‘We pay too much': Public funds wasted on inflated government costs, says Zibi
The Scopa chair called for stricter financial discipline, and proposed benchmarks to curb excessive spending.
Rise Mzansi leader Songezo Zibi has criticised the government for wasting public funds by overpaying for goods and services, and failing to hold officials accountable for wasteful spending.
His comments came during a media briefing by parliament's finance cluster on Thursday, a day after South Africa's third national budget was tabled.
The latest fiscal plan outlined R68 billion in spending cuts over the next three years.
The reductions aim to address revenue losses caused by the government's decision not to increase the value-added tax (VAT) rate.
'Pro-poor' budget
During Thursday's briefing, Joe Maswanganyi, chairperson of the Standing Committee on Finance, described the 2025/2026 budget as 'pro-poor'.
'The budget, we believe, will bring inclusive growth even under constrained conditions,' he said.
'The budget contains hard choices, but it protects the vulnerable and positions our economy for stability and reforms.'
ALSO READ: Pressure on Sars to prevent tax increases in 2026
Maswanganyi also praised the R7.5 billion allocated to the South African Revenue Service (Sars), aimed at boosting revenue collection.
'This reinforces fairness in our tax system, ensuring that all citizens and companies, especially the wealthy, pay what they owe.'
However, he raised a red flag over the country's debt costs, pointing out that South Africa spends R1.2 billion per day on servicing debt.
'That needs to be addressed.'
Watch the briefing below:
Budget should prioritise solving real problems
Zibi, the chairperson of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts (Scopa), spoke of the positive elements in the budget process, especially the growing engagement of South Africans.
'Taxpayers finally said, 'No more money. We make do with what we already give you'.
'This is a very good thing because people can now appreciate that the government, and that means taxpayers themselves, do not have limitless resources.
READ MORE: Sensible or underwhelming? Economists react to Godongwana's Budget 3.0
'Money does not fall from trees. So you cannot commit to do everything, pay for everything, and not have problems thereafter.'
He argued that the controversy over VAT had detracted from the real purpose of a national budget, which is setting expenditure priorities.
'Budgets are meant to solve problems. The debate around budgets is supposed to be about the order of those priorities and whether these allocations are sufficient or to be spent in an efficient manner.'
Government wasting money
Zibi highlighted flaws in how the government allocates and manages expenditure, pointing out that over R820 billion is spent on salaries, R440 billion on social grants, and R424 billion on debt servicing.
The Rise Mzansi leader criticised government inefficiency and overspending, particularly in the procurement of goods and services.
'We pay too much because some of them are poorly conceived, poorly planned, poorly managed and often there is corruption.'
READ MORE: Budget 3.0: not austerity budget, but a redistributive budget
He called for expenditure reviews to ensure that 'every rent goes as far as possible' and also questioned whether the government remains fit for purpose.
'Do we have the right number of civil servants doing the kind of work that needs to be done? Or are we trying to fit a square into a circle?'
Zibi called for stricter financial discipline and proposed the introduction of benchmarks to curb excessive spending.
'We need to set benchmarks where the government does not spend more than 100% of planned project spend, and staff are incentivised for projects that are completed on time and within budget.
'We cannot have civil and construction projects lasting double or triple the time, at double or triple the cost that was initially planned. That is not value for money.'
Budget expenditure review
Zibi further recommended 'centralising' project management to improve oversight and reduce inefficiencies.
'Consulting engineers, we've learned, are a massive weakness, failing to ensure that the work is of the right quality, payments are only made when the work is done, and when those payments are made, they're in line with what we should be paying.
'Fighting corruption is a priority to the minister reaffirmed yesterday.'
Zibi added that both National Treasury and the Government Technical Advisory Centre (GTAC) have done work in recent years to better understand public expenditure patterns.
He revealed that he has invited Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana for further engagements on the matter.
'We will look at exploring a joint sitting between the finance committees where he will lay out for two days, the areas where the government since 2013-2014 has been spending money, where that expenditure has been efficient, whether that expenditure has not been efficient, and what some of the critical interventions that can be made are.'
NOW READ: Godongwana cuts zero-rated food basket in Budget 3.0
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Gwede Mantashe highlights the importance of foreign investment in South Africa's mining industry
Foreign investment remains key to the growth of South Africa's mining and energy sectors Image: GCIS Foreign investment remains key to the growth of South Africa's mining and energy sectors, according to Mineral and Petroleum Resources Minister Gwede Mantashe. During a visit to Orion Minerals' copper project in Prieska, Northern Cape, Mantashe emphasised the crucial role of global capital in unlocking the country's mineral wealth. The project is expected to start copper production within two years. 'Orion is important because it reflects the interest of foreign direct investment,' Mantashe said in an interview with public broadcaster SABC. "It is an Australian company that is very interested in producing copper here, and we want to encourage them to do that. It is important for South Africans to always appreciate that attracting an investor is quite a huge effort, and it is very important for society to have investment in their society.' Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ IOL previously reported that South Africa's mining sector faces ongoing challenges, threatening its export potential and overall viability. According to Statistics South Africa (Stats SA), mining production fell by 2.8% year-on-year in March, following a sharper 9.7% decline in February. 'Seasonally adjusted mining production declined by 4.5% in the first quarter of 2025 compared with the fourth quarter of 2024,' Jean-Pierre Terblanche, principal service statistician at Stats SA, told IOL two weeks ago.
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Cyril Ramaphosa's Basic Education Employment Initiative empowers 200,000 youth
President Ramaphosa celebrates 200,000 young South Africans starting work at schools through the Basic Education Employment Initiative, gaining vital skills and experience for future opportunities. President Cyril Ramaphosa has welcomed the return of the Basic Education Employment Initiative (BEEI), describing it as a vital pathway to work experience and skills development for South Africa's youth. In his weekly letter to the nation, Ramaphosa highlighted that around 200,000 young people are starting jobs at over 20,000 schools across the country. 'Today marks the 'first day at school' for about 200,000 young people; they are not arriving at school as learners, but as working adults,' he said. This marks the fifth phase of the BEEI, South Africa's largest youth employment programme, now funded by the UIF Labour Activation Programme and national government. The initiative, a key component of the Presidential Employment Stimulus launched in 2020, returns after a year's pause, aiming to bring 'hope, energy and incomes' to areas where job opportunities are often scarce. The programme provides participants with essential work skills, including time management, teamwork, IT, administration, and problem-solving.
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
This is where we would be if SA sustained an economic growth rate of 4.5%
It is enough to make you weep when you read how much better off South Africa could have been with economic growth of 4.5%. If South Africa had sustained an economic growth rate of 4.5% per year, in line with its emerging market peers, its GDP would have been just under R12 trillion in 2024 instead of the actual R7.5 trillion. Government revenue could also have been around R800 billion higher than it is. Investment strategist at Investec Wealth and Investment International, Osagyefo Mazwai, notes that although South Africa has grown over the last 15 years, averaging economic growth around 1% a year, the population has grown at a higher rate of around 1.3%. He points out that there has been a structural break in South Africa's economic performance compared to the rest of the world, with a stark dislocation in gross domestic product (GDP) per capita. 'In essence, people are worse off than they were in 2010, suggesting that economic policy has been ineffectual in addressing poverty, unemployment and inequality. 'On a per capita basis, the rest of the world is 50% richer than the average South African. Growth of 1% will not lead to the envisaged goals of lifting people out of poverty and meaningfully addressing the problems of unemployment and inequality.' This chart compares nominal GDP over the period with what it would have been if the South African economy grew at 4.5% a year to illustrate the point on the opportunity cost of foregone growth in policy formation and execution: ALSO READ: Experts say no way SA can achieve economic growth of 3% this year How does economic growth of R12 trillion sound? Mazwai says if the economy grew at 4.5%, South Africa's nominal GDP would have been just below R12 trillion in 2024, a significant number, especially considering the benefits that could have been derived from a vastly larger GDP. He points out that South Africa's economic growth rates similarly had an effect on government revenue. 'Government revenue in 2024 alone could have been around R800 billion higher, while just a few weeks ago, South Africa faced a budget impasse due to a shortfall in funding, needing to raise R75 billion in the medium term to cover the shortfall. 'That shortfall is insignificant considering how much more could have been raised had the economy grown more in line with emerging market peers. 'The cumulative figure of revenue foregone is scary, at around R5 trillion over the last 15 years. 'That is material, considering the fiscal constraints facing South Africa and demonstrates the need to ensure economic growth to boost the fiscal war chest and further enable the capacity of the state to deliver services.' ALSO READ: IMF's bad news about economic growth for SA, thanks to Trump tariffs What economic growth of 4.5% could have meant Mazwai says these statistics put this into perspective: The R5 trillion lost would be enough to clear almost 90% of South Africa's gross national debt and bring the debt-to-GDP ratio down to just below 10%, compared to the currently expected 77% ratio this year. Eskom needs R390 billion over the next decade for transmission lines, a fundamental pillar of creating greater capacity in the energy sector. Electricity is the backbone of any structural improvement, especially considering the government's goals to build domestic manufacturing capacity and create meaningful employment opportunities. The R390 billion would be a drop in the ocean had growth been 4.5% over the last 15 years. Transnet needs R160 billion to upgrade rail and port infrastructure. Our logistics networks are key in connecting the economy across its internal nodes, but also key in building additional capacity to meet the demands of external markets. Again, R160 billion would have been a drop in the ocean had growth been in line with our peers. Eskom has debt of R400 billion. With economic growth at 4.5%, the government could have bailed Eskom out 12 times. Transnet has a debt of R140 billion, and the government could have bailed out Transnet many times, too. Social grants will cost the fiscus around R266 billion this year. With economic growth of 4.5%, these would have been more than affordable and potentially materially higher than what marginalised citizens receive now, also considering that many more people would have been absorbed into the labour market. ALSO READ: Fourth quarter GDP improved but economists say its still not great – here's why With higher economic growth, South Africa would have functioned better Mazwai says these statistics are significant because they show how South Africa could have been in a better position to address the prevailing needs of the state. 'Granted, if the economy was growing at 4.5% the assumption is that Transnet and Eskom and some of the other structural enablers of the economy would have been functioning properly. 'The numbers indicate the potential for vastly greater capacity to invest in the productive elements of the South African economy, such as in infrastructure, education, healthcare and the salaries of teachers, nurses and doctors.' He also notes that business confidence has been unusually correlated with the performance of state-owned enterprises (SOEs) in the post-pandemic environment, and therefore, SOE reform momentum must be sustained or increased. 'Business confidence is the key leading indicator of economic growth and employment creation. The unemployment rate would be closer to around 20% compared to the current 32.9% had the economy been growing at 4.5%. 'In other words, a third of those presently unemployed, according to the narrow definition of unemployment, would have jobs.' ALSO READ: Absa foresees economic growth of 2.1%, but Trump and budget can disrupt it But there have been some victories so far for the economy However, Mazwai says none of this should detract from some of the victories seen of late, such as: The formation of the government of national unity (GNU) and subsequent political stability and increased policy certainty, although the recent budget impasse showed that these are nonetheless fragile. The increased momentum of Operation Vulindlela in addressing the various structural impediments in the economy. The next steps are critical for addressing water infrastructure and local government inefficiencies. Improvements in the electricity supply and logistics network. Mazwai says there has been some stagnation in the recovery of SOEs, which may be cause for concern, although the worst of SOE performance appears to be behind us. However, he says a reacceleration in trend improvement is important for business confidence to grow. ALSO READ: Economic activity still moving sideways but optimism increases Recovery in PMI could mean higher economic growth 'We recently saw a modest recovery in the S&P Global Purchasing Managers Index (PMI), to a neutral level of 50. There must be a trend improvement in PMIs, which are typically linked to economic outcomes. 'Should PMIs continue to improve, the economy should continue on its path of recovery. This will likely be driven by the continued success of Operation Vulindlela.' Looking at GDP projections, Mazwai says data released so far suggest that while growth was likely weak in the first quarter, a persistent upward trend in PMIs can result in a marked acceleration in growth outcomes. 'PMI improvement will largely be a function of continued improvement in SOE performance. At present, the economy, by our estimates, is tracking at 1.3% for the year, which is well above the 0.6% seen in 2024 and 0.8% in 2023. 'This can then lead to more meaningful employment creation and a trend reversal in GDP per capita from the pattern of decline since 2011.' ALSO READ: World Bank has simple answer to improve South Africa's economic growth What SA can do to keep momentum going to grow He suggests that South Africa follow these steps to keep the momentum going and put South Africa on a firmer growth trajectory:
