Letters to the Editor: Milburn, Fyfe and Mungo
Thank you Cr Jim O'Malley for applying common sense and supporting the inland port at Milburn rather than at Mosgiel. The Mayor, who obviously supports heavy trucks rolling through Mosgiel, must live in Dunedin city.
As a Mosgiel resident, I know we already have enough heavy trucks travelling along our roads, especially our main street. This street is heavily used by locals and visitors, motorists and pedestrians, including many students, elderly and disabled people.
The Milburn quadrant will enable trucks to travel straight off SH1 on to the privately funded site rather than on to city council and Land Transport Agency funded roads through our township.
Even with the so-called "Mosgiel by-pass", which the agency will not fund, the Mosgiel site makes no sense. Geography lesson
I don't have a view on the location of the inland port but, as a Dunedin lad now residing in Lower Hutt, I think Cr O'Malley needs to look at a map.
Comparing travel from Dunedin to Milburn with Wellington to Lower Hutt is stretching things by a large margin. Lower Hutt's CBD is only 15km from Wellington's, the same distance as Dunedin to Mosgiel. Milburn is 49km from the city centre. That distance from Wellington would take you to the foot of the Remutaka Hill at the head of the Hutt Valley, and some 14km beyond Upper Hutt's urban boundary.
Admittedly, peak travel times by road can be higher up north, but on the rare occasions that I go to Wellington at those times, it's a pleasant 20-minute train ride beside the harbour. Random thoughts
Re the inland port. History says there is no solid ground on the Taieri: Milburn is an area of solid ground. No matter how much time one allows to drive to Dunedin, there is always lorries, some with trailers carting heavy goods, and the odd very slow cars as well. Patience is always required.
This inevitably will worsen as now in the South so many pine forests have been planted. Congratulations to Calder Stewart for their common sense actions. Bypass needed
Has any thought at all gone into how transport is going to get to and from the proposed transport hub in Mosgiel?
Obviously now is the time to get a traffic bypass operating to relieve pressure on using SH87 through Mosgiel. We do not want this heavy traffic through our main shopping area. Pillocks and manure
Bravo to Dr Robert Hamlin on his recent letter, ( ODT 15.5.25) about Sir Ian Taylor's use of the word pillock. The only time I use Kate Shepherd $10 note is to pay for bags of horse manure at our local horse stables. No disrespect meant. Fyfe praised
What a wonderful tribute to Jim Fyfe in today's Weekend Mix (17.5.25). It is truly outstanding. One has to ask, though, why he is retiring at the age of 59 when his work in advocacy for the wildlife of the Otago coast is so important both to the region and to the survival of endangered species?
I wish him all the very best in his future endeavours.
It was wonderful to see such good local reporting with the recent article on "Mungo's Cottage" ( ODT 17.5.25).
I recall standing in that lounge, looking out the window, cold, wet, and rescued. Without that sweeping view of the harbour, the Lewis family may not have noticed a scrappy blonde 11-year-old with one oar and no lifejacket drifting down the harbour in a small dinghy one evening. Down or out, whichever the correct nautical term, it was towards the ocean. The outgoing tide was fast.
"No lifejacket" you say. Were you around in the '70s? We did have some heavy orange things on the small family yacht, moored at Carey's Bay. I think they were made of sand. Even the rats did not eat them.
The relevant point was only one oar. A mistake that.
A beautiful freckled teenage boy was sent out to rescue me while his grandad sat and watched. Could have been a great romance, had I not been an obviously wilful and stupid child, exceedingly young for such adventures and rather humiliated waiting for Dad to come and collect me.
Never found the oar. But thank you Lewis family, and bless you for making sure the cottage will continue to live on to do more good works.
Address Letters to the Editor to: Otago Daily Times, PO Box 517, 52-56 Lower Stuart St, Dunedin. Email: editor@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Letters to Editor: inquiry, 1080, airport
Today's letters to the Editor include discussion about the inquiry into the government response to the Covid-19 pandemic, 1080 drops by DOC, and an airport in Central Otago. It is reported that former ministers have refused to attend a Royal Commission of Inquiry hearing. (ODT 14.8.25) That is probably well advised, as we have seen the venom expressed by a few members of our society who sometimes have anonymously created a web of hatred and misleading theory over the actions of the Labour government trying to protect us from the effects of this new and unknown pandemic. Yes there were mistakes made, and some suffered the emotional loss of not being with their dearest as they died. Some found the mandates offensive, and some were concerned about loss of personal freedom. The hearing will give some more insight into the causes and effects of a worldwide pandemic such as this. The steps taken were, I believe, in good faith and given that this pandemic was a new and unknown viral variation, the government under advice, took the only steps it could. It is worthwhile reading the article "Analysing past pandemics to inform future responses" (ODT 13.8.25). This outlined just how quickly the Spanish Flu of 1918 spread; and remember, no commercial airlines. It was estimated that worldwide 50 million people died. New Zealand lost 9000 in six weeks. That is equivalent to 40,000 today. Preparedness and survival during the next pandemic will depend on readiness and mandates such as vaccines and movement control, so we should be grateful for the work that our epidemiologists are doing. You may be alive and angry, but please consider those who survived because of strong mitigation by our leaders who tried to do the right thing. David Blair Port Chalmers [Abridged — length. Editor.] Take care I have observed that for some time there has been a crashed car down the bank on one of the corners of Three Mile Hill. There is a temporary speed limit of 30kmh on a section of the corners which has now become semi-permanent, with the recommended speed signs being replaced by circular 30 signs. The question arises as to why the crashed car has not been removed? On the subject of the temporary speed restriction, I have endeavoured to reduce my normal speed and stick to the limit. This has inevitably caused some impatient motorists to tailgate and on one occasion, the person passed me on a blind corner with another car coming the other way. My message is to drive with care over Three Mile Hill, especially in winter. John Batt Wakari Surcharge woes This government is not spending wisely, as they claim. Telling thousands of retailers that they are not allowed to add a surcharge for credit and contactless etc payments will result in employing lots of people to administer/prosecute those that don't comply which is wasteful. By telling banks that they can't charge retailers extra for that service when there are very few of them to check up on is much better. Banks make huge profits: they can carry that extra cost. Retailers that are struggling won't have to increase their costs to cover what the banks are charging for that service, thus not increasing the pressure on the cost of living. What is the government afraid of? Robert Morey Dunedin Centenary North Otago Rural Women New Zealand will be celebrating the centenary of the founding of the organisation with a luncheon at the Brydone Hotel on August 29. Guest speaker will be ODT business and rural editor Sally Rae. Registration of interest from current and former members: Judy Kingan jaydeekgn@ The reason why use of 'super toxin' opposed RE the ODT article "Doc claims predators bigger threat than 1080" (9.8.25). Having monitored several 1080 poison drops, one in particular defies all the robust science I have read and what I have witnessed. In 2002 Ecological Networks carried out, at the request of Doc, a study on the effects of 1080 poison on tomtits in the Waianakarua Scenic Reserve. Three days after the drop I and a few others had a casual walk through the poisoned area and picked up 16 dead tomtits along with dead brown creeper, a grey warbler and blackbirds. More decomposed bird carcasses were found in later months. The only dead predators found were half a dozen possums: no rats, cats, mice, ferrets, stoats, hedgehogs or weasels but plenty of dead deer and birds. All tomtits were offered to the Doc for autopsy: they declined saying 'we only have funding for one autopsy a year'. Sometime later I was invited along with other interested parties to a Maf biosecurity meeting in Christchurch to discuss a pest management strategy in Christchurch at which Doc didn't turn up. I took to the meeting a map of all the grid-referenced dead birds found in the Waianakarua Scenic Reserve to show a senior Landcare scientist in attendance and asked him to extrapolate the total bird deaths in the 4000ha reserve. He said he had heard of that operation; he came up with a figure that astounded me — 10,000. Is it any wonder I and many others continually oppose the use of this poison known as a super toxin? Lewis Hore Oamaru Plot loss It seems Dunedin City Council has more interest in creating playgrounds in George St than in creating essential parking or drop-off areas for hospital staff. Have we not lost the plot here? Graham Kitchin Oamaru Common sense hoped for in airport debate There has been quite a lot of plotting to build a new international airport somewhere in Central Otago. Christchurch City Holdings seem hell-bent on a new airport at Tarras. But when you land there you would require a bus to Queenstown which would take 90 minutes or more. Not acceptable. It is my contention that these plans are seriously flawed. Firstly the government, I'm sure, would possibly like fewer airports in the South Island not more. I doubt if it would support this pie-in-the-sky plan. Secondly it would seem to me to be far more practical to expand the Dunedin airport, particularly internationally, and then arrange domestic flights to Wanaka, Queenstown or anywhere. If you fly into San Francisco and want to go inland this is achieved with a domestic service rather than building a new international airport inland. I hope common sense prevails. Andrew Burton Lowburn Letters changes The Otago Daily Times welcomes letters. They are a vital part of the newspaper, and an important forum for readers to express their views. To make it easier for us to receive your letters we have created a new email address — letters@ — for you to write to us at. The old system, whereby letters were sent to an "editor" address, meant that letters were being missed due to the sheer volume of emails received. Letters will receive an automatic reply to say that the ODT has received your submission and that it is under consideration. Letters longer than 250 words may require abridgement; in some cases they will be rejected because they are too long. Our letters rules are at the bottom of the page. Rest assured, all letters sent to the ODT are read. However, we will seldom enter into discussion about selection or editing. We look forward to receiving your letters at letters@ — Editor
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
O'Malley would have put hearing outcome at risk: lawyers
Jim O'Malley. PHOTO: ODT FILES The Dunedin City Council would have been vulnerable to a High Court challenge if Cr Jim O'Malley had not recused himself from a hearing about a cycleway, its lawyers concluded. Cr O'Malley had made a series of comments that were critical of businessmen who fought the potential loss of carparks in the Albany St Connection project and this led to questions about whether he could consider consultation feedback with an open mind. The council asked law firm Anderson Lloyd for its advice after property owner Greg Paterson took issue with Cr O'Malley's involvement in the hearing. The councillor accepted the law firm's recommendation he recuse himself and Cr O'Malley then went further and quit altogether as hearings committee chairman. Anderson Lloyd said if Cr O'Malley had chosen to stay involved on the Albany St matter, this would have created a moderate level of legal risk a challenge to the High Court about the council's process would have been successful. "This means such a claim should be expected to succeed, resulting in council's decision-making process being found to be invalid." The Albany St project has been a stop-start affair, which has been hampered by funding uncertainty and criticism about inadequate consultation. In the end, nine carparks were added back in and an additional round of consultation was run about limited aspects of the project. Yesterday's hearing went ahead but with Cr O'Malley not taking part there was little decision-making headway, as the two other panel members, deputy mayor Cherry Lucas and Cr Mandy Mayhem, were split about what to recommend to the council. Anderson Lloyd's assessment was Cr O'Malley had made repeated public statements indicating he was frustrated with where the process had landed. His comments "strongly indicate that he is unlikely to alter the view he formed when making his first decision on the project and gives the clear impression he is not prepared to fairly consider feedback from consultation from those who seek further carparks on Albany St".
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Govt ‘asking a lot' of councils
Steve Walker. PHOTO: ODT FILES At least two Dunedin councillors are not impressed the government is looking to load more costs on to councils through civil defence reforms. Implementing new requirements, updating emergency management plans and engaging with iwi Māori and communities disproportionately affected by disasters are expected to have a four-year cost of about $82.8million. Local Government New Zealand said the government planned to get councils to cover the bill. Cr Steve Walker was one person to observe this was "yet another example in the continuing trend of loading more costs and responsibilities on to councils and expecting ratepayers to pick up the tab". Cr Mandy Mayhem has often been part of community responses north of Dunedin, such as providing food when motorists are stranded. "We've got good people here," she said. "I think the government is asking a lot." Mandy Mayhem. PHOTO: SUPPLIED Cr Mayhem suggested it was unfair to saddle councils with extra costs that would have to be covered by increasing rates. "The government has to stop punishing councils." A Cabinet paper said proposed changes should make the emergency management system stronger by clarifying roles and obligations. In particular, there would be clarity about who was in control during emergencies and accountability at the local level, the paper said. Objectives included enabling a higher minimum standard of emergency management, minimising disruption to essential services and strengthening the participation of communities and iwi Māori in emergency management. Local Government New Zealand chief executive Susan Freeman-Greene said imposition of compliance requirements would come with no additional funding. Councils would have to increase rates to cover the extra costs, she said. "Like the government, councils want to keep rates down," Ms Freeman-Greene said. "But rates are the only way they can cover these kinds of costs imposed by central government." The government intends to introduce and pass the Emergency Management Bill during this term of Parliament.
