Council vows 'lessons must be learned' after report into complaint handling
The report found that Edinburgh council needed to improve its safeguarding measures, and that a 'prevalent' culture of hospitality needed to be looked at by the council.
But it found that council officers had acted appropriately in handling complaints made to them.
It also said that people who had complained about the behaviour of the former council leader experienced a 'significant perceived power imbalance' when making complaints about him.
Council leader Jane Meagher said the report was 'largely reassuring' – but that recommendations made in the report needed to be carried out 'swiftly and comprehensively'.
Kevin Dunion, former chair of the Standards Commission for Scotland, carried out the third party investigation that resulted in the report, which itself was commissioned by the council.
Mr Dunion's investigation came after recent and historic complaints about alleged sexual harassment by former Labour council leader Cammy Day came to light.
Councillor Day resigned in December 2024 soon after the first allegations were published in the press, and he was suspended from the Labour Party soon after.
Multiple Ukrainian refugees said Cllr Day had sent them unsolicited images and messages on social media, even after being asked to stop.
In one historic incident, which took place in 2010 and was reported in 2018, a then 15-year-old boy said he was sexually harassed online by Cllr Day.
Since his resignation, a police investigation into his behaviour has found no evidence of criminality, with the former leader claiming he is the target of a political witch hunt.
SNP group leader, councillor Simita Kumar, said: 'It is imperative that lessons must be learned.
'A common thread throughout this report is that staff and complainants felt unable – or unwilling – to raise concerns due to the power and influence of the accused.
'We must establish better systems to support and protect those who come forward or the risk of abuse by those in positions of authority will persist.'
Mr Dunion's report found that leaks of information about alleged leaks by councillors had impeded the city's whistleblowing process.
Councillor Ed Thornley, leader of the Liberal Democrat group, said: 'I want to thank Kevin Dunion for his report and the work that's gone into it. He's highlighted several issues with the way the Council's processes aren't working correctly and the gaps in them.
'It's clear reading the report that where Council officers have been aware and informed, they acted appropriately and gave sound advice in line with the agreed processes. That is not the case for councillors.
'The two leaks of confidential information by councillors seriously undermine the integrity of the systems in place, and call into question the judgement of the individuals responsible.
'Such leaks represent a deliberate and blatant breach of the Councillors' Code of Conduct. The Lib Dem group will consider Mr Dunion's recommendations thoroughly over the coming days.'
Edinburgh Council's leader, Labour councillor Jane Meagher said: 'I want to thank Mr Dunion for leading this review, and for his report.
'While I'm largely reassured by Mr Dunion's findings about how recent complaints have been handled by officers, clearly, there are elements of this report which are of serious concern to us as elected members and we must act on his recommendations swiftly and comprehensively. I have already taken practical steps to begin to change the culture in the City Chambers.
'Our priority must be to nurture positive working relationships throughout the Council where colleagues feel able to speak up if something isn't right, they know and trust the channels open to them and they feel safe and supported in doing so.
'I'm fully committed to taking Mr Dunion's recommendations forward and, subject to approval by councillors next Thursday, look forward to agreeing concrete actions when officers bring a further report back in August outlining our proposed actions in response to Mr Dunion's recommendations.'
Independent councillor Ross McKenzie, who was part of the Labour group until 2023, said: 'It's now up to the Labour Party to decide whether they are comfortable with Cammy Day being a Labour councillor.
'The report contains details of an extraordinarily serious allegation made in 2018 and a pattern of sexual harassment allegations since.
'If Labour are serious about safeguarding then they will have conducted an exhaustive investigation into all of these allegations.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Guardian
8 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
North Korean and Russian leaders in call to reaffirm alignment over Ukraine
The call came ahead of Mr Putin's planned meeting with US president Donald Trump in Alaska. During the call on Tuesday, Mr Putin praised the 'bravery, heroism and self-sacrificing spirit' displayed by North Korean troops as they fought with Russian forces to repel a Ukrainian incursion into Russia's Kursk border region, North Korea's official Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) said. Mr Putin also shared with Mr Kim information about his upcoming talks with Mr Trump scheduled to take place on Friday, according to Russia's TASS news agency, citing the Kremlin. Mr Kim told Mr Putin that Pyongyang would fully support 'all measures to be taken by the Russian leadership in the future, too', as they discussed advancing ties in 'all fields' under a strategic partnership agreement they signed during a summit last year, KCNA said. Since Russia's invasion of Ukraine, Mr Kim has made Moscow the priority of his foreign policy as he aims to break out of diplomatic isolation and expand relations with countries confronting Washington. His government has dismissed Washington and Seoul's stated desires to restart diplomacy aimed at defusing the North's nuclear programme, which derailed in 2019 following a collapsed summit with Mr Trump during his first term. According to South Korean assessments, North Korea has sent around 15,000 troops to Russia since last autumn and also supplied large quantities of military equipment, including artillery and ballistic missiles, in support of Mr Putin's war efforts against Ukraine. Mr Kim has also agreed to send thousands of military construction workers and deminers to Russia's Kursk region, a deployment South Korean intelligence believes could happen soon.
The Independent
8 minutes ago
- The Independent
Treasury looks at inheritance tax ahead of autumn budget
The Treasury is reportedly considering tightening inheritance tax rules to address a £50bn shortfall in public finances. Proposed measures include scrapping the 'seven-year rule' for gifts and introducing a potential lifetime cap on gifts to limit pre-death asset transfers. Inheritance tax, which applies to estates worth more than £325,000, generated a record £6.7bn in 2022-2023 and is seen by some as a de facto wealth tax. The move comes amid pressure on Rachel Reeves to find solutions for a projected £41.2bn shortfall by 2029-2030, with calls for a broader wealth tax. Despite suggestions for wealth taxes from some Labour figures, the Treasury's official stance is to focus on economic growth and avoid raising income tax, National Insurance, or VAT.
The Independent
8 minutes ago
- The Independent
Palestine Action terror ban risks ‘I am Spartacus' moment, Labour peer warns
A Labour peer has warned that the government's ban on Palestine Action is at risk of becoming an 'I am Spartacus' moment, suggesting the decision to proscribe the group as a terrorist organisation was disproportionate. Shami Chakrabarti, a former shadow attorney general and civil liberties campaigner, urged the government to 'think again', warning that the group's ban may lead to more people, not fewer, taking to the streets to support it. She said her concerns are 'greater now even than they were before' after more than 500 people were arrested over the weekend, demonstrating in support of the group. An "I Am Spartacus" moment – from the 1960 film, Spartacus - refers to a situation where a group of people collectively claim to be one person, often in solidarity or defiance, to protect that individual or to confuse an authority figure. The Metropolitan Police confirmed on Sunday that 532 arrests were made, 522 for displaying an item in support of a proscribed organisation at the march in central London over the weekend. Asked whether the government had got it wrong on the issue, Baroness Chakrabarti told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: 'I'm afraid that my concerns are greater now even than they were before. This is in danger of becoming a sort of 'I am Spartacus' moment where more people, not fewer people, are taking to the streets.' She added: 'There are blurred lines now… some people are, as always, protesting about the horrific events they're watching unfold in Gaza, but others think they're standing up for civil liberties because this ban was disproportionate.' The Labour peer warned that 'even criminal damage is not terrorism'. 'Spraying paint on airplanes, which is a serious criminal damage, is not the same as being the IRA or al Qaeda or a group that actually wants to blow people up. 'And so we've got more people taking to the streets, a bigger headache for the police. Frankly, I'm very sympathetic to the police on this issue. I think it may be time to think again.' It comes just days after she told The Independent that the 'proscription of Palestine Action is in danger of becoming a mistake of poll tax proportions' – a reference to Margaret Thatcher's unpopular policy that triggered civil disobedience and riots. The group hit the headlines earlier this year when four members were accused of causing around £7m worth of damage to aircraft at RAF Brize Norton. The mass detention of protesters on Saturday is thought to be the highest number of arrests made by the Metropolitan Police in a single protest event since the poll tax riot of 31 March 1990. Earlier this week, MPs from across the political divide warned of an excessive use of counterterrorism powers that was riding roughshod over the right to peaceful protest, after it emerged that many of those held were aged over 60. Meanwhile, civil liberties groups, including Amnesty and Libert,y said the arrests were 'disproportionate to the point of absurdity' and that the government's terrorism laws were a threat to freedom of expression. Former Labour cabinet minister Peter Hain described the mass arrests as 'madness', saying Palestine Action was not 'equivalent to real terrorist groups like al-Qaeda or Islamic State'. Lord Hain, who led the anti-apartheid movement and the Anti-Nazi League in Britain during the 1970s and 1980s, went on to warn that the ban will 'end in tears for the government'. 'We are seeing retired magistrates, retired and serving doctors and all sorts of people being arrested and now effectively being equated with terrorists such as al-Qaida, which is absolutely wrong', he said. 'It's going to get worse [for the government] because I don't see people from that 'middle Britain' background who have joined these protests in such large numbers to suddenly decide that all is OK.' But home secretary Yvette Cooper defended the police and suggested those who were arrested may not 'know the full nature of this organisation'. After the arrests, Downing Street defended the move to ban the group, saying it was 'violent', had committed 'significant injury' as well as criminal damage, and that the Joint Terrorism Analysis Centre had found the organisation had carried out three separate acts of terrorism. 'We've said that many people may not yet know the reality of this organisation, but the assessments are very clear: this is a violent organisation that has committed violence, significant injury and extensive criminal damage,' Sir Keir Starmer's spokesman said on Monday.
