How Toronto considered a privately-operated tunnel to alleviate congestion
The proposal, obtained by Global News through freedom of information laws, outlined plans for one tunnel between Jameson Avenue and Cherry Street and a second tunnel connecting Front Street and Spadina Avenue to Exhibition Place.
The pitch, which was first made by John Beck, then-CEO of construction firm Aecon, in 2015, was formalized two years later and presented to then-mayor John Tory and senior staff.
While the idea was later dropped, Tory's office appeared to be seriously weighing the project and pushed a Toronto-area Liberal MP to consider the proposal as part of the newly created Canada Infrastructure Bank.
Story continues below advertisement
'Potential marquee, first-out-of-the-gate project for the Infrastructure Bank,' Tory's chief of staff Chris Eby wrote to the federal MP in 2017, under the subject line 'Gardiner tunnel.'
Sources, however, insist the idea was considered moot when the city decided to rehabilitate the Gardiner instead.
In an earlier statement to Global News, Aecon said the company has a long history of 'sharing emerging technologies and innovative new approaches with decision makers.'
'Aecon is proud to have built game-changing energy and transportation projects for Ontarians,' the company said in a statement. 'Building tunnels in support of transit and roadways to help relieve congestion is one solution that makes sense.'
A tolled tunnel
As part of its presentation to the city — titled 'GTConnect initiative' — Aecon proposed a wide-ranging solution for the Gardiner Expressway, Don Valley Parkway and Lakeshore Boulevard.
Story continues below advertisement
The idea would have included two main tunnels, a two-lane expansion to the DVP, and a potential transit corridor on a 'modified Lakeshore boulevard' — all of which would be financed, operated and maintained by the developer for a 50-year term.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
The benefit to the city, Aecon argued, would come in the form of 2,000 construction jobs, new land development opportunities and 'enhanced value of city and provincial lands.'
View image in full screen
A presentation about the proposed tunnel obtained using freedom of information laws. Global News
While commuters would save '10-20 minutes during peak hours,' drivers would have to pay for the privilege. The company's proposal said the dual-tunnel route, along with the expanded lanes of the DVP, would be tolled for a 50-year period.
The slide deck also includes key timelines for the proposed project: 18 to 24 months to conduct an environmental assessment; 36 months to build the Front Street tunnel and widen the DVP and 72 months to build the Gardiner Expressway tunnel.
Story continues below advertisement
Emails, obtained by Global News, show Tory's office was personally in touch with then-Aecon CEO John Beck and arranged a meeting with company representatives for Oct. 20, 2017.
Six days after the meeting took place, Tory's chief of staff punted the idea to the federal government, asking for it to be considered for Infrastructure Bank funding.
A provincial pitch
To cover its bases, Aecon also went to the provincial government, which has significantly more financial firepower and oversees the rest of Ontario's highways, to pitch the same idea.
Sources said Beck, who was appointed to the Order of Ontario in 2024, presented the same idea to the Ministry of Transportation, suggesting Aecon was looking for provincial support for the Toronto Gardiner tunnel.
The proposal, sources said, never made it past the one meeting.
Story continues below advertisement
In 2019, the idea was revived once again, but this time it moved north to target the growing gridlock on Highway 401.
The company filed an unsolicited proposal to Infrastructure Ontario offering a potential tunnel as the cure to highway congestion at a cost, sources said, of roughly $50 to $60 billion to build.
The 22-kilometre expressway tunnel proposal would have taken drivers under the most congested portions of Highway 401 — from the 427 to the 404 — with periodic on and off-ramps and a potential connection to Toronto Pearson International Airport.
While it's unclear how closely the two proposals would have aligned, Aecon appeared to be offering what governments had been looking for: a job-creating, traffic-alleviating solution along with 'world-class transportation infrastructure,' and entirely funded by the private sector.
The pitch may have been tempting, with the Ford government now studying a strikingly similar plan to build beneath Highway 401.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Calgary Herald
24 minutes ago
- Calgary Herald
Carney, Trump and Rocket Richard: Best defence is a good offence
Article content Canadian hockey fans raised in the Connor McDavid era, and even those like me who fondly recall the Wayne Gretzky era, may not know much about Maurice (the Rocket) Richard, but he was a 'fiery force on ice' during his 18 NHL seasons. Article content He was the first player to score 50 goals in a season, the first to reach 500 career goals and was a leader on eight Stanley Cup-winning teams. His suspension for striking an official during a fight in March 1945, by then-NHL commissioner Clarence Campbell, sparked a riot in Montreal, which was the closest Quebec ever got to replicating the French Revolution — with Campbell barely escaping the guillotine. Article content Article content Article content Richard was once asked, 'When you cross the blueline on a breakaway, do you have a plan as to how to beat the goalie?' He replied, 'When I cross the blueline on a breakaway, I don't have the faintest idea what I'm going to do. So how can the goalie know or plan for what I'm going to do?' Article content Article content Fast forward to the North American trade arena and the unwelcome contest between Prime Minister Mark Carney and U.S. President Donald Trump over tariffs. Trump, all bluster and bluff, demonstrates utter unpredictability as he approaches the Canada-U.S. border line — initially proposing to impose a blanket 25 per cent tariff on steel and aluminum, and everything else if Canada didn't tighten its borders against drug and migrant smuggling. Then a month later, a 10 per cent tariff on energy exports and a further increase on steel and aluminum. Then last month, an apoplectic fit over a proposed Canadian tax (since abandoned) on digital services, then pivoting to a 35 per cent overall tariff this month after just settling for 15 per cent tariffs in reciprocity agreements with Japan and the EU. Article content Article content In goal for Canada, to defend Canada's interests, is a former high-level bureaucrat, someone accustomed to working in the polite, predictable and orderly environment of central bankers. Someone who may quite possibly be discomfited and discombobulated by unpredictability as when Trump threatens at the blueline. Article content What to do if you were Canada's coach? What's possible, with Carney in net, to better withstand Trump attacks and even to go on the offensive? Article content Bolster the defence and team around Carney — not with Justin Trudeau-tainted ministers like Dominic LeBlanc, Chrystia Freeland or David Lametti, but with negotiators and spokespeople who have had no association at all with the Trudeau regime. Not fellow public sector bureaucrats such as Marc-Andre Blanchard and Michael Sabia (although they, particularly Sabia, may play a useful support role). Article content Bring in strong executives and union leaders with experience in the areas most susceptible to attack, but also those who can shout, bluff and tweet just as vigorously as Trump from sectors such as the oilpatch, which he needs to attain his goal of continental economic security. Article content Most importantly, do not showcase an unorganized gaggle of provincial premiers posing for photo ops, but mobilizing those like Danielle Smith and Scott Moe to move Trump by getting to his populist base. Article content And coming back to goalie Carney, if, as some commentators have suggested, we are actually heading into a 'tariff war,' maybe he could also draw inspiration and wisdom from William Lyon Mackenzie King, Canada's Liberal prime minister throughout the Second World War. Article content My father, who was Alberta premier from 1943 to 1968, dealt with four prime ministers — John Diefenbaker, Lester B. Pearson, Louis St-Laurent and Mackenzie King — and their administrations. He maintained that Mackenzie King's war cabinet and administration were by far the strongest of the four, and that perhaps his greatest strength was the ability to see his own weaknesses and deficiencies, and to recruit others to compensate for them. Article content Article content It remains to be seen whether Carney can do the same. To do so would require a substantial degree of humility, which Carney professes to value most highly and to which he devoted the last pages of his voluminous book. Article content The end result might then be 'a real Team Canada' — with skill and experience at every position as well as on the bench. A team yet to be built — not yet even in the locker-room, let alone on the ice — but a team most urgently needed if Canada is to prevail in its struggles with the Trump administration.
CTV News
24 minutes ago
- CTV News
‘We just got lucky': How some GTA homebuyers are finding space in a changing market
A real estate agent puts up a 'sold' sign in front of a house in Toronto, on Tuesday, April 20, 2010. (Darren Calabrese / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Jon Campbell didn't expect to buy a house in Newmarket this year. He also didn't expect to postpone his wedding in Japan after having to move out of his Yonge and Eglinton condo when his landlord decided to put it on the market, or negotiate a mortgage — all at the same time. 'As you can imagine, (for) someone that's about to get married in a few months, that doesn't sound good,' Campbell said. 'I might get a call one day saying we've got to move, and we've got to move right before the wedding.' But when his landlord gave notice about intentions to sell — Campbell and his fiancée, both in their early 30s finally made a decision. They weren't going to rent again. They were going to buy — despite years of market frustration. 'We sat down and said 'OK we're going to buy... looks like there's blood on the streets from the market.'' Campbell is just one of several buyers who told CTV News Toronto they were able to seize a long-awaited opening in the housing market this summer. It comes as new figures from the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board show 6,100 homes changed hands in July — up nearly 11 per cent from the same time last year and marking the busiest July since 2021. The surge came as the average selling price fell another 5.5 per cent to $1,051,719 and inventory rose more than 26 per cent across the region. For some buyers those conditions - more listings, fewer bidding wars and slightly lower prices - created what experts describe as a 'window in time.' But as to whether the shift signals the beginning of a lasting trend remains to be seen. Forced to leave the big city For Campbell and his fiancée, he says the 'real search' began this past February. With a household income of more than $200,000, they initially looked at condo townhomes in the city — but quickly ran into issues. 'The maintenance fees were ridiculous,' he said. 'All the condo towns were so small, it was going to be a five-year plan. There's no way we're going to get married, have a kid, and be in a two-bedroom, two-washroom for that long.' house toronto A new townhouse complex is under construction in Toronto on Thursday, November 3, 2016. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette (Nathan Denette/THE CANADIAN PRESS) After roughly 10 showings in Toronto, he says their agent suggested looking further north. Campbell had lived in Newmarket as a child and once they expanded their search, he says it clicked. 'It was night and day,' he said. 'We were like 'OK, now we're talking space.'' They found a freehold townhouse listed at $850,000, made an offer and had it accepted the same night they viewed it. 'We went to go see the property. Fell in love. We offered them $850K the same day… We closed at 12:30 a.m. Saturday night,' Campbell said. 'Someone on my street just sold for $880K. So we got a perfect deal, the perfect property. I didn't think this existed.' A 'stress-free' transaction Other buyers who wrote to CTV News say the experience has changed dramatically from the peak of the market frenzy in 2021. Peter Amelunxen and his wife had rented near Toronto's Mimico neighbourhood with their three children since returning to Canada in April 2020. After years of watching the market and walking away from 'blind bidding wars,' he says they finally found the right property this summer. 'With the cooling market, our recent purchase has gone very smoothly, was stress-free, and the whole family is excited to move into our beautiful new house,' he said. The couple bid slightly over asking and got a fast acceptance. 'We gave the seller a couple hours to make up his mind, and he accepted the offer right away,' Amelunxen said. 'Our real estate agent… said about a year ago, when he would have shown the house, he would have had to sit in the car and make the offer right away, because he wouldn't have had time to drive back to the office before another one came in. Now… houses are sitting for a week or two. It makes it a lot less stressful," he added. A 'window in time,' says one expert While July sales were up, the months leading up to that moment painted a less rosy picture. Sales in April, May, and June were down year-over-year, and many buyers had remained on the sidelines amid uncertainty surrounding interest rates and the U.S.-Canada trade war. Last week, the Bank of Canada held interest rates steady for a third time, a move seen by some as a sign of stability — though the future of further rate cuts remains unclear. For Campbell, that balance mattered. 'I didn't want to get priced out of the market,' he said. 'I would say the biggest factor was definitely interest rates. I was like, I'm not paying five per cent when the interest rates are going down. I'm going to try and get in a sweet spot where interest rates are a little bit high, but they're affordable and the price is down.' Cailey Heaps, president and CEO of the Heaps Estrin Team real estate brokerage, said that logic tracks with what she is hearing from clients. 'More listings plus slightly softened prices have created opportunity, prompting many long-waiting buyers to act,' she said. 'We're not seeing bargain-basement pricing, but buyers are enjoying something closer to control.' Jason Mercer, Chief Information Officer for the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board, says while July's numbers look promising, 'one month doesn't make a trend.' 'If we see a couple more months moving into the fall, where we're seeing sales up in comparison to last year... then that would add credence to the argument that we are starting to see more people move off the sidelines.' Jason Mercer Jason Mercer, Chief Information Officer for the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board speaks to CP24 (CP24 file photo). Still, Mercer emphasizes the need for more diverse housing types to meet demand and prevent future affordability issues. In addition, it should be noted that one report by last month suggested that home affordability deteriorated in 12 of 13 major markets in June. In Toronto, said that you had to have a household income of $206,500 to afford the average home in June, up more than $1,600 from the previous month. The average household income in Toronto is $129,000, according to Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation data. 'What we're seeing now feels like a window in time more than a long-term trend Heaps said.' 'The fall will be a testing ground—will motivated sellers meet motivated buyers?' A 'picture-perfect situation' CTV News also heard from buyers who said their recent home hunting experiences were notably less chaotic than in past years — citing fewer bidding wars, more choice, and less urgency to act. 'Buying our house was actually a picture-perfect situation,' Campbell said. 'I didn't think it exists.' With a three-bedroom, three-washroom townhouse near the GO train, Campbell says he and his fiancée feel like they're exactly where they need to be — even if it took a shift in expectations to get there. 'It was just the right opportunity at the right time,' he said. 'We just got lucky.'
Montreal Gazette
an hour ago
- Montreal Gazette
Libman: Maybe it's time to hit pause on our dizzying dance with Trump
I remember as a kid frenetically chasing after a rubber Superball as it bounced around, careening off everything, not knowing where it would bounce next, constantly out of reach. That's what it must feel like to deal with Donald Trump and try to figure out a way to pin down a complicated trade agreement, of all things. International trade, commerce and business need economic stability and predictability. In Canada's history, we've never had to face such a wild card U.S. presidency and been forced to navigate as volatile a relationship with our largest trading partner. Every day seems to bring a different turn. The goalposts seem to move whenever a new idea or insult pops into Trump's head — which he broadcasts on social media — surprising our politicians. There's often no common-sense rationale with Trump. It's dizzying, infuriating and in many ways surreal. One day his chiding of Canada could be related to fentanyl, the next illegal immigrants or imaginary trade imbalances. Perhaps disdain due to slights by our former prime minister still lingers, or maybe current PM Mark Carey hasn't been flattering enough. Who knows? Many Canadians boldly want to see an 'elbows up' approach of defiance. But let's face it — economically we're at the mercy of our much bigger U.S. neighbour. Particularly with this president, as with most bullies or egomaniacs, any attempt at fighting back is likely to backfire. When Ontario Premier Doug Ford threatened to impose a 25-per-cent surcharge on electricity exports to three U.S. states, Trump roared, threatening a 50-per-cent retaliatory tariff the next day, causing Ford to meekly scurry backwards. Trump's flunky, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, said '(Trump) needed to break some guy in Ontario who said he was going to tax American energy.' Lutnick himself often looks foolish, talking in a vacuum without any idea what his boss might decide the next day. Our politicians don't seem to have any game plan or know how to handle this, as they have no idea what to expect next. Federal ministers Dominic LeBlanc, François-Philippe Champagne, Anita Anand and Mélanie Joly seem to be running like hamsters on a wheel. You also get the sense Carney is constantly biting his tongue to avoid criticizing the president, knowing it could boomerang. Last week, not having reached a deal by the Aug. 1 deadline, Trump raised the tariff rate from 25 to 35 per cent on Canadian goods not covered under the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement, again evoking Canada's failure to control the 'ongoing flood of fentanyl and other illicit drugs.' Fentanyl seizures from Canada are less than 0.1 per cent of total U.S. seizures of the drug, but facts are irrelevant in this alternate reality. Perhaps it's time our federal government just went back to governing and stopped this dance. The more we dance, the more Trump will make us dance. If a deal is struck, fine — but patience may be a more sensible approach than scrambling for a deal, any deal. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington is soon expected to rule on whether Trump's tariffs are even legal under the Constitution, which grants Congress powers over trade. Trump has circumvented this by claiming he can use presidential emergency powers under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, something the judges hearing the case have skeptically questioned. Also, the cost impact of tariffs — the higher wages to American workers to produce goods and materials in the U.S., rather than importing at a lower price — presumably will soon start hitting Americans in their wallets. Only if Americans wake up and start questioning Trump's policies will he likely blink. Maybe it's time to stop chasing the ball for now and let the courts and other economic indicators shape the narrative. Robert Libman is an architect and planning consultant who has served as Equality Party leader and MNA, mayor of Côte-St-Luc and a member of the Montreal executive committee. He was a Conservative candidate in the 2015 federal election.
