logo
Editorial: New York is Uncle Sam's piggy bank — Tom DiNapoli shows the state/federal balance of payments

Editorial: New York is Uncle Sam's piggy bank — Tom DiNapoli shows the state/federal balance of payments

Yahoo24-04-2025

Thank you to state Comptroller Tom DiNapoli for publishing an analysis of the balance of payments between the 50 states and the federal government. This is his ninth annual review, continuing a tradition that began when Pat Moynihan first arrived in the U.S. Senate in 1977 and that Moynihan kept up for all his 24 years of service.
Moynihan, always the professor, called his report the 'fisc.' While the word 'fisc' was archaic (look it up and learn something), the purpose was, and remains, cutting edge: How much does each state pay into the U.S. treasury in total taxes and how much government spending does each state receive from Uncle Sam?
Thus there are surplus states and deficit states, or recipient states and donor states and, of course, it does not balance to zero since the U.S. government annually runs hundreds of billions in the red. Getting the most back from the federal government are the poorest states like Mississippi and West Virginia, which makes sense since they need the most assistance. At the other end are the richest ones like New York, Massachusetts and Washington State paying for that assistance.
The other factor than poverty is government spending, so Virginia is a big surplus state being loaded with federal facilities like the Pentagon and No. 1 on the DiNapoli's list is New Mexico, which has the Sandia National Laboratories and the Los Alamos National Laboratory, both funded with billions from the feds every year. On that scale, New York also comes up short, with many fewer per capita federal employees and at the bottom for federal highway expenditures.
Which is why for decades New York has been one of the biggest donor states, sending more money each year to Washington than we got back. What temporarily changed that was COVID, as the Congress sent out billions to state and local governments and businesses and individuals when the pandemic began in 2020 in order to keep people afloat and prevent the economy from collapsing as the virus tore through the country, killing more than a million Americans.
DiNapoli's report finds that during the last four years, due to all those COVID dollars, New York was a surplus state, but that is ending. Yet even being on the plus side was not by much, as for every tax dollar remitted to feds from New Yorkers in fiscal year 2023, New York got back $1.06 in return, but the national average was $1.32.
Now comes what could be the next disaster putting New York into even more of a negative balance than before COVID, as DiNapoli warns: 'Actions taken by the Trump administration and Congress may cut health care, food assistance, infrastructure and other critical programs to the detriment of all New Yorkers.' He continued, saying that 'will exacerbate the long-standing history of New Yorkers sending more of their hard-earned tax dollars to the federal government than they get back.'
For two dozen years, Moynihan showed that New York was carrying much more of the federal weight than other states. The numbers told the truth, even as politicians from elsewhere complained about New York getting too big of a share. The facts, now collected by DiNapoli, are that New York gets a small slice of the pie.
___

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Senate GOP unveil long-awaited SNAP proposals for Trump bill
Senate GOP unveil long-awaited SNAP proposals for Trump bill

The Hill

time16 minutes ago

  • The Hill

Senate GOP unveil long-awaited SNAP proposals for Trump bill

Senate Republicans on Wednesday rolled out a suite of proposed changes to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) as a key component of President Trump's 'big beautiful bill' – but it dials back some of the proposals sought by the House that drew intraparty concerns. The new legislative text from the Senate would require states to cover some of the cost of SNAP benefits, which are currently completely funded by the federal government, if they have a payment error rate above 6 percent beginning in fiscal 2028, while allowing states with rates below that level to continue paying zero percent. It also proposes states with higher payment error rates cover a greater share of benefit costs. If the error rate is 6 percent or higher, states would be subject to a sliding scale that could see its share of allotments rise to a range of between 5 percent to 15 percent. The House, by contrast, called for all states to cover 5 percent of the cost of allotments in its agricultural proposal passed as part of a broader plan to advance Trump's tax agenda last month, with states that had higher payment error rates having to pay anywhere between 15 to 25 percent. The softened proposal comes as Senate Republicans expressed concerns about how the House pitch would have impacted states. 'This bill takes a commonsense approach to reforming SNAP-cutting waste, increasing state accountability, and helping recipients transition to self-sufficiency through work and training,' Senate Agriculture Chairman John Boozman (R-Ariz.) said in a statement on Wednesday. 'It's about being good stewards of taxpayer dollars while giving folks the tools to succeed.' 'At the same time, our farmers and ranchers are facing real challenges,' he said. 'This legislation delivers the risk management tools and updated farm bill safety net they need to keep producing the safest, most abundant and affordable food, fuel, and fiber in the world. It's an investment in rural America and the future of agriculture.' Like the House bill, the Senate bill would also decrease the administrative cost the federal government is required to pay to help cover program operations in the states by 25 percent, but beginning in fiscal year 2027. The proposals in both chambers also seek to limit the federal government's ability to increase monthly benefits in the future and beef up work requirements, as well as farm provisions that GOP leaders have argued will make it easier to craft a bipartisan farm bill in the months ahead – although Democrats have said otherwise. Republicans on the Senate Agriculture Committee estimated the recent legislation would generate $144 billion in net savings in the years ahead as the party looks to ramp up cost-cutting measures in Trump's plan amid concerns about the overall deficit impact of his tax priorities.

Microsoft developing version of AI Copilot for the Pentagon, BI reports
Microsoft developing version of AI Copilot for the Pentagon, BI reports

Business Insider

time18 minutes ago

  • Business Insider

Microsoft developing version of AI Copilot for the Pentagon, BI reports

Microsoft (MSFT) is working on a version of its 365 Copilot AI tool for the Pentagon, Business Insider's Ashley Stewart reports. 'For DoD environments, Microsoft 365 Copilot is expected to become available no earlier than summer 2025,' the company stated in a recent blog written for government customers. 'Work is ongoing to ensure the offering meets the necessary security and compliance standards.' Confident Investing Starts Here: Published first on TheFly – the ultimate source for real-time, market-moving breaking financial news. Try Now>>

'Don't just wave the flag:' Military leaders, NFL execs, and veterans gather at Mount Vernon for Army's 250th
'Don't just wave the flag:' Military leaders, NFL execs, and veterans gather at Mount Vernon for Army's 250th

Yahoo

time18 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

'Don't just wave the flag:' Military leaders, NFL execs, and veterans gather at Mount Vernon for Army's 250th

Some of the nation's top military leaders, veterans, and civic voices are gathering this week at George Washington's estate to launch a campaign urging Americans to serve their country: not just by honoring the flag, but by living out its values. The event, held June 12–13 at Mount Vernon, marks the 250th anniversary of the United States Army and Flag Day. It also kicks off the Military 250 campaign, a national effort led by the nonpartisan nonprofit We the Veterans and Military Families to inspire 250,000 acts of service across the country. "This isn't just about waving the flag," said Ellen Gustafson, co-founder of We the Veterans and Military Families, in an exclusive interview with Fox News Digital. "It's about doing something to support it." Trump To Host Military Parade To Celebrate Army's 250Th Birthday, Honor Active-duty Service Members, Veterans Gustafson, a Navy spouse and granddaughter of military veterans, is leading the new campaign, called Military 250. The campaign will also highlight 250 veteran-led organizations and 250 stories of continued service. Read On The Fox News App The kickoff begins Thursday with a formal reception at Mount Vernon's Smith Theater. Speakers include retired Army Chief of Staff Gen. George W. Casey Jr., NFL Chief Financial Officer and Army veteran Christine Dorfler, and former presidential candidate Carly Fiorina. Celebrity chef and Royal Navy veteran Robert Irvine will also speak. Friday's programming at the George Washington Presidential Library features panels on civic duty, trusted leadership, and patriotic service. Trump To Create Task Force To Plan 'Extraordinary Celebration' For 250Th Anniversary Of America's Independence Participants include Lt. Gen. Paul Mikolashek, former Army Inspector General; Green Beret and former NFL player Nate Boyer; U.S. Chamber of Commerce Vice President Hilary Crow; and U.S. Army veteran and comedian Thom Tran. Gustafson said the location of the event sends a message. "This is where Washington was called to lead the Continental Army," she said. "He kept answering the call: as a general, president, and private citizen. That's what we need again." We the Veterans is a nonpartisan nonprofit that empowers veterans and military families to lead by example. Its past work includes Vet the Vote, which recruited over 160,000 veterans and military family members to serve as poll workers in the 2024 election. "When the country needed help running elections, our community showed up," Gustafson said. "That's what real patriotism looks like." She said service doesn't have to mean joining the military. It can mean volunteering at schools, helping neighbors, mentoring, or getting involved in local government. "Being a patriot is about what you do," she said. "Not what you post online." As a mom of three raising a military family, Gustafson said she sees service every day. Her kids have lived through deployments and cross-country moves. She teaches them that sacrifice comes with responsibility and pride. "They know what the flag stands for," she said. "And I want them to grow up in a country where more people step up." "It's time to bring service back into our culture," Gustafson said. "If you love this country, show it." To learn more about the Military 250 campaign or log an act of service, visit article source: 'Don't just wave the flag:' Military leaders, NFL execs, and veterans gather at Mount Vernon for Army's 250th

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store