‘Groundbreaking' case over Airbnb lettings in West Bank will set precedent for Irish companies, says Senator
Airbnb
will set a precedent for legal action against any Irish companies with links to illegal
Israeli
settlements, an Independent Senator has warned.
Frances Black
said similar cases will continue to be taken until the Government includes services in the upcoming
Occupied Territories Bill
.
She was speaking on Tuesday as five separate international legal challenges were launched against the company, which pro-Palestinian and human rights activists say is currently managing more than 300 holiday lettings in the
West Bank
.
The strategic action, which includes an Irish court case, is being led by Sadaka, the Ireland-Palestine Alliance and the Global Legal Action Network (GLAN).
READ MORE
The groups said they are seeking a judicial review against a decision by An Garda Síochána's national economic crime bureau not to proceed with a complaint from activists in August 2023.
This alleged that Airbnb is in breach of Irish money laundering legislation for profits it has made from lettings in illegal Israeli settlements.
According to GLAN, gardaí initially found there had been 'no offence' in this jurisdiction.
The group is now challenging that decision. Airbnb's European, Middle East and Africa headquarters is in Dublin.
In a statement, a spokesperson for Airbnb said: 'Airbnb operates in compliance with applicable Irish and US laws. Since 2019, Airbnb has
donated
all profits generated from host activity in the West Bank to an international non-profit, in line with our global framework on disputed territories.'
Ms Black, who described the case against Airbnb as a 'groundbreaking legal action', said similar cases will follow if the Government does not legislate to restrict the trading of goods and services in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
'This case is hugely important, but Airbnb is just one company. There are many, many others. It should not be left up to brilliant civil society organisations and campaigners to seek to identify individual companies and push them to end their complicity in Israeli war crimes one by one,' she said.
'We need Government to step up and take responsibility, pass full, proper, complete legislation that bans all trade with the illegal settlements in both goods and services for every company, so that cases like this are not necessary.'
In 2018, Airbnb announced it would remove more than 200 listings in the occupied West Bank. But it reversed this decision some months later after a US case was taken against it on behalf of hosts who had had their listings removed.
Ms Black said Ireland was 'required' under international law not to trade with the Occupied Territories.
Speaking at the same event, Ms Black played down her potential candidacy for this year's presidential election.
Asked for her thoughts on running as a candidate for an alliance of left-wing parties, she replied: 'There are no thoughts. At this time, it's not something I have even considered.'
Ms Black said she was '98 per cent sure' at this point that she would not be running.
'It's just blown way out of proportion,' she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Seán Kelly to seek Fine Gael nomination to run in presidential election
Fine Gael MEP Seán Kelly has announced his intention to seek the party's nomination to run in the forthcoming presidential election. A contest between Mr Kelly and former minister Heather Humphreys became increasingly likely on Monday night after the party's executive council decided to seek fresh nominations rather than selecting a single candidate. The meeting was convened after the sudden announcement on Thursday by party nominee Mairead McGuinness that she was dropping out of the race for health reasons . Speaking on Tuesday morning, the Ireland South MEP said that he had 'underestimated' the grassroots support for him and that he will 'certainly seek the nomination' from his party. READ MORE 'So I would be looking for the nomination, and after that, and if I'm nominated, I will be greatly honoured to represent the party and stand for election as president,' Mr Kelly told RTÉ's Morning Ireland. Mr Kelly said he believed the 'time is right' to put himself forward, after discussing it with family and supporters, in light of the changed circumstances following the decision by Ms McGuinness to withdraw from the race. The former president of the GAA said that having spent time in Ireland over the last few weeks, he understood that he had grassroots support and momentum as many people had told him they were disappointed that he was not running for the Áras. Mr Kelly had previously ruled himself out of running. He considered contesting the nomination against Ms McGuinness earlier in summer, but he ultimately decided against it. After deliberating for little over an hour on Monday evening, Fine Gael's executive council decided it would reopen nominations on Tuesday until September 2nd. Ms Humphreys, who also previously ruled herself out, has yet to declare her intentions. However, party sources have said that following the vacation of the nomination by Ms McGuinness, she has expressed strong interest in representing the party in the autumn poll. Her candidacy has been strongly backed by Tánaiste and party leader Simon Harris . Last month, Mr Kelly had ruled himself out of the contest by saying the presidency was a largely 'ceremonial' role. He appeared to walk those comments back on Tuesday, and said that his comment 'was in comparison to presidents around the world who have executive powers.' 'But I think actually there's a huge potential in the job, it is the highest honour in Ireland. And if you look at what the last number of presidents have done, they've done tremendous work. There's huge flexibility there,' he said. He said that a remark he made in ruling himself out that 'a day out of Kerry was a day wasted' was a 'a tongue in cheek' comment. 'I'd be bringing the Áras to the people as much as the people to the Áras, so that's not a problem at all.' Mr Kelly said that he will now start lobbying for support from the Fine Gael parliamentary party. He will need the support of at least 20 TDs and senators. It is understood Ms Humphreys already has the overwhelming support of Fine Gael's parliamentary party, despite having not yet formally started lobbying for support. Mr Kelly said that he believes Fine Gael's base would like to see a contest for its presidential candidates. 'I think the people, particularly members of the party, would like to have a contest. We didn't have a contest for a long time now, because we didn't have a contest at the last presidential election seven years ago, we didn't have a contest for the leadership. 'We weren't going to have a contest when Mairead got the nomination, so I think people would like to have a contest. Contests are good for parties, are good for democracies, and I think that I would welcome a contest, and hope I'd be part of it.'
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
The most complained about companies in Ireland
Ryanair, Eir and Sky were the companies most complained about in the first half of 2025 while Ticketmaster saw its ranking with Ireland's consumer watchdog improve as concerns over high-priced Oasis tickets last September faded away. Conor Pope reports. Glenveagh Homes is weighing big changes to a 650-home housing development including omitting a number of housing units from the site, and a plan for a 379-unit, mixed-use development in Swords, Co Dublin. Hugh Dooley has the details. An Coimisiún Pleanála (ACP) has reopened an appeal over a 106 home development next to the Phoenix Park after the High Court quashed its decision to grant planning permission for the complex. Hugh has the story. How transformative is AI really going to be? At this stage it's an open question, but in his column Hugh Linehan shows how it is already having a huge impact on the media world. READ MORE Cantillon looks at an own goal by AIB, and why the Republic may not be a true ' rich ' country despite our GDP. In Your Money, Siobhan Maguire shows how it can be possible to make money out of watches , while Dominic Coyle answers questions on pensions and UK tax law, as well as whether borrowing from your children will impact the small gift tax exemption. Belfast-based neurotechnology company Neurovalens has closed a £6 million (€6.95 million) investment round to help fund its commercial expansion in the US and global markets. Ciara O'Brien reports. Dundrum Town Centre's owners have appealed a decision by Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council to refuse retention permission for long-standing food truck concessions at the front entrance to the retail complex. Hugh has the story. A row over demands by contractors involving a potential investor in the refinancing of debt-ridden airline CityJet, over proposed upfront payment terms for future maintenance work, could collapse rescue plans for the company which is currently in examinership, the High Court was told on Monday. Ray Managh was in court. Ticketing software specialist Future Ticketing has renewed its deal with top League of Ireland Football club, Shamrock Rovers until 2030. Barry O'Halloran has the story. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
An Coimisiún Pleanála reopens appeal over Phoenix Park apartments plan
An Coimisiún Pleanála (ACP) has reopened an appeal over a 106-home development next to the Phoenix Park after the High Court quashed its decision to grant planning permission for the complex. The proposed development, which has been sought by Linders of Smithfield Limited, is made up of 96 apartments in two blocks and 10 duplex apartments in a third block, at Quadrant House on Chapelizod Road. The large residential development (LRD) application was made in July 2023, seeking permission to level the Chapelizod Road site and to construct three residential blocks ranging from three to five storeys. The development, which was proposed to have a gross floor area of 9,786.5sq m, was to include a residents' gym, a cafe, a communal work space and a basement car park with 84 parking spaces. The development was not set to include any childcare facilities. Despite a series of objections from local residents, the Chapelizod Residents Association and Friends of the Phoenix Park, Dublin City Council granted permission. READ MORE Four separate appeals were lodged, with Chapelizod Tidy Towns' appeal being brought to ACP, which noted that 'particular concerns [were] raised about childcare provision and lack thereof', but planning permission for the development was affirmed after ACP found it to be in line with the Dublin City Development Plan. The case against ACP was brought before the High Court in early 2024 by Friends of the Phoenix Park, a group of local parents that noted their concerns that the development will further overload childcare provision in the area. The group is made up of parents whose children attended a childcare centre which was located on the site of the proposed development until it closed in June 2023. The childcare centre, which was described as 'integral' in an affidavit submitted by the group, was said to provide a significant number of care spaces. The national planning body conceded the case in January 2025. Its representatives admitted it had 'failed to give adequate reasons for its conclusion that the development was in compliance with the density provisions of the Development Plan with specific reference to the issue of public transport capacity'. Acting on behalf of ACP, Byrne Wallace Shields LLP suggested the court quash the order granting the planning application and issue an order that it pay the costs of the applicant, Friends of the Phoenix Park, and the costs of the court. Mr Justice Richard Humphreys quashed the decision in March, sending the case back to ACP. The planning commission is set to make a decision on the matter by December 4th.
