The robot empathy divide
A new digital divide is growing between people who trust AI for emotional support and those who don't.
Why it matters: AI startups are pushing their tools not just as enterprise productivity enhancers, but also as therapists, companions and life coaches.
Driving the news: Two new studies from OpenAI, in partnership with MIT Media Lab, found that users are turning to bots to help cope with difficult situations because they say that the AI is able to "display human-like sensitivity."
The studies found that ChatGPT "power users" are likely to consider the bot a "friend" and find it more comfortable to interact with the bot than with people.
The big picture: On one hand, more than half (55%) of 18-to-29-year-old Americans feel comfortable chatting with AI about mental health concerns, according to a 2024 YouGov survey.
On the other, many mental health professionals and experts view reliance on bot-based therapy as a poor substitute for the real thing.
"We know we can feel better from writing in a diary or talking aloud to ourselves or texting with a machine. That is not therapy," Hannah Zeavin, author of "The Distance Cure: A History of Teletherapy," told the Washington Post in 2023.
AI can't effectively substitute for a human therapist because "a therapeutic relationship is about ... forming a relationship with another human being who understands the complexity of life," argues sociologist Sherry Turkle, who has been studying digital culture for decades.
Between the lines: Lucas LaFreniere, an assistant professor of psychology at Skidmore College who recently taught a seminar called "My Therapist is a Robot," says there are two kinds of people — those who are willing to suspend disbelief to accept that a chatbot could help them with personal problems and those who aren't.
"You can tell in the first five minutes of talking with somebody, whether they think it's all going to be bullshit, or they are really open to it, think it has a lot of potential and could be cool, and can relate to it," LaFreniere told Axios.
Empathy is in the eye of the beholder, he said: "If the client is perceiving empathy, they benefit from the empathy."
But he says there are a lot of people who simply don't feel that empathy — or if they do feel it, it will disappear at the first glitch. "That just kind of reminds the user very starkly that they're talking to software," he said.
The other side: Some experts argue that generative AI can help with thorny emotional questions because it's been trained, in part, on literature.
"Works of art, Shakespeare's plays" and similar works give generative AI the ability to help humans with emotions — or at least to make them feel less alone, Chris Mattmann, chief data and AI officer at UCLA, told Axios.
The fiction in LLM training data includes "characters that don't exist, but they're inherently human. And they mirror our properties, including empathy," he says.
Yes, but: LLMs have also been trained on Reddit, Facebook, Twitter and 4chan.
Even as chatbots get better at "empathetic" and human-like communication, some people will never accept them as companions or therapists because it's too difficult to square this with their own ideas about what it means to be human.
In 1950 computing pioneer Alan Turing described what he called the " heads in the sand objection" to the prospect of artificial intelligence: "The consequences of machines thinking would be too dreadful. Let us hope and believe that they cannot do so."
This argument, Turing wrote, "is likely to be quite strong in intellectual people, since they value the power of thinking more highly than others, and are more inclined to base their belief in the superiority of Man on this power."
The intrigue: Turing was talking about intelligence, not empathy, but some types of empathy are closer to intelligence than others.
Cognitive empathy is the ability to understand what another person is thinking and why they're thinking it.
"All of that is sort of informational and knowledge-based," LaFreniere says. "And AI may actually be able to crunch the words and numbers a lot better than a person could. And cognitive empathy does matter."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
TikTok Says In-Stream Shopping Has Increased 120% This Year
This story was originally published on Social Media Today. To receive daily news and insights, subscribe to our free daily Social Media Today newsletter. TikTok has shared some new stats on in-stream shopping engagement in the app, which it says has seen a big rise over the past year. According to TikTok, Americans, in particular, are warming to its TikTok Shop offerings, as it continues to promote its in-app buying options to its billion-plus users. As per TikTok: 'Over the past year, our community of sellers has expanded into more than 750 categories, bringing shoppers an incredible selection of over 70 million products. So far in 2025, our growing community of shoppers, sellers, and creators has driven impressive momentum across the TikTok Shop platform. In the U.S., TikTok Shop sales have increased 120% compared to the same period last year.' TikTok says that womenswear, beauty & personal care, health, sports & outdoors, and electronics are the top sales categories in the app, with TikTok shopping now available in even more regions. 'Today, millions of people are discovering products they love on TikTok through shoppable videos and livestreams from sellers and creators who demonstrate how the products actually work and answer all your questions in real time. In fact, according to a new research by GlobalData and TikTok Shop, 83% of all shoppers say they have discovered a new product on TikTok Shop, and 70% have discovered a new brand.' Those are some impressive numbers, while TikTok also claims that: Brands and creators have hosted over 8 million hours of LIVE shopping sessions in the U.S. 171,000 local and small businesses are now operating TikTok Shops 76% of consumers who've engaged with TikTok Shop bought something from a livestream in the past year. Sales to small U.S. businesses in the app have grown by 70% year-over-year So, livestreams are generating more interest in TikTok shopping, which is also where TikTok has seen significant in-stream sales success in China as well. In order to further fuel this growth, TikTok says that it's adding a new set of 'assortment, content and empowerment tools' in its Seller Center, which are designed to provide tailored, actionable guidance to help sellers attract the right audience. It's also gearing up with new offers for summer's 'Deals for You Days' July 7 – 19), including a 'LIVE Price Match Guaranteed' program, which will enable customers watching select 'Deals for You Days' livestreams to get cash back if they find a lower price off-platform on featured products. Which all sounds positive, all sounds like TikTok's shopping push is headed in the right direction. But even so, the platform is still a long way off from where it envisioned that it would be at this stage. As noted, TikTok's been pushing to get Western audiences excited about in-stream shopping for years, but thus far, TikTok users have been less enamored by the platform's expanded digital shopping mall vision, preferring instead to keep their shopping activities within dedicated shopping apps. In China, however, it's been a much different story. Shopping is now the top revenue stream for Douyin, the Chinese version of the app, with Douyin bringing in $US490 billion in gross merchandise value (GMV) in 2024 alone. Indeed, Douyin is now the third-largest ecommerce platform in China. In comparison, TikTok generated around $US6 billion via in-app spending throughout 2024. Yet even so, that smaller intake is still up 15% year-over-year, so TikTok shopping is catching on, while as TikTok notes, overall shopping engagement in the app is trending up, in various ways. The next step, then, could see TikTok leaning into services, like meal ordering and ride-hailing, direct from the app. Douyin has seen big success with these options, which has helped to get even more money moving through the app's circuits. If more people feel more comfortable spending in the app, that'll lead to more shopping activity, which could help to spark TikTok's in-stream shopping push, as it builds towards its broader revenue goals. Though the signals do remain mixed. TikTok's future in the U.S. is still under a cloud, as the White House works on a sell-off deal, while TikTok also recently restructured its entire U.S. commerce team, after it failed to meet its 2024 targets. So while the data that TikTok's reporting suggests that things are all going well, that everything's all rosy for TikTok's in-app sales push, clearly, they're not exactly where it wants them to be just yet. Can TikTok translate its broader success into becoming an online sales juggernaut in the West? And more specifically, is it worth trying out TikTok Shop for your brand? It is worth noting the broader push here, and considering what's resonating with the TikTok audience.
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Reddit is the 2nd most-cited source in Google AI Overviews, but that might not mean much for its bottom line
Analytics firm Semrush studied how AI is affecting Google Search traffic. It found that Reddit is the second most-cited website by Google AI Overviews. Quora was the most cited source. Reddit's relationship with Google is complicated. The social media forum, which went public last year and is under pressure like never before to attract advertisers and turn a profit, has recently enjoyed priority status on Google Search. And now that Google has launched its AI Overview, a natural language synopsis of search results at the top of the page, it seems its preference for citing Reddit remains. Analytics firm Semrush shared data this month on how AI-powered search is affecting traffic. It found that Reddit is the second most-cited website in Google AI Overviews, following Quora. "Quora and Reddit users often ask and answer niche questions that aren't addressed elsewhere. Making them rich information sources for highly specific AI prompts," the study's authors wrote. "Reddit may also perform well because Google has a partnership with Reddit and uses Reddit data to train its systems." Reddit and Google entered a partnership, worth a reported $60 million, in 2024 that allowed Google to train its AI models on Reddit's content. Google said the deal would "facilitate more content-forward displays of Reddit information." All of this has helped Reddit increase its traffic over the last year, which might entice more advertisers. That traffic, however, is largely coming from so-called logged-out users, meaning they aren't account holders at Reddit and are unlikely regular visitors. Analysts at Redburn called much of Reddit's growth "misconstrued." "Accelerated user growth has been driven predominantly by logged-out users who arrive on the platform largely via Google Search," the Redburn analysts wrote in March. "These users are much less valuable to Reddit as they are typically just looking for an answer to a query and thus spend little time on the platform." And while Google AI Overview might often cite Reddit as a source, the way it displays search results in a natural language summary means many searchers will be less likely to click through to Reddit itself. Reddit's stocks fell in May after Google launched its new AI Mode, as concerned analysts said the new feature would likely decrease traffic to Reddit. Representatives for Reddit and Quora did not respond to a request for comment from Business Insider. Read the original article on Business Insider Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Forbes
an hour ago
- Forbes
AI Reshapes Startup Ecosystems Around The World, Despite the Funding Winter
Silicon Valley is still the number one startup ecosystem in the world, thanks to its leadership in the creation of AI-native startups, according to The Global Startup Ecosystem Report 2025, produced by Startup Genome. It is home to 22% of all AI-native startups worldwide, greatly outdistancing most other ecosystems, the researchers found. New York City, tied with London for second place for the past four years, gained ground on the list, pushing London to third place. Startup Genome is an innovation ecosystem development organization that collaborates with economic and innovation ministries in 65 countries. The annual report, first published in 2012, examines 40 startup ecosystems worldwide. The findings reflect a surge in AI and Big Data, now the fastest-growing sub-sector. The industry saw a 33% increase in VC funding and now garners 40% of all global VC investment, up from 26% in 2021, according to the report. Cities that want to foster job creation need to embrace policies supportive of a strong tech ecosystem sooner rather than later, according to JF Gauthier, founder and president of Startup Genome. "A lot of people are unhappy because they were doing well in their job, their city was doing well, and suddenly they're doing less and less well, and they don't know why," says Gauthier. "They blame the government, but it's not the government's fault; it is that tech is growing four to five times faster than the rest of the economies, those cities that have a lot of tech are booming, and that creates a lot of disparity. Those cities that don't have a lot of tech are losing their best engineers, their best people." Rounding out the top 10 in the ranking were (4) Tel Aviv, (5) Boston/Beijing (tied), (7) Los Angeles, (8) Seoul, (9) Singapore, and (10) Shanghai. The list also suggested where much of the startup activity around the globe in the next few years will take place. Paris rose two positions on the list to number 12; Philadelphia jumped 12 ranks to number 13; Bengaluru-Karnataka in India rose seven positions to number 14; and Seattle jumped five points to number 15. Hong Kong surged to number 27 globally, rising off the list of emerging ecosystems. It's not only AI that's powering the trend. Two other fast-growing sectors are life sciences, with total deal amounts rising by 17%, and cybersecurity, with a 4% increase, the report found. Cleantech is declining, with a 40% drop in total deal amounts, while edtech has shrunk by 57%, as investors have looked to other sectors for opportunity. Among other key findings: The total value of startup ecosystems worldwide has declined sharply for the first time since 2020. The trend began in 2022, as early-stage funding declined in deal count and total amount. There were 13,215 early-stage funding deals in 2021; by 2025, only an estimated 4,020 more are expected, according to Startup Genome. Some regions suffered disproportionately from the decline in value. Asian and sub-Saharan African ecosystems declined by 17%, while Latin America startup communities reported an aggregate drop of 45%, Europe 24%, the MENA region 22%, Oceania 19%, and North America 18%. The number of large exits declined by 31%, with the number of unicorns dipping, too. Exits above $50 million peaked in 2021, with 3,531 exits valued at $973 billion. For 2025, Startup Genome projects 3,008 exits valued at $237 billion. Inflationary valuations following the pandemic contributed to the trend, making it challenging for startups to recreate a similar lift in value now, the report states. It remains to be seen which ecosystems, beyond the largest ones, will make the most of the trend toward AI-native startups. In Delhi, Istanbul, Paris and San Diego, the number of AI-native startups more than doubled from 2021 to 2024, the research found. However, ample funding will be a factor in many ecosystems. Currently, 90% of AI funding is concentrated in the US and China, the researchers noted. Toronto-Waterloo, Shenzhen, Shanghai and Mumbai saw a more than 10-fold increase in AI-related financing between 2022 and 2024. Also unclear is how successfully AI-native startups will monetize their business models. "Everybody is trying different things, and we don't know where it's going to go," Gauthier says. But Startup Genome projects that some business models now common in the startup world, like software-as-a-service (SaaS) companies, may become dated. The report compares them to the packaged software companies that died after the browser Netscape launched in 1994, helping to usher in the internet era. "You need to start with AI," says Gauthier. "If you start a SaaS company right now, you're going to get killed by an AI-native startup product because they're going to do what you do, plus 100 other things, and then do them faster. To help more ecosystems take full advantage of AI in job creation, Startup Genome is creating an entrepreneurial policy action alliance that calls upon leaders of countries' ministries of innovation, economic development, and other city and public agencies. The goal is to encourage them to support homegrown AI startups rather than purchase infrastructure. "You need to act; you need to start investing massively, as much as much as you can, into an entrepreneurial AI because buying infrastructure is just sending more money to Seattle and Silicon Valley," says Gauthier. "If you invest in your AI entrepreneurs, you're creating a loop, you're supporting AI startups that will export, will attract foreign direct investment that will hire talent and give them experience." Although some of the bigger ecosystems are spawning the most startups, there is plenty of activity in the emerging ecosystems Startup Genome ranked, as well. Nomiki Petrolla is running her startup, a data-driven social network for women founders, ... More in Columbus, Ohio, a fast-growing startup hub. One such ecosystem is Columbus, Ohio, which is tied for 51st through 60th place with US cities such as Nashville, Pittsburgh, Sacramento, and Tampa Bay, as well as internationally with Abu Dhabi, Bangkok, Bogotá, Chengdu, and Prague. Nomiki Petrolla leads theanna, a data-driven social network for women founders based in Columbius. Petrolla, also mentor in the prestigious Techstars accelerator, started in February 2024 and has attracted more than 150 members paying $99 a month as she continues to scale up. With the business picking up traction, Petrolla is focused on her next challenge: "How do we turn that small ripple we've created into something bigger?" It's a question that many entrepreneurs in startup ecosystems around the world will be asking themselves in the next few years, as AI and other trends bring new opportunities.
