Property taxes hit low-income areas hard
Why it matters: The study helps explain why homeowners and renters have seen their taxes and rents rise in recent years, adding to the city's housing cost burden.
From 2021 to 2023 commercial real estate owners saw their property tax bills drop by $3.3 billion, while homeowners took on nearly $2 billion more in taxes.
Yes, but: Those years wreaked havoc on the commercial real estate market as remote work slashed demand for office space. So their lowered valuations and taxes aren't a huge surprise.
By the numbers: The analysis revealed that business property owners appealed their valuations more than twice as often as homeowners.
While business reductions rose to $25.5 billion from 2021 to 2023 (compared with $9.9 billion from 2015 to 2017), assessed value reductions for homeowners declined.
What they're saying: The Board of Review"cut $17.3 billion in commercial property values on appeal, turning $22.5 billion of potential growth into an increase of just $5.2 billion," Cook County Assessor spokesperson Christian Belanger tells Axios.
The other side: The BOR reduced the assessment because "the Assessor has been overvaluing properties," BOR commissioner Samantha Steele tells Axios.
Our "role is to give the taxpayers their due process. … It's time for the Assessor to do the basic functions of the office and get the assessments right in the first place."
Of note: An independent analysis of CCAO and BOR actions suggests that both agencies have mis-assessed values, albeit in different county regions.
Rich vs poor neighborhoods: Homeowners in the wealthiest neighborhoods were four times more likely to appeal their assessment than those in the lowest-income areas, the Treasurer's report says.
Appeal rates in primarily white neighborhoods were 35.5% but 10.85% in Black and 14.06% in Latino areas.
The tax burden from appeals increased by about 5% in high-income areas and about 10% in low-income areas.
The intrigue: Filing appeals can seem daunting (and we explain how to do it here), but the analysis suggests it can make a difference, citing these two examples:
In one Census tract of Gage Park, a low-income majority Latino community where only 5.2% of homeowners appealed, tax bills rose nearly 23%.
But in a tract of high-income, majority white North Center, 60% of homeowners appealed their assessment; tax bills rose less than 15%.
What's next: Belanger says the assessor's office will be "sharing information and working with the BOR on joint standards for property valuations" to create a more "uniform process."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
3 hours ago
- Axios
CPS chief bucks mayor on $200M loan
Interim CPS CEO Macquline King has presented a budget that defies Mayor Brandon Johnson on taking out a $200 million loan and hedges on covering a city pension payment — issues that led to the firing of her predecessor Pedro Martinez. Why it matters: When King was appointed interim CEO/superintendent, many assumed she'd act as a proxy for the mayor, who'd been her city hall boss since 2023 and wants CPS to cover the city pension payment, in part, by taking out a loan. The big picture: Forgoing the loan could save taxpayers millions. And King's move to make the pension payment contingent on additional state support or TIF funding could attract more money to the district. Some who rallied near or spoke at the Wednesday CPS board meeting where King was presenting the plan applauded the moves as ways to help the district's financial health. What they're saying: "It looks like our superintendent is not a rubber stamp superintendent," elected school board member Che "Rhymefest" Smith told Chalkbeat this week. "She heard the community loud and clear." The other side: When asked about loan concerns on Tuesday Johnson snapped, "No parent has ever come up to me and asked that question, not one. This is about the long-term solvency and sustainability of a school district that overwhelmingly services working people, overwhelmingly brown and Black." He called CPS debt, "a focal point for a couple of people." Reality check: At a CPS public budget meeting last month, many attendees expressed shock that the district spends $800 million a year in debt payments and they strongly advised against adding to that burden. Between the lines: Johnson and the Chicago Teachers Union are calling on state lawmakers to pony up more cash for the district. They point to a state funding formula program, aimed at providing 90% adequate funding by 2027, that suggests a fully funded CPS would need $1.6 billion in additional state support. But even if the state approved more funding in the veto session, it would come too late for this budget process. What's next: The 21-member CPS board — with 11 members appointed by Johnson — must review and approve a budget by Aug. 28.
Chicago Tribune
5 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Willie Wilson: Even Pharaoh knew his limits when it came to taxes
The 2026 budget crisis has reached 'a point of no return,' according to Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson. Severe underfunding of pensions and excessive government spending has led to this crisis. The city is facing a $1.1 billion budget deficit for 2026. That number will grow given the pension legislation signed by Gov JB Pritzker that increases retirement benefits for Chicago police and firefighters. Mayor Brandon Johnson is considering, among other things, a corporate payroll expense tax, a head tax, grocery tax and even a congestion tax on cars coming into downtown to close the deficit. How much more can Pharaoh tax businesses and the people without driving the city into financial ruin? These are bad ideas and would discourage employers from hiring people and harm jobs. A previous mayor called the head tax a 'job killer that puts Chicago at a disadvantage.' In this time of economic uncertainty, we need more jobs, not fewer. The mayor should be cutting costs, reforming pensions and renegotiating union contracts. A tax on businesses is a tax on consumers. Businesses pass the cost to customers by raising prices. A prime example is President Donald Trump's tariffs. The new tariffs implemented by the Trump administration will drive costs up. Prices rose 2.6% in June, up from an annual pace of 2.4% in May, the U.S. Department of Commerce reported last month. The consumer price index also went up in June. It is also expected that prices on food and drinks will climb due to the tariffs. Johnson has failed to control overtime spending. The Chicago Police Department exceeded its personnel budget by $127 million in 2024 even though it has 1,000 vacancies. Additionally, the mayor needs to get more people into the workforce. Three communities on the West Side have Great Depression levels of unemployment. According to the July 2025 Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning community data snapshots, North Lawndale unemployment was 13.9% in 2023 and 46.1% were not in the labor force. Austin had a 14.4% unemployment rate and 41.6% of people were not in the labor force. In West Garfield Park, the unemployment rate was 22.5% and 45.6% were not in the labor force. These communities underscore what is wrong with Chicago. The national unemployment rate is 4.2%. Johnson should not rely on budgetary gimmicks to balance the budget. Casino revenue is not consistent — it is a volatile source. Red-light and speed camera traffic enforcement tools have had a disproportionate impact on Black and Latino communities. Several studies have revealed that households in majority-Black and Latino ZIP codes receive tickets from red-light and speed cameras at a rate roughly twice that of households in white areas. Regressive revenue penalizes hardworking citizens. Why would citizens vote for someone who burdens them with regressive taxes and prioritizes labor unions and migrants over them? The mayor has been doing the bidding for his labor union buddies while costs are being borne by taxpayers. We need to create opportunities for people who are not a part of the union. Johnson should represent all the citizens of Chicago. The following are suggestions to address the impending budget crisis: We must get individuals in communities working. More people with W-2's increases tax revenue to the city and stabilizes families. The city of Chicago has spent $638.7 million on migrant aid since August 2022, Fox 32 reports. These are resources that were spent because of the city's sanctuary status. The people of Chicago deserve to have a say on how their tax dollars are spent. The mayor and his administration should be looking at ways to lower taxes and regulations on businesses and residents. This will lead to increased business receipts, jobs, and bring us back from the point of no return. I write this commentary to make those comfortable with raising taxes on businesses and residents uncomfortable.
Axios
5 hours ago
- Axios
DeSantis' lieutenant governor pick raises 2026 questions
Gov. Ron DeSantis' choice of State Sen. Jay Collins (R-Hillsborough) as Florida's next lieutenant governor is sending ripples through the state's political scene and the 2026 race for the governor's mansion. Why it matters: The appointment fuels speculation that Collins may be DeSantis' preferred successor over U.S. Rep. Byron Donalds, teeing up another showdown between the governor and President Trump. Catch up quick: Trump derailed any succession maneuvering by DeSantis — once seen as a kingmaker in Florida — by throwing his weight behind Donalds before the congressman had even announced. DeSantis dismissed Donalds, telling him to prioritize the president's agenda in Congress and stressing that the congressman "wasn't part of any of the victories we've had here over these last years." Thanks to the Sunshine State-to-West Wing pipeline and a game of political musical chairs, DeSantis had the rare opportunity to appoint loyalists to almost every elected Florida cabinet post. Enter Collins, a former Green Beret who spent three years in the state Senate representing Tampa — a seat he won with DeSantis' backing — now replacing Jeanette Nuñez as the governor's second-in-command. The post sat vacant for six months after Nuñez became president of Florida International University. Meanwhile, chatter about a Casey DeSantis 2026 campaign cooled after a state House investigation into Hope Florida, the welfare assistance program she spearheaded. Driving the news: Collins hasn't closed the door on a run for governor, and political insiders told Axios he could announce as soon as October. He and DeSantis brushed off questions about it during the announcement. The governor's office didn't respond to Axios' request for comment. But DeSantis has said he wants his other appointees, the attorney general and the chief financial officer, to remain in office. What they're saying: U.S. Rep. Randy Fine (R), who supports Donalds but worked with Collins in the state Senate, told Axios that Collins is now "out of the job in a year and a half... so that's a reason he might run." "He'll have an extremely difficult time, if that's what he decides to do," Fine said. "Jay is a complete unknown. What I can tell you, as a former state senator, no one knows who you are around the state." "This is Trump's Republican Party ... and beyond having his endorsement, Donalds has raised an astonishing amount of money." Donalds, for his part, congratulated Collins on his appointment on X, saying he wishes him "all the best" — to which Collins replied, "Thank you." But when asked about Collins' potential run, Donalds' campaign pointed Axios to Trump's endorsement. David Jolly, who's running for the Democratic nomination for governor, called Collins an "American hero" in comments to Axios, but said "the DeSantis-Trump proxy war is real."
