life hacks that can fill each day with quick wins. 'The Calm app helps everyone practise mindfulness, as do my videos,' she says 'Therapy isn't rocket science and living curiously means you're always learning. Take back those small micro moments during the day… and replenish your mind.' For all of Dr Smith's tips, life hacks, insights and stories, catch the latest episode of Bright Ideas with Anita Rani on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music or wherever you get your podcasts. Episodes are released weekly on Wednesdays.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store