Israeli data shows 83 percent of Gaza war dead are civilians: Report
Figures reviewed by the outlets revealed on Thursday indicate that, as of May 2025 – 19 months into Israel's war on Gaza – Israeli military intelligence had listed 8,900 fighters from Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ) as confirmed or 'probably' dead.
Over the same period, Gaza's health authorities recorded at least 53,000 deaths from Israeli attacks, meaning that named fighters accounted for just 17 percent of those killed, with civilians at about about 83 percent of the total death toll.
Conflict researchers say that ratio is almost unparalleled in modern warfare. Only the Rwandan genocide, the 1995 Srebrenica massacre, and Russia's 2022 siege of Mariupol recorded a higher civilian death rate, the authors noted.
Rights groups and genocide scholars argue the findings further support claims that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza, pointing to mass civilian deaths alongside deliberate starvation.
When asked to comment by The Guardian, +972 Magazine, and Local Call, the Israeli military did not deny the existence of the intelligence database or the listed figures for Hamas and PIJ casualties.
Instead, a spokesperson said 'figures presented in the article are incorrect', but did not clarify which numbers were disputed. The statement also claimed the data does 'not reflect the data available in the [Israeli military's] systems', without explaining what those systems contained.
Israeli politicians and military leaders have long inflated fighter death tolls, at times claiming as many as 20,000 fighters killed or insisting on a civilian-to-combatant ratio of 1:1 – figures that the report notes they do not believe in private.
Meanwhile, Israeli rhetoric has increasingly mirrored genocidal language.
In leaked audio recordings aired on Israel's Channel 12, Aharon Haliva, the former head of military intelligence, claimed, 'The fact that there are already 50,000 dead in Gaza is necessary and required for future generations.'
He went further, saying: 'For each [victim] on 7 October, 50 Palestinians have to die … There's no choice, they need a Nakba every now and then to feel the consequences.' The Nakba, or 'catastrophe', refers to the killing and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians in 1948 to make way for the creation of Israel.
By March, Gaza's death toll had reached 50,000; it has since risen to beyond 62,000, according to the enclave's health ministry. The total number of wounded has now exceeded 157,000.
The International Criminal Court has issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant, accusing them of war crimes and crimes against humanity committed between October 2023 and May 2024.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
2 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
UN chief calls for immediate Gaza ceasefire
QNA Tokyo United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres on Thursday called for an immediate ceasefire in the Gaza Strip, after the Israeli entity announced the first steps of an operation to take over Gaza City. 'It is vital to reach immediately a ceasefire in Gaza,' that was necessary 'to avoid the death and destruction that a military operation against Gaza City would inevitably cause,' Guterres said in Japan where he is attending the Tokyo International Conference on African Development. Guterres urged Israel to reverse a decision to expand 'illegal' settlement construction in the West Bank.
Qatar Tribune
2 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
UK summons Israeli ambassador over West Bank settlement plan
LondoncTypeface:> The British Foreign Office has summoned Israeli Ambassador Tzipi Hotovely over Tel Aviv's approval of a major settlement in the West Bank. The move follows Israel's decision to go ahead with the E1 settlement east of Jerusalem, which would effectively cut the West Bank in two. In a joint statement on Thursday, foreign ministers from the United Kingdom, European Union and 20 countries called on Tel Aviv to reverse the decision, saying it would bring 'no benefits to the Israeli people' and 'risks undermining security and fuels further violence and instability.' They added: 'The government of Israel still has an opportunity to stop the E1 plan going any further. We encourage them to urgently retract this plan.' The E1 settlement has been under consideration by Israel for at least two decades, but has previously been prevented by pressure from the US. (dpa)
Al Jazeera
2 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Netanyahu approves Gaza City seizure despite ordering truce talks to resume
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he will give final approval for the seizure of Gaza City while also restarting negotiations with Hamas aimed at returning all the remaining captives and ending the nearly two-year-old war, but on 'terms acceptable to Israel'. Speaking to soldiers near Gaza on Thursday, Netanyahu said he was still set on approving plans for seizing Gaza City, the densely populated centre at the heart of the Palestinian enclave, forcibly displacing close to 1 million people and carrying out the systematic demolitions of Palestinian homes. 'At the same time I have issued instructions to begin immediate negotiations for the release of all our hostages and an end to the war on terms acceptable to Israel,' Netanyahu said, adding: 'We are in the decision-making phase.' The wide-scale operation in Gaza City could start within days after Netanyahu grants final approval at a meeting with senior security officials later on Thursday. Israeli forces have already stepped up attacks there, and thousands of Palestinians have left their homes as Israeli tanks edged closer to Gaza City over the last 10 days. Hamas said earlier this week that it had agreed to a ceasefire proposal from mediators Qatar and Egypt, which, if accepted by Israel, could forestall the assault. Israel's army plans to call up 60,000 reservists and extend the service of 20,000 more. The proposal on the table calls for a 60-day ceasefire and the release of 10 living captives held in Gaza by Hamas and of 18 bodies. In turn, Israel would release about 200 Palestinian prisoners held by Israel. Once the temporary ceasefire begins, the proposal is for Hamas and Israel to begin negotiations on a permanent ceasefire that would include the return of the remaining captives. Marwan Bishara, Al Jazeera's senior political analyst, has likened Netanyahu's announcement about relaunching purported truce talks while the military escalates its assault on Gaza City to 'negotiation under fire'. 'There will be no stoppage of the fighting. There will be no breaks in the genocide. Hamas is going to have to make up its mind as Israel kills dozens, perhaps hundreds, of Palestinians moving forward [and] as it transfers a million Palestinians southward in Gaza,' Bishara said. 'Israel is now dictating all the terms, and it's not listening to anyone, and it has a green light from Washington.' At least 43 Palestinians were killed in Israeli attacks across Gaza since dawn, including 13 aid seekers who were the latest victims of shootings at GHF aid distribution points. Meanwhile, two more people have starved to death in Gaza in the past 24 hours, the Health Ministry said on Thursday. The new deaths raised the number of Palestinians who have died from Israeli-induced hunger to 271, including 112 children, since the war began. 'Systematic destruction' A renewed Israeli offensive could bring even more casualties and displacement to the famine-struck territory. The UN agency for Palestinian refugees (UNRWA) estimated that 90 percent of Gaza's residents have been displaced, warning that shelters are deteriorating and any further displacement will worsen the catastrophic situation. The Palestinian Ministry of Interior denounced Israel's push to seize Gaza City as a 'death sentence' for the more than one million people living there. The Palestinian Health Ministry also released a statement responding to what it says is an Israeli push to transfer health system resources to the south of the enclave. 'The Ministry of Health expresses its rejection of any step that would undermine what remains of the health system following the systematic destruction carried out by the Israeli occupation authorities,' it said. 'This step would deprive more than one million people of their right to treatment and put the lives of residents, patients and the wounded at imminent risk.' Some Palestinian families in Gaza City have left for shelters along the coast, while others have moved to central and southern parts of the enclave, according to residents there. 'We are facing a bitter, bitter situation, to die at home or leave and die somewhere else. As long as this war continues, survival is uncertain,' Rabah Abu Elias, 67, a father of seven, told the Reuters news agency. 'In the news, they speak about a possible truce, on the ground, we only hear explosions and see deaths. To leave Gaza City or not isn't an easy decision to make,' he said. Meanwhile, Israeli air attacks also destroyed a tent camp in Deir el-Balah, central Gaza, where many people have sought refuge. Residents said the Israeli military warned them to flee shortly before the attacks set the camp ablaze. Families, many with children, could later be seen sifting through the ashes for the belongings they had managed to take with them during earlier evacuations. Mohammad Kahlout, who had been displaced from northern Gaza, told The Associated Press they were given just five minutes to gather what they could and flee. 'We are civilians, not terrorists. What did we do, and what did our children do, to be displaced again?'
