Key West City Commissioners vote to end police agreement with ICE. What's next?
In a 6-1 vote Tuesday, the City Commission said the agreement, which allows police officers to stop, question and detain undocumented immigrants, was not enforceable because it was approved by the police chief and not the city manager by way of elected officials.
'I try not to make decisions with my heart because it can get me into trouble,' said Commissioner Donald Lee, the city's former police chief, who voted to sever the so-called 287(g) agreement, named after a section in the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996.
READ MORE: 'Govern yourselves accordingly': Florida goes after city that rejected ICE partnership
'Tonight, I am going to make a decision from my heart, and I hope it doesn't get the city in trouble,' Lee said.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier indicated in a statement released on X Tuesday morning that his office is prepared to take action against the Southernmost City.
'The City of Key West will be hearing from my office very soon,' Uthmeier wrote.
In Florida, law enforcement departments that operate county jails must enter partnerships with the federal government so their officers can carry out limited immigration agent functions.
State statutes do not explicitly require local and municipal police departments to join these agreements with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, known as the 287(g) program. But DeSantis and his administration have put pressure on local officials, saying that their departments must join to comply with the state's sanctuary city laws, which prohibit local governments from limiting collaboration with ICE.
READ MORE: Bunk beds and 28,000 feet of razor wire. Look inside Florida's Alligator Alcatraz
In correspondence, Uthmeier's office has threatened local officials in Orlando and Ft Myers with removal from office if their local governments don't agree to have their police departments join 287(g) agreements.
DeSantis Tuesday told reporters at the opening of the new 'Alligator Alcatraz' immigration detention facility in the Everglades that Key West officials could face suspension as a result of not upholding the agreement.
READ MORE: It's official: Alligator Alcatraz is not a nickname. It's Florida's name for detention site
'I think the attorney general has weighed in on that, and I'll let him do the analysis and sent them whatever warnings need to be sent. But, the reality is, you have a responsibility for full participation,' DeSantis said. 'And, you can virtue signal and try to make political statements, but the reality is, local governments have to abide by Florida law.
Residents and business owners packed City Hall for the meeting to protest the agreement, saying undocumented immigrants who live and work in the city are living in fear already because of ICE agents who have been operating in the Keys since the Trump administration began its mass deportation program earlier this year.
Bobi Lore, owner of the Island House Key West Resort on Fleming Street, said 'masked, unnamed, unnumbered and heavily armed' ICE agents are spreading 'terrorism' in the city, and he said local police officers should not be helping them.
'Everybody is afraid. It doesn't matter whether we're talking about immigrants. This is not about immigrants anymore. This is about a deep fear and intimidation practice that is being spread throughout the entire country,' Lore said. 'But for Key West, a place we consider paradise, a place we consider one of the best places on this earth to live, work and be, it's just completely unacceptable.'
READ MORE: Do FL cities need to do immigration enforcement? City of South Miami sues to find out
Police Chief Sean Brandenburg singed the agreement with ICE in March, he said, because he was told by colleagues in other municipalities that if he didn't, he faced removal of office by the governor.
'It has been made abundantly clear that entering into the 287(g) is the law, and I am trying to follow the law,' Brandenburg told commissioners.
Commissioner Samuel Kaufman said he did not know the city had entered into the agreement until last month when a group of business owners told him that their employees have been detained by ICE who have legal status to be in the country, including asylum seekers and those with permanent legal residency, or Green Card holders.
They then told him that Key West police entered into the 287(g) agreement.
'No way, I didn't believe it,' Kaufman said, adding later in the meeting, 'Why was I informed by constituents three months after that agreement was put in place? That's just improper.'
The meeting held Monday was to terminate the agreement, but Kaufman, who is trial and litigation attorney, changed the resolution, arguing there was nothing to terminate because, in his view, it was not singed by the city manager under the delegation of the city council.
'The agreement is void,' he said. 'So, we don't have to terminate the agreement.'
The resolution to end the agreement was approved by Commissioner Monica Haskell, who introduced it, Kaufman, Lee and Commissioners Mary Lou Hoover and Aaron Castillo. Commissioner Lissette Cuervo Carey voted against it.
Carey told the Herald having a mother and grandmother who immigrated from Cuba to Key West in the 1950s, she is a supporter of legal immigration, but, 'I believe in upholding and respecting the laws of the State of Florida. As a public servant, I am committed to making decisions that balance compassion, legal integrity, and the best interests of our city.'
Carey said she heard from constituents who were concerned about defying the state.
'Having done extensive research on this issue — and after reviewing how similar decisions have affected cities like Fort Myers — I recognized the potential consequences, including the risk of losing critical funding and other repercussions that could significantly impact our city. Based on this understanding, I felt it was important to vote the way I did,' she said.
READ MORE: Trump OKs using National Guard as immigration judges at Florida detention center
Chris McNulty, executive director of the Queer Keys Community Center, said several of his immigrant friends wanted to speak at the meeting, but were afraid doing so would put them at risk of detention from ICE. And while he said more Key West immigrants speaking out would make a powerful statement, he has been advising them to keep a low profile.
'I love my community, and I love my immigrant friends, and I am pained that they are afraid, and I am actually afraid for my immigrant friends who are not afraid,' McNulty said.
Miami Herald immigration reporter Syra Ortiz Blanes contributed to this report.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump Asks DeSantis A Cringe Question About Marjorie Taylor Greene, In Front Of Her Boyfriend
President Donald Trump on Tuesday asked Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) what it might be like to date Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.), creating an awkward scene as Greene's boyfriend looked on. Trump, during a visit to his administration's controversial new 'Alligator Alcatraz' migration detention center in the Everglades, came across Real America's Voice's Brian Glenn, who is dating Greene. Trump introduced DeSantis to Glenn. 'Hi Brian. Ron, this is the boyfriend, very lucky, of Marjorie Taylor Greene,' said the president. 'Oh really?' replied DeSantis. Trump informed DeSantis who Glenn works for, then asked the governor: 'Do you think it's easy being with Marjorie?' DeSantis laughed off the question and Trump and DeSantis eventually moved on. Glenn shared a video of the moment on X, formerly Twitter. 'I'm not going to answer that… kidding,' he wrote of Trump's question about whether 'it's easy being' with Greene. Both are huge Trump supporters. He then added that conspiracy theory-floating, anti-Islam remark-making Greene is 'a joy to be with and I love her with all my heart.' Greene shared her beau's post on X with a smiling face with hearts emoji. Wall Street Journal Warns Trump May Have Just Sabotaged His Own Presidency Karoline Leavitt's Giddy 'Alligator Alcatraz' Pitch Sends Shivers Down Critics' Spines Ex-GOP Strategist Warns How A Lara Trump Run Could Backfire Badly On Republicans
Los Angeles Times
39 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
Immigration raids targeting workers spark dissent even in Trump-friendly Orange County
As protests broke out in cities across Southern California over President Trump's aggressive immigration enforcement sweeps, the mood in Huntington Beach was celebratory. 'Make America Great Again' and 'Trump 2024' banners waved at the intersection of Main Street and Pacific Coast Highway as the president's supporters turned out at a protest last month. One sign held up by a teen encouraged attendees to 'support your local ICE raid.' It wasn't a surprise in the conservative beach town where leaders had months earlier declared Huntington Beach a nonsanctuary city. At the time, the city filed a lawsuit against the state over its law limiting cooperation between local law enforcement and federal immigration authorities, arguing that illegal immigration was to blame for a rise in crime. 'Huntington Beach will not sit idly by and allow the obstructionist sanctuary state law to put our 200,000 residents at risk of harm from those who seek to commit violent crimes on U.S. soil,' Mayor Pat Burns said at the time. Elsewhere in Orange County, particularly in cities with higher immigrant populations, the conversation about the raids has been much more muted. Republicans who voted for Trump and support his efforts to deport those who have committed crimes expressed hesitation about the sweeps that have targeted workers and longtime residents. A group of Republican legislators in California, including two who represent Orange County, sent a letter to Trump last week urging him to direct United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the Department of Homeland Security to focus their enforcement operations on criminals and 'avoid the kinds of sweeping raids that instill fear and disrupt the workplace.' 'The fear is driving vital workers out of critical industries, taking California's affordability crisis and making it even worse for our constituents,' wrote the legislators, including Assemblymembers Diane Dixon (R-Newport Beach) and Laurie Davies (R-Laguna Niguel). They called on Trump to modernize the country's immigration process to give undocumented immigrants with long-standing local ties a path toward legal status. Jo Reitkopp, a Republican political organizer from Orange, supports Trump's immigration policy, saying that she believes the country has become safer since he began fulfilling his campaign promise to rid the country of criminals. But her own family's history has softened her opinion about the raids, despite her stance that deportations should continue. Her father, an undocumented immigrant from Sicily, was deported to Italy in the 1950s after he'd met Reitkopp's mother. He later returned to America using a pathway for immigrants to gain legal status, she said. 'I do have a lot of compassion for the people who don't know their home country or came when they were 5,' she said. 'I don't understand why they never became citizens. If they would've, they wouldn't have been deported.' Although Trump has repeatedly said his administration is focusing deportation efforts on criminals, data show that the majority of those arrested in early June in the Los Angeles area were men who had never been charged with a crime. In the early days of the enforcement action — between June 1 and 10 — about 69% of those arrested in the Los Angeles region had no criminal conviction and 58% had never been charged with a crime, according to a Times data analysis. Reitkopp said it's 'sad' when raids sweep up individuals who haven't committed crimes. But the federal government's offer for undocumented immigrants to self-deport and possibly have a chance to return is a silver lining, she added. 'It's a bad scenario, but [Trump] is giving them an opportunity,' she said. Trump's plans for deportations that he outlined during his campaign aren't particularly popular among many Orange County voters. Only a third of Orange County residents who responded to a UC Irvine poll published in January agreed with Trump on the issue. Nearly 60% of residents polled preferred that undocumented individuals have an option to obtain legal status. Although almost half of white respondents supported deportations, nearly three-quarters of Latino respondents preferred an option for legal status, the poll shows. Orange County is home to roughly 236,000 undocumented immigrants, the majority of whom were born in Mexico, Central America and Asia, according to data published in 2019 from the Migration Policy Institute. Data at the time show that 33% of those undocumented individuals had been in the United States for at least 20 years and that 67% were employed. Jeffrey Ball, president and CEO of the Orange County Business Council, said he agrees with California lawmakers calling for immigration enforcement to be focused on criminals rather than broader sweeps. While businesses so far haven't reported significant impacts, Ball said when people don't feel safe working 'it's not the type of positive environment you want from a business standpoint.' 'This immigrant population is an important part of our workforce,' he said. 'We are still in a labor shortage in this region and so to the extent you have people leaving the region out of fear or not feeling comfortable going to work it further exacerbates some of the problems we have related to the efficiency and reliability of the workforce.' Christopher Granucci, an independent, acknowledged that although illegal immigration has become a problem for many in Southern California, he's troubled by the indiscriminate nature of the deportations. 'We have millions and millions of people who came in, but I think they need to be laser-focused on the real criminals,' Granucci said. 'I think for those criminals, everyone in the country agrees that they should be kicked out.' As a teacher, Granucci has seen students whose parents aren't legal residents or are on a path to obtaining residency. 'If they could be more strategic about who is being removed, that would be so much better,' Granucci said. 'Right now, everyone is freaked out. Students are freaked out and parents are freaked out because of it.' In areas of Little Saigon — which encompasses parts of Westminster, Fountain Valley, Garden Grove and Santa Ana — news of the raids has hit the community harder than ever before. There are many undocumented Vietnamese residents who call the largest ethnic enclave outside of Vietnam home. But many weren't concerned about facing deportations for years, activists say, because of a 2008 agreement between the United States and Vietnam that allowed most Vietnamese immigrants who entered the United States before 1995 — mainly refugees who fled violence following the Vietnam War — to stay in the country. An updated memorandum of understanding between the U.S. and Vietnam in 2020 created a process for deporting such immigrants. 'What we're seeing is the people who are immigrants themselves that support Trump's deportation agenda only support it until it affects them,' said Tracy La, executive director of VietRISE. 'Trump isn't just going after undocumented Latino immigrants — he's going after Vietnamese, other Southeast Asians, Chinese, Indian and many other communities. That's something that I think a lot of people who supported it have been grappling with.' In Fountain Valley, a city with a large Vietnamese American population where 32% of residents identify as being foreign-born, Mayor Ted Bui hasn't seen much public pushback for the raids. Many of the Vietnamese Americans who live there value law and order, and see the raids as federal law enforcement simply carrying out their duties, he said. He feels the same, he said. Bui's family fled Vietnam after the fall of Saigon, first heading to France, where his grandfather was a citizen. He later came to the United States to study under a student visa. He fell in love with the graciousness he felt among Americans and went through the process to become a citizen, he said. 'What are we saying if we allow people to break the law?' Bui said. 'If we allow people to break the law, then why have laws in the first place? There would be no meaning behind it, and we'd be a country of chaos.' Three decades ago, Orange County was the birthplace of Proposition 187, a statewide ballot initiative that would have denied schooling, nonemergency healthcare and other public services to immigrants living in the country illegally. The measure, which passed 59% to 41% in 1994, would have also required teachers to tell authorities about any children they suspected of being in the country illegally. But the act never took effect after being blocked by federal judges. Anti-illegal immigration sentiment in Orange County still ran deep into the early 2000s. In Costa Mesa, then-Mayor Allan Mansoor presented a plan in 2005 to train city police officers to enforce immigration law. As the demographics of Orange County continued to change — transitioning from a reliable Republican stronghold to a politically competitive locale — immigration became a more nuanced issue even in Republican circles. In the 2024 presidential election, Kamala Harris won Orange County, but by a much tighter margin than either Hillary Clinton in 2016 or Joe Biden in 2020, cementing the county's position as a suburban battleground. In Santa Ana, a Latino immigrant hub in the center of Orange County, immigration sweeps sparked days of protests downtown. City officials have demanded that National Guard troops at the federal courthouse leave and have been working on ways to help those swept up and their families. Santa Ana City Councilmember Thai Viet Phan, a Democrat, said even those who agree with Trump about better border protection are unnerved by raids outside Home Depots and at car washes. 'People have a lot of sympathy,' Phan said. 'People voted for Trump based on a variety of things, principally the economy. But I don't think they anticipated it would be like this.'
Los Angeles Times
39 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
Faith leaders bear witness as migrants make their case in immigration court
Rev. Jason Cook, a minister at Tapestry, a Unitarian Universalist congregation, wore his traditional white collar and a colorful stole resembling stained glass when he arrived at immigration court in Santa Ana last Friday. For several weeks, Cook and clergy members from a cross section of religions have been showing up at courtrooms in Orange County, Los Angeles, San Francisco and San Diego to stand with immigrants during their deportation hearings. The practice was launched after faith leaders learned that many immigrants seeking asylum were being whisked away by federal agents after what had been billed as routine court appearances, and locked up in remote detention facilities without a chance to prepare or say goodbye to family. They have sought to use their presence to comfort migrants and lend a sense of moral authority to the proceedings. They have also taken to the courtroom benches to bear witness with silent prayer. On Friday, clergy members roamed the courthouse halls in search of Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents. If plainclothes agents sat outside a courtroom, it was a good indication that the migrants inside had been targeted for expedited removal once their cases were heard. Cook knows the presence of clergy won't necessarily change the outcome of the legal proceedings — though in at least one instance last month, ICE agents scattered when clergy showed up at a courthouse in San Diego. If nothing else, they hope to offer spiritual comfort, so the immigrants know they're not forgotten. 'There's a big piece of [our faith] that's about welcoming the stranger, about treating immigrants with compassion and care,' Cook said. 'We're there trying to appeal to a higher authority than ICE.' Many of the immigrants being detained at immigration court are asylum seekers who came into the country using the CBP One mobile app that the Biden administration had employed since early 2023 to create a more orderly process of applying for asylum. Migrants could use the app once they reached Mexican soil to schedule appointments with U.S. authorities at legal ports of entry to present their bids for asylum and provide biographical information for screening. President Trump shut down the CBP One app hours after taking office in January. His administration has given ICE officials the power to quickly deport tens of thousands of immigrants who were granted legal entry to the U.S. for up to two years through the CBP One program, and is waging legal battles to roll back protections for hundreds of thousands of migrants from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela who were granted temporary parole while seeking asylum. Faith leaders say the work is an extension of their services for immigrants, who often attend their churches in sizable numbers. In the past, some places of worship have opened up their doors to shelter undocumented immigrants at risk of being deported. In L.A., faith leaders have organized food drives for immigrants afraid to leave their homes, as well as vigils and peaceful marches at the downtown Los Angeles federal building. In the Inland Empire, clergy members have gone into grape fields to hand out 'Know Your Rights' cards. 'Throughout history, across the world, clergy and faith leaders and spiritual leaders have played a really catalytic role in bending the arc toward moral justice,' said Joseph Tomás Mckellar, executive director of PICO California, the largest faith-based community organizing network in the state. 'When they do it right, they leave space for others to walk the walk, as well.' On June 11, the Catholic Diocese of San Diego reached out to area clergy to ask for help in expanding efforts to accompany migrants to their hearings. Father Scott Santarosa, of Our Lady of Guadalupe Parish, said the letter garnered so much interest, they had to limit the number of clergy who could attend. That Friday, which also coincided with World Refugee Day, they held a Mass before arriving at immigration court. 'We weren't planning to block or get in the way or do anything to disrupt. We just planned to be present and observe and say with our presence to migrants and refugees, 'Hey, you're not alone,'' he said. One Venezuelan asylum seeker, who asked not to be identified for fear of retribution if she is deported back to her home country, had a hearing scheduled in L.A. County in early June with her children. She arrived in the U.S. in December after entering through the CBP One app. The June hearing would be her first. She knew she was at risk of deportation and wondered whether to attend her hearing. She shared her fears with an area pastor, who offered to go with her. On the morning of her hearing, she arrived at court accompanied by three pastors and a translator. She felt protected, she said, when the judge granted a future court hearing and she was allowed to leave. 'Everything went well,' she said. 'I feel as if it was because of the Christian support that I had at that moment.' Cook, the Unitarian Universalist minister in Orange County, said he attends court at least twice a week. Initially, ICE agents seemed averse to confronting religious leaders, and in some cases, left the courthouse when clergy members arrived. But over time, Cook said, the agents have gotten more confrontational, telling clergy they must stay 10 feet away from agents. He said he watched one ICE agent push a clergy member against the wall after she tried to escort an immigrant out of court. They have carried on, he said, because the work feels important and aligned with their mission of faith. 'What we are is conscience on display for these folks, and if that triggers shame or reflection, that's a good thing,' Cook said outside a courtroom, not far from ICE agents. Dave Gibbons, founder of the Newsong Church in Santa Ana, said he took a break from court visits after a Central American couple he was escorting got pulled away and detained in front of their child. He broke down in tears recounting the episode for his congregation. But he was determined to return. 'We believe it's at the heart of the gospel,' Gibbons said. 'There's nothing more sacred than standing alongside those being marginalized.' Rev. Terry LePage, a community minister in Orange County, has attended immigration hearings nearly daily. She spent Friday morning handing out fliers that notified migrants headed to hearings of their rights and warning that ICE agents were present. That morning, clergy members encountered a Haitian man who had been granted temporary protected status during the Biden administration. He arrived for his asylum hearing without an attorney. He wore a crisp white shirt and carried his documents in a black case. Clergy leaders urged him to contact his family and let them know that he might be detained. But the man, who spoke Spanish, was sure he would be allowed to return home. Inside the courtroom, a Department of Homeland Security attorney argued that the man's case should be dismissed, a request the judge granted despite the migrant's pleas. Seated in the audience, Thomas Crisp, an Orange County chaplain, watched in dismay and offered a few last words of comfort: 'May God bless you.' The Haitian man made it two steps out of the courtroom before he was swarmed by federal agents and ushered down an emergency exit stairwell. This article is part of The Times' equity reporting initiative, funded by the James Irvine Foundation, exploring the challenges facing low-income workers and the efforts being made to address California's economic divide.
