‘Dystopian future' warning as noise of commercial drone ‘delivering burgers, lattes' played in Dáil
A recording of the noise of a commercial drone was played in the
Dáil
as the House was warned that 'our sky is going to become as busy as our roads'.
Opposition TDs highlighted the 'dystopian future' Dublin and other cities faced because of the unregulated growth in the use of drones that are 'not delivering blood or medicine. They're delivering burgers and lattes for profit.'
Social Democrats TD
Gary Gannon
and Solidarity TD
Ruth Coppinger
warned of the growing noise disturbance and intrusion on privacy because of the failure to regulate the increased use of commercial drones across the north and west of Dublin for fast food deliveries.
[
'Like living near a helicopter': Residents fed up with takeaway delivery drones buzzing over their homes
Opens in new window
]
Mr Gannon called for a drone restriction zone to be created over Glasnevin which has been designated Ireland's first autism friendly village.
READ MORE
Ms Coppinger played the recording of the drone and said 'in Blanchardstown, we've been suffering this for over a year and a half, and nobody's listening'.
Mr Gannon said the autism friendly designation 'carries responsibility to protect the sensory and the environmental stability the community relies upon. Unregulated drone activity, threatens that stability'.
He said the area is also home to protected bats and nesting birds and the drones pose a risk to the species 'operating without any environmental assessment'.
The role of the Irish Aviation Authority (IAA) is restricted to licensing and mechanical safety, he said as he called on Minister for Transport
Darragh O'Brien
to 'establish a temporary drone restriction zone' over Glasnevin. 'It should be something that we can just clearly agree on.'
Ms Coppinger said that since drone company
Manna
began operating in the area there have been more than 170,000 flights 'and the plan is for two million'. She added that they have now linked up with food delivery company
Deliveroo
.
'And let's be clear here, they're not delivering blood or medicine. They're delivering burgers and lattes for profit.'
People are 'losing their right to enjoy their backyard, they're losing their right to privacy, and the noise is unbelievable for many, many people'.
She added that 'drone delivery of fast food and consumer goods is not a public necessity'.
[
EV owners could have free charger installed and be paid to share with neighbours under new EasyGo scheme
Opens in new window
]
It 'undermines the quiet residential character of the neighbourhood. It adds yet another layer of stress to daily life and reflects a broader problem, the growing incursion of tech companies into our communities without democratic oversight or meaningful accountability.'
Mr Gannon warned of a 'dystopian future' of drone activity. 'We have one operator at the moment' causing major annoyance and disturbance. 'What happens when we have the second one, the third one,' he said.
The use of drones 'could probably be beneficial in more remote areas' but for the city areas of Glasnevin, Castleknock 'this is not a requirement'.
Minister of State
Jerry Buttimer
, replying for the Government said he agreed that 'there must be other ways of being able to get home delivery done', and he would bring the matter back to the Department of Transport.
He said the IAA is working with the EU on 'developing guidelines and regulations around drone noises'. Two specific current regulations deal with ensuring drones are 'safe and secure'.
He said that commercial drone operations such as Deliveroo delivery are 'more closely regulated' and may require 'specific authorisation'.
The Minister said 'I actually agree with Deputy Coppinger. There must be other ways of being able to get home delivery done.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
21 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Growing hope of trade deal to avoid tariffs between EU and US, says Tanaiste Simon Harris
Simon Harris, said the 'mood music' has improved in recent days and that he is more 'encouraged' following a discussion earlier today with Donald Trump's Trade Representative, Jamieson Greer. Last month Trump lashed out an EU negotiators and threatened a 50pc tariff from June 1 as punishment for 'our discussions with them going nowhere.' But a phone call with the European Commission President, Ursula von der Leyen two days later put discussions back on track and pushed the tariffs start date back to July. With that deadline approaching Minister Harris said: 'there isn't a day to lose' and while there is a 'way to go.. negotiations have now begun in earnest'. He said: 'What we need to find out in the days ahead, is there a landing zone that can work for everyone? And quite frankly, there has to be because this transatlantic trade agreement matters.' The EU and Ireland want to negotiate an outcome, he said 'and from my discussion with President Trump's trade representative, I think he wants that as well.' The Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade said: 'The deadline for the pause in tariffs will run out in July so it is very important that people intensively engage, there isn't a day to lose here. "But I do now think that the mood music, in terms of trying to find a deal, to find agreement, is somewhat better than what it was days ago. The relationship is worth more than €1.4 trillion between the EU and US 'it cannot be snuffed at and therefore a solution has to be found,' he said. On Tuesday Minister Harris told Cabinet colleagues that he would urge the EU to exempt key sectors key to the Irish economy from any retaliatory tariffs should the current negotiations fail. These would include aviation, medical, agrifood and the equine industry. In a letter to the EU's negotiator, Maros Sefcovic, he also urged the trade commissioner to ensure that any retaliation against the US would not adversely impact the North. Although talks between the EU and US have intensified in recent days, the EU has been preparing a list of hundreds of US products worth some €95bn.
Irish Times
40 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Motor insurance premiums rise almost 10%, according to latest data
The increasing cost of motor insurance premiums , with the latest official data pointing to a jump of almost 10 per cent year on year, has led to the junior Minister with oversight of the area to express his concern. According to the Central Statistics Office (CSO), the cost of motor insurance climbed by 8.4 per cent over the last 12 months, more than four times the general rate of inflation which was put at 1.7 per cent. The recent jump in prices comes on top of multiple increases in 2023 and 2024 with the average cost of a premium said to be well in excess of €600 as a result. 'The year-on-year increase in motor insurance is concerning, despite prices being over a third lower since their 2016 peak,' said the Minister of State with Special Responsibility for Financial Services, Credit Unions, and Insurance, Robert Troy. READ MORE 'While recent reforms in the sector have had a positive impact, it is clear that more needs to be done from a policy perspective to ensure that consumers are getting access to cheaper premiums.' More engagement with the Injuries Board has led to a reduction of 30 per cent in respect of motor injury claims and 41 per cent in respect of awards values over a six-year review period covered by a recent report. [ Opens in new window ] There have been substantial changes to the motor insurance sector over recent months that have made it harder for people driving without insurance to escape detection. Reforms have also brought about greater transparency when it comes to claims and driver behaviour all of which suggest g the cost of premiums should be on a downward trajectory. Will rent reform make building apartments viable? Listen | 40:12 However that has not been happening with some motorists now paying more than €200 for cover now than they were just three years ago. The Minister for State said that is his meetings with 'the main insurance players since taking office, I have underlined my expectation that savings arising from these reforms be passed on to consumers. ' He said that a public consultation on the new Action Plan for Insurance Reform has been completed and reviewed by officials in the Department of Finance. 'Insurance reform is a key priority for me and this Government, and we will be in a position to publish this Action Plan over the summer,' he continued. He said it was his intention that the plan would l focus on a 'series of targeted actions which can have meaningful impact for consumers, including an expansion of the Office to Promote Competition in the Insurance Market.'
Irish Times
40 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Ryanair's O'Leary paid €3.8m last year
Ryanair Group chief executive Michael O'Leary received a total pay package of €3.83 million last year, the carrier's annual report shows. The report shows that in the 12 months to the end of March, Mr O'Leary received the maximum bonus possible of €600,000, or 50 per cent of basic pay under his contract, as Ryanair recorded pretax profits of €1.78 billion on the back of revenues climbing to €13.94 billion. The airline achieved the revenues as passenger numbers increased by 9 per cent to a record 200 million for the first time. Mr O'Leary's pay package was made up of basic pay of €1.2 million, a bonus payment of €600,000 and share options of €2.03 million. READ MORE [ Nine-figure payouts to Ryanair and Starbucks CEOs are controversial, but Michael O'Leary can point to results Opens in new window ] A note attached to the accounts states that the options came about through the company recording a technical non-cash accounting charge in relation to share options granted to Mr O'Leary. The note states that no such payment was made to Mr O'Leary and the share options remain unvested. At the end of May, Mr O'Leary qualified for share options worth more than €100 million as part of a bonus scheme. The 64 year old will have to stay at Ryanair until the end of July 2028 to collect the options. The annual report shows that while overall Ryanair revenues increased 3.75 per cent to €13.94 billion, its Irish revenues contracted 4 per cent from €791 million to €757.5 million. In his message to shareholders, Mr O'Leary said the airline's home market is being 'hampered by failed regulation and political inaction', citing the 32 million per year passenger cap at Dublin Airport. Referring to Dublin Airport's €320 million second runway, Mr O'Leary said: 'Only in Ireland would we allow this vital access infrastructure to be built, but then refuse our airlines and citizens the ability to use it, due to bureaucratic failure to abolish an absurd and outdated planning restriction.' The annual report also makes reference to the Data Protection Commission (DPC) here launching an inquiry into Ryanair's booking verification process last October. The report states that Ryanair has engaged with the DPC 'explaining that its verification requirement is designed to ensure compliance with safety and security protocols, and that the process of verification fully complies with the requirements of the GDPR'. The report states that the inquiry is expected to take at least one year 'and while Ryanair is confident in its position, the DPC may ultimately find that the verification process has not fully complied with the GDPR, which could lead to the imposition of a substantial fine'.
