After 38 Years in Prison for Murder, British Man Is Freed by New DNA Evidence
The man, Peter Sullivan, 68, is thought to be the victim of the country's longest miscarriage of justice involving a living prisoner. The judgment follows the emergence of several other wrongful convictions in recent years, casting a shadow over the reputation of Britain's criminal justice system and raising grave questions about the credibility of the appeals process.
Mr. Sullivan was imprisoned after the killing in August 1986 of Diane Sindall, 21, who suffered a frenzied sexual attack in Birkenhead, near Liverpool, as she made her way home from a pub where she also worked.
After DNA evidence was presented in the case, the Court of Appeal overturned Mr. Sullivan's conviction.
'In the light of that evidence, it is impossible to regard the appellant's conviction as safe,' said Timothy Holroyde, one of three judges presiding over the hearing. 'We quash the conviction,' he added, ordering that Mr. Sullivan be released from custody.
Appearing via a video link from prison in Wakefield, West Yorkshire, Mr. Sullivan broke down in tears and held his hand over his mouth as he was told he would be freed, the BBC reported.
In a statement read by his lawyer, Sarah Myatt, on his behalf after the ruling, Mr. Sullivan said, 'What happened to me was very wrong, but it does not detract or minimize that all of this happened off the back of a heinous and most terrible loss of life.' He added: 'I am not angry; I am not bitter. I am simply anxious to return to my loved ones and family as I've got to make the most of what is left of the existence I am granted in this world.'
Mr. Sullivan's wrongful imprisonment will most likely intensify the debate over the reliability of Britain's Criminal Cases Review Commission, which is responsible for investigating possible miscarriages of justice.
In 2023, Andrew Malkinson, who spent 17 years in prison for a rape he did not commit, was freed after years of protesting his innocence.
James Burley, who led the investigation into Mr. Malkinson's case by a charity, Appeal, said in a statement on Tuesday, 'Peter Sullivan's exoneration today after nearly four decades of wrongful imprisonment provides further evidence that our current appeals system cannot be trusted to swiftly identify and rectify miscarriages of justice.'
Ms. Sindall, who was a florist and was engaged to be married, was attacked while walking to a gas station in Bebington, Merseyside, after her van broke down just after midnight.
Twelve hours later, Ms. Sindall's body was discovered by a member of the public in an alleyway with extensive injuries. The cause of death was established as a cerebral hemorrhage following multiple blows.
The hunt for her killer gained nationwide attention and, because of the brutality of the assault, tabloid newspapers referred to Mr. Sullivan after his conviction as the 'Beast of Birkenhead.'
Mr. Sullivan applied in 2008 for his case to be reviewed by the Criminal Cases Review Commission, but his application was rejected. He applied for permission to appeal in 2019, but that, too, was turned down.
After another application was lodged in 2021, the commission decided that, because of technological advances, it was worth testing the semen samples preserved from the crime scene in 1986. They did not match Mr. Sullivan's DNA.
The police, who have since reopened their investigation into the case, say that more than 260 other men have since been screened and eliminated from their inquiry.
'Our thoughts remain with the family and friends of Diane Sindall who continue to mourn her loss and will have to endure the implications of this new development so many years after her murder,' Detective Chief Superintendent Karen Jaundrill of the Merseyside Police said in a statement on Tuesday. 'We are committed to doing everything within our power to find whom the DNA, which was left at the scene, belongs to.'
After his arrest, Mr. Sullivan was initially denied legal representation and confessed to the murder before retracting it. He has long protested his innocence, a factor that makes it harder to get parole.
In a statement, the Criminal Cases Review Commission said that 'the new DNA evidence that has led to Mr. Sullivan's conviction being quashed could not have been available when we first considered his case,' which, it said, justified its decision not to send this case back to the courts in 2008.
It added, 'However, we do regret that we were not able to identify Mr. Sullivan's conviction as a potential miscarriage of justice in our first review.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Horror outside primary school as knifeman tries to stab dad picking up his child
A knifeman threatened to stab a parent outside a primary school as children were being picked up. Cardell Hamman, 20, approached the dad as he collected his child outside the north Manchester school in January. Without warning, Hamman brandished a knife and shouted: "You want to f*** with my sister?" He then moved towards the man, swinging the knife at his body. The blade brushed the man's shoulder before he grabbed Hamman and pulled him away, Manchester Crown Court heard. READ MORE: 'Can someone get this man away from us': Woman's horror Jet2 flight after stranger sat next to her strikes READ MORE: Man planned to spend day 'on the beer drinking 16 pints' before meeting woman he's accused of murdering, court told He then ran towards the school, followed by Hamman, who shouted: "I'm gonna stab you up." Sign up to the MEN Court newsletter here Kate Gaskell, prosecuting, said: "CCTV at the school recorded him as he arrived, followed by the defendant. As the defendant entered the school playground he appeared to secret the knife about his body. "He left as the victim neared the door to the building. As he left the defendant shouted, 'You want to f*** with my sister. Watch, I'm gonna stab you up'." Others also heard Hamman shout words to the effect of 'you're a dead man'. The victim recognised Hamman, but 'as far he was aware there was no ill feelings between them', Ms Gaskell added. In a statement the victim said: ''This incident has shocked me and makes me worried and concerned for my family's safety. So many thoughts are going through my head about what might happen in the future or what could have happened. 'I want to be strong for my family, and my opinion is that I don't want to show my emotions to them or anyone else because as a father I have to be strong for them and show them that their dad isn't scared of anything. 'As time goes by I might begin to feel differently but for now my thoughts rest with what could have happened if I hadn't managed to get away and what if something else like this happens in the future.' He added: 'I have no idea why Cardell would target me, as far as I'm concerned, until today I had no problem with him.' Hamman was arrested after CCTV footage led police to his home in Droylsden. He told officers he had taken an overdose the day before and was taken to hospital. He was examined and released as being fit to be interviewed. Hamman denied the offences. He accepted he knew the victim as the man's child knew his sister, but said there were 'no ill feelings' between them. He later pleaded guilty to attempted wounding with intent; and possession of a bladed article. Join our Court and Crime WhatsApp group HERE Defending, Graham Rishton said the incident took place due to a 'culmination in a disagreement between the victim and Hamman's sister', though, he added: 'Nothing can come close to justifying this type of behaviour. It is only his good fortune, and obviously that of the victim, that there was no injury.' Mr Rishton said the defendant, who had previous convictions for carrying a knife, had since become a father which had provided him with a 'new perspective'. Jailing him for three-and-a-half years, Judge Alan Conrad KC said: 'Your victim had done nothing to deserve this. I accept you had a very difficult start in life. You are a young man who tends to go out with a knife and finds it difficult to control yourself.' Hamman, of Moss bank Avenue, was banned from contacting the victim, under the terms of a restraining order, indefinitely.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Eltham mental health counsellor had six month online relationship with girl, 14
A mental health counsellor from Eltham who had a six-month online relationship with a 14-year-old girl has avoided prison. Steve Hughes, 55, sent sexualised and grooming messages to the young girl after he sought her out on social media in November 2022. In May 2023 he was confronted by paedophile hunters as he discovered he had spent the last six months messaging a decoy account. On inspection of his phone it was then revealed that Hughes had also been messaging three other 'girls' - all aged either 13 or 14 – who were also decoy accounts run by other paedophile hunter organisations. Hughes, of Eltham Hill, claimed at trial that he knew all along that these were 'scam' accounts and that he did not genuinely believe he was talking to teenage girls. But a jury unanimously rejected his defence and convicted him of four charges of attempting to engage in sexual communication with a child. On Monday, August 18, Hughes was sentenced to 18 months in custody suspended for 18 months. He will be the subject of a 10-year Sexual Harm Prevention Order which will allow police to monitor his online activity. Prior to his arrest Hughes was an experienced adult counsellor and psychotherapist working in Welling and later Eltham. His website stated he successfully worked on issues relating to 'sex and shame'. READ MORE: Judge David Miller said: 'Between October 2022 and May 2023 you sought out teenage girls to form digital relationships with. 'You found four girls, you engaged in chat with them on various social media sites and you soon turned the conversations sexual – there is an element of grooming , particularly regarding on girl who you were in communication with for six months.' He told Hughes that if these were actual children, rather than decoys, he would have received a considerably higher sentence and one which would not have been suspended. 'Having read the pre-sentence report and the character references, I'm suspending the sentence because I consider there's a realistic chance of rehabilitation. I think you will comply with the order and won't reoffend,' Judge Miller said. Hughes was ordered to pay £4,380 to cover the four-day Woolwich Crown Court trial he elected to have.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Even Costa has left St Peter's Street. It is a 'flashing red warning sign'
One of the UK's biggest high street brands has made the decision to leave one of Derby's busiest shopping streets - something which a councillor says should serve as a "flashing red warning light". Costa Coffee confirmed it would be leaving its unit on the corner of East Street and St Peter's Street last month after more than 13 years in the building. St Peter's Street has suffered a very difficult year so far. On May 6, Derby business owner Gurvinder Singh Johal died after a stabbing inside Lloyds Bank and, on July 14, three masked men carried out a brazen robbery at Ramsdens Pawnbrokers, as crowds gathered and watched on helplessly. Costa lies just a few yards from where the dramatic incidents unfolded. It has now left the street for good. A spokesperson said: 'We can confirm that our St Peter's Street, Derby, Costa Coffee store has closed for trade. READ MORE: Derby Royal Mail sorting offices could be demolished under major redevelopment plans READ MORE: Rural pub in picturesque town to reopen after four-year-closure with £240k facelift "All team members have relocated to nearby stores. Customers can continue to enjoy their favourite Costa coffee at nearby stores at the Derbion shopping centre.' It also comes after a recent survey in which eight out of ten Derbyshire Live readers said they felt unsafe in the city centre - with 39 per cent blaming the police and 27 per cent the council. We asked Costa Coffee if the recent trouble and incidents in St Peter's Street played any part in the closure - and if not, a reason why - but it refused to answer the question directly. Derby Conservatives leader Steve Hassall says the closure of such a huge brand on such a busy street "should serve as a flashing red warning light to the council and police". He said: "When a national brand like Costa pulls out of what is supposed to be Derby's main shopping street, it's not just about footfall, it's about fear, frustration and a complete lack of confidence in the authorities to get a grip. "This closure reflects what many of us already know: people no longer feel safe in the city centre. Businesses are suffering. Residents are anxious. And the response from those in charge has been weak, inconsistent and laced with mixed messages. "From claiming our city centre is safe one week, to writing to the Home Secretary in a panic the next, it's clear this council is out of its depth. We don't need knife amnesty bins in civic buildings (a position I presume that has been quietly dropped), we need a zero-tolerance approach, robust enforcement and a serious plan to restore public confidence." Labour city council leader Nadine Peatfield sent a letter to Home Secretary Yvette Cooper earlier this month in response to the recent incidents, after telling a full council meeting that she was going to request more police officers to serve the city. Ms Cooper made a special visit to Derby where she said funding is in place to give Derbyshire Constabulary an extra 35 officers to combat anti-social behaviour. But in her her letter, Cllr Peatfield wrote: 'Recently you announced Derbyshire would receive 35 new police officers, for which we are very grateful. However, once they are spread across the county, I am concerned that Derby city centre won't see the impact of this increase. 'Too often our small but highly dedicated SNT (Safer Neighbourhood Team) city centre officers are pulled away from patrols to deal with emergency calls because we don't have enough officers to cover the entire city, let alone the high street. PCSOs are scarce because so many have been recruited to step up to policing.' A lack of footfall and, in turn, money not hitting the pockets of local businesses are the immediate repercussions of such violence and anti-social behaviour - but businesses themselves are also being forced to make changes for their own safety. Hannah Lancashire, who works at Jon Paul Menswear in Babington Lane, said business owners are frightened for the safety of staff in the city - adding that measures must be taken to increase security. Speaking on the closure of Costa, which opened in the city back in 2012, Hannah said: "It doesn't surprise me at all. It's absolutely awful around there. The council has made it impossible for businesses to stay open, they've upped the rates, and it's just a terrible time to own a business in the city. "The homeless situation is dangerous. Staff are often here by themselves and we need to make sure the doors are locked whenever that is the case. Every day we see homeless people gathering on the street, and the drug problem is just awful. "We see drug deals across the road all the time. In fact, I've had police sitting in my shop watching and waiting for drug deals. It's that much of a problem. All the council seem to do is make it impossible for people to park and they've carried out unnecessary roadworks that have disrupted business. "I know people who live between Derby and Burton, and I know for a fact that they would rather shop in Burton most of the time, mostly because it's so easy to park. But the crime is the main issue that needs fixing." Satnan Shanan owns The Sandwich Shop in St Peter's Churchyard, just a stone's throw from the troubled part of the city. He says he "doesn't blame Costa" for getting rid of the store, adding that, from a business's perspective, the "area is dead". "There are so many problems faced by businesses in the city centre, whether it be footfall or violence, or just an environment that's hard to navigate around," said Satnan. "For example, we unload goods often on the street, and almost every time we have a ticket from traffic wardens. "There are so many problems. Crime is also bad, particularly the area next to Costa, which is just full of drunks and the homeless. We've been at the same spot since 1994, and we sell confectionery, cigarettes and sandwiches. "But the problem is that, in those 30 years, we've had dozens of new shops that sell the same - mini markets - open up all over the city centre. Our business is now struggling as a result, and the whole town centre is just dead." Following the closure of the St Peter's Street Costa, the closest branches can now be found inside Derbion and at Derby railway station. It comes after another Derby Costa site, at the Meteor Centre in Mansfield Road, recently applied to stay open 24 hours a day, seven days a week, in a notice published in the Derby Telegraph. A Derby City Council spokesman said: "Of course we are disappointed to see any business close, but while Costa have taken the decision to stop trading from the St Peter's Street site, this does not mean they have left the city altogether. 'The easy thing to do would be to attribute such closures to a single issue like crime, but that ignores the complex reality of the retail and hospitality sector, which is seeing trends such as rising costs and increased competition. 'Despite these challenges, Derby's coffee scene remains vibrant and competitive, with a strong mix of thriving independent establishments and large chains. Our city continues to be a bustling hub, attracting visitors daily for events, shopping, and social gatherings. 'We are committed to working in collaboration with our partners to manage the city centre and keep it safe for all."
