‘Groundbreaking' case over Airbnb lettings in West Bank will set precedent for Irish companies, says Senator
A 'groundbreaking' case against
Airbnb
will set a precedent for legal action against any Irish companies with links to illegal
Israeli
settlements, an Independent Senator has warned.
Frances Black
said similar cases will continue to be taken until the Government includes services in the upcoming
Occupied Territories Bill
.
She was speaking on Tuesday as five separate international legal challenges were launched against the company, which pro-Palestinian and human rights activists say is currently managing more than 300 holiday lettings in the
West Bank
.
The strategic action, which includes an Irish court case, is being led by Sadaka, the Ireland-Palestine Alliance and the Global Legal Action Network (GLAN).
READ MORE
The groups said they are seeking a judicial review against a decision by An Garda Síochána's national economic crime bureau not to proceed with a complaint from activists in August 2023.
This alleged that Airbnb is in breach of Irish money laundering legislation for profits it has made from lettings in illegal Israeli settlements.
According to GLAN, gardaí initially found there had been 'no offence' in this jurisdiction.
The group is now challenging that decision. Airbnb's European, Middle East and Africa headquarters is in Dublin.
In a statement, a spokesperson for Airbnb said: 'Airbnb operates in compliance with applicable Irish and US laws. Since 2019, Airbnb has
donated
all profits generated from host activity in the West Bank to an international non-profit, in line with our global framework on disputed territories.'
Ms Black, who described the case against Airbnb as a 'groundbreaking legal action', said similar cases will follow if the Government does not legislate to restrict the trading of goods and services in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
'This case is hugely important, but Airbnb is just one company. There are many, many others. It should not be left up to brilliant civil society organisations and campaigners to seek to identify individual companies and push them to end their complicity in Israeli war crimes one by one,' she said.
'We need Government to step up and take responsibility, pass full, proper, complete legislation that bans all trade with the illegal settlements in both goods and services for every company, so that cases like this are not necessary.'
In 2018, Airbnb announced it would remove more than 200 listings in the occupied West Bank. But it reversed this decision some months later after a US case was taken against it on behalf of hosts who had had their listings removed.
Ms Black said Ireland was 'required' under international law not to trade with the Occupied Territories.
Speaking at the same event, Ms Black played down her potential candidacy for this year's presidential election.
Asked for her thoughts on running as a candidate for an alliance of left-wing parties, she replied: 'There are no thoughts. At this time, it's not something I have even considered.'
Ms Black said she was '98 per cent sure' at this point that she would not be running.
'It's just blown way out of proportion,' she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Carlow gunman disclosure set to lead to scrutiny of An Garda Síochána
It was Drew Harris 's last appearance before the Oireachtas Justice Committee before his retirement. In between well-wishes for his contribution to policing over a long career – including from Sinn Féin's chair Matt Carthy – there was some close questioning and a political edge to it. The most dramatic came from Labour TD Alan Kelly, who disclosed that Evan Fitzgerald, the young man who fired shots in a shopping centre in Carlow before turning his shotgun on himself, had been supplied with guns and ammunition by undercover gardaí . As Pat Leahy and Conor Lally report, it was confirmed by the Commissioner that Fitzgerald (22) was supplied with the guns by gardaí under what is called a 'controlled delivery'. The gardaí then arrested and charged him with possession of firearms and ammunition offences. It was some disclosure. Such are the time limits on the questioning – because there are so many committees in the 34th Dáil there are strict restrictions – Harris didn't actually manage to respond to the question posed by Kelly. READ MORE A little later, however, Michael McDowell came back to the specific question and Harris said that controlled deliveries were frequently used in drugs and firearms cases. The matter has been referred to Fiosrú, the policing ombudsman, but has now a public and political dimension. It's certain that down the line, the Garda will come under political and public scrutiny for the deployment of this tactic. As Kelly later told The Irish Times: 'What he was doing was wrong, but where is the proportionality in the actions of An Garda Síochána? When undercover gardaí met this young man, followed him and knew who they were dealing with, did they not assess the level of threat differently and look at alternative interventions? 'They knew they were not dealing with dissidents or organised crime gangs but a young man with some issues. They have effectively said the same and even agreed to his bail, so obviously they didn't believe he was a huge threat.' Payback time (or more pay time) for former ministers and senior civil servants There was a bit of surprise when it was announced on Tuesday that Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers was holding a media conference in relation to the National Shared Services Office (NSSO), a classic back-office State agency that doesn't exactly draw news headlines. But as Cormac McQuinn reports, errors in handling pension payments have resulted in a situation where Government ministers and as many as 13,000 retired civil servants could either owe money or be owed money because of miscalculations in relation to their pension contributions. 'This cohort of former civil servants were in work-share arrangements and, while not all are necessarily affected, their pensions are to be checked for underpayments,' writes McQuinn. 'There is also an issue in relation to the pensions of 30 retired senior civil servants and one of them could owe as much as €280,000 as a result of NSSO errors.' It is believed most current Government ministers will owe money to the State, though some may be due some money back. The highest overpayment may be in the region of €30,000. Ministerial Pressure Zones There was a time when the political pressure zone only surrounded the Minister for Housing but this week it has extended nationwide, as it were, to the whole of Government. Not only did the Minister James Browne have a testing day trying to explain the changes he has introduced to rent pressure zones (RPZs), the issue dominated Leaders' Questions. There was a snarly back and forth all day between the Government and Opposition parties over the changes, with some very thorny prose being used (see best reads below). Extending the RPZ from the current 111 local election areas to all 166 was simple to explain. It was the future arrangements for tenants – especially existing ones – that came under scrutiny and, by extension, put the Government under the cosh. Browne was explaining all day and living up to the Karl Rove dictum that when you are doing that, you are losing. Under the new classification, a landlord who owns three properties or less is a 'mom and pop' landlord. That became an issue. The distinction between new accommodation coming on stream and existing accommodation also became an issue. The Opposition pounded the Government all day on whether existing tenants in RPZ zones would see changes to the increase limits after six years, like new tenancies that begin from March 2026. 'The rights of existing tenants will not change' became the mantra of all Government people during the day. In other words, RPZ rules would continue for them ad infinitum. However, it did not succeed in convincing. The Smaller the Party the Bigger the Split Wow. We did not see that coming. People Before Profit coming under attack from within for becoming too mainstream. A group of some 30 activists have left the party over concerns it would enter a future Government with Sinn Féin . It's not over the concerns the likes of Simon Harris or Micheál Martin would have. It's because Sinn Féin is essentially an establishment party, they say. The group's best known politician is Dublin City Council member Madeleine Johansson. In a statement, it said a Sinn Féin-led government would 'coalesce with the establishment and leave untouched the real government, the permanent government – the State bureaucracy, army chiefs and head of Guards'. Ronan McGreevy has the full story on this latest split among the micro parties of the far-left . Best reads Miriam Lord has the full welly on the back and forth over the RPZ changes yesterday including some choice name-dropping by the Taoiseach. Ellen Coyne, our newest colleague on the political team, covered the press conference on Gaza on Tuesday, hosted by Senator Frances Black and others. She reports that the Independent Senator said a 'groundbreaking' case against Airbnb will set a precedent for legal action against any Irish companies with links to illegal Israeli settlements. Black said similar cases will continue to be taken until the Government includes services in the upcoming Occupied Territories Bill . Gordon Deegan writes that Michael Healy-Rae's family property company has posted €842,000 in profit over two years. Playbook Dáil Wed, Jun 11th 09.00: Topical Issues 10.00: Private Members' Business (Social Democrats): Motion re Ending the Central Bank's facilitation of the sale of Israel Bonds 12.00: Leaders' Questions. 12.34: Other Members' Questions 17.02: Government Business: Mental Health Bill 2024 – Committee Stage 21.02: Deferred Divisions 21.32: Dáil adjourns Seanad 10.30: Commencement Matters 11.30: Order of Business 13.00: Government Business: Supports for Survivors of Residential Institutional Abuse Bill 2024 – Second Stage 15.30: Private Members' Business: Child Trafficking and Child Sexual Exploitation Material (Amendment) Bill 2022 – Committee Stage 17.30: Seanad adjourns Committees 09.30: Transport Driving Test and NCT Delays The NCT will say it has reduced the waiting time for tests from 27 weeks to 20 weeks and that one of the causes of the delays were a 60 per cent upsurge in driving test applications. 09.45: Health Issues relating to the priorities and concerns in the context of the Mental Health Bill 2024 10.45: Social Protecion Engagement with Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary 12.30: Arts, Media and Communications Committee Matters relating to the termination of the Arts Council Grant Management IT system. Pat Leahy has details of the opening statement , which deeply regrets the decision by Minister for Arts Patrick O'Donovan not to renew the contract of director Maureen Kennelly over the handling of a controversial ICT project. 12.30: Further and Higher Education Engagement with Minister for Further and Higher Education James Lawless. 15.30: Finance, Public Expenditure Israeli Bond Programme 15.30: Agriculture Examination of the impacts of the Veterinary Medicinal Products, Medicated Feed and Fertilisers Regulation Act 2023
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Cost of health insurance nears €2,000
If health insurance, along with most things these days, feels like it's getting more expensive , then you're right. The cost of private health insurance has jumped to almost €2,000 per person, according to industry watchdog HIA. As Conor Pope reports, as well as a spike in prices, the figures highlight a significant slowdown in the numbers taking out cover in the first three months of the year. As the Government brings in sweeping changes to the rental market here, John McManus assesses how housing has become an issue that voters expect the State to provide in the same way as health or education, and explores the implications for financing new homes such a change has. These days it seems almost impossible to buy a home if you aren't part of a couple. But it can be done . In Money Matters Joanne Hunt outlines what you need to know about buying your home on your own. US trade tariffs will result in a major slowdown in global growth but not a recession, the World Bank has said. In its latest Global Economic Prospects report, the Washington-based institution said that heightened trade tensions and wider policy uncertainty would drive global growth down this year 'to its slowest pace since 2008 outside of outright global recessions'. Eoin Burke-Kennedy reports. READ MORE The impact of the proliferation of artificial intelligence (AI) on Ireland's energy demands is 'not going to be as steep as many people believe', Research Ireland has told an Oireachtas committee. Colin Gleeson watched the hearing. A team of four Trinity College Dublin students placed third at the Global Finals of the Boston University Susilo Business and Ethics Case Competition. The students were the first Irish team to reach the world finals in the competition. Hugh Dooley reports. How to manage your pension in these volatile times Listen | 37:00 In Commercial Property, Fiona Reddan reports that a high-spec manufacturing facility, currently owned and operated by Wyeth Nutritionals Ireland, in Askeaton, Co Limerick, is being brought to the market asking €22 million. Also in Commercial Property, Ronald Quinlan writes that Coonan Property and Savills are guiding a price of €6.55 million for a 10.92-acre site with full planning permission for the development of six industrial units in Rathcoole, Co Dublin. Ronald also reports that the first building in what is being billed as Ireland's first co-located university enterprise quarter has been launched on the site of the former Waterford Crystal factory site on Waterford City's Cork Road. Boots booked a €2.4 million impairment charge against the value of its Irish property portfolio last year as a precaution against rising sales costs and overheads, as profit growth eased significantly from the previous year. Ian Curran has the story. A mystery objector is opposing a planned new gate as part of house revamp plans by Dee and Ian Lawlor for their property at Coolbeg, Shrewsbury Road in Dublin 4. Gordon Deegan has details of the objection against the work planned for the house, which was used in scenes from the 1990s Hollywood blockbuster Far and Away starring Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman. Retailer Marks & Spencer resumed taking some online orders for clothing lines for customers in England, Scotland and Wales on Tuesday after a 46-day hiatus following a cyberattack, but customers in Ireland will have to wait a while longer. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Government had to choose tenants over investors
After months of deliberation the Government seems to have finally settled on a rent control strategy . It is something of a dog's dinner and can best be seen as an attempt to reconcile two things that are fundamentally irreconcilable. The first is the need to reassure the increasing number of people in rented accommodation that their already sky-high rents are not going to be driven even higher by avaricious landlords capitalising on a severe housing shortage . The second is creating the conditions that will entice international institutional investors into the property market, which requires convincing them that they will be able to set and keep rents at a level where they can earn the sort of market-beating returns that would make investing in Ireland an attractive option relative to the myriad of other global opportunities. READ MORE Much of the emphasis is understandably being put on the measures intended to protect existing tenants, which include the extension of rent controls across the State. Rent increases will be subject to a limit – inflation or 2 per cent – and landlords will be severely restricted in their ability to reset rents to market levels when a tenancy ends. [ Why is the housing crisis Ireland's most enduring failure? Opens in new window ] There will, however, be a distinction drawn between small and large landlords. Those with fewer than three properties will be able to evict tenants and presumably put up rents. There is less emphasis or detail on the measures intended to encourage institutional investment. New builds will not be subject to rental caps and landlords will be able to increase rent to match inflation. The industry is understood to be disappointed. The Government will argue with some justification that it has done its best to balance various competing interests and that a compromise was inevitable. Doing nothing was not an option. The Government is right about that. But how this fudge will work in practice is anyone's guess and the potential for unintended consequences is high. One thing is for sure. Rents will go up. A combination of upward pressure from small landlords at the bottom and a pull from large institutional investors at the top will ensure that rents in the middle also rise. The details of the plan have not been published but the apparent decision to focus more on protecting tenants than encouraging investors may prove the right one. The inherent contradictions in trying to coax private capital seeking high returns into investing in a sector in which policy is to keep rents down is probably insurmountable. The most likely outcome is that the new measures will prove sufficient to swing the investment case for some projects already in the pipeline and a few more top-end developments will be built for rent than might have been otherwise. Every little helps of course The Government would appear to have resisted the entreaties of property developers and their backers as represented by lobby group Irish Institutional Property, which holds that 60 per cent of the funding needed to address the housing shortage must come from international investors. The State and the domestic banks will make up the rest, they believe. The fundamental problem with this argument is that we are approaching the limit in terms of people who can pay the sort of rent that international investors will be seeking without enduring significant financial pain, which in turn will have a detrimental knock-on effect for the economy. Most people are already paying rents in excess of what economists deem sustainable, which is between 20 and 35 per cent of net income. The average Irish person earns about €44,000 a year and the average rent is €1,600 a month or about €20,000 a year. The political pressure that has led to implementation of nationwide rent controls and other pro-tenant measures confirms that we are at the limits of what can be tolerated by society in terms of housing costs. Any international investor looking at investing in housing in Ireland as a long-term bet that will return more than 10 per cent a year would really want to get their head around that before committing. The ones that get in early might do okay, but the risk premium they will want is only going to push up the rent they charge. The reality is that a property market as badly broken as our one does not represent an appetising low-risk investment opportunity. The system – based around widespread home ownership and the accumulation of private wealth – worked reasonably well for a long time but now it doesn't. The reasons are a combination of factors beyond the State's control and the ball being dropped in areas that are its responsibility, such as planning and infrastructure. Housing and rental accommodation in particular are increasingly taking on the characteristics of a public good along the lines of health and education in the minds of voters: something the State regulates, provides and supports on a not-for-profit basis. Nationwide rent controls are just further evidence of this. Health and education are not services that the State looks to fund via hedge funds. They are funded by the exchequer and ultimately in the sovereign debt markets. That is where the Government should be looking for investment. It may now have no choice.
