Son of Scottish helicopter crash victim still seeking answers after visiting site
The son of a victim of the RAF 1994 Chinook helicopter crash is calling on the Prime Minister to intervene and allow a public inquiry after visiting the site of the disaster.
RAF Chinook ZD576 was carrying 25 British intelligence personnel from RAF Aldergrove in Northern Ireland to a conference at Fort George near Inverness when it crashed in foggy weather on June 2 1994 on the Mull of Kintyre in Scotland. All 25 passengers - made up of personnel from MI5, the Royal Ulster Constabulary and the British Army - were killed, along with the helicopter's four crew members.
Joel Hornby, whose father, Major Anthony Hornby, was one of the victims, visited a memorial cairn at the crash site on Saturday and again on Sunday. He and other families have said they will press on with seeking a judicial review after the Ministry of Defence (MoD) dismissed their demands for a judge-led public inquiry into the incident, and have written to Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer asking him to intervene.
Mr Hornby, who was seven when his father died, visited the site with his one-year-old son and laid a wreath at the cairn along with a note which read "Dad, we are still fighting for you". Speaking afterwards Mr Hornby, who lives in Berlin in Germany, said: "We, the families of those lost, have still been denied answers over 30 years on.
Sign up for Edinburgh Live newsletters for more headlines straight to your inbox
"The MoD has rejected our request for a full judge-led public inquiry, and furthermore, has sealed documents relating to the crash for 100 years. We are requesting that the Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer live up to his promises on duty of candour and overrule the MoD's decision."
He has also urged people to sign a change.org petition calling on the Prime Minister to overturn the MoD decision and release the documents. Following the crash, the Chinook's pilots, Flight Lieutenants Richard Cook and Jonathan Tapper, were accused of gross negligence, but this verdict was overturned by the UK Government 17 years later following a campaign by the families.
A subsequent review by Lord Philip set out "numerous concerns" raised by those who worked on the Chinooks, with the MoD's testing centre at Boscombe Down in Wiltshire declaring the Chinook Mk2 helicopters "unairworthy" prior to the crash. In a statement after the calls made by the families on Friday an MoD spokesperson said: "The Mull of Kintyre crash was a tragic accident, and our thoughts and sympathies remain with the families, friends and colleagues of all those who died.
Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
"We understand that the lack of certainty about the cause of the crash has added to the distress of the families. We provided a detailed and considered response to the pre-action protocol letter stating the reasons why we cannot accept the demand for establishing a new public inquiry.
"It's unlikely that a public inquiry would identify any new evidence or reach new conclusions on the basis of existing evidence. The accident has already been the subject of six inquiries and investigations, including an independent judge-led review."
The MoD did not wish to make further comment on Sunday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
41 minutes ago
- Times
Tulip Siddiq ‘used influence over her aunt to acquire land for family'
Tulip Siddiq used her 'special power' as an MP in Britain to exert influence over her aunt, the former prime minister of Bangladesh, to acquire state-owned land, an anti-corruption trial was told. Prosecutors in Bangladesh allege that Siddiq applied pressure on Sheikh Hasina, who was deposed as the country's leader last year, to secure plots of land for her mother, brother, and sister. Siddiq, 42, resigned as the anti-corruption minister in Sir Keir Starmer's government in January over 'reputational risks' from her family's links with the Hasina regime. The MP is not attending the trial at Dhaka Special Judge Court 4, which formally began on Wednesday, and has described the case against her as 'persecution and a farce'. • Joy and trepidation in Bangladesh a year since ousting of Sheikh Hasina She claims to have become 'collateral damage' in a power struggle between her aunt and Muhammad Yunus, Hasina's replacement as leader in the south Asian country. Officials from the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) told the court that Siddiq played a central role in acquiring plots of land for relatives in the diplomatic zone of Dhaka in 2022. The court was told that Siddiq had learnt that her aunt had 'used her power' to acquire plots in the Purbachal New Town Project, a long-running land development programme operated by a government agency, Rajuk. Siddiq is then said to have 'simultaneously used her special power to exert pressure and influence on her aunt', according to Afnan Jannat Keya, an ACC assistant director. He said that this led to plots being allotted to her mother, Sheikh Rehana; her sister, Azmina Siddique; and her brother, Radwan Mujib Siddiq. • Tulip Siddiq's flyers found in palace of deposed Bangladesh leader Siddiq is also accused of seeking to influence the secretary of the Ministry of Housing and Public Works and other officials on the instructions of her aunt to acquire a plot for her sister. 'In view of this, the Ministry of Housing and Public Works issued a letter to the chairman of Rajuk to proceed with the allotment,' the court heard. Siddiq is alleged to own a flat in the upmarket Gulshan neighbourhood of the capital, Dhaka, which investigators say should have ruled her out from availing of the award of land under the scheme. The ACC is examining claims that Hasina and her family misappropriated billions of pounds of state money during her 15-year reign. Hasina, who is living in exile in India after fleeing during mass protests, faces trial in absentia for crimes against humanity during her time in power. Judge Muhammad Rabiul Alam heard the opening statements from three ACC officials relating to three cases on Wednesday. SM Rashidul Hasan, another ACC assistant director, named Tulip Siddiq among 16 people who are accused of offences, including her brother and aunt. The judge set aside August 28 for the next stage in the trial, when prosecution witnesses and evidence will be presented. In a statement published on Monday, Siddiq claimed that she had yet to receive a summons, adding: 'No fair legal process should begin with a media headline. Unfortunately that's what I have been handed out. No engagement. No evidence. Not even a response to legitimate inquiries from my lawyers.' In an interview in The Guardian, she said: 'I'm yet to see a summons … I'm supposedly days away from a showcase trial in a foreign country, and I still don't know what the charges are. 'I feel a bit like I'm trapped in this Kafkaesque nightmare where I've been put on trial and I genuinely haven't found out what the allegations are.' The ACC's prosecutor, Muhammad Tariqul Islam, said Bangladeshi authorities had served notices on each of the accused, instructing them to appear before the court as the trial began. 'If any of them want to contest the allegations, they must appear before the court,' he told reporters outside the courtroom. None of those accused has engaged counsel to represent them at the trial. Prosecutors have separately disputed Siddiq's claims not to have Bangladeshi citizenship, claiming they have unearthed her Bangladeshi passport and identity card. In 2017 she said: 'I am not Bangladeshi.' Asked about her nationality, Mohammad Sultan Mahmud, another ACC prosecutor, said all necessary documents relating to Siddiq and her family would be produced during the trial. Siddiq's lawyers, from Stephenson Harwood, denied that such documents existed and said that she has not had a Bangladeshi passport since she was a child. The MP for Hampstead & Highgate has always denied wrongdoing and accused the Bangladeshi authorities of a 'targeted and baseless' campaign against her. 'I'm collateral damage, because of this feud between Muhammad Yunus and my aunt,' she said. 'These are wider forces that I'm battling against.' She resigned from the Labour frontbench after referring herself to the ministerial standards adviser after reports that she had lived in London properties with links to Hasina. Siddiq had initially claimed that a £650,000 flat in King's Cross in London was given to her by her parents. It later transpired, however, that the flat had been paid for by a developer and associate of figures in the Awami League, Hasina's party.
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
Bangladeshi anti-corruption officials give evidence against UK MP Tulip Siddiq
Ms Siddiq, who is Ms Hasina's niece, resigned from her post in Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer's Government in January following reports that she lived in London properties linked to her aunt and was named in an anti-corruption investigation in Bangladesh. The Labour MP represents the north London district of Hampstead and Highgate and served as economic secretary to the Treasury – the minister responsible for tackling financial corruption. The trial at the Dhaka Special Judge Court-4 formally began on Wednesday (Mahmud Hossain Opu/AP) She is being tried together with her mother, Sheikh Rehana, brother Radwan Mujib and sister Azmina. Ms Siddiq has been charged with facilitating their receipt of state land in a township project near the capital Dhaka. They are out of the country and being tried in absentia. Ms Siddiq's lawyers have called the charges baseless and politically motivated. Muhammad Tariqul Islam, a public prosecutor, disputed a claim by Ms Siddiq that she is not Bangladeshi, saying the anti-corruption watchdog through investigations found that she is a citizen. The prosecutor said if Ms Siddiq is convicted she could be sentenced to three to 10 years in prison. Public prosecutor Muhammad Tariqul Islam, wearing a tie, spoke to reporters after the hearing (Mahmud Hossain Opu/AP) Ms Siddiq in an interview with the British newspaper The Guardian recently referred to Bangladesh as 'a foreign country' and called the charges against her 'completely absurd'. She asserted to The Guardian she was 'collateral damage' in the longstanding feud between her aunt and Bangladesh's interim leader Muhammad Yunus. Ms Hasina had a frosty relation with Mr Yunus, and during her rule Mr Yunus faced a number of cases including for graft allegations. Courts overturned those charges before he took over as interim leader days after Ms Hasina's ousting last year in a student-led uprising. Separately, the anti-corruption investigation has alleged that Ms Siddiq's family was involved in brokering a 2013 deal with Russia for a nuclear power plant in Bangladesh in which large sums of money were said to have been embezzled.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Gers figures give anti-indy press something to write about
IT'S Gersmas Day, when British nationalist Santa puts supporters of Scottish independence on the naughty list and the anti-independence Scottish media, which is to say almost all of it, crows triumphantly about how much of an economic basket case Scotland supposedly is. That's thanks to the annual release of the Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland (GERS) figures, which purport to show Scots the extent to which they depend on the largesse of the UK Treasury. Apparently, it's a testament to the success of Westminster rule that a literal power house like Scotland is incapable of supporting itself financially. It's an odd definition of success, but with the GERS figures we long ago passed through the mirror into the topsy turvy world of Westminster Wonderland. Gersmas Day has been going on so long that it has developed its own rituals. The Scottish Secretary makes an announcement about the cash amount which each individual Scottish person allegedly benefits from Westminster's munificence. This year it's £2669. Oh goodie! Can I get mine in National Lottery scratch cards please? You've got a much better chance of financially benefiting from a lottery ticket than you do from the Westminster government. Meanwhile anti-independence campaigners who view GERS as Holy Writ denounce heretical "GERS deniers" who have their own Gersmas ritual, which is the temerity to point out that the GERS figures tell us absolutely nothing about the finances of an independent Scotland. As financial services consultancy Deloitte noted in 2017: "Commentators suggested that, under these conditions [the global slump in oil prices that year], Scotland would struggle to operate as an independent country. However, GERS data is produced for Scotland as part of the UK - it does not model scenarios for an independent Scotland in which the Scottish government would be enabled to make its own fiscal choices." Independence supporters also point out every Gersmas that this annual charade was instituted in 1992 by then Conservative Scottish Secretary Ian Lang as a tool to use against his political opponents who were arguing in favour of greater Scottish self-government. 33 years later the figures are still performing the same job. In a leaked memo written at the time Lang wrote: "I judge that [GERS] is just what is needed at present in our campaign to maintain the initiative and undermine the other parties. This initiative could score against all of them." The campaign to which Lang was referring was the campaign for the creation of a Scottish Parliament which the Conservatives vigorously opposed, mounting a scaremongering campaign which alleged that the creation of a Scottish Parliament would lead to massive tax rises and the decimation of Scottish public services. Decades later, the Westminster parties are still deploying scare stories from the same playbook to argue against greater Scottish self-government. The reality is that the GERS figures have long since ceased to make a credible or meaningful contribution to Scotland's constitutional debate, opponents of independence still view them with veneration as though they were chiseled on tablets of stone by God himself and handed down to his faithful on Mount Sinai, while supporters of independence see them as discredited political tools which only distort and mislead the debate, but we continue to go through this annual farce every August as it is politically useful to the Westminster government. It also supplies the anti-independence Scottish press with something to write about during the silly season when there's otherwise a dearth of political news. Vacay Vance scheduled to infest Scotland Vacay Vance, the American Vice President who is now on his sixth holiday since taking office in January, including a trip to Ohio during which Vance had the Army Corps of Engineers raise the level of the Little Miami River in order to improve his kayaking experience, is currently in the UK, staying at a luxury mansion in the Cotswolds, and is reportedly scheduled to infest Scotland later this week. All that performative cruelty and milking the public purse is exhausting and the poor dear needs a break. Vance is only following the example of his boss Trump, who has spent approximately a quarter of his time since taking office in January on golf trips. While Vance takes one holiday after another paid for by the American taxpayer and inflicts costs on Scottish taxpayers too, who have to foot the not inconsiderable bill for his police protection, his Republican party colleagues in Missouri have just voted to strip any rights to sick leave from workers in the state. The US is the only OECD country without a nationally mandated minimum standard for paid employee leave. On average US employees get just ten days annual leave, many get less than this and millions have no paid leave at all. As an Ayrshire resident I am starting to suspect that the county is cursed. We were inflicted with Donald Trump and his spawn at the end of July, and now Ayrshire is due to become the latest stop off in Vance's perma-holiday with Vance and his entourage staying at the luxury Carnell Estates near Hurlford, which played host to Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie when Pitt was in Glasgow filming the zombie horror movie World War Z in 2013. Vance is also expected to pay a visit to Trump's golf estate at Turnberry. The visit has once again highlighted Vance's lies about Scotland earlier this year when he falsely claimed that Scotland's abortion buffer zone laws criminalise Christians praying privately in their own homes. Today, the annual US State Department assessment, which analyses human rights conditions worldwide, also hit out at what it described as 'serious restrictions' on freedom of expression in the UK. The report specifically said laws limiting speech around abortion clinics, pointing to 'safe access zones' curbed expression, including silent protests and prayer. Scottish Greens MSP Gillian Mackay – who spearheaded the abortion buffer zones legislation said: 'JD Vance has made a career of spreading misinformation and sowing mistrust in order to gain power and influence. The Vice President's absurd lies haven't just been about eating cats and dogs in Ohio; he has lied about Scotland. 'Earlier this year, JD Vance made false claims on an international stage about Scotland's buffer zones law, which prevents harassment and intimidation of patients outside abortion clinics, a bill proudly passed by the Scottish Greens.' She added: 'Now, whilst his extremist government is attacking LGBTQ+ and women's rights, illegally arresting innocent civilians on the streets, arming Israel's genocide in Gaza and wrecking our climate, he thinks that he can peacefully run away from it all to enjoy a holiday in our country. 'Let's set this clear: the toxic misinformation of JD Vance is a threat to democracy and freedom around the world.'
