
Why Keir Starmer could face a fresh rebellion over disability support for Send children?
A similar coalition of MPs and campaign groups, including many of the same charities that opposed reforms to welfare, are warning the prime minister not to cut education plans for children and young people with special educational needs and disabilities (Send).
The PM was badly weakened by the chaos around his planned welfare bill, and backbenchers now appear to know they can force their leader's hand if they apply enough pressure.
But Sir Keir, and his chancellor Rachel Reeves, will be acutely aware of the pressure on the public finances and can scarcely afford another multi-billion pound policy change.
The Independent looks at why the government is under pressure over Send, and what it is likely to do about it.
What are education, health and care plans (ECHPs)?
An education, health and care plan (EHCP) outlines the tailored support needed by those aged 25 and under to meet their social care needs.
It is designed to help those with disabilities get what they need to access learning and achieve their potential.
The documents are legally binding, based on assessments by professionals and set out the support young people individually need.
Are the ECHPs at risk?
The campaign group Save Our Children's Rights has warned that the government is planning to weaken or remove the right to an ECHP, as well as other rights including the right to attend a suitable school and receive support such as speech and language therapy.
It said the government plans are to save money, with support for children with learning difficulties or disabilities currently costing £12bn a year.
The Department for Education has said there are 'no plans to remove funding or support from children, families and schools'.
'It would be totally inaccurate to suggest that children, families or schools might experience any loss of funding or support,' a spokesman said.
Why would the government cut EHCPs?
The government previously turned to support for the disabled when it sought to slash £5bn from the welfare bill through cuts to the personal independence payment (Pip), the main disability benefit.
The argument was that the bill was rising unsustainably, and the National Audit Office (NAO) has raised a similar warning about ECHPs.
The number of EHCPs soared by 150 per cent to 576,000 between 2015 and 2024, with the NAO estimating it could top 1 million by 2033.
What have campaigners said?
A letter to The Guardian on Monday signed by dozens of special needs groups said 'every sign from the government suggests the right to an ECHP is to be removed from children attending mainstream schools'.
'Whatever the Send system's problems, the answer is not to remove the rights of children and young people,' the letter said.
It said removing ECHPs would not make young people's needs magically vanish, but would increase applications for already overcrowded special schools or force children out of school altogether.
What have MPs said?
One Labour MP preparing to rebel told The Independent that backbenchers are gearing up for a similar fight over ECHPs to the battle they fought over cuts to Pip.
'They have built strong relationships with Send campaigners, if they are now being told this is a betrayal, they will push back against any cuts,' the MP warned.
Another was quoted in The Times as saying: 'If they thought taking money away from disabled adults was bad, watch what happens when they try the same with disabled kids.'
When will the changes become clear?
The government is expected to publish a white paper detailing its reforms to Send education in the autumn.
It means that ministers have a chance to ensure they get any reforms right, and get backbenchers onside, in order to stave off any potential rebellion over the changes.
But the long delay also means disability campaigners will have all summer to get in the ears of MPs, and that rebellious Labour parliamentarians will have plenty of time to plan a revolt.
Ultimately, the reforms will represent a test of how well Sir Keir has listened and learned from previous handling of politically sensitive changes that make Labour MPs uneasy.
Any changes will stand or fall on whether he has done the necessary outreach to MPs from across the party and the relevant campaign groups lobbying them.
If not, he faces returning from the summer holiday to exactly the same problems he left behind.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
Former Tory Cabinet minister David Jones joins Reform UK
A former Conservative cabinet minister has announced he is now backing Reform UK as the party that now 'best represents my views'. David Jones, who served as Welsh secretary under David Cameron between 2012 and 2014, announced he was joining Nigel Farage's party on Monday after more than 50 years as a Tory. The former Clwyd West MP described the move as 'a very difficult decision for me' and said he had written to the Conservatives in October to say he would not renew his membership, but received no reply. He said: 'I joined the Conservatives all those years ago because I believed it was the party that best reflected my values and beliefs. Regrettably, that is no longer the case. 'Today, Reform UK is the party that best represents my views – and, I believe, those of many others who have become disillusioned with the two old major parties.' After losing his cabinet job in the 2014 reshuffle, he went on to become a minister in the Department for Exiting the EU under Theresa May for a year between 2016 and 2017. He later became deputy chairman of the European Research Group, a Eurosceptic group of Tory MPs. Mr Jones, who stood down from Parliament last year after 19 years as an MP, said he had no intention of standing for election, and had joined Reform 'as a private individual'. But as a former cabinet minister, he is the most senior ex-Tory MP to join Reform so far, following Marco Longhi, Anne Marie Morris, Ross Thomson, Aiden Burley and Dame Andrea Jenkyns, now the mayor of Greater Lincolnshire. His defection also comes as Mr Farage's party seeks to make significant gains in next year's elections at the Senedd in Wales, where polls suggest the party is in second or third place. It is a boost for Reform after a difficult weekend in which one of its five MPs 'removed the party whip from himself' amid allegations about two of his businesses. James McMurdock, MP for South Basildon and East Thurrock, insisted 'all' of his 'business dealings' complied with regulations following claims he improperly borrowed money from the government during the pandemic. A Liberal Democrat source said Mr Jones had 'jumped from the sinking ship straight into Farage's circus tent'. They added: 'The Liberal Democrats are the party standing up to Reform and their divisive politics in Wales and across the country, fighting to protect local services and stop Farage doing to our communities what Trump is doing in America.'


The Sun
31 minutes ago
- The Sun
Ministers face ANOTHER rebellion over fears disabled kids could lose legal right to extra support
MINISTERS are facing a brewing rebellion over fears children with special needs may no longer receive the legal right to extra support. Campaigners are warning the government not to make changes to education, health and care plans that six hundred thousand children and young people rely on. 2 Labour MP Helen Hayes, who chairs the education select committee, said commitments must be made amid fears support could be scaled back. She said new proposals have to 'build the trust and confidence of parents and which doesn't make parents feel even more fearful' about their children's future. But the row is on the verge of having the hallmarks of the welfare rebellion as rebels hit back at potential cost-cutting measures. The government is expected to publish a plan in the autumn on how it will reform SEND provision. Education minister Stephen Morgan insisted parents should have 'absolutely' no fear that support for children with special needs or disabilities hauled back. However, he could not guarantee that the current system would remain in place. Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson told MPs that children with special needs will 'always' have a legal right to extra support. The total number of requests for SEND support has risen to 638,745 support plans in January which was up ten per cent on the same point last year. Changes to UC & PIP payments in full as Labour reveals bruising welfare bill concessions in bid to quell rebellion 2


BBC News
39 minutes ago
- BBC News
MPs could vote on Premier League free-to-air plan
MPs could be set to vote on a proposal to make at least 10 Premier League games available on free-to-air television each Liberal Democrats have tabled an amendment to the Football Governance Bill, which continues to make its way through legislation will establish a regulator that is independent from government and the sport's authorities to oversee the men's game in England's top five amendment would require it to ensure that the top-flight matches - along with the League Cup Final, and the Championship, League One and League Two play-off finals - would be Lib Dems say they are confident that a vote will be granted on the proposal. Last year, the party committed to widen public access to major sporting events by ensuring more are available to view without subscription TV packages. It says it favours a similar approach to one taken in Spain where La Liga must offer one free game a week to fans after a change in the law in Wilkinson MP, Lib Dem spokesperson for Culture, Media and Sport said: "I'm urging MPs of all stripes to back our amendment to tear down the paywall and make Premier League games available on free to air channels."For too long, the jewel in the crown of British football has been locked behind an expensive barrier that keeps fans out while lining the pockets of broadcasters."That must end today - with a free-to-air revolution that gives the Premier League back to the country."A spokesperson for the Department of Culture, Media and Sport said: "The government has no plans to review the listed events regime."The Premier League declined to legislation has now reached the report stage in the House of Commons.A similar amendment was tabled at the committee stage last the time, the Sports Minister Stephanie Peacock said: "The listed events regime have protected key moments such as the FA Cup Final while ensuring that the Premier League, EFL & FA are able to raise billions of pounds annually, which is invested back into the pyramid."We all want to see more matches being televised free-to-air, but that must be balanced against that investment and not risk it… It would not be appropriate for the regulator to intervene in commercial decisions between the relevant broadcasters and rights holders."The Lib Dems claim analysis of subscription prices shows that to watch each available Premier League game live next season fans will have to pay £660 a month, it was revealed Premier League television viewing figures on main live rights-holder Sky Sports were down 10% last season, while TNT Sports had a 17% reduction in its year-on-year figures.