‘Gone Girl' kidnap hoaxer Sherri Papini now claims she really WAS abducted by ex & didn't tell cops truth for key reason
Keith Papini quickly took measures to find the 34-year-old mum of two, tracing her phone to her last location and driving straight there, but his panic soon turned to horror when he found her phone lying on the side of the road.
Advertisement
7
Sherri Papini was kidnapped while ona run in 2016
7
Local residents and church groups came out in their hundreds to bring her home
Credit: Social Media - Refer to Source
7
Her husband begged for the mum to come home and apologised for not being able to find her
Credit: AP
It was November 2nd, 2016, in California, and Keith, who was the prime suspect in her disappearance at the time for police, was doing the media rounds begging for his wife's return to him and their two children.
'If she is listening, I want to say, 'We are trying. We are trying the best we can, and I am sorry I'm not there,' he said in a tearful interview.
'I'm doing everything I can, and I love you.'
News
of the disappearance dominated the news across the world, as hundreds of local residents took time out of their lives to find the mum and bring her home.
Advertisement
READ MORE REAL LIFE STORIES
Three weeks later, on Thanksgiving, Sherri was miraculously discovered 150 miles away from her home running across a church car park with a chain around her waist.
Her hands were zip-tied together, her body was bruised and burned, her nose was broken, and she had been branded with a hot iron.
Sherri spent weeks with police going over the details of her kidnapping, claiming two Hispanic women had taken her and put her in a small dark room, beating her and starving her until the abductors had an argument and one decided to release Sherri.
Her memory was foggy, and the trauma she endured seemed severe, as she recounted the incident to police, her husband stood by her every step of the way.
Advertisement
Most read in Fabulous
Sherri claimed to have overheard a conversation about a 'buyer', implying the two women intended to sell her into sex trafficking.
It seemed like a miracle that Sherri was let go, considering the extent of the abuse she endured, and law enforcement was quick to hunt for the perpetrators as they feared it was part of a larger pattern of human trafficking.
7
Sherri was eventually found in a car park with a broken nose and letters branded into her skin
Credit: Facebook
Sherri Papini admits she's 'embarrassed' she staged kidnapping during tearful police interrogation
7
She spend two years telling the police of her abduction, but it all turned out to be a lie
Credit: ABC
Advertisement
Web of lies
But after years of dead ends, the two women were never caught, in fact, they
Now, 42, Sherri has been dubbed the real life 'Gone Girl' after faking her own kidnapping to run away with her ex-partner.
In 2020 police found DNA on her clothes that matched with her ex James Reyes.
She knew what she was doing in that moment. And to this day, I remember that time, and it hurts. I'll forever remember that.
Keith Papini
Sherri's Husband
When they tracked him down, he was quick to reveal that Sherri had asked him to pick her up at a staged abduction site, then to take her back to his home in Costa Mesa, hundreds of miles down the coast.
Advertisement
She'd even asked him to help her injure herself to bolster her kidnapping claims by branding her and holding a
hockey
stick up so she could run into it and break her nose.
Sherri's 'Gone Girl' Timeline
2 November 2016:
Sherri Papini was reported missing after failing to return from a jog near her home in Mountain Gate, California. She also missed picking up her children from daycare.
24 November 2016 (Thanksgiving Day):
Papini was found around 146 miles away in Yolo County, near Woodland, California. She was discovered with injuries and restraints, claiming she had been abducted by two Hispanic women.
August 2020:
Papini was interviewed by a federal agent and a Shasta County Sheriff's detective, where she continued to maintain her story of being kidnapped by two Hispanic women.
3 March 2022:
Sherri Papini was arrested on charges of making false statements to federal law enforcement and mail fraud. Authorities revealed she had been staying with a former boyfriend in Costa Mesa, California, and had inflicted injuries on herself.
April 2022:
Papini signed a plea agreement.
19 September 2022:
Sherri Papini was sentenced to 18 months in prison, followed by 36 months of supervised release. She was also ordered to pay $309,902 in restitution.
8 November 2022:
Papini reported to federal prison at the Victorville Federal Correctional Complex in Adelanto, California, to begin serving her 18-month sentence.
James was never tried for a connection to the crime and three weeks after he 'kidnapped' Sherri, she wanted to return home as she missed her kids.
Before dropping her off, Sherri asked him to brand her with the word 'EXODUS' using a wood burning tool.
Looking back, Keith reveals the heartbreak he felt when his wife Sherri came home, telling him, 'I have to live with the fact that you never found me.'
Advertisement
'I remember I was pleading with her,' Keith says now. 'Like, 'I did everything I could, I'm so sorry you had to go through that.''
'She knew what she was doing in that moment. And to this day, I remember that time, and it hurts. I'll forever remember that.'
Sherri was ultimately charged with 34 counts of mail fraud and one count of making false statements in 2022, and spent ten months in jail.
Her husband, Keith, divorced her soon after she was sentenced and has custody of the children.
Advertisement
7
This is the moment police told Sherri they knew she had lied about the entire ordeal
Credit: The Mega Agency
Bold new claims
Now, Sherri has claimed all is not as it seems in a new Investigation Discovery's docuseries, Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie.
"Haven't you ever lied? And then, has the lie been blown up?" Sherri said in the trailer.
"I went missing in 2016, was gone for 22 days. I was tortured; I was branded; I was chained to a wall. All that is true. I did keep some secrets from you, though."
Advertisement
Now, the mum-of-two claims she was in fact kidnapped by her lover James Reyes but made up the two Hispanic women as she was terrified about what her husband would do if he found out about the affair.
"I was concealing an affair from my husband, who (was) threatening to take everything from me if he found out that I was having any involvement with another man," she said.
Now she claims she went to meet James to break things off, but alleges he soon turned violent.
"I remember waking up briefly in the back of the vehicle and not being able to even keep my eyes open," she said.
Advertisement
She claims the
next
thing she knew it was dark and she was being carried out of the car into a house.
"I just remember thinking, 'This is not where I'm supposed to be. I'm supposed to be picking my kids up from day care. I am not supposed to be here,'" she adds.
"The injuries that occurred… the bites on my thigh, the footprint on my back, the brand, the melting of my skin — I am telling you there was no consent."
Sherri alleges that James then had her chained up to a pole inside his home so she could not escape.
Advertisement
'I wanted to leave,' Sherri claimed. 'So I tried to pull one of the boards off the window and James came in and hit me in the face. And that's the first bruise that I got ... And after being knocked out and waking up, that's when the chain was around my waist, secured with a padlock attached to a cable that was attached to a pole in the closet.'
Every injury, every incident, the description of the room down to every last bit of fragment, was not a lie.
Sherri Papini
Just before she 'escaped,' Sherri says she had a conversation with James, who agreed to let her go on the condition she lied about what really happened and blamed two Hispanic women for the abduction.
Her claims continued: 'James had let me off the chain.
"I said, my husband's going to find me. He's never going to stop looking for you ... You need to let me go. He was like, 'Well, there's too much has happened.'
Advertisement
"So it all came down to me. It all came down to my cover-up, and that's [when] I agreed to ... make up that someone else did it.'
"I lied about James' identity. I lied about the man who abducted me to keep him a secret," she said in the docuseries. James denies these claims.
"It wasn't the right choice and I know that... I wish I would've told the truth from the day I was in the hospital — that it was James," she continued.
7
Now, she shares her side of the story and says it's not all as it seems
Credit: YouTube/investigationdiscovery
Advertisement
"I wasn't thinking about my neighbor that was searching for me. I wasn't thinking about the churches that were lighting candlelit vigils," she continued. "I was thinking about myself."
"Every injury, every incident, the description of the room down to every last bit of fragment, was not a lie," she adds.
Mother knows best?
Keith, who has full custody of the children they share, was accused by Sherri throughout the show of being abusive; he heavily denies these claims.
And it seems even Sherri's own mum doesn't believe her new story.
Advertisement
Speaking to the filmmakers, Loretta Graeff said: "No, it wasn't a kidnapping."
"My daughter was very, very unhappy in her marriage. She wanted some kind of happiness.
"When he showed up and Sherri went with him, it wasn't a kidnapping, it was more 'I want to have a little bit of happiness in my life because it's been very, very hard.'"
"She needed to get away from him and she didn't abandon her children," Graeff told
Advertisement
Where is Sherri now?
Sherri was
released from prison
in August 2023 and transferred to a residential reentry facility in Sacramento County, California.
She
left the home
that October — eight months early — and will remain on supervised release until late 2026.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Brent Hinds dead aged 51: Lead guitarist of heavy metal band Mastodon killed in horror motorcycle crash with SUV
He was rushed to the hospital after being found unresponsive ROCKER GONE Brent Hinds dead aged 51: Lead guitarist of heavy metal band Mastodon killed in horror motorcycle crash with SUV THE former lead guitarist for the popular heavy metal band Mastodon has tragically died in an overnight bike crash. William Brent Hinds, 51, was riding his Harley Davidson when a BMW SUV crashed into him near Boulevard, Atlanta. 2 William Brent Hinds performs in concert in Madrid, Spain. 2 Heavy Metal band Mastodon performing live at Mayhem Fest 2013 The musician, who co-founded the band in 2000, was rushed to the hospital after being found unresponsive. The Fulton County medical examiner's office confirmed his death, Atlanta News First reports. Atlanta Police Department said: "Officers located an unresponsive male who was involved in the collision. "The male appeared to be operating a Harley Davidson during the time of the collision. "Preliminary investigation indicates the male was travelling West on Boulevard. "The female operating the BMW SUV failed to yield while turning left and collided into the male victim who was operating the Harley Davidson." Brent Hinds founded the heavy metal band with bassist Troy Sanders, guitarist Bill Kelliher and drummer Brann Dailor. The band's 2002 debut album, Remission, garnered significant critical acclaim for its unique sound. Brent Hinds left the band earlier this year in March. More to follow... For the latest news on this story, keep checking back at The U.S. Sun, your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, sports news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures, and must-see videos. Like us on Facebook at TheSunUS and follow us on X at @TheUSSun
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Appeal court throws out massive civil fraud penalty against Donald Trump
An appeal court has thrown out a massive civil fraud penalty against Donald Trump in a New York state lawsuit accusing him of exaggerating his wealth. The decision came seven months after the Republican returned to the White House. A panel of five judges in New York's mid-level Appellate Division said the verdict, which stood to cost the president more than 515 million dollars (£382 million) and rock his property empire, was 'excessive'. After finding that Mr Trump engaged in fraud by flagrantly padding financial statements that went to lenders and insurers, Judge Arthur Engoron ordered him last year to pay 355 million dollars (£263 million) in penalties. With interest, the sum has topped 515 million dollars. The total — combined with penalties levied on some other Trump Organisation executives including Mr Trump's sons Eric and Donald Jr — now exceeds 527 million dollars (£391 million), with interest. Judge Arthur Engoron (Shannon Stapleton/AP) 'While the injunctive relief ordered by the court is well crafted to curb defendants' business culture, the court's disgorgement order, which directs that defendants pay nearly half a billion dollars to the State of New York, is an excessive fine that violates the Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution,' Judges Dianne T Renwick and Peter H Moulton wrote in one of several opinions shaping the appeals court's ruling. Judge Engoron had also imposed other punishments, such as banning Mr Trump and his two eldest sons from serving in corporate leadership for a few years. Those provisions have been on pause during the appeal, and Mr Trump was able to hold off collection of the money by posting a 175 million dollar (£130 million) bond. The court, which was split on the merits of the lawsuit and the lower court's fraud finding, dismissed the penalty Judge Engoron imposed in its entirety while leaving a pathway for further appeals to the state's highest court, the Court of Appeals. The appeals court, the Appellate Division of the state's trial court, took an unusually long time to rule, weighing Mr Trump's appeal for nearly 11 months after oral arguments last autumn. Normally, appeals are decided in a matter of weeks or a few months. New York attorney general Letitia James, who brought the suit on the state's behalf, has said the businessman-turned-politician engaged in 'lying, cheating and staggering fraud'. The president and his co-defendants denied wrongdoing. In a six-minute summation of sorts after a months-long trial, Mr Trump said in January last year that he was 'an innocent man' and the case was a 'fraud on me'. He has repeatedly maintained that the case and verdict were political moves by Ms James and Judge Engoron, who are both Democrats. The Justice Department has subpoenaed Ms James for records related to the lawsuit, among other documents, as part of an investigation into whether she violated the president's civil rights. New York attorney general Letitia James (Yuki Iwamura/AP) Her lawyer Abbe D Lowell has said that investigating the fraud case is 'the most blatant and desperate example of this administration carrying out the president's political retribution campaign'. Mr Trump and his lawyers said his financial statements were not deceptive because they came with disclaimers noting they had not been audited. The defence also noted that bankers and insurers independently evaluated the numbers and the loans were repaid. Despite such discrepancies as tripling the size of his Trump Tower penthouse, he said the financial statements were, if anything, low estimates of his fortune. During an appellate court hearing in September, the president's lawyers said many of the case's allegations were too old, a claim they made unsuccessfully before trial. The defence also says Ms James misused a consumer protection law to sue Mr Trump and improperly policed private business transactions that were satisfactory to those involved. State attorneys said the law in question applies to fraudulent or illegal business conduct, whether it targets everyday consumers or big corporations. Though Mr Trump insists no one was harmed by the financial statements, the state says the numbers led lenders to make riskier loans than they knew, and that honest borrowers lose out when others boost their net-worth numbers. The state has argued that the verdict rested on ample evidence and that the scale of the penalty comported with Mr Trump's gains, including his profits on properties financed with the loans and the interest he saved by getting favourable terms offered to wealthy borrowers. The civil fraud case was one of several legal obstacles for Mr Trump as he campaigned, won and started a second term as president.
The Journal
3 hours ago
- The Journal
How to spot a scam if you see an ad for discount clothes on social media
AS PART OF a new investigation, The Journal Investigates has uncovered almost 100 websites that have falsely presented themselves as legitimate Irish stores, as well as hundreds more targeting users in at least 14 other countries. These pages masquerading as Irish shops have posted more than 50,000 ads on Facebook between them, potentially targeting millions of social media users. The websites use the same methods to trick customers around the world into buying what they think are high-end goods that are actually much flimsier items that tend to come from Asia – if they arrive at all. There are five things you can ask yourself to make sure the shop you're buying from is legitimate. Although the methods that are outlined here can be enough to tell a scam website on their own, we recommend using a few of them in combination to be absolutely sure. — Investigations like this don't happen without your support… Impactful investigative reporting is powered by people like you. Support The Journal Investigates 1. What does the company's website tell you? Scam fashion websites are taking increasing steps to mimic real businesses, right down to including information like opening hours, physical addresses and contact details. Some even go to the trouble of writing touching backstories on the 'About Us' section of their websites, and claim that they're decades-old companies or much-loved family businesses. But these are the kinds of details that can sometimes reveal the website isn't what it claims to be. If a website lists a specific, real-world address, you can use Google Maps to see if the company really exists where it claims to be located; even if it only names a street, you can check along the street to see if there are any businesses with that name based there. Google Street View can also help with this: if you can't find a shop at the address using Google Maps, you can double-check using the street view function to make sure it's not there – sometimes legitimate businesses don't actually appear on Google Maps. If a shop doesn't appear on Google Maps, and the street view function shows something like a house or an office where the company listed its address, it's a sign that it's a scam or fraudulent drop-shipping business. Another tool you can use is government-run company registration databases. Irish-based businesses will usually register with the Companies Registration Office (CRO), which incorporates companies in Ireland and is where they file their annual returns. The CRO helpfully has a search function called Core that allows people to look up companies that are registered in Ireland. If the company you're buying from claims to be Irish – like a supposed family-run business or a high street store – but you can't find it on the CRO, then it's best to treat it with caution. Companies House, the UK equivalent to the CRO, has a similar function that allows people to search for businesses that are registered in the North or across the water. So if the shop you're looking at claims to be based in the UK, but you can't find any mention of it on the Companies House website, you should also be careful about ordering from it. Advertisement And some drop-shopping websites and social media pages will occasionally include landline phone numbers. If you've taken the steps above and you're still unsure about whether a business is real or fake, you can always give them a ring and see what happens. Products listed on fraudulent drop-shipping websites can likewise provide clues that the page is a scam. One thing we've noticed about these websites is that the sale prices on almost all items tend to end in the same two digits (though never .99 or .00); for example, items that sell for €25.95, €44.95 and €71.95. This would be unusual for a legitimate business to do, even if it's selling items as part of a wider sale event, so if you see this happening (particularly if the sale price doesn't end in .99 or .00) then watch out. Items for sale on a website called Vellor Dublin - the price format includes a comma, which is not standard for Irish retailers 2. Can social media pages provide any clues? In a lot of cases, shoppers will come across these websites on social media, particularly in the form of sponsored posts (AKA ads) on Facebook or Instagram that announce discounts or closing down sales. These posts usually link to third-party websites that look like they belong to normal shops, and might show examples of the products they're selling. They often convey a sense of urgency to make people want to click into them and leave social media without checking out the page that's running the ad. But even just a 30-second look at some of these pages can be enough to show they're not genuine. If you click into a Facebook page that's running ads, and it has just a handful of followers and only one or two posts, that's a big indication that it's a fake profile. The 'About' tab can also be helpful: if you click on it, you might find some contact and other basic information (like a location or phone number) about the business that isn't on its website, and you can repeat the steps from the section above. It's not uncommon for scammers to leave major clues here by accident; for example, the Facebook page might be for a shop that says it's in Dublin, but the 'About' tab actually shows a map that says it's in Vietnam or provides a phone number that clearly isn't Irish. But even bigger indications that a page is a scam can be found under the 'Page Transparency' section, which you'll also find in the 'About' tab. Here's where to find the 'Page Transparency' tab on Facebook If you go there and click the 'See All' button, it will tell you if a page has recently been set up and (often, but not always) if it's changed names before and where its administrators are based. It's probably safe to say that if a page has recently been set up or changed names – especially if it used to be called something completely different – or if it has admins in a country that isn't where it says it's based, it doesn't belong to a legitimate business. You can also find similar information about Instagram pages – just look for the 'About this account' button, and it'll tell you where a profile is based, how long ago it was set up, and how many times it's changed names. 3. Are the same images being used elsewhere? It won't seem obvious to anyone browsing just one website, but a lot of scam websites tend to sell similar products that use the same images. It's actually one of the biggest giveaways that these websites are fraudulent. High street retailers and smaller businesses will generally use their own photographers and/or design agencies for the pictures of products they're selling online; if a business is legitimate, you almost certainly wouldn't see photos of its products being used elsewhere. Thankfully, there are a number of free online tools that you can use to check this. Related Reads 'Never order off this site': Massive web of fake shops targeting Irish Facebook users uncovered Google has its own reverse image search function that allows you to upload an image to see where else it might appear on the internet. To use it, screenshot or save the photo of the product; then go to Google, click the camera symbol that's to the right of the search bar, upload a photo, and check by 'exact matches'. You can also use Google Lens, which is a version of the same tool, if you're browsing via Chrome on a desktop or using an Android phone; again, just screenshot or save the image and search via this tool (or you can right-click and use it like that if you're on a desktop). The same image of a woman in a coat on two seemingly unconnected websites, Ruby & Maeve Kerry and Oliver Harrison London A similar tool called TinEye also allows you to search via an image you've saved, and also via the URL (the link beginning to see if an image will show up elsewhere; to do the latter hold (if on mobile) or right-click (if on desktop) the image you want to search, and copy the link address, then paste it into TinEye. We advise that you try both of these tools if you want to see if an image has been used on multiple websites – sometimes you'll get results on one tool that you won't get on the other one. The more unconnected websites that a product image features on, the more likely it is that all is not as it seems with the online stores that are selling it. And if that happens, it's also possible to compare the websites that use the image to see if some or all of them are fraudulent. If the pages are structured in the same way (e.g. their logos and details like their opening hours are located on the same part of their home page, they have similar 'About Us' info, or they're all selling discounted products for similar prices), then it's likely they aren't legitimate and may be connected in some way. 4. Do the website and its social media ads use artificial intelligence? Artificial intelligence technologies are frequently used by scammers, both on the scam websites themselves and on ads for them. Creating a unique website with a backstory and descriptions for hundreds of products is a time-consuming exercise, but programs like ChatGPT or Google Gemini can speed this up for scammers who want to make money with minimal effort. It's not always easy to tell at first glance when a website is relying on AI programs like these, but there are a couple of tools you can use to get a sense. GPTZero allows users to paste text from anywhere – including a website – to assess the likelihood that it was written by an AI chatbot or a human. As a test, we used the text from a product description on the website of a confirmed dodgy store, which the tool said was 100% likely to have been generated by AI. We also ran sections of this article through the tool, and were given a 92% certainty that the text was written by a human (though of course all of it was). It's important to note that these tools are imperfect; although the two examples given are clear-cut, it's not always going to be the case, particularly because many AI models have been trained by humans. As a result, it's better to use this tool in conjunction with other methods outlined in this article. Scam websites also occasionally use AI images to create fabricated images of shops, people supposedly involved in the business, or crisis events that have led them to sell off stock at a 'discounted' rate. The fake images of people usually don't look like real photos of people but appear more cartoonish; if you're finding it hard to tell if it's an AI image, check for unnatural patterns in textures like a person's hair, skin, or clothes, as well as background parts of the image. If an ad or website shows what looks like a physical shop, do a reverse image search using the method outlined above to see if it appears on Google (as a legitimate business would). Sign up The Journal Investigates is dedicated to lifting the lid on how Ireland works. Our newsletter gives you an inside look at how we do this. Sign up here... Sign up .spinner{transform-origin:center;animation:spinner .75s infinite linear}@keyframes spinner{100%{transform:rotate(360deg)}} You are now signed up You can also do this if an ad or social media page describes a crisis event like a fire or break-in that causes damage – it'll likely have been reported on the news or elsewhere on social media. An AI image of the 'owners' of Ruby & Maeve Kerry 5. Have people complained about the company? The unfortunate reality is that dodgy websites have scammed a lot of people around the world over the past two years. The result is that scammers have been emboldened to keep going – but the silver lining is that those who've been duped are increasingly warning others. There are a few different ways you can check whether a website is trustworthy, as well as some valuable clues that suggest it's not in the absence of other information. As mentioned above, most drop-shopping stores will have an accompanying Facebook page. If you click on the 'About' section on a website's Facebook page, you can see any reviews at the bottom; many of the scam websites we found had a stream of negative Facebook reviews from people calling them out and describing how they'd been scammed. Of course, this won't be the case for all pages: some will have few if any reviews, while people may also complain about legitimate businesses. We'd suggest that if a page seems suspicious and has only one or two positive reviews, do some further research as outlined above to see if it could be fraudulent. And if the majority of a page's reviews are negative and calling it out as a scam, you're probably best avoiding it. The home page of the websites themselves may also contain images showing five-star testimonials from Trustpilot, a worldwide online review platform . In a lot of cases these reviews are fake: if you search by the website's URL on Trustpilot, you won't find them – a clear sign that the site is run by scammers. In fact, many of the Trustpilot pages for these website will have more negative reviews that also call out the page as a scam. Although some legitimate websites tend to link to their Trustpilot profiles so that users can assess reviews for themselves, scam websites don't do this (presumably to avoid directing people to negative reviews that identify it as a scam website). If you click on a Trustpilot review on a scam page, you'll see that it's just an image rather than a link – never trust a website that does this, and double-check to see what its reviews are actually like for yourself on Trustpilot. Some websites may also have a small number of positive reviews on Trustpilot. If you spot this, check to see if people who left reviews left other reviews for different websites: if they didn't, or if they left a small number of similar reviews for the same type of websites, it's an indication that the reviewer may be fake. The Journal Investigates Reporter: Stephen McDermott • Investigation Editor: Christine Bohan • The Journal Investigates Editor: Maria Delaney Investigations like this don't happen without your support... Impactful investigative reporting is powered by people like you. Over 5,000 readers have already supported our mission with a monthly or one-off payment. Join them here: Support The Journal
