Man accused of throwing pot plants at Louth Garda from a balcony is cleared of assault
Marius Vaiciullis, Coach House, Bachelors Lane, Drogheda, denied any wrongdoing at an apartment below his nearly two years ago.
The defence case was one of mistaken identity, the accused testifying that a friend had jumped from his balcony to the other.
Gda John O'Connor gave evidence that on August 18, 2023, the owner of the apartment beneath was asleep when awoken by a loud crashing noise.
He received a report at 8.56pm of a male on this woman's second floor private balcony at Coach House, Bachelors Lane. He was driving of a patrol car at the time and immediately went to the scene.
Gda O'Connor said he saw several smashed pots and plants beneath the balcony, and that the defendant 'picked up a potted plant and attempted to hit me'.
He threw at least two at him. None of them connected.
The man started shouting and damaged a satellite dish by attempting to remove it from a wall.
The witness continued that he was allowed inside by the apartment owner and went to the balcony which was narrow, about a foot wide.
He saw the accused and cautioned him. While speaking to him he got a smell of alcohol. Mr Vaiciullis, he alleged, told him to 'f**k off', and was arrested on the balcony at 9.15pm on suspicion of causing criminal damage.
'Are you sure you have the right man?' solicitor Fergal Boyle asked.
ADVERTISEMENT
'It was a few years ago. I'm pretty convinced," Gda O'Connor replied.
It was put to the officer that Mr Vaiciullis wasn't on the balcony in question. A friend who was highly intoxicated jumped from his balcony to the balcony below.
Gda O'Connor said he couldn't recall what the defendant was wearing. He was looking directly at him.
Mr Boyle continued that a different name was written down first on the custody record, 'then stroked out'.
The custody record also indicated two marks of some description on his client's arms. He didn't have any marks.
Gda O'Connor said that he didn't fill in the custody record. The Member in Charge who did was no longer in the job and not present.
"I don't believe the wrong man is in court,' the witness added.
Marius Vaiciullis, who had the assistance of an interpreter, testified that he was at home in his apartment after returning from work. He saw his friend on the balcony of the apartment below.
"I wasn't on this balcony. I didn't see pots being thrown.'
He continued that he wasn't in the garda station after this incident. He had no scars, marks or tattoos on his arms.
The witness maintained that a completely different person was arrested. Nobody asked him for identification.
He told Inspector Kevin Toner that he wasn't drinking and showed him his bare arms.
Judge Nicola Andrews asked if there was CCTV in the garda station, and was told, no, that it 'would be gone.'
The summons was dismissed.
Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
7 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Juvenile Louth arsonist among gang of five who caused €81,000 damage to local authority home
A jury found the defendant guilty of arson and the case was back before Dundalk Circuit Court for sentencing. He was one of five co-accused who caused more than €81,000 damage to a local authority house in Rathmullan Park on July 3, 2019. The house was effectively gutted. There was no evidence as to who ignited petrol to start the blaze. The front and back doors had been set alight to make escape more difficult. An adult male was awake downstairs and two teenagers upstairs. He raised the alarm and everyone got out. The householder was not present at the time. She was left with only the clothes on her back and lost items of great sentimental value. Using CCTV from various points throughout Drogheda investigators were able to track the movements of the five accused. The defendant was recognised by Gardaí. Petrol and a lighter were bought at one stage. There was no CCTV of the incident. The defendant had no previous convictions nor had he come to adverse attention since. The court heard that he had a difficult childhood and been taken into care. His mother left and he had no contact with her. He had been misusing drugs. It was the view of the Probation Service that he was at low risk of re-offending and that further supervision was not required. Judge Dara Hayes said this was an attack on an occupied family home. Fortunately, the alarm was raised otherwise the consequences could have been more serious or fatal. It was a joint enterprise of arson, a very serious offence. The defendant was a child at the time. He was now employed and in a stable relationship. Two of the co-accused had received custodial sentences, and two non-custodial. The judge continued that an immediate custodial sentence was not appropriate in this case. A five-year sentence was imposed, suspended for five years. The defendant must provide three further clear urinalysis tests. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
Irish Independent
7 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Juvenile Louth arsonist amongst gang of five that caused €81,000 damage to local authority house
A jury found the defendant guilty of arson and the case was back before Dundalk Circuit Court for sentencing. He was one of five co-accused who caused more than €81,000 damage to a local authority house in Rathmullan Park on July 3, 2019. The house was effectively gutted. There was no evidence as to who ignited petrol to start the blaze. The front and back doors had been set alight to make escape more difficult. An adult male was awake downstairs and two teenagers upstairs. He raised the alarm and everyone got out. The householder was not present at the time. She was left with only the clothes on her back and lost items of great sentimental value. Using CCTV from various points throughout Drogheda investigators were able to track the movements of the five accused. The defendant was recognised by Gardaí. Petrol and a lighter were bought at one stage. There was no CCTV of the incident. The defendant had no previous convictions nor had he come to adverse attention since. The court heard that he had a difficult childhood and been taken into care. His mother left and he had no contact with her. He had been misusing drugs. It was the view of the Probation Service that he was at low risk of re-offending and that further supervision was not required. Judge Dara Hayes said this was an attack on an occupied family home. Fortunately, the alarm was raised otherwise the consequences could have been more serious or fatal. It was a joint enterprise of arson, a very serious offence. The defendant was a child at the time. He was now employed and in a stable relationship. Two of the co-accused had received custodial sentences, and two non-custodial. The judge continued that an immediate custodial sentence was not appropriate in this case. A five-year sentence was imposed, suspended for five years. The defendant must provide three further clear urinalysis tests. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
Irish Independent
8 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Jail for man who robbed couple at knifepoint in Louth shopping centre
Morgan Ryan (26), with an address at the time of Dundalk Simon Community, pleaded guilty to a charge of robbery at Tesco Extra, Stapleton Drive, Dundalk, on April 27, 2024. The circuit court was asked to take into consideration charges of possession of a knife and making a threat to kill or cause serious harm. Evidence was given last March that the defendant had gone up to several people that evening including an elderly lady on a mobile phone who ignored him before he targeted a male and female as they walked towards a covered car park around 7.25pm. CCTV footage of the interaction was viewed in court. Gda Ciarán McTeague said the victims were walking back to their car when they were approached by a man 'frothing at the mouth' and holding in his hand a partially crushed energy drink can. He asked them for €3 for his girlfriend to get a bus. The man told him that he didn't carry cash. Mr Ryan reached into his pocket and said, 'I will stab you in the neck'. The woman was 'in genuine fear for her life' when she saw that he had a serrated steak-knife. Her companion indicated that he would withdraw money from a nearby ATM. The three people walked to the ATM beside an escalator. Mr Ryan was holding the knife in his hand. ADVERTISEMENT When he was given a €20 note he calmed down and remarked that he was there to protect people like them. He walked with the couple and tried to hug and kiss them. Gda McTeague said the young woman cried with relief when they got to the car. The couple went to the garda station. There were previous convictions including for robbery, attempted robbery, possession of knives and production of an article. It was stated on Mr Ryan's behalf that he was born in the UK and placed in foster care when he came to Ireland. His foster mother passed away two years ago, and he was refused permission to attend the funeral by the prison governor. He had been in custody most of his adult life and had spent the last eight Christmases inside. The defendant took drugs and alcohol and got into a lot of trouble as a child and teenager. He had taken drugs in custody but was clean for the last month. Counsel said what he did in Tesco Extra was an 'incredibly stupid action in an intoxicated state'. Passing sentence, Judge Dara Hayes said he suspected that the couple would have done anything to get away from Morgan Ryan. What he carried out was done under fear, duress and threat. The female made a Victim Impact Statement. The incident had a considerable impact on her. Judge Hayes imposed a three-and-a-half year sentence, backdated to April 29, 2024, when the defendant went into custody. The final 12 months were suspended on condition that he place himself under Probation Service supervision for 12 months and complete a residential drug treatment programme and aftercare upon his release. He must also be drug- and alcohol-free and provide urinalysis if requested. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
