Occupation or siege? Israel's leadership split on Gaza strategy
Israel's military establishment has entered a new standoff with the political leadership following Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's decision to pursue the occupation of Gaza.
Chief of Staff Eyal Zamir canceled a planned visit to Washington and, according to leaked internal discussions, stated that he would not issue orders for the army to occupy Gaza. He reportedly added that if forced to implement the decision, he would resign.
In response, Netanyahu convened a limited security meeting at his office with ministers Israel Katz and Ron Dermer, Chief of Staff Zamir, and Operations Directorate head Itzik Cohen, aiming to finalize the nature of military operations in Gaza — whether to launch a full occupation or adopt Zamir's alternative: encirclement combined with targeted strikes.
Ministers Katz and Itamar Ben-Gvir escalated tensions ahead of the meeting, pressuring the army chief. Katz insisted that the chief of staff is obligated to carry out decisions made by the political leadership, while Ben-Gvir publicly demanded that Zamir implement the Gaza occupation plan.
Zamir, instead, recommended focused operations in central Gaza refugee camps, along with the establishment of a security cordon aimed at wearing down Hamas and prioritizing the safety of hostages. He argued that the failure to eliminate Hamas after 22 months of war would not be resolved through the occupation of Gaza.
Amid these diverging positions, expectations are growing for a possible compromise between the political and military leadership.
Some political and security officials believe Netanyahu floated the 'Gaza occupation' proposal as a tactical move — both to pressure Hamas into advancing toward a deal on his terms and to appease members of his coalition who view occupation as the only path to defeating Hamas.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
L'Orient-Le Jour
2 hours ago
- L'Orient-Le Jour
'Cairo and Ankara agree on the need to end the Israeli occupation in southern Lebanon,' Egyptian Foreign Minister says
Egypt and Turkey have agreed on the need to end the Israeli occupation in southern Lebanon, Egyptian Foreign Minister Badr Abdel Aaty said in a joint statement on Saturday. Israel continues to occupy five points in southern Lebanon and has carried out almost daily attacks there since a ceasefire on Nov. 27 ended nearly 13 months of fighting between Hezbollah and Israel. Israel has also launched attacks in the Bekaa Valley and the southern suburbs of Beirut since the cease-fire. On Thursday, the Lebanese government adopted the 'objectives' of a U.S. envoy Tom Barrack's roadmap, setting a deadline to restore the state's monopoly on arms by the end of the year. Abdel Aaty highlighted that relations between Egypt and Turkey are entering a crucial phase of strategic convergence. He noted that Egyptian President Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi discussed regional issues with Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan during his visit. Both countries emphasized the importance of addressing the situation in Gaza, opposing Israeli actions, and reaffirmed their support for the Palestinian right to establish an independent state. Meanwhile, amid international criticism, Israel's army prepared to take control of Gaza City to defeat Hamas and secure the release of hostages, while also distributing humanitarian aid to civilians outside combat zones. Egypt and Turkey also expressed their desire for Syria's stability across its entire territory. After a visit to Damascus, Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan praised Syria's efforts since the ousting of longtime ruler Bashar al-Assad in December and expressed interest in deepening ties. Turkey has built close relations with Syria's current authorities, who are working to attract investment for reconstructing infrastructure damaged during the country's civil war.
Nahar Net
3 hours ago
- Nahar Net
Gaza civil defense says 10 killed across territory
by Naharnet Newsdesk 09 August 2025, 13:05 Gaza's civil defense agency said at least 10 people were killed across the Palestinian territory on Saturday, including civilians who were waiting to collect aid. Civil defense spokesman Mahmud Bassal told AFP that at least six people were killed and 30 wounded after Israeli troops targeted civilians assembling near an aid point in central Gaza. The spokesman said strikes also hit areas in central Gaza, resulting in multiple casualties. Media restrictions in Gaza and difficulties accessing swathes of the territory mean AFP is unable to independently verify the tolls and details provided by the civil defense and the Israeli military. Thousands of Gazans congregate daily near food distribution points in Gaza, including four managed by the U.S.- and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation. Since launching in late May, its operations have been marred by almost-daily reports of Israeli forces targeting those waiting to collect aid supplies. Israeli restrictions on the entry of supplies into Gaza since the start of the war nearly two years ago have led to shortages of food and essential supplies, including medicine and fuel, which hospitals require to power their generators. Early Friday, the Israeli security cabinet approved plans to launch major operations to seize Gaza City, triggering a wave of outrage across the globe. Despite the backlash and rumors of dissent from Israeli military top brass, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu remained defiant over the decision. In a post on social media late Friday, Netanyahu said "we are not going to occupy Gaza -- we are going to free Gaza from Hamas". Netanyahu faces mounting pressure to secure a ceasefire to bring the territory's more than two million people back from the brink of famine and free the hostages held by Palestinian militants. Israel's arch enemy Hamas, whose October 7, 2023 attack triggered the war, slammed the plan to expand the fighting, calling it a "new war crime". Israel's offensive has killed over 61,000 Palestinians, according to Hamas-run Gaza's health ministry, figures the U.N. says are reliable. The 2023 attack on Israel resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, according to an AFP tally based on official figures.
L'Orient-Le Jour
7 hours ago
- L'Orient-Le Jour
Despite international criticism, Israel prepares to take control of Gaza
Under international criticism, the Israeli army prepared Saturday to take control of Gaza City, the largest in the Palestinian territory, in order to 'defeat' Hamas and secure the release of hostages. After 22 months of war, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu faces intense pressure both in Israel and abroad to end his offensive in the Gaza Strip, where more than two million Palestinians are threatened with 'widespread famine,' according to the U.N. Under a plan approved by Israel's security cabinet, the army 'is preparing to take control of Gaza City,' a largely destroyed urban area in the north of the territory, 'while distributing humanitarian aid to civilians outside combat zones.' Following the announcement of this plan, the U.N. Security Council will hold an emergency meeting on Gaza at 10 a.m. Sunday, several diplomatic sources told AFP on Friday. In addition to disarming Hamas and securing the return 'of all hostages, alive and dead,' the plan aims to demilitarize the Gaza Strip and place it under Israeli control before establishing 'a civilian administration' that is 'neither Hamas nor the Palestinian Authority,' Netanyahu's office said Friday. 'We are not going to occupy Gaza; we are going to free Gaza from Hamas,' which has ruled the territory since 2007, Netanyahu said on X. The army 'is already preparing today for full implementation of the decisions,' Defense Minister Israel Katz said. From Germany, one of Israel's staunchest allies, to the E.U., France, China and many Muslim countries, the plan's announcement has drawn international condemnation. The U.N. Security Council will meet Saturday in an emergency session. Berlin announced it would suspend exports of military equipment that could be used in the Gaza Strip. Netanyahu called Chancellor Friedrich Merz to 'express his disappointment' over sanctions that 'reward' Hamas. U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres warned Israel against 'a dangerous escalation' that 'risks worsening the already catastrophic consequences for millions of Palestinians.' 'Protect our young men' Hamas, which still holds 49 hostages, of which 27 presumed dead, said Israel's decision amounted to 'sacrificing' them. Buffeted for months by Israeli army evacuation orders and daily bombardments, Gaza City residents feared the worst. The occupation of the city 'will lead to many displacements. And we, as Palestinians, have been displaced dozens of times,' said Rafik Abu Jarad, a 54-year-old displaced resident. 'We will have to leave Gaza City to protect our young men, whom the occupier [Israel] will arrest,' said Jenin Rafik Abu Jarad, 23. 'Children and the elderly will be forced to walk for kilometers under the sun, when there is no food.' In Israel, hostage families are also concerned. The plan 'means abandoning the hostages, while completely ignoring repeated warnings from the military leadership and the clear will of the majority of the Israeli public,' the Hostages' Families Forum said. Currently, the Israeli army occupies or operates on the ground in nearly 75% of the Gaza Strip, mainly from permanent positions along the border. Israel previously occupied Gaza in 1967 and established 21 settlements, dismantled during its unilateral withdrawal in 2005. 'Risky' airdrops According to public broadcaster Kan, the Israeli plan calls for 'conquering Gaza City, whose residents will be evacuated over the next two months' to refugee camps. 'Then the troops will encircle the city and operate inside.' The army, in cooperation with intelligence services, announced Friday it had carried out a series of 'targeted eliminations' in Gaza, killing five Hamas and Islamic Jihad commanders and fighters who took part in the Oct. 7, 2023 attack on Israel. Civil Defense spokesperson Mahmoud Bassal told AFP Friday that 18 people were killed by Israeli fire across the Gaza Strip. He also expressed concern over the 'high risks' of injury and death caused by aid airdrops. According to Amjad Al-Chawa, director of the Palestinian NGOs Network in Gaza, inspection procedures at entry points slow aid deliveries, which he said are 'between 70 and 80 trucks per day,' while the U.N. estimates the need at at least 600 trucks daily. The WHO says 99 people, including 29 children under five, have died of malnutrition since January, 'figures likely underestimated.' The Gaza Health Ministry said Friday the toll was 202, including 98 children. Israeli reprisals have already killed 61,330 people in Gaza, mostly civilians, according to figures from the Gaza Health Ministry deemed reliable by the U.N. On the Israeli side, Hamas attack killed 1,219 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official data.
