WhatsApp's new ad feature sparks backlash—and a golden opportunity for Signal
After the tech giant announced it would begin to include ads in WhatsApp's Updates tab, which is used by roughly 1.5 million people per day, Signal president Meredith Whittaker took to X to lure users to her messaging tool: 'Use Signal,' she wrote. 'We promise, no AI clutter, no surveillance ads—whatever the rest of the industry does.'
Signal and WhatsApp have long competed to attract encryption-minded users. Meta's promises that its new WhatsApp ad features would be implemented 'in the most privacy-oriented way possible,' have done little to quell doubts. Max Schrems, a data privacy advocate who runs the European non-profit Noyb, warned that with the addition of ads Metawas blatantly ignoring EU privacy laws. 'Meta seems to follow the approach by the Trump administration and simply ignores EU rules as somehow 'illegitimate,'' he wrote in a blog post. 'European regulators urgently need to take clear action.'
Privacy concerns overMeta's data practices reached a fever pitch in 2018 with the Cambridge Analytica scandal. In 2021, WhatsApp saw another wave of users migrate to Signal after a privacy policy update allowed for increased data sharing with businesses and third-parties.
Monday's addition of ads raised more concerns. As Lena Cohen, a staff technologist at the Electronic Frontier Foundation told Fast Company this week, 'the fact that Meta has promised that it's adding ads to WhatsApp with privacy in mind does not make me trust this new feature.'
Signal is adept at turning such moments into branding opportunities. Earlier this year, it saw a surge in sign-ups in the midst of the 'Signalgate' national security crisis —when a journalist from The Atlantic was accidentally added to a private Signal group chat involving the highest levels of government that discussed, in real time, an imminent U.S. military strike—in part because it became part of the national discussion, but also because Signal ensured the story wasn't spun to blame the app for the leak
Whittaker has never hesitated to take a swing at WhatsApp and Meta, either. Earlier this year, in an interview with a Dutch newspaper, she discussed the app's data collection, saying 'It tells you exactly who you're communicating with, at what time, how often, and where you are. You can derive so much from that. WhatsApp can link that information to Facebook, to Instagram and to payment data that they could buy into. Signal simply doesn't have all that data.'
Will Cathcart, WhatsApp's head, denied that, saying his product used the same security protocol as Signal. (The war of words continued to escalate between the two for days to follow.)
While Signal might have the guerrilla marketing upper hand, WhatsApp wins when it comes to scale. WhatsApp reportedly has roughly three billion monthly active users globally, and Signal has an estimated 40 to 70 million.
Signal is a nonprofit and open-source platform, whereas WhatsApp has benefited from Meta's resources and marketing muscle (advantages that aid in user growth but can also prompt suspicions). 'Meta's business model is based on collecting as much data as they can about people in order to sell highly targeted ads,' the EFF's Cohen tells Fast Company. 'The reason this new [WhatsApp] feature concerns me is that it creates yet another opportunity for Meta to abuse people's private information.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Android Authority
15 minutes ago
- Android Authority
Multiple Galaxy S25 FE leaks reveal renders, colors, and possible launch date
Ryan Haines / Android Authority Galaxy S24 FE TL;DR New renders of the Galaxy S25 FE have leaked. The names of the colorways could be Awesome Black, Midnight Blue, Light Blue, and White. The launch date will reportedly be September 5, 2025. Samsung will be hosting a press conference next month during Europe's largest consumer electronics trade show, IFA. While the focus is expected to be mostly on AI, it's possible the company could also use the moment to announce its next Android phone, the Galaxy S25 FE. While that event is weeks away, there's some new Galaxy S25 FE leaks you can check out right now. Don't want to miss the best from Android Authority? Set us as a preferred source in Google Search to support us and make sure you never miss our latest exclusive reports, expert analysis, and much more. The Galaxy S25 FE has appeared once again in a new leak from Android Headlines. In this leak, we get a look at renders that show the handset in all four of its available colors. These renders arrive a little over a week after a previous leak gave us our first potential look at the colorways. There are a few differences between the previous leak and these renders. For example, the Navy shade looks a little duller here than it does in last week's leak. Another difference is that the frame on the black colorway is silver, whereas the frame was black in the other report. Also, Icy Blue appears to have a pinker hue in these renders. In addition to showing the color options, today's leak provides a view of the Galaxy S25 FE from different angles. We can see the front, left side, right side, and back of the device. This wasn't the only leak about the Fan Edition phone today. The folks over at Dealabs have shared what could be the official colorway names, configurations, European prices, and launch date. According to the report, here's what we're looking at: Galaxy S25 FE (8GB / 128GB): Absolute Black, Midnight Blue, Light Blue, White | €749 ($871) Absolute Black, Midnight Blue, Light Blue, White | €749 ($871) Galaxy S25 FE (8GB / 256GB): Absolute Black, Midnight Blue, Light Blue, White | €809 ($941) Absolute Black, Midnight Blue, Light Blue, White | €809 ($941) Galaxy S25 FE (8 GB / 512GB): Absolute Black, Midnight Blue | €929 ($1,081) The report claims that Samsung will launch the phone on September 5, 2025. If this is true, then it would indeed be announced during IFA. Samsung is also working on the Galaxy Tab S11, S11 Ultra, and S10 Lite. It's not implausible to think that if Samsung launches the Galaxy S25 FE on this date, it could also use the event to launch these tablets. Follow
Entrepreneur
15 minutes ago
- Entrepreneur
James Dyson Created His 'Mad' Vacuum Idea While $1M in Debt
It took James Dyson five years of work and 5,127 failed prototypes to create the world's first bagless vacuum cleaner. In 1978, James Dyson had an idea for a bagless vacuum cleaner that maintained suction. He was frustrated with what was considered to be a top-of-the-line model, which he said frequently clogged and lost cleaning power as soon as it filled with dust. Dyson worked on his idea full-time, and after five years of work and 5,127 failed prototypes, he created the world's first bagless vacuum cleaner — the now-famous Dyson, which has since become a consumer electronics brand reaching sales of $9.6 billion in 2023. But those early years came at a cost: He was borrowing heavily from the bank to make ends meet and had accumulated over $1 million in debt. "Eventually, I owed over a million dollars, which for a penniless person in those days, going back 30 odd years, was a lot of money," Dyson, 78, told Entrepreneur in an interview. "I didn't have any money." Related: Emma Grede Dropped Out of School at 16. Now the Skims Boss Runs a $4 Billion Empire. But he also had "little to lose," he says, which is why he took a chance on his vacuum idea despite the financial pit. He lost his father at a young age and felt a keen sense of ownership and passion for what he was building and for his future. "I suppose I don't mind living on the edge," Dyson said. "I lost my father when I was nine years old. I had it built into me that my future was entirely down to me, and to do it on my own." "I wanted to do it," he added. James Dyson. Credit: Dyson Financial constraints made Dyson more creative because not having money taught him how to cope without it. For example, he couldn't hire salespeople, advertisers, or promoters, so he went out himself to sell the vacuum cleaner. "It took quite a long time," Dyson said. "Almost every businessperson I spoke to said that I was mad." Related: Nick Offerman's Side Hustle as an Actor Helps Fund the Business He Started 23 Years Ago — and Still Works at Every Day In 1993, Dyson set up his own shop and produced the first unit of the Dyson Dual Cyclone DC-01 vacuum cleaner at a price of $399. By 1998, Dyson had sold 1.4 million units of the vacuum globally, and by 2004, the DC-01 was cemented as a commercial success, outselling its nearest competitor in the U.K. by a ratio of five to one, per Industry Week. In recent years, Dyson's eponymous company has reached new heights. In 2023, with a broader product portfolio, including hair tools, lighting, fans, and headphones, Dyson's company achieved a record global revenue of £7.1 billion ($9.6 billion) and employed 6,500 workers. Revenue increased 9% from the previous year. Now, Dyson's net worth is reportedly around $15.3 billion, making him the third-wealthiest person in the U.K. He's received other honors, too, including a knighthood in 2006 for his services to business. Related: A Billionaire Founder Admits He Had 'Horrible Habits' — Then He Started a Morning Routine That 'Transformed' His Life Dyson has certainly paid off those early debts and says he celebrates the "little successes" just as much (or even more) than the big ones. He points to Dyson hand dryers as an example — the product isn't a "huge" business, like, say, the Dyson hair dryer, he says, but he still finds it "interesting." "You shouldn't do everything in life just to get big numbers, big successes," Dyson said. "Little successes are just as satisfying."
Washington Post
16 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Wrexham smashes its transfer record by signing Broadhead in a deal worth up to $13.5M
Wrexham's spending moved into a new stratosphere Thursday when the team owned by Hollywood celebrities signed winger Nathan Broadhead from Ipswich in a club-record deal that could reportedly reach 10 million pounds ($13.50 million). It took the Welsh club's outlay in the transfer market to more than 20 million pounds ($27 million) in this window as Wrexham reshapes its squad for life in the second-tier Championship following an unprecedented three straight promotions .
