'Hīkoi for Health': Doctors on journey to change New Zealand's public health system
Photo:
RNZ/Peter de Graaf
Two doctors are hoping to turn their anger and frustration over the decline of New Zealand's public health system into a bottom-up blueprint for change.
Doctors Art Nahill and Glenn Colquhoun are on a two-week "Hīkoi for Health" the length of the North Island, talking to as many people as possible about their experiences of the health system and their ideas of how it could be fixed.
With both men known for their poetry, they also hope to harness their anger and turn it into art.
The second-hand van they are travelling in, dubbed the "vanbulance", is itself a mobile work of protest art, decorated by Dunedin painter Nigel Brown.
Nahill said he and Colquhoun had become increasingly alarmed about the deterioration of the public health system.
"It's just got to a point where we've become more and more angry and more and more frustrated, and all of our colleagues and our patients are angry and frustrated, and we wanted to try to do something to turn that anger and frustration into a positive movement," he said.
"In some ways, we feel like we're doing the government's job, because we're going out trying to find out what a good health system would look like for people on the ground, and then we're going to try to put it together and present it to the government so they have a blueprint for moving forward."
The pair's Hīkoi for Health started in Kaitāia on Saturday morning, stopped in Kerikeri that afternoon and in Whangārei on Sunday, spent Monday in Auckland, and heads to Hamilton on Tuesday.
After stops in another seven towns and cities they aim to arrive at Parliament on 8 May to present a preliminary report of their findings.
A more polished report would follow later, Nahill said.
As well as the interviews they were collecting en route, people were invited to make submissions
via the hīkoi's website
.
Nahill said more than 100 suggestions for a better health system had been received even before they left Kaitāia.
The US-trained doctor said when he arrived in New Zealand 20 years ago, he could say "hand on heart" New Zealand's health system was better than the one he had left behind.
"But over the past couple of decades, hospitals have become busier and busier. Emergency rooms are overrun. We've shifted from being carers to being assembly line workers, and our goal is to just push people through the system as quickly as possible.
"There's a lot of moral injury that health care providers suffer, because we know we're not providing the care that people need and deserve," he said.
"It's just reached a point where people are burning out and people are leaving the profession, which makes the whole problem worse, and we're not tackling the public health issues that are really driving the increased need for hospital care. Primary care is broken."
The Hīkoi for Health "vanbulance" has been turned into a mobile work of art by painter Nigel Brown.
Photo:
RNZ/Peter de Graaf
A big part of the problem was that the public health problems that made people sick in the first place had been largely ignored.
Those problems included an "epidemic" of childhood trauma, poor nutrition, and drug and alcohol abuse.
Nahill said he had patients desperate to give up drinking but he could not find a detox programme with space to take them.
"So they just go back out and they drink some more, and they come back into the emergency room."
Other problems facing the health system included the lack of long-term planning, and a political system that led to constant change and policy reversals.
"At the same time, GPs are retiring and they're not being replaced quickly enough. Many hospital doctors are leaving the system to go and work in Australia or in the private system, where it's much more lucrative, which then means wait lists back up, and then hospitals end up contracting to the private groups for those very same doctor services."
Nahill said he had his own ideas of what should be done, but right now he wanted to hear from the New Zealand public.
The Hīkoi for Health 'vanbulance' has been turned into a mobile work of art by painter Nigel Brown. Photo: RNZ / Peter de Graaf
Photo:
RNZ/Peter de Graaf
As it was, too much of the healthcare system was built form the top down, without regard for what people themselves believed they needed.
So far the main themes coming through were access to primary care and people's desire to retain health services in their communities, rather than having to travel long distances to get help.
People were also worried about the public-private divide, which some felt was eroding what used to be equitable access to healthcare for all New Zealanders, irrespective of income.
Nahill said he had spoken to a couple who had lived in Kaitāia for three years but still had not been able to enrol with a GP.
He had also spoken to a senior nurse who was now having to spend part of her time cleaning rooms, because the cleaners on her ward had been laid off.
Nahill said that made a lie of claims that the current cuts to "back office" services would not affect frontline services.
He urged anyone with an interest in health to come to one of the hui - the itinerary was on
the website
- or make a submission.
The hīkoi would last only 13 days, and was limited to the North Island, because it was self-funded and carried out during their annual leave.
"But we've had a really great response to what we're doing, and we're really very, very grateful. But we'd love more stories. We can't get enough stories."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Bangladesh dengue deaths top 100, August could be worse
Health experts are warning that August could bring an even more severe outbreak of the mosquito-borne disease. Photo: RNZ Bangladesh is experiencing a surge in dengue cases and deaths, with health experts warning that August could bring an even more severe outbreak of the mosquito-borne disease if urgent action is not taken. Dengue has killed 101 people and infected 24,183 so far this year, official data showed, placing a severe strain on the country's already overstretched healthcare system. A sharp rise in fatalities has accompanied the spike in cases. Nineteen people have already died of dengue so far in August, following 41 deaths in July, more than double June's 19 fatalities. "The situation is critical. The virus is already widespread across the country, and without aggressive intervention, hospitals will be overwhelmed," said Kabirul Bashar, an entomologist at Jahangirnagar University. "August could see at least three times as many cases as July, with numbers potentially peaking in September." Health officials are urging people to use mosquito repellents, sleep under nets, and eliminate stagnant water where mosquitoes breed. "We need coordinated spraying and community clean-up drives, especially in high-risk zones," Bashar said. Experts say climate change, along with warm, humid weather and intermittent rain, has created ideal breeding conditions for Aedes mosquitoes, the carriers of the dengue virus. While Dhaka remains a major hotspot, dengue is peaking across the country. Large numbers of infections are being reported from outside the capital, adding pressure to rural healthcare facilities with limited capacity to treat severe cases. Doctors warn that early medical attention is critical. Severe abdominal pain, vomiting, bleeding, or extreme fatigue should prompt immediate hospital visits to reduce the risk of complications or death. With the peak dengue season still ahead, health experts have stressed that community participation, alongside government-led mosquito control, will be critical in preventing what could become one of Bangladesh's worst outbreaks in years. The deadliest year on record was 2023, with 1,705 deaths and more than 321,000 infections reported. - Reuters
RNZ News
13 hours ago
- RNZ News
ACC services not designed for people with concussion, says support group
A brain-injury support group says ACC's one-size-fits-all approach doesn't work for people with concussion. Photo: People with concussion are struggling to find the right support from ACC following a diagnosis, a brain injury support group says. Headway has campaigned for years to change the way ACC manages people with Traumatic Brain Injuries. Chief executive Stacey Mowbray told RNZ's Afternoons it was great New Zealand had a national insurance scheme like ACC, but said the one-size-fits-all approach did not work. "We're really worried that the system of ACC really expects someone with a concussion - so they're struggling to think straight, they're really having memory issues - to navigate the same processes as someone with a twisted ankle," she said. "We just don't think that the system is set up to deal with the complexities that someone faces with a concussion. "Sitting on the phone on hold for an hour when I've got a concussion and there's music playing really loudly, that is going to be really challenging for someone with a concussion." By contrast, some banks allowed customers to opt out of listening to music, while they were on hold, Mowbray said. ACC's acting head of client recovery, Matthew Goodger, pushed back on Mowbray's comments however, and said ACC did not have a one-size-fits-all approach. "Our systems and teams are designed to support a wide range of injuries, including concussion, within this broader context. All claims are assessed and handled on a case-by-case basis. "The way we support people, and which team supports them, depends on their needs." Mowbray called for more understanding from ACC, and more education and training for staff. "We think the real gap is better understanding from the staff and just thinking about some of those simple processes." People trying to access ACC services were not always told what support they may be entitled to, she said. "Unfortunately, that doesn't seem to always happen and, again, I think it might come back to education and understanding. "You don't know what you don't know, so I don't know what entitlements there are for me with ACC, and unless ACC consistently discloses these entitlements, it makes it so difficult for someone to actually say, 'Look, I'm having real visual issues, my vision is foggy, I'm struggling to see distances, it's not safe for me to drive'. "We would like to see ACC frontfooting that and saying, 'We will cover transport to your appointments, we'll cover transport'... just a little bit more openness around disclosing entitlements." While staff may be trying their best, they may not know, for example, visual issues and feeling dizzy were common with concussion, and driving may be a problem, Mowbray said. Goodger said ACC staff dealing directly with clients completed an eLearning module during induction which taught them about TBIs - it covered how the different types of brain injury affect different functions in clients' brains and the tasks they do in everyday life. There was also a facilitated training session that expanded on the initial training, he said. "If someone has a severe TBI they will have a lead provider who can also help them navigate the health system, which includes ACC. We work closely with lead providers. "Clients can also appoint someone else, such as friend or family member, who can communicate with us on their behalf about their claim." Mowbray suggested anyone having trouble with the process should contact Wayfinders, a free service that helped the public deal with ACC, Goodger agreed with this. It was not all bad news, with a new brain-injury screening tool helping general practitioners develop care plans for people with concussion. "We are the best place in the world to have a concussion, I think, because we've got these world-leading researchers," Mowbray said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Otago Daily Times
4 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Thousands giving up Medic Alert bracelets due to cost
Photo: Supplied/RNZ The Medic Alert Foundation has started a petition calling for government funding to ensure all those who need a medic alert bracelet, can get one. The bracelets carry an emergency number so first responders can access their medical records if they cannot speak for themselves, due to an allergic reaction, epilepsy or another condition. However, chief executive Murray Lord has told RNZ that up to 9000 New Zealanders were letting lapse their $70-a year membership due to cost of living pressures. "Over the last year or two we've had an increased incidence of people saying 'Look, I just can't find the money anymore'. We do everything we possibly can to help them keep their service - but being a charity, you're limited by the capacity of your funding." Research commissioned by the foundation found for every dollar spent on the service, it saved the health system $11. About 22 percent of the population could benefit from a medic alert bracelet, but it was currently only servicing around 2 percent. However, that was already saving the country about $56 million a year in reduced hospital costs, harm and deaths, Lord said. "If more people could access the service without these barriers, then through volume the cost of the service comes down but through technology and other aspects of the service, the value of it comes up. "So it's a bit of a no-brainer really." The enrolment process was another barrier for some people, but the capability was there (as Medic Alert was already a recognised health information service) to make it available to all, perhaps through their existing health record log-in. "There's an opportunity here. The service is already deployed nationally, the software already exists. "That technology is very advanced, it's connectable with other systems and it's life saving. We've got the opportunity to give every New Zealander access to that service, to get their information shared even if they can't talk, and make it accessible nationally and if they travel overseas."
