MP concerned over proposed change to South Devon cardiac care
Delays to treatment are among the concerns being raised by a proposal to move an out-of-hours cardiac service out of Torbay.The suggested trial comes after two reviews undertaken by a healthcare programme found the joint service across hospitals in the county could be improved.Primary Percutaneous Coronary Intervention (PPCI), an emergency treatment for heart attacks, is currently provided at hospitals in Torbay and Exeter, but the proposal could see the service moved to just the latter. Liberal Democrat MP for Torbay Steve Darling said he was "extremely concerned" at the prospect of losing the procedure from the Torbay area as it could mean "poorer outcomes for patients".
He said: "For patients throughout South Devon, clearly Torbay is a lot closer than Exeter, particularly on a busy summer's day."I'm just concerned that delays in treatment can mean poorer outcomes and I'm looking for a briefing with the hospital to get some reassurances, but also to see if the trial does come out negatively, that they will reverse this decision."In an update to local MPs the Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust (TSD) said it hoped the temporary change would "demonstrate improved access and equity"."The agreement, which would see both trusts working together with a shared rota, follows input from clinicians and managers from TSD, Royal Devon, NHS Devon and Getting It Right First Time (GIRFT)," it added.
Eight-week trial
Darling said the proposal needed to be tested "a lot more"."I will not compromise on patient care in South Devon," he said.TSD said the full terms and conditions of the test of change were yet to be finalised and the project would not proceed until a rigorous review had taken place. It added: "However, executives at TSD, Royal Devon and NHS Devon, along with GIRFT leaders, have collectively approved the overarching approach, and the plan is to work towards a start date of 17 March for an eight-week period."Once the pilot has concluded, a full evaluation, including clinical outcomes and experiences of patients, will be externally commissioned to ensure the learning is captured thoroughly and presented back to all cardiology teams and executive colleagues for review."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
29-05-2025
- The Guardian
Second Lib Dem MP withdraws support for England and Wales assisted dying bill
A second Liberal Democrat MP has said they have changed their mind over the assisted dying bill and will vote against it at the next Commons stage, in another sign of a wider, if so far slight, ebbing away of support for the measure. In an email to constituents, Brian Mathew, the Melksham and Devizes MP, said that while he had backed the bill at its second reading vote, in April, scrutiny of the plans had left 'several concerns I feel have been inadequately answered'. His announcement follows comments last week by Steve Darling, the Torbay MP who is also the Lib Democrat work and pensions spokesperson. Darling said that while he had backed the bill in April he was now 'marginally against' it, but had not yet decided whether he would vote against it or abstain. About eight other MPs who either supported the private member's bill, led by Labour MP Kim Leadbeater, at its second reading or did not vote have said they will now oppose it. However, at least two who abstained in April are now supporters, while the Runcorn and Helsby byelection earlier in May resulted in a Labour MP who opposed the plan replaced by a Reform UK one who backs it. Given the second reading of the bill was passed with a majority of 55, the numbers thus far indicate it should also get through the third reading, scheduled for 20 June. A week before, on 13 June, MPs will debate amendments to the bill for a second day. The first day of debates on amendments drawn up during a lengthy committee stage resulted in some changes being agreed, including an opt-out for all healthcare workers from being involved in assisted dying, extending the exemption from just doctors. That debate also featured angry complaints from some MPs opposed to assisted dying after the prominent campaigner Esther Rantzen argued many in their camp were fighting against the changes to the law because of secret religious views. In his message to constituents, Mathew said he had heard 'eloquent and challenging viewpoints' from all sides, and he changed his stance over the bill following the recent weeks of debates. 'I share the concerns of many constituents that individuals facing terminal illness will take the decision based on concerns that they have become a burden upon their family,' he wrote. 'This is a serious concern for me; I worry that in someone's final days, this question will loom heavy when it does not need to.' This was all the more the case, Mathew said, when the palliative care system as it stood was so bad. Speaking ahead of the first day of debates about amendments, Leadbeater warned that if MPs voted down her bill at third reading then 'the conversation ends' on the subject, with dreadful consequences for many terminally ill people. She dismissed the idea that if the bill was defeated, the subject could return as government legislation or a royal commission, noting the long gap between the last time assisted dying was debated in the Commons, in 2015, and her efforts. 'What worries me is, if the bill doesn't pass, the conversation ends, and that would be really dreadful for so many people, for so many reasons,' she said.
BBC News
28-05-2025
- BBC News
Devon heart attack care trial pulled to review feedback
A proposal to trial changes to heart attack services in part of Devon has been withdrawn to allow time to consider feedback on the Devon's Integrated Care Board (ICB) was due to discuss a "test and learn" process for out-of-hours services in Torbay and Exeter during a meeting on part of the move, the trial could have seen patients driven to hospital in Exeter rather than Torbay to help cut costs and release resources to cut treatment following concerns raised locally, NHS Devon said it had decided to delay the proposal so comments can be reviewed before an updated plan is presented to the ICB in July. 'Deeply concerning' A report which formed part of the trial from NHS Devon said it believed consolidating centres might "provide increased value with minimal and clinically acceptable impact on safety and quality".However, the idea was criticised by Liberal Democrat MPs Steve Darling and Caroline Voaden who both raised the issue in the House of MP Darling said the proposal put patients at risk of not receiving treatment fast enough while South Devon MP Voaden said it would put people in critical Torbay Conservative MP Kevin Foster also raised concerns with the trial, which he described as "deeply concerning". In a statement on Wednesday, NHS Devon said its chair and chief executive had decided to pull the plans from the board meeting off the back of "wide-ranging" comments from politicians, health professionals and patients."This will enable the feedback to be fully considered and allow time to reflect on whether such a process will lead to clarity on future commissioning arrangements to ensure the long-term sustainability of this important service," NHS Devon added its key priority was to commission "safe, reliable and sustainable" services for the future of healthcare in the Devon said: "We will engage with our clinicians and partners to design this and find the most effective solutions for the whole population of Devon."An updated proposal will be presented to the board in July, taking into account the valuable feedback received."
BBC News
08-05-2025
- BBC News
Devon MPs concerned over proposal to move coronary care
Two Devon MPs have raised fears about a proposal to move out-of-hours coronary care from Torbay to Exeter, believing the move could endanger comes after the NHS and the integrated care board (ICB) said it was considering stopping out-of-hours coronary care in Torbay and moving treatment to Exeter Devon MP Caroline Voaden said the move would "put people in critical danger" and called for a rethink, while Torbay MP Steve Darling said the proposal could put residents at "risk of tissue death".An NHS spokesperson said: "Our board of directors has not made any decision on this proposed test of change." 'Urge everyone to call 999' They added the NHS was "committed to working with our cardiology clinical leads" to "ensure their thoughts were captured" and shared with NHS Devon to help inform its spokesperson also said: "We continue to urge everyone to call 999 or visit our emergency department if they have a chest pain or a suspected heart attack."Mr Darling has pressed for an urgent meeting with the board to explain the rationale behind the potential change. In a letter to the board's chief executive following the debate, he said: "Your cardiologists have told us that for residents in Torbay, Dartmouth or elsewhere in South Devon their chances of full recovery from a heart attack could be severely impacted by the extra time needed to get to Exeter."In our view this does not provide equitable care for all – would you agree?"
