Paso Robles, councilman clash over who's to blame for Tribune's records lawsuit
But there were two things everyone agreed on: The Tribune had a right to the records, and the issues should be resolved in a timely manner.
The Tribune sued both Bausch and the city for violating the Public Records Act in March after the city claimed Bausch refused to comply with state law unless ordered to do so by a court.
Bausch, for his part, denies that allegation.
He held the public records delay was the city's fault, claiming attorneys hired to represent him in former city manager Ty Lewis' $2.275 million claim had told him to not respond to requests. He also claimed the city wrongly denied him legal representation, and he demanded the city provide him an attorney.
As Bausch searches for an attorney to represent him — it was a 'probably a mistake' to represent himself, he said — he is also claiming to be searching for public records.
In an April 2 court filing, Bausch claimed the search — which he has allegedly been doing since January despite having requests dating back to October — will take him six months to complete. He also asked to have himself dismissed from the lawsuit and for The Tribune's outstanding records requests to be dismissed, according to the filing.
Both the city and Bausch are expected to have their response to The Tribune's lawsuit filed by April 21. The city is expected to provide a log of any records that are exempt from disclosure and why by the next hearing on April 30.
Bausch spoke about his public records delays publicly and in depth for the first time Wednesday, representing himself during the first hearing in The Tribune's legal case.
The councilmember claimed he is currently conducting around 700 individual searches on his personal devices for the delayed records — an effort he said has been ongoing since before city attorney Elizabeth Hull sent her February email to The Tribune calling him out for refusing to comply with public records law.
Bausch did not specify when he started searching for the records and refused to clarify this detail with a Tribune reporter following the hearing.
Bausch did acknowledge to the court it would be in his 'best interest' to turn over the responsive records. He also denied Hull's claim that he wouldn't turn over records without an order from a judge.
'That quote is, in fact, a lie,' he said.
Instead, administrative hangups, questions and concerns have prevented Bausch from turning over documents so far, he said.
Tribune sues city of Paso Robles, Chris Bausch after councilman refuses to release records
The councilman claimed in court that he attempted to upload a batch of responsive emails to the city's server on Jan. 24. However, the files were corrupted in the process, Bausch said, forcing him to start his search anew.
'To be sure, that conversion failure is probably on me,' Bausch added.
Bausch said Jan. 24 was also the date he submitted the recording of a meeting among himself, Paso Robles Mayor John Hamon and former city manager Ty Lewis at Angela's Pastries — a public record The Tribune first requested in October.
That request was at first denied by the city but later reopened after a clip of the recording was leaked online by Cal Coast News reporter Karen Velie in December. Velie posted what she said was a full version of the recording in January. The full recording was provided to The Tribune by the city on Feb. 7 — just shy of two months after Velie initially released the partial recording.
According to Bausch's case management statement, which he filed in court, he did not release the recording earlier 'on advice of counsel.'
'More questions came in from across typical media contacts but curiously, only the SLO Tribune sent the formal CPRA requests, eight all together to me, seeking to expose some sort of conspiracy to the employee who had made the hostile work environment claim,' he said in the filing.
Bausch has refused to speak to The Tribune on the record since October, despite multiple attempts.
In a Jan. 7 email to Hull and attorney Richard Egger, which is typically attorney-client privileged but was attached to the court filing, Bausch wrote, 'I recorded the March 8, 2024, meeting to protect myself against a perceived risk that my discussion might later be misrepresented. I did not record the meeting with the intent to create a city record subject to public disclosure.'
In addition to the technological difficulties he faced, Bausch also aired to the court a laundry list of concerns about the city's handling of his search for records and recent refusal to provide him with legal representation.
According to Bausch, he has been represented by three different lawyers since Lewis first filed his claim against the city.
Bausch said his first attorney, appointed through the city's insurer, clashed with city attorney Hull after Bausch directed Hull to communicate with the attorney about public records requests, rather than the councilman himself. The second attorney also had to be replaced, Bausch said.
In the process of searching for records responsive to The Tribune's requests, Bausch said he was counseled not to release records that could potentially trigger a defamation lawsuit, presumably by Lewis, who alleged in his claim that Bausch harassed and spread rumors about him. That advice was given after the settlement agreement had been reached between the two, Bausch said.
And now, after Bausch's alleged refusal to comply with public records law, the city has refused to supply him with legal counsel, he said.
Exclusive: Paso Robles councilman made threats, spread rumors, school board colleagues say
A March 20 email attached to Bausch's statement illuminated a backroom conversation at City Hall, confirming that detail.
The email, sent from Hull to Bausch, claimed the Paso Robles City Council discussed The Tribune's lawsuit in closed session March 19, the same day The Tribune served Bausch with the lawsuit. During that meeting, the subject of Bausch's legal counsel was brought up, Hull wrote.
Bausch was invited to participate in that conversation, Hull wrote, but he left the meeting before it was finished.
Ultimately, the city decided not to provide Bausch's legal representation due to his 'refusal to cooperate' with the city's public records process.
Bausch took issue with that decision in court Wednesday.
'We need to come to some sort of an agreement for the city to correct course in, what I believe, is a serious error in the city's judgment in convincing City Council to deny legal representation to me on the basis of me not providing a search of my devices,' Bausch told Judge Kelley. 'If they use that as a basis for not providing counsel to me, they were in error, and they need to pay for counsel.'
Judge Michael C. Kelley replied: 'That dispute is not before me today, and I'm not even sure it would be before me in any form or shape in this case.'
Bausch also asked the court whether the city has the right to review his public records or if he should hand the records over straight to the judge or The Tribune, since the city is no longer representing him.
'I think since I have been cut loose from the city of Paso Robles, I believe BBK has given up their right to accept these documents,' Bausch said.
BBK is the law firm that represents the city.
BBK attorney Egger, who appeared in court virtually representing Paso Robles, emphasized the city's need to examine the documents prior to their release by Bausch.
In its review process, the city would be looking for potential redactions or withholdings, including information falling under attorney-client privilege, work product privilege or other legal exemptions for public records.
Kelley agreed with the city.
Kelley told Bausch the city does have a right to review the records for redactions and exemptions prior to their release, even though the city is no longer representing him.
Kelley also clarified that the city has a right to provide records to The Tribune on a rolling basis, but should not require Bausch to sign an affidavit until he has fully completed his searches.
In addition to not representing Bausch in court, it appears the city may also file a cross-complaint against him.
In Wednesday's hearing, Egger told Kelley the city was considering a cross-complaint, but did not specify what that would entail.
But Bausch clarified it in his own statement, saying Egger 'threatened to file a cross-complaint against me.'
According to Bausch's court filing, Egger told the councilman the city was going to file a cross-complaint against him because Bausch was 'a threat to the city.'
Bausch claimed in his filing that Egger was unable to articulate how or why he was a threat, chalking the issue up to the repeal of the city's controversial paid parking program.
'Perhaps there are lingering sour grapes over my request that BBK reimburse the City $1,000,000 in legal billing for admittedly poor advice regarding a failed parking program,' Bausch wrote in the filing. 'I find it sad that their parking vendetta is turning this ugly.'
Bausch claimed Egger 'is apparently unwilling to seek remedies that would likely save Paso Robles taxpayers quite a bit of money,' including mediation, settlement conferences or arbitration.
'I have requested that the court either transfer jurisdiction of this case to federal court or dismiss all remaining public record requests as I truly believe there was not any level of animosity between the employee and myself that has been imagined,' Bausch wrote in the filing.
The federal courts do not have jurisdiction over state public records act requests.
'If the court in its wisdom and discretion believes that I should continue to search through my personal devices, I will respect the court's decision, but I ask the court to realize that I volunteer to be a city councilperson. I can't control who sends me an email or text,' Bausch wrote.
Bausch claimed 'he is not the enemy here' and that the independent investigation into Lewis' claim found Lewis' allegations 'never existed,' calling Lewis' allegations 'the fantasy that might have led to a large payout (that) never materialized.'
The Tribune requested all investigative documents and reports regarding Lewis' claim on Dec. 10. The city denied the Tribune's request on Dec. 17, claiming the records were exempt from disclosure under personnel privacy and attorney-client privileges.
In the final statement of his filing, Bausch parroted a false claim about The Tribune that has been wielded by other critics in recent months.
'I don't think I should have to pay for McClatchy's fancy inhouse attorney,' he wrote. 'I know they are allegedly going out of business and I'm sure sorry about that, but I didn't cause that to happen. I don't want to donate to the cause.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
10 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Daywatch: A private school loophole
Good morning, Chicago. The Language and Music School in Oak Park advertises 'a year round 'homeschool in school' style of education' where children can learn at their own pace, using a curriculum tailored to their needs and interests — a Spanish-immersive alternative to the perceived rigidness of the public school system. And it all takes place in a Hogwarts-like mansion. Finding the school, said one mother, felt like 'magic.' But she and a few other families have since come to question whether the state is doing enough to keep watch over how this kind of school is run. Although Illinois law allows nonprofit private schools to register voluntarily with the state or seek state recognition, it bars for-profit operations such as The Language and Music School from doing either. In written responses to Tribune questions, conveyed through its attorney, the school said it does not shun government oversight and would immediately seek recognition from the state if the law were changed to allow it to do so. Read the full story from the Tribune's Jonathan Bullington and Gregory Royal Pratt. Here are the top stories you need to know to start your day, including the race to lower SNAP costs, Cardinal Blase Cupich celebrates 50 years with the Catholic Church and how the South Side welcomed Savannah this weekend. Today's eNewspaper edition | Subscribe to more newsletters | Asking Eric | Horoscopes | Puzzles & Games | Today in History A little more than a month after President Donald Trump signed into law a sweeping Republican domestic package that expanded work requirements for SNAP benefits to previously exempt groups such as adults ages 55 to 64, the state and people receiving benefits are getting ready for a recalibration. Democratic Gov. JB Pritzker's administration is sprinting to figure out how to avoid a potential $700 million price tag by changing operations to achieve a level of payment accuracy that the vast majority of states currently do not meet. At the same time, Illinois also must handle the federally mandated work requirements on new groups that experts say could lead to people losing benefits. At a farm in the south suburbs, upbeat Arabic music swept across the land as more than a dozen Palestinian children — many with prosthetic limbs or in wheelchairs — and their families danced and moved to the music in the center of a raised platform. One of the children, Khalil Abu Shaban, traveled in a circle using his wheelchair and periodically sang into a microphone as the dozens who attended the Saturday celebration at Arab Chicago Farm in Frankfort excitedly clapped for him. As climate change and invasive species threaten the whitefish's reproductive patterns, experts say the species is at risk of disappearing entirely from Lake Michigan in the next few years. From salted whitefish exports that poured out of Chicago's harbor in the late 1800s, to whitefish dinners in northern Michigan and Wisconsin, to their integral role in some Anishinaabe creation stories, they've been a cultural and culinary cornerstone of the region for thousands of years. They're also a major economic engine for fisheries across the Great Lakes, which bring an estimated $5.1 billion to the region annually. After mounting pressure from advocates and elected officials, ICE granted Jose Gregorio Gonzalez a temporary humanitarian parole so that they could proceed with the transplant, an unexpected move at a time when the agency is ramping up enforcement. Unlike in past administrations, immigration experts say agents today have less discretion over individual cases and are under pressure to meet deportation quotas, leaving little room for compassion. Cardinal Blase Cupich celebrated the 50th anniversary of his ordination with a golden jubilee Mass on Saturday at Holy Name Cathedral in Chicago. Despite major challenges facing the global Catholic Church — from financial woes to ongoing fallout from the church sex abuse crisis — Cupich says his love for pastoring and service hasn't waned since his ordination five decades ago. Bally's Chicago announced Friday it has completed its $250 million initial public offering, adding 1,800 individual investors to the project, but falling short of its fundraising goals. Days after an incident at a bar in Wicker Park, the Chicago Police Department on Friday stripped the police powers of the officer who fatally shot Officer Krystal Rivera earlier this year. A department spokesperson confirmed that Officer Carlos Baker, who is on medical leave from the department, was stripped of his police powers Friday. A former public relations manager for the Chicago Blackhawks filed a discrimination lawsuit against the team last week, alleging he was wrongfully fired after sharing his experiences as a gay man in an article with Outsports, a site covering LGBTQ+ sports news. The Bears crushed the Bills, 38-0, in a nationally televised preseason game, one in which quarterback Josh Allen and the Bills' starters did not play. Still, coach Ben Johnson's new offense was on full display during the opening possession. The dancing, baseball-playing — sorry, Banana Ball-playing — team finished their first trip to Rate Field on Saturday with a second game in as many nights against the Firefighters. The weekend included trick plays, dancing in the heat and nonstop music from start till dawn. Tribune photojournalists captured moments from this year's Chicago Air and Water Show, the largest free show of its kind in the United States. Ten visually impaired models walked in the Beautiful Lives Fashion Show earlier this month at the CD Peacock Mansion in Oak Brook. The inaugural event celebrated the idea that everyone can enjoy clothing — even if they experience it in a different way than most. 'Good fashion feels like the textures that send tingling sensations through your fingers,' said Beautiful Lives Project co-founder Bryce Weiler, who has been blind since birth. 'Textures mean something.'
Chicago Tribune
12 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Letters: Corporations follow talent, not taxes
The Tribune's recent editorial about corporations leaving Chicago due to high taxation misses the mark when it comes to explaining company motives for locating in or leaving Chicago ('Brandon Johnson and friends think it's 'a privilege to do business in Chicago.' Wrong,' Aug. 7). Let's look at some of the examples: Boeing moved to Washington, D.C. to be closer to the Pentagon (its primary customer) and the Federal Aviation Administration (its regulator) as well as seeking engineering talent. Citadel leader Ken Griffin cited rising crime in the city as the primary reason for the company's departure. (Since the departure, this administration's investments in violence prevention, youth jobs and mental health programs have produced one of the lowest crime rates of major cities). Caterpillar (actually headquartered in Deerfield) was attracted to the luxury lifestyle in suburban Irving, Texas where 'a lot of celebrities live, and there are also a lot of gated communities that C-suite level executives find attractive.' In this same time period, Google greatly expanded its Chicago workforce, purchasing the Thompson Center, Kellogg moved a division to Chicago, and Abbott moved 450 jobs to Willis Towers. In all, 111 firms expanded or relocated to Chicago in 2022. So what brings, and keeps jobs in this city? Our people and our infrastructure. Quality of life that people feel and can afford. Things like reductions in crime when we invest in violence prevention, stability when residents are able to access affordable housing, improved well being through access to mental health care from city clinics, investments in small businesses that make our neighborhoods thriving. Being a world class talent hub. Having such a diverse array of colleges, universities and ongoing education that brings people into this city and invests in their growth. Building unrivaled logistics and infrastructure. This infrastructure makes Chicago a logistical powerhouse, critical for businesses that rely on supply chains and global connectivity. We can't do these things without this city investing in its people and its infrastructure. With groceries and rent prices through the roof, and the federal government folding in front of our eyes, everyday Chicagoans cannot afford an even higher cost of living from increased property taxes — the foregone conclusion without asking more from businesses. Taxing large corporations to support investments in quality of life for Chicagoans makes life better for you, me and the talent that businesses hope to Donald Trump named Heritage Foundation economist E.J. Antoni as head of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, replacing Erika McEntarfer, whose last jobs report was unfavorable to Trump and got her fired. The only surprising thing about this was the immediate panning of the appointment by a number of conservative economists on the basis that Antoni was not a competent economist, that he would be in over his head in this position. Interesting, but beside the point. Antoni was not appointed for his economic credentials. The real reason was noted by other — again, conservative — economists. For example, Stan Verger, a senior fellow at the conservative American Enterprise Institute stated that Antoni's work at Heritage has included errors that 'bias his findings in the same partisan direction'. Dave Hebert, an economist at the American Institute for Economic Research stated that 'I've been on several programs with him at this point and have been impressed by two things: his inability to understand basic economics and the speed with which he's gone MAGA.' Economist Justin Wolfers said that he is a '1,200%, 1,300%, maybe 1,400% in-the-tank Trumper, with few credentials beyond a long history of misrepresenting or misunderstanding basic economic statistics.' If Antoni is confirmed by the Senate, the analysis of him by conservative economists and the history of Trump appointees tells us that the next jobs report will show not only a marked improvement in August, and that the July report will be revised from negative to positive. That is the point of his nomination. Results seems Jed Hoyer is more concerned about the Cubs of 2032 than this year's ballclub. For those of us who remember the Cub's 1945 World Series appearance, and more importantly, the team's dramatic victory in the 2016 Series, maybe just maybe, we should remind Hoyer that there's nothing like the present to ring up a 2025 World Series championship. There's where his focus should be; otherwise he might not be around much longer to worry about op-ed ''Made in America' is alive, well and misunderstood' (Aug. 14) presented a good argument for entrepreneurship and the amount of patents that are issued in the United States. But, the notion that universities are responsible for the issuances of these patents is statistically true, but overlooks the number of ideas brought to life by the end users in the field. Not noted in this article are the advances made years ago in manufacturing by the workers on the line seeing better and more efficient ways to produce products. Relying on universities is fine; if you have ever assembled a product with instructions written by these university minds you may have a change of heart. Assembly instructions written by the users are more easily understood and straightforward as they are the ones using the product and are more familiar with it than a university mind. Products are made overseas because the labor rate is substantially lower than American labor and as Americans we want the best of everything but do not expect to pay high prices. Automobiles may be assembled in America but approximately 40% of the parts are made overseas. Nippon has purchased United States Steel with the promise of maintaining union jobs in the new facility. Reviewing history, the likelihood is the antiquated blast furnaces and systems in place will be demolished and replaced with modern technology involving robotics or they will simply be demolished to eliminate competition. With respect to universities, the costs have become prohibitively expensive and there are thousands of American kids who would love to go to school and contribute but unfortunately cannot afford the high cost. Coupled with a college education oftentimes not providing a large enough advantage in the job market, we are producing a generation who tread water and live in their parents' basements. As a kid growing up in the 1960s we always looked at the tag on clothing to make sure the item was made in America. It made a difference then because the manufacturing techniques in foreign countries produced an inferior product. Today? If we had to rely on 'made in America' we would have bare shelves in our closets and we would be wearing hand me downs that are 'made in America' of course. Along with the 'made in America' label was a strong sense of pride. Pride in workmanship. Pride of place. Pride in our schooling. Pride in government. As we are now scratching to remain competitive in a global economy, perhaps dismounting our high horse, rolling up our sleeves and getting down in the dirt and working will reinvigorate the pride we once had. Then we can focus on patents and making goods in America.
Chicago Tribune
a day ago
- Chicago Tribune
Video of Merrillville woman's arrest by Lake County Sheriff's Department shows excessive force before miscarriage, lawyer says
A Merrillville woman's lawyer said recently released bodycam footage backs up her accusations that Lake County Sheriff's deputies forcibly pulled her from a vehicle during an arrest despite knowing she was pregnant. Three months later, she had a miscarriage. I'm '(expletive) pregnant,' Shikeia Randolph, 31, yells just before two officers pull her from a red Chevrolet Trailblazer, according to video obtained by the Post-Tribune through a public records request. A federal lawsuit accusing the officers of excessive force was filed two months ago in the U.S. District Court in Hammond. It alleges that a 3:24 a.m. traffic stop on June 5, 2023 was 'pretextual' — for an issue with a license plate cover, then a school truancy warrant — and quickly spiraled out of control. The video from an officer's dashboard camera appears to show, as she is arrested, the two officers turn her on her stomach as one pins her down to handcuff her hands behind her back. Randolph previously told the Post-Tribune she had just stopped for milk at a 24-hour gas station in Gary near Ridge Road and Grant Street with her four kids in the vehicle. She was supposed to drop them off at her mother's house, then head to her early shift as a receptionist at the Gary Housing Authority. Officer Peter Hamady, who pulled her over, is named with the sheriff's department in the lawsuit. His lawyer Casey McCloskey declined comment. In a federal filing on Aug. 7, McCloskey formally denied the accusations against Hamady, saying in part that his actions were 'objectively reasonable' and protected by 'qualified immunity.' Some of Randolph's claims could fall outside of a two-year statute of limitations, he wrote. McCloskey argued because Randolph refused to get out of her SUV, she forced cops to go after her, according to court documents. She disputed this, in interviews with the Post-Tribune. On the way to booking, Randolph tells Hamady the truancy case in Merrillville Town Court was for taking her daughter repeatedly to school a little late when she was in pain from just having another baby, according to footage recorded inside Hamady's police car. He appears to soften. 'I didn't know they had warrants for that,' he said in the footage. In an interview, Matthew Custardo, Randolph's lawyer in the federal lawsuit, argued the use of force was unjustified, even if she was arguing with the cops. 'She was confused why she was being pulled over,' he said. 'She's scared. She has every reason to be a little concerned about what's going on. She's standing up for herself, certainly.' According to the nearly 40-minute bodycam video, police officers tell her to call someone to pick up the kids, so they don't have to call child protective services. Originally, Randolph said she thought it might have been a warrant for an old driving while suspended case. 'Call CPS for what?' she responds in the video. 'A warrant for a suspended license?' 'It's not for that,' Hamady tells her in the footage. After she asks again, he says it's for truancy. 'Listen, you have a warrant,' Hamady said in the video. 'You're lucky I don't have you cuffed out of the car right now. You wanna go that route?' In the video, she accuses Hamady of pulling out of a nearby parking lot before she passed him. 'Ma'am, I was behind you,' he responded in the footage. At least three other officers are in view. 'I'm taking you to court,' she the phone, Randolph tells her mother the '(expletive) police' pulled her over as she asked her to get her kids, according to the video. She asks officers to wait until her mother arrives. 'I guess they are going to take me to jail,' she said over the phone in the footage. Randolph said in a previous interview with the Post-Tribune that the encounter appeared to escalate when she rolled up her window slightly to hear what her mom was saying. The arrest happens within about 12 minutes into the footage. As officers open her car door and grab her arm, Randolph's children can be heard crying in the back seat. 'This is your last warning,' one of the officers said in the video. 'We don't want your kids to see this.' 'You already freaked my kids out,' she said. 'Get out of the (expletive) car,' one officer stated in the footage. I'm '(expletive) pregnant,' she yells just before two officers pull her from the vehicle after she tried to cling to the steering wheel in the video. 'Let me go! Get off of me! Please get off of me! Somebody help me!' After she is handcuffed on the ground, a police dog is seen in the background of the dashboard camera footage. Randolph's white shoes are scattered nearby. 'I'm trying to help you out here,' one officer tells her in the video. Randolph was charged with resisting law enforcement two months later. Hamady's account in court documents makes no mention of her pregnancy. During the ride to booking at the Lake County Jail, they talk at length about her decision to have a fifth child, according to footage inside the police car. Her fiancé wanted one last child, she said. When Hamady asks how far along she is on the video, she responds she's nearly 12 weeks pregnant. 'Well, congrats to you,' he said in the video. Hamady stated in the footage that her bond should be $400. It's 'not Friday, so it's a good thing,' he tells her in the video. 'I'll make sure they keep you updated.' He asks if she's comfortable as late-'90s era music plays over the radio, the footage shows, before they chat about where she is planning to get married. Do you 'want the window open back there, or are you good?' he asks in the video. Since police insisted on towing her red Chevrolet Trailblazer, Randolph's mother had to take four kids back in a cramped sedan, a situation that was not likely 'legally safe,' Custardo said. Randolph's lawsuit alleged her arrest suggested a 'broader pattern' in the Lake County Sheriff's Department, including 'inadequate training,' 'insufficient supervision' and a 'failure to implement effective accountability measures,' according to court documents. The Lake County Sheriff's Department refused to answer questions related to the incident, including what kind of de-escalation training its officers receive at various stages in their careers. Hamady joined the department in 2022, according to court filings. Sheriff Oscar Martinez Jr. declined comment through a spokeswoman, who said he could not discuss pending litigation. Watching the video with her mother was 'very emotional,' Randolph said in an Aug. 5 interview, especially hearing her kids crying in the video's background. She refused to let her 12-year-old daughter view it. 'I feel better now that I've seen it,' Randolph said. 'It matches the exact story I've been telling for so long.' There's been some 'expected' backlash online after a pair of articles in local newspapers, Randolph said. She was there trying to protect herself and her Williams, her criminal public defender, said she did remember parts of the case in retrospect, and confirmed she tried to get the bodycam from the Lake County Sheriff's Department 'multiple times' since the case was filed in August 2023. Court filings show one discovery request for the body cam was made as late as October 2024. The only reason not to turn it over was if they 'didn't want me to see something,' she said. Randolph was tired of repeatedly coming to court for a slow-moving case, Williams said. She told her client that she could fight to get the bodycam footage, or take a pretrial diversion to get rid of the case in a year. 'It's common to get slow discovery (evidence) when you're requesting bodycams,' Williams said, adding that some police departments are worse than others, but she's had 'good experience' with the sheriff's department in the past. Randolph's case is scheduled for a pretrial diversion hearing on Aug. 15. However, an automatic court filing on Aug. 11 appears to show there may be a snag. Court filings show Randolph, her fiancé and sister were charged June 26 with resisting law enforcement in Hobart. Hobart Police Cpl. Christopher Sipes wrote that Randolph and her fiancé got his attention around 1:30 a.m. May 25 on Main Street for ignoring a 'pedestrian signal.' , Randolph said they were out that night celebrating her fiancé's birthday. As End Zone let out across the street, a crowd, including the half-dozen in her group, were migrating to the other bar, Randolph said. At least two officers were there, as someone behind them yelled something about the guy handcuffed on the ground getting arrested nearby. The officer thought her fiancé said something, she said. Sipes wrote he and the other officer followed them into Cagney's. 'Bulls jersey, stop right there,' the other officer said to Randolph's fiancé, according to court records. As they got to the bar, Randolph said an officer grabbed her arm from behind. According to court documents, when the officer asked for identification, the couple 'ignored' him and said they 'didn't do anything.' Randolph 'stepped in front' of officers to block them from her fiance. As the cops went to arrest them just inside the bar's entrance, the crowd 'became aggressive,' the officer wrote. During a 'struggle' as she was being handcuffed, Randolph's black strapless top fell down, exposing her breasts, records state. Randolph said in an interview she tried to turn away for some privacy, because there were a 'million people standing around.' Once she stood up, an officer wrote, he pulled her top back up, records state. She denied she got in their way or refused to give her identification card. The officer was bigger than her, and it didn't make sense that she could overpower him. The whole incident was 'very unfortunate,' her lawyer Patrick Young said Aug. 7, adding he's working with prosecutors to resolve the case.
