Scots MP blasts Nicola Sturgeon for refusing to say she was wrong on gender reform in book
A Scottish Labour MP has blasted Nicola Sturgeon for failing to "admit she was wrong" about gender reform in her book.
Joani Reid said the former first minister's "deranged gender reform bill... would have endangered thousands of women."
She also blasted Sturgeon's memoir - which was released last week - as "self-serving" with "all the same narcissistic traits, arrogance and moral superiority we saw from her in government."
East Kilbride and Strathaven MP Reid told the Record: "It's hard to think of a fall from grace so spectacular - Nicola Sturgeon was once hailed across the UK, including by people who should have known better, as some sort of progressive beacon. It all went to her head and she got drunk on her own hype.
"Her deranged 'gender reform' bill would have allowed creepy men pretending to be women access to our toilets and female-only spaces. She ignored legal and expert warnings and anyone raising common sense safety issues was branded as bigots.
"It was a crazy plan that would have endangered thousands of women. Fortunately, it was outside the powers of the Scottish Government, but they spent a fortune getting humiliated in the Supreme Court and yet she still can't admit she was wrong.
"This self-serving, self-regarding memoir is full of petty score-settling and reveals all the same narcissistic traits, arrogance and moral superiority we saw from her in government.
"Scotland needed a leader who would protect our rights, not sacrifice them on the altar of political vanity. Beyond the gimmicks and woke virtue signalling, she achieved little of substance during her eight years at the helm, and it all caught up with her in the end."
Sturgeon's memoir, Frankly, was officially released on Thursday. Copies of it were on sale in Waterstones shops earlier in the week.
In it, she accused JK Rowling of helping create a a "toxic" climate around Scotland's gender reform debate.
The MSP said the Harry Potter author's decision to wear a T-shirt branding her a 'destroyer of women's rights' marked the point at which "rational debate" on the issue became "impossible" and "any hope of finding common ground disappeared".
Sturgeon's Government passed a bill which would have made it possible for trans people to change gender without a medical diagnosis.
But the bill was stopped from becoming law by Tory Scotland Secretary Alister Jack, who said it breached UK Equalities law.
At the same time, there was public outrage after convicted double rapist Isla Bryson - who identified as female - was initially sent to a women's prison.
Sturgeon then refused to say if Bryson was a man or woman, but said last week that male rapists should "probably" lose the right to choose their gender.
Earlier this year there was a landmark ruling where the Supreme Court said that the words 'woman' and 'sex' in the Equality Act 2010 refer to a biological woman and biological sex.
The SNP was approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
24 minutes ago
- Daily Record
East Kilbride Labour leader rallies town to ‘win our future back' ahead of Holyrood election
Joe Fagan said Scottish politics was not working for the Scottish people and called for new ideas to make East Kilbride 'new' again. Labour's candidate to become East Kilbride's next MSP rallied supporters to 'win the town's future back' – ramping up the campaign for the Holyrood election next year. Addressing supporters from the local Labour Party and beyond at East Kilbride Arts Centre, Joe Fagan said Scottish politics "was not working for the Scottish people" and called for new ideas to "make East Kilbride 'new' again" and put the Scottish Parliament back to work for Scotland. Rallying supporters, Fagan said: 'East Kilbride is where I live, where I grew up, where I went to school, where I first joined a trade union. It's the place I fight for week-in, week-out as a councillor and a local leader. It would be an honour to speak for my home town in the Scottish Parliament. And I promise then I when I speak for East Kilbride, we will not be ignored.' The East Kilbride MSP seat has been held by SNP MSP Collette Stevenson since 2021. Fagan is the councillor for East Kilbride Central North and Leader of Labour in South Lanarkshire. He grew up in St Leonards and East Mains and attended St Bride's High School. Analysing the problems facing the town, he said: 'East Kilbride is Scotland's first and most successful New Town, built on the promise of good jobs and good homes, where generations of working people came to make a better life and give a better start to their families. Many still do. The town is still growing. But it's not new anymore. 'East Kilbride was disfigured by the privatisation of our most important assets – our industrial estates and our town centre – when the Development Corporation was wound up by the Major Government 30 years ago. East Kilbride lost something of its identity when the Tories abolished our district council, as many suburban towns did, but few with as strong a sense of place or civic pride as East Kilbride. 'East Kilbride lost something of its community when the real consequence of the Right to Buy set in, unprecedented growth in a transient private rented sector now larger than the social rented sector in many of our most established communities. East Kilbride lost industries we built through the New Town years as the world changed and industrial policy was neglected. 'East Kilbride lost out to austerity as years of government funding cuts to councils deprived us of the resources we need to invest in the fabric of our town and in the quality of people's lives." East Kilbride and Strathaven MP Joani Reid; candidate for the neighbouring Clydesdale constituency, Lynsey Hamilton; and summer by-election winner Davy Russell MSP all joined the event to back East Kilbride Labour's campaign. Scottish Labour aim to build on their momentum following their win in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election in constituencies across South Lanarkshire. Fagan added: 'I don't believe that the forces driving decline are unstoppable. I'm here to push back against them. I believe that the choices we make matter. The choices governments make matter. With the most consequential Scottish election in years almost here, it's time to make East Kilbride matter.' In a rallying call to supporters and undecided voters across the town, Fagan called for today's generation to 'win' the town's future back, saying: 'In 1947, East Kilbride was designated a New Town by the post-war Labour Government - a government and a generation with the vision to build the welfare state, to build industry, to build a National Health Service and to build a New Town for the future. Now it is for this generation to win our future back. 'New homes. New jobs. A new town centre. A new public transport system run for passengers, not for profit. A new deal for councils. A new deal for workers. New leadership for our NHS. New ambition for our schools. New direction for our country. Building back for East Kilbride. Fighting back for East Kilbride. Labour's leading the way - and it's the way to make this New Town new again.'
Evening Standard
25 minutes ago
- Evening Standard
JK Rowling compares Nicola Sturgeon's memoir to Twilight
Her English fans can't be expected to know about every single clusterfuck over which the supposedly competent Sturgeon presided, and they certainly won't find out about them from Frankly. The mysteriously vanished government WhatsApp messages from the pandemic, the tanking educational outcomes, the CalMac Ferry disaster, the disappearance of a half a million pounds of her own supporters' money that was supposedly ringfenced for a new independence referendum: you'll search in vain for candid accounts of these in Frankly; indeed, most aren't mentioned at all. Perhaps the most disgraceful omission – and I'll admit to a personal interest here, because I'm married to a doctor who used to run a methadone clinic, so saw the national scandal up close – is the fact that Scotland continues to lead the whole of Europe in drug deaths.
Telegraph
26 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Reeves threatened with legal action over protection for bats and newts
Environmental groups have threatened legal action against the Government if Rachel Reeves waters down rules protecting bats and newts from construction projects. Ms Reeves is said to be exploring reforms that would make it more difficult to slow down or block large developments over environmental concerns, amid fears that red tape is holding back the economy. Earlier this year the Chancellor complained that environmental regulation had become a 'barrier' to investment. She highlighted the £100m 'bat tunnel' built as part of HS2, calling it an example of ' absolutely insane costs that are added to essential infrastructure investments'. However, environmental groups warned they would fight any attempts by the Chancellor to weaken regulations, which ensure developers must protect rare species such as bats and newts. Richard Benwell, the chief executive of Wildlife and Countryside Link – England's largest environment and wildlife coalition – said: 'It would be absurd for the Treasury to roll back basic environmental protections when flooding, wildfires, drought and crop failures are already costing the economy as much as £70bn this decade. 'Investing in nature is not only the right thing to do, it is also the wiser economic strategy. 'The Government is legally obliged to halt the decline of species by 2030 and weakening protections for wildlife could make it impossible to meet that duty. We will hold the Government to account on delivery – including through Parliament and, if necessary, legal action.' Paul Miner, head of planning and policy at countryside charity CPRE, said: 'The changes seem to us to be unnecessary and not getting at the main issue. Projects like HS2 have taken a long time because government ministers kept on changing their mind about what they wanted the project to do, and also because they didn't have a sufficiently open public debate about HS2 before they passed the bill to allow it to happen.
