Murder accused must have had 'a colossal amount' of whiskey before incident, witness tells trial
The witness also agreed that the accused must have had "a colossal amount" of whiskey on the night.
Advertisement
Valeriu Melnic (24), with an address at Calliaghstown Lower, Rathcoole, Co Dublin, is charged with murdering Ion Daghi (39) at The Close, Sallins Park, Sallins in Co Kildare on May 12th, 2024.
Mr Melnic has pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to Mr Daghi's manslaughter.
A pathologist has told the jury that Mr Daghi died from a single stab wound to the chest, which measured 13cm in depth, and death would have been very rapid.
Moldovan național Alexandru Beccieu (24), who has given evidence over the last two days, told Carl Hanahoe SC, prosecuting, that he and Mr Melnic went to Mr Daghi's house in Sallins for a barbeque around 8pm on May 11th. He said the accused's sister was the partner of Mr Daghi.
Advertisement
Mr Beccieu said he had brought a bottle of whiskey, which he shared with the accused and Mr Daghi. The men bought another bottle of whiskey or "a strong drink" later in the night and returned to Mr Daghi's house, where they continued drinking.
The witness said the atmosphere was "different" before they went to get a third bottle of whiskey from a nightclub in Naas. He said the accused had gotten drunk and was "speaking ugly" to Mr Daghi.
The witness said both he and Mr Daghi were trying to calm Mr Melnic down, but the accused was "very drunk".
Mr Beccieu said Mr Daghi was trying to calm the accused down "with nice words," but the deceased's patience was wearing thin. He said when Mr Melnic's behaviour wasn't changing, Mr Daghi "wasn't being very kind either" and told him to take his car and go home.
Advertisement
The accused and Mr Daghi then started to pull at each other. Mr Melnic, the witness said, had started to pull at Mr Daghi first, and the accused said he wasn't going anywhere.
The witness said he went between his friends to pull them apart when they started throwing punches at each other. Mr Beccieu said the accused tried to hit him and was successful on the second occasion. He said Mr Daghi then got in between them and separated them.
Mr Baccieu went to look for the accused's car keys because Mr Melnic wasn't calming down after Mr Daghi told him to go home.
When the witness came back, he said the accused was "down" or on the ground with his hands on his head, trying to ward something off" and that Mr Daghi had a piece of a chair in his hand.
Advertisement
A woman took Mr Melnic into the house, and Mr Baccieu and Mr Daghi stayed outside smoking a cigarette.
The witness said Mr Daghi looked in the window of the house and saw the accused and his sister pulling at each other.
Mr Daghi went into the kitchen to see what was happening and came out seconds later.
The witness continued: "Mr Daghi said he cut and fell down in front of me. After he fell down on his stomach, I turned him around on his back and asked what was wrong with him".
Advertisement
He said Mr Daghi's mother was crying and screaming. Asked how long Mr Daghi was in the kitchen for, the witness said "he just went in and came back out".
Mr Baccieu said the deceased had fallen around a metre from the entrance to the kitchen.
Asked again what Mr Daghi had said when he came out of the kitchen, the witness said the deceased told him "he cut me, go," but he didn't understand where Mr Daghi was telling him to go.
Under cross-examination, Mr Beccieu agreed with Brendan Grehan SC, defending, that the accused was "very drunk" as he had never seen him "speak like that way before".
The witness also agreed that the accused had been pouring more whiskey for himself than the others.
He further agreed Mr Melnic must have had "a colossal amount" of the whiskey as the deceased didn't have a lot of alcohol in his system.
The witness clarified that Mr Daghi had the leg of the chair in his hand when the accused was squatting down with his hands over his head, trying to protect it.
He said he hadn't seen Mr Daghi hit Mr Melnic but heard the deceased say, "stop or I'll beat you one".
In his opening address, Mr Hanahoe said it was the State's case that the accused 'armed himself with a kitchen knife' and stabbed Mr Daghi once in the chest following an altercation after the pair had spent the night drinking together.
The trial continues on Monday before Mr Justice David Keane and a jury of eight men and four women.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
12 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Body of woman, 31, is found near spot where British expat was murdered in frenzied stabbing attack in Dordogne
The dead body of a young woman has been found close to the spot where a British woman was murdered in a frenzied knife attack in rural France. Floriane Roux, 31, was reported missing exactly a week ago, before her corpse was uncovered by a police dog on Monday. It was hidden in thick undergrowth in the village of Paunat, in the Dordogne department, east of Bordeaux. This is less than five miles from Trémolot, where Karen Carter, 65 and a mother of four, was stabbed repeatedly before succumbing to her wounds outside her home on April 29. The British-South African national had spent a night out with friends, before dying next to her car. Florian Roux, who was French, had also been planning a night out with friends, before her body was found close to her Vauxhall Corsa. Both deaths are now being investigated by local prosecutors, supported by judicial police and gendarmes. An investigating source said on Wednesday: 'The body of Floriane Roux was found on Monday, at 4pm. 'It was in a small shelter, hidden by tall grass and plants and not far from her vehicle, next to the Dordogne River.' The body was found by a dog, who was one of seven involved in a search organised by gendarmes from Bergerac, said the source. A doctor pronounced Ms Roux dead at the scene, before police removed her body. Neither the circumstances nor cause of Ms Roux's death are yet known, and no theory – including the possibility of suicide – is being ruled out, said the source. According to her her family, Floriane Roux was supposed to meet a friend for the evening on July 23, but the friend claims not to have seen her. An investigation was opened last week by the Bergerac prosecutor's office into a 'disturbing disappearance.' Those questioned by police included Ms Roux's boyfriend, whom she lived with in Montanceix, near Saint-Astier. Ms Carter had attended a wine tasting hosted by Jean-François Guerrier, her 75-year-old lover, in the hours before her death. Both Mr Guerrier and Marie-Laure Autefort, another Trémolat resident said to have been passionately in love with him, were originally arrested, but then released without charge. Ms Carter left the party at 10pm, and had promised to phone Mr Guerrier when she got home. Concerned when he heard nothing, Mr Guerrier, a former managing director of Fujitsu Services who worked in Britain at one point, drove to check on her, and found her body sprawled on the driveway of the property she ran as a rental business. Despite attempts to save her, Ms Carter died from severe blood loss, after being stabbed in the chest, groin, arm and leg, according to an autopsy. Investigators leading the investigation feared that someone who held a grudge against Ms Carter – or 'the new couple' she was forming with Jean-François Guerrier – may have killed her. Prosecutors believe the murder was a meticulously planned crime, carried out by someone who knew Ms Carter. He or she lay in wait, they believe, and took care to avoid leaving forensic evidence, before using 'unspeakable violence' against the defenceless Ms Carter, according an investigating source. 'It certainly could have been someone who knew the victim from the Café Village, or a contract killer acting on their behalf,' the source added. Ms Carter had British and South African nationality, and her husband, Alan Carter, was at their home in East London, South Africa, at the time of the killing. He arrived in Trémolat soon afterwards, and visited the scene of the suspected murder, before organising his wife's funeral, which took place in Bergerac in early July. Mr Guerrier has meanwhile declined to speak at length, saying: 'Karen was a lovely lady, but I can't answer any more questions at the moment.' He confirmed hosting a party at his converted farmhouse, close to the village, just before Ms Carter's death.
The Sun
15 minutes ago
- The Sun
Mum murdered children, 7 & 11, hours after cops released her for attacking partner & threatening to stab him in sleep
A MUM brutally murdered her children hours after she was released by cops following an attack on her husband, an inquest heard. Veronique John was detained indefinitely after stabbing her son Ethan, 11, and daughter Elizabeth, seven, at their home in Stoke-on-Trent in June 2023. 4 4 In a trial of facts last July, a jury ruled Ethan had been knifed 27 times by John, before she inflicted a fatal head injury on Elizabeth. She then travelled to a nearby car wash, where she stabbed her husband Nathan John. Charity worker John, 51, dialled 999 and said: "I am calling to report I just killed my two kids." She was charged with two counts of murder and the attempted murder of her partner, but she was ruled unfit to make a plea due to her mental illness. And an inquest this week heard that John had been arrested and taken into custody just hours before she killed her children. Stoke Civic Centre heard police were called twice in the two days leading up to the the horrific murders on Sunday, June 11. Two days before, John had dialled 999 and officers attended the family home in Flax Street. Nathan was not in the property, but both children were upstairs and deemed to be "medium risk". The following day, Nathan called the cops and was discovered with a swollen arm and lump on his head. He reported his wife had struck him with a piece of wood and threatened to kill him in his sleep. Officers then arrested John at home before taking her into custody for questioning, where she denied making threats to kill her husband. She was interviewed under caution and released with a community resolution notice, returning him in the early hours of Sunday. Moment dad who murdered newborn by smashing his head against hospital wall calmly smokes cig as docs fought to save tot Hours later, Ethan was found dead in his bedroom with a neck wound. His younger sister Elizabeth had head trauma and "three areas of sharp force" injury, including to her stomach. PC John Harrison, who was involved in the case review, told the inquest: "Officers initially went to the home address and that's where officers found both of the children. "Veronique John contacted police, stating she was at her home and had killed the children. "This was a highly unusual outcome. Officers will see a high number of domestic abuse cases, but case like these are extremely rare." Sergeant Steven Marriott was responsible for booking John into custody. He added: "There was nothing that made me feel she needed to see a healthcare professional at the time. "I did not believe there was any reason to delay the interview with Mrs John." PC Megan Maddox, who attended the home on the Saturday, said that John seemed "apologetic" about the assault on her husband. She added: "While I was speaking to Mr John on the Saturday evening I asked if the children were safe at home with mum and he said yes. "I believed there was no physical threat to the children. "He had somewhere else to go and we didn't believe that she did. "She was the main carer for the children while he worked and I thought the physical risk was focused on Mr John, not the children." An investigation into Staffordshire Police found the force's service level had been "inadequate". The inquest, opened by coroner Emma Serrano, heard that John could have been prevented from returning to her address if a domestic violence protection notice had been issued. At the trial of facts last year, Nottingham Crown Court heard John had told officers: "If you have a gun shoot me." What is a trial of facts? A trial of facts takes place when a court determines that a person is unfit to stand trial under usual criminal proceedings. It cannot result in a conviction but a jury will instead determine whether an accused committed the alleged acts. Prosecutors will put their evidence against the defendant before a judge and jury, in a courtroom, in a similar way to a normal criminal trial. But the accused will not play a role in proceedings and do not even have to attend court. Unlike a criminal trial, the jury do not find the defendant guilty or not guilty and are instead asked to decide if the defendant committed the offence with which they are charged. They will also focus solely on what the accused has allegedly done, rather than if they had the mental capacity at the time to be found guilty. The defendant can still be acquitted as per a normal trial if the panel is not satisfied they carried out the crime. Sentencing options include treatment orders, hospital orders and supervision or guardianship orders. In some cases, a judge will grant an absolute discharge - meaning the defendant is free to go. She later claimed her husband had been cheating on her, adding: "I did it because I love my children - to protect the children. "It's something I was thinking about for a long time - just kill myself and the kids. "I am not a monster - he was going to take them from me. "If there's any possible way I could be put to death, I would like that. I mean it 100 per cent." Prosecutor Peter Grieves-Smith said her "rage was boiling just under the surface". Mr Grieves-Smith said: "What happened on June 11 didn't come out of the blue. Tension grew in the days before. "That day she just erupted, killed her children and attacked Nathan." The inquest continues. 4
BreakingNews.ie
15 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
'Jekyll and Hyde' character jailed after going on a road rampage in Co Donegal
A man described as a 'Jekyll and Hyde' character after he drank alcohol has been jailed for eight months and put off the road for five years after going on a rampage in Co Donegal. Owen Orr committed a series of offences on St Valentine's Day in 2019 leaving a trail of destruction in his wake. Advertisement The father-of-five punched another motorist in the face, assaulted a Garda, damaged his motorbike and then crashed his car into a terrified mother and daughter. Orr, who has 31 previous convictions, appeared at Letterkenny Circuit Court where he pleaded guilty to a range of offences which all occurred on the same evening. Judge Roderick Maguire said it was completely unacceptable that gardaí had been put in such danger while doing their duty. He also said members of the public were fortunate not to have suffered more serious and lasting injuries as a result of Orr's actions. Advertisement The 32-year-old was charged that, at Cullion Road, Letterkenny, he assaulted Garda Michael Kilcoyne, a peace officer, acting in the course of his duty. The charge is contrary to Section 19 (3) of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act, 1994, as amended by Section 185 of the Criminal Justice Act, 2006. He was charged that he did without lawful excuse damage property, to wit, a Garda Honda motorcycle, belonging to the Chief Superintendent, An Garda Siochana. The charge is contrary to Section 2 (1) of the Criminal Damage Act, 1991. Advertisement Orr was charged with the unlawful interference with a mechanically propelled vehicle, the property of Charles Bonner, while such vehicle was stationary at Manorcunningham by removing the key from the ignition. The charge is contrary to Section 113 or the Road Traffic Act, 1961, as amended by Section 6 of the Road Traffic Act, 1968 and Section 18 of the Road Traffic Act, 2006. He is also charged with dangerous driving o the N13 on February 14th, 2019 He is further charged that, at Dromore, Letterkenny, on February 14th 2019, that he did without lawful excuse damage property, to wit, a Toyota Corolla belonging to Kathleen Birch intending to damage such property or being reckless as to whether such property would be damaged. The charge is contrary to Section 2 (1) of the Criminal Damage Act, 1991. Advertisement He is also charged with failing to report an accident when injury was caused to property or a person at Dromore Lower on February 14th, 2019 being the driver of a vehicle involved in the accident. Other charges were also taken into account by the court. Prosecutor for the State, Ms Fiona Crawford, BL, along with Garda Daire Sheridan outlined the series of events on the day which led to Orr's arrest. He told how another motorist, Charles Bonner, was driving on the dual carriageway into Letterkenny when he saw another car overtaking a series of other vehicles before pulling in front of him. Advertisement Mr Bonner flashed his lights at the car but the other driver, now known to be Owen Orr, slammed on his brakes forcing the other driver to brake. Mr Bonner stopped and the driver of the other car came over, punched him in the nose, pulled the keys out of his jeep and then threw them into a hedge and drove off with the entire incident being captured on dashcam. At Dromore Lower, some kilometres down the road, Mrs Kathleen Birch and her daughter were traveling towards Letterkenny down Lurgybrack when a car pulled out and smashed into them. Mrs Birch suffered pain in her back and legs and feared her car was going to go on fire as other motorists came to her aid. The driver of the other car fled on foot but left his wallet with bank cards and identification at the scene. Garda motorcyclist Michael Kilcoyne arrived at the scene of the accident and went in search of the driver of the other car and found Owen Orr walking at nearby Cullion Road. He addressed Orr who became aggressive and assaulted the Garda by grabbing him by the neck causing his motorbike to fall to the ground. A scuffle broke out and Orr lashed out at the arresting officer by kicking him before he was taken to Letterkenny Garda Station for questioning. While in the station, Orr refused to give either a blood or urine sample to a registered nurse. The accused man was interviewed four days later when sober and the court was told he was very apologetic about the incident. Barrister for Orr, Mr Ciaran Elders, BL, directed by solicitor Frank Dorrian, said his client was very cooperative during the second interview describing him as a 'Jekyll and Hyde' character when he had alcohol taken. He added that he finds himself in a better place today and has been sober since 2023 after two periods in rehabilitation apart from a small lapse. The accused man had a total of €2,000 in compensation to offer including a sum to replace the €500 key for Mr Bonner's jeep, another €750 for the damage to his glasses and €750 to be given to a charity of Garda Kilcoyne's choice. A further €500 was also available to Mrs Birch while the court was also told that civil proceedings are also ongoing arising from the collision. Mr Elders added that his client was now trying to put his life back together and was a man with a high IQ with five children, the oldest of which were also academically gifted and wanted to attend college. Judge Roderick Maguire addressed the accused and asked him how his family were now keeping and how his life was now that he is trying to remain sober. Orr said that he was attending AA meetings four times a week. Mr Elders added that now that it appears that Orr has been rehabilitated and has also come a long way since this incident in 2019, he was not sure how a custodial sentence could benefit Orr or society at large. Passing sentence, Judge Maguire outlined all the events of the night saying he had considered all matters. He outlined a headline sentence but then said he had to consider mitigation before passing a final sentence. He said gardaí had noted that Orr was very easy to deal with when sober, he had not come to Garda attention since, had entered an early plea and was in a much better place today. The Judge also noted his probation report, the fact that he has five children and also considered the management of his alcohol abuse and that he is now attending alcoholics anonymous four times a week. He also noted that compensation had been offered to those caught up in Orr's rampage which he said were concrete expressions or remorse of the accused. Taking all these matters into account, Judge Maguire reduced the headline sentence to one of sixteen months with the last eight months suspended and banned Orr from holding a driving license for five years. He also ordered him to enter a bond to keep the peace for a period of two years upon his release from prison.
