The voices in the cockpit fuelling controversy over Air India crash
Instead, the 15-page report added fuel to a firestorm of speculation. For, despite the measured tone of the report, one detail continues to haunt investigators, aviation analysts and the public alike.
Seconds after take-off, both fuel-control switches on the 12-year-old Boeing 787 abruptly moved to "cut-off", cutting fuel to the engines and causing total power loss - a step normally done only after landing.
The cockpit voice recording captures one pilot asking the other why he "did the cut-off", to which the person replies that he didn't. The recording doesn't clarify who said what. At the time of take-off, the co-pilot was flying the aircraft while the captain was monitoring.
What we know so far about Air India crash investigation
Read the preliminary report
Are India's skies safe? Air safety watchdog responds amid rising concerns
The switches were returned to their normal inflight position, triggering automatic engine relight. At the time of the crash, one engine was regaining thrust while the other had relit but had not yet recovered power. The plane was airborne for less than a minute before crashing into a neighbourhood in the western Indian city of Ahmedabad.
Several speculative theories have emerged since the preliminary report - a full report is expected in a year or so.
The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) and Reuters news agency have reported that "new details in the probe of last month's Air India crash are shifting the focus to the senior pilot in the cockpit".
Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera claimed that its sources had told them the first officer repeatedly asked the captain why he "shut off the engines".
Sumeet Sabharwal, 56, was the captain on the flight, while Clive Kunder, 32, was the co-pilot who was flying the plane. Together, the two pilots had more than 19,000 hours of flight experience - nearly half of it on the Boeing 787. Both had passed all pre-flight health checks before the crash.
Understandably, the wave of speculative leaks has rattled investigators and angered Indian pilots.
As theories swirl about Air India crash, key details remain unknown
Last week, India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB), the lead investigator, stated in a release that "certain sections of the international media are repeatedly attempting to draw conclusions through selective and unverified reporting". It described these "actions [as] irresponsible, especially while the investigation remains ongoing".
Jennifer Homendy, chairwoman of the US's National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), which is assisting the investigation, said on X that the media reports were "premature and speculative" and that investigations of this magnitude take time".
Back in India, the Indian Commercial Pilots' Association condemned the rush to blame the crew as "reckless" and "deeply insensitive", urging restraint until the final report is out.
Sam Thomas, head of the Airline Pilots' Association of India (ALPA India), told the BBC that "speculation has triumphed over transparency", emphasising the need to review the aircraft's maintenance history and documentation alongside the cockpit voice recorder data.
At the heart of the controversy is the brief cockpit recording in the report - the full transcript, expected in the final report, should shed clearer light on what truly happened.
A Canada-based air accident investigator, who preferred to remain unnamed, said that the excerpt of the conversation in the report presents at several possibilities.
For example, "if pilot 'B' was the one who operated the switches - and did so unwittingly or unconsciously - it's understandable that they would later deny having done it," the investigator said.
"But if pilot 'A' operated the switches deliberately and with intent, he may have posed the question knowing full well that the cockpit voice recorder would be scrutinised, and with the aim of deflecting attention and avoiding identification as the one responsible.
"Even if the AAIB is eventually able to determine who said what, that doesn't decisively answer the question 'Who turned the fuel off?'".
"We may even never know the answer to that question."
Investigators told the BBC that while there appeared to be strong evidence the fuel switches were manually turned off, it's still important to keep "an open mind".
A glitch in the plane's Full Authority Digital Engine Control (FADEC) system - which monitors engine health and performance - could, in theory, trigger an automatic shutdown if it receives false signals from sensors, some pilots suggest.
However, if the pilot's exclamation - 'why did you cut-off [the fuel]?' - came after the switches moved to cut-off (as noted in the preliminary report), it would undermine that theory. The final report will likely include time-stamped dialogue and a detailed analysis of engine data to clarify this.
Speculation has been fuelled less by who said what, and more by what wasn't said.
The preliminary report withheld the full cockpit voice recorder (CVR) transcript, revealing only a single, telling line from the final moments.
This selective disclosure has raised questions: was the investigation team confident about the speakers' identities but chose to withhold the rest out of sensitivity? Or are they still uncertain whose voices they were hearing and needed more time to fully investigate the matter before publishing any conclusions?
Peter Goelz, former NTSB managing director, says the AAIB should release a voice recorder transcript with pilot voices identified.
"If any malfunctions began during take-off, they would be recorded in the Flight Data Recorder (FDR) and would likely have triggered alerts in the flight management system - alerts the crew would almost certainly have noticed and, more importantly, discussed."
Investigators are urging restraint in drawing conclusions.
"We have to be cautious because it's easy to assume that if the switches were turned off, it must mean intentional action - pilot error, suicide, or something else. And that's a dangerous path to go down with the limited information we have," Shawn Pruchnicki, a former airline accident investigator and aviation expert at Ohio State University, told the BBC.
At the same time, alternative theories continue to circulate.
Indian newspapers includig the Indian Express flagged a possible electrical fire in the tail as a key focus. But the preliminary report makes clear: the engines shut down because both fuel switches were moved to cut-off - a fact backed by recorder data. If a tail fire occurred, it likely happened post-impact, triggered by spilled fuel or damaged batteries, an independent investigator said.
Last week, AAIB chief GVG Yugandhar stressed that the preliminary report aims to "provide information about 'WHAT' happened".
"It's too early for definite conclusions," he said, emphasising the investigation is ongoing and the final report will identify "root causes and recommendations". He also pledged to share updates on "technical or public interest matters" as they arise.
Summing up, Mr Pruchnicki said the probe "boils down to two possibilities - either deliberate action or confusion, or an automation-related issue".
"The report doesn't rush to blame human error or intent; there's no proof it was done intentionally," he added.
In other words, no smoking gun - just an uneasy wait for answers that may never even fully emerge.
Air India crash report live updates
Fuel to engines cut off before Air India crash, preliminary report says
Who are the victims of the Air India plane crash?
Solve the daily Crossword

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The World's New Most Populous Country
Eight billion people live on Earth. But did you know that more than half of them reside in Asian countries? China was previously considered the most populous country–but that has now changed. TRAVELBOOK reveals which nation currently has the most inhabitants and where Germany ranks. Of course, no one knows exactly when the eight billionth person was actually born. However, according to United Nations estimates in the 'World Populations Prospect,' this occurred on November 15, 2022. Thus, more than 8 billion people now live on Earth. The world population is expected to continue growing significantly, at least according to UN experts. They estimate that by around 2080, 10.4 billion people will inhabit the Earth. This number is expected to remain stable until 2100 and then begin to decline. Whether the 10 billion people will be distributed proportionally like the current 8 billion is unknown. The fact is that the majority of the population currently lives in Asian countries. For a long time, China held the top spot, with more than 1.4 billion people living in the 'Middle Kingdom.' However, while its population is slowly decreasing, it is steadily increasing in another Asian country, which now holds the number one spot. TRAVELBOOK knows which country this is and reveals, based on a 2022 ranking from the online portal 'Statista,' which other countries are in the top ten. Spoiler: Although it is the largest country by area, Russia does not make it into the top ranks. The Most Populous Countries in the World 1. India As of the end of April 2023, India is considered the most populous country in the world. According to an estimate by the 'United Nations,' India's population reached 1,425,775,850 people. Yet, India ranks only seventh among the largest countries by area! Experts have long predicted that India would overtake China as the most populous country, as its population grows significantly faster. In 1971, India averaged six births per woman. Although this number dropped to just three births per woman over three and a half decades, it was much slower than in China. According to the 'United Nations,' India's current fertility rate is 2.0 births per woman. 2. China With a total of 1.42 billion inhabitants, China was long the most populous country on Earth. To put large numbers into perspective: The entire population of Europe is estimated at 750 million. This means that almost twice as many people live in China as on the European continent. However, China's population is declining–while in 1971, according to the 'United Nations,' there were nearly six births per woman, the number had already drastically decreased to less than three births per woman by the late 1970s–and in 2022, China had one of the lowest fertility rates in the world (1.2 births per woman). 3. USA The third-largest country by area ranks far behind the top two with 'only' 330 million inhabitants. This makes the United States the most populous country outside of Asia. Also interesting: The 20 Richest Countries in the World 4. Indonesia Indonesia has 272 million inhabitants, making it the fourth-largest country by population. This may be surprising to some, as the Southeast Asian country is not among the 20 largest by area. In recent years, Indonesia's population has grown significantly. In 2008, there were about 40 million fewer inhabitants. Projections for the coming decades also suggest that the number will continue to rise. 5. Brazil With its 212.6 million inhabitants, Brazil ranks as the fifth-largest country by population. This may come as a surprise to some, as the Southeast Asian country is not among the largest countries by area. However, it is expected that the number will continue to rise in the coming decades. 5. Pakistan Pakistan's population totals 212.48 million people. The Asian country narrowly loses the fifth spot, but since it has a fertility rate of 2.0 births per woman, compared to China's lower rate, it is expected that this will soon change. 6. Nigeria With its 211 million inhabitants, Nigeria ranks seventh in this list, and it is also the most populous country in Africa. However, while it has a high population, it also has a low life expectancy of 53.9 years, which is among the lowest in the world. 6. Bangladesh Bangladesh has 166 million people, making it the eighth-largest country by population. For some, this may be surprising, but the country's population has been growing steadily, and forecasts for the coming decades suggest that the number will continue to rise. 7. Russia With 146 million people, Russia is the largest country in the world by area, but it does not make it into the top ranks by population. 8. Mexico Mexico has 128 million inhabitants, making it the tenth-largest country by population. 9. Japan Japan has 125 million people, placing it in the eleventh position in terms of population size. 10. Egypt With 102 million inhabitants, Egypt ranks as the thirteenth most populous country in the world. 11. Vietnam Vietnam has 98.3 million people, making it the fifteenth-largest country by population. 12. Ethiopia With 98.7 million people, Ethiopia ranks fourteenth in terms of population size. 13. Philippines The Philippines has 113 million people, making it the twelfth-largest country by population. 14. Egypt With 102 million people, Egypt ranks as the thirteenth most populous country in the world. 15. Vietnam Vietnam has 98.3 million people, making it the fifteenth-largest country by population. 16. Democratic Republic of the Congo The Democratic Republic of the Congo has 92 million people, ranking sixteenth in terms of population size. 17. Germany Germany ranks seventeenth with a population of 83 million. 18. Turkey Turkey has 84.6 million people, making it the eighteenth-largest country by population. 19. Iran Iran has 86 million people, ranking it as the nineteenth most populous country in the world. 20. Thailand Thailand has 69 million people, making it the twentieth-largest country by population. The post The World's New Most Populous Country appeared first on TRAVELBOOK.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
P.E.I. ferry fire in 2022 prompts national investigation by safety board
CHARLOTTETOWN — Canada's transportation safety board has launched a national investigation into fires aboard ships and the responses to them. The independent agency announced the investigation in its report released today on a fire that broke out aboard a ferry as it approached a terminal in Prince Edward Island in July 2022. The fire on the MV Holiday Island started in the engine room after a repair to its fuel injection system failed. The agency says there was confusion over who was responsible for the ferry's safety. It recommends that Transport Canada provide better guidance to reduce the risk of vessels operating without minimum safety requirements. The board says its national investigation will consider how to improve systemic safety gaps related to ship fires. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 23, 2025. The Canadian Press Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data


Fox News
3 hours ago
- Fox News
Delta plane aborts takeoff in Mexico City after plane nearly lands on top of aircraft
A Delta Air Lines passenger jet aborted takeoff this week in Mexico City after its flight crew observed another plane landing in front of it on the same runway. The incident Monday involving Delta Flight 590 happened just days after a pilot of a SkyWest Airlines flight operated by Delta Air Lines was forced to perform an "aggressive maneuver" to avoid a U.S. Air Force B-52 bomber. Another Delta flight also experienced an apparent engine fire shortly after departing from Los Angeles last week, forcing it to turn around. "Because nothing is more important than the safety of our customers and people, Delta will fully cooperate with authorities as the circumstances around this flight are investigated," a Delta spokesperson told Fox News Digital regarding the Mexico City incident. "We appreciate the flight crew's actions to maintain situational awareness and act quickly – part of Delta's extensive training." The spokesperson said the Boeing 737-800 plane, carrying 144 passengers, two pilots and four flight attendants, was initiating its takeoff process for Atlanta Monday morning when the flight crew spotted another plane landing in front of them. That plane was identified in media reports as an Embraer E190 operated by Aeromexico. The flight crew safely stopped the takeoff and returned to a gate at the airport, according to the spokesperson. Then after taking on additional fuel and consulting with Delta safety and flight operations officials, the plane left Mexico City for Georgia about three hours later. The Delta spokesperson also said the airline filed reports with aviation authorities in Mexico as well as the Federal Aviation Administration and U.S. National Transportation Safety Board. Officials said Delta Flight 590 and Aeromexico Flight 1631 were just 200 feet apart at the time of the incident, with the Delta aircraft only reaching speeds of about 60 mph before braking, according to WSB-TV. Aeromexico did not immediately respond to a request for comment Wednesday from Fox News Digital. "We are working closely with the corresponding authorities to conduct a detailed investigation," a spokesperson told Simple Flying. "At Aeromexico, the safety of our customers and employees is, and will always be, our highest priority."