Academia margins to NCERT row: French-born scholar's tryst with India's past
Danino, who heads the panel on the NCERT social science textbooks, is no stranger to row. He has delved into subjects, that have generated heat in academic and political circles for decades, which include questions related to the Aryan invasion — in his writings and lectures he rejects it — and the Sarasvati river, which he terms the 'life-giving river' of the 'Indus-Sarasvati civilisation' or the Harappan civilisation.
While the new NCERT books have brought him into the limelight again, the French-born Danino, who was awarded the Padma Shri in 2017, was once, in his words, 'on the margins of academia'. In France, he studied maths, physics and engineering. While he enjoyed science, he felt it didn't have 'answers to major issues'. In the early 1970s, he got interested in Indian spirituality, Sri Aurobindo, and the 'Mother' (Mirra Alfassa, who established Auroville in Pondicherry).
'It was in the air — there was information going around (on Sri Aurobindo and Auroville). There was a famous short movie on French TV by a well-known filmmaker. Auroville started in 1968, and people were already working there. It attracted me because of Sri Aurobindo's vision of human unity — it would be possible only with a very substantial transformation of human nature. I landed in Auroville in 1977,' said Danino.
Deciding to spend his life in India, Danino started translating, editing and publishing texts related to Aurobindo and the 'Mother'. He was drawn to Aurobindo's ideas on Indian civilisation and its ancient past. 'In his writings, he (Aurobindo) brought up what used to be called the 'genius of Indian civilisation'. He was convinced going back to those roots could help us meet today's and tomorrow's challenges much better. This led me to further exploration of Indian civilisation.'
His 'cursory readings' became systematic, and he began to take part in conferences, and present, publish papers. He gave three series of lectures at IIT Kanpur. Danino was then scholar-in-residence at IIT Kanpur. The lectures caught IIT Gandhinagar's founding director Professor Sudhir Jain's attention. Danino began as guest professor at IIT Gandhinagar in 2011, helped set up Archaeological Sciences Centre at the institute, coordinated an Indian Knowledge Systems discipline, and offered courses like 'Perspectives on Indian Civilisation'.
Now, referring to his NCERT panel, Danino said it was mandated to develop the social science textbooks within the framework of the National Education Policy 2020 and the National Curriculum Framework for School Education 2023. On new textbooks, he said: 'In some of our workshops, I said we'll get brickbats when the textbooks are out. I declared my objective was to get equal brickbats from both sides of the spectrum so that we will know we have done a good job. And ironically, that's almost what's happening.'
Danino said since the new curriculum involves having a single social science book instead of separate ones for subjects like history, geography, and political science, 'we have limited space'. 'We try to focus on what is important that we would like our students to remember, if possible, all their life.'
Danino said: 'The least genuine criticism is we are writing under the gaze of ideological movements like RSS, etc. This is completely false. We never felt any undue influence. People are not willing to believe that because it's a convenient argument to dismiss the whole effort without seriously looking at it. We have not said that the textbooks are perfect. How can they be perfect? It's the first attempt and done in a short time. They have to be revised and looked at afresh from year to year.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
23 minutes ago
- The Hindu
A bistable gene in a deadly bacterium offers a clue to beating it
The French biochemist Jacques Monod (1910-1976), who won a Nobel Prize in 1965 for discovering how cells regulate the expression of genes, famously said, 'What is true for Escherichia coli is true for the elephant.' He meant the same fundamental mechanisms of molecular biology, such as protein synthesis, DNA replication, and cellular metabolism, are shared by both bacteria and elephants. In his comment, Monod was taking a bird's-eye view of biology. If you zoomed in enough, two bacterial cells with identical genomes — and even from the same colony — can be quite different from each other. One cell might express a particular gene at a high level while the other might express it at a low level or not at all. Each bacterium goes on to transmit its expression level to its offspring in a process called epigenetic inheritance. Such variations among otherwise identical cells and organisms is called bistability. Bistability might be a survival strategy that single-celled organisms use to adapt to fluctuating environmental conditions. Now, a team of researchers, led by scientists from the Helmholtz Centre for Infection Research in Germany, has reported that a gene in the bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa shows bistable expression. This is important because P. aeruginosa is an opportunistic and deadly pathogen. Most burn victims succumb to secondary P. aeruginosa infections. It is a major cause of keratitis, an eye infection, and also infects urinary catheters. Hospital infections of P. aeruginosa are notoriously resistant to antibiotics. Medical researchers and doctors are keen to understand what makes the bacterium so deadly — and the new study opens a door towards this goal. The researchers have reported that the differential expression of the glpD gene in individual cells of P. aeruginosa was associated with differences in the bacterium's ability to cause disease, i.e. its pathogenicity properties. The findings were reported in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Tracking gene expression The genome of P. aeruginosa contains nearly 6,000 genes. When a gene is expressed, the cell makes corresponding RNA. These RNA serve as transcripts. Think of them as the gene's working copies. The cell loads these RNA onto protein-making factories called ribosomes. There the information from the RNA is used to stitch amino acids together in different sequences to make the protein corresponding to that gene. Many genes produce relatively few transcripts. Let's call them low expression genes (LEGs). The high expression genes (HEGs) on the other hand produce many more transcripts — in some instances 100x to 10,000x more. In general, there is less variation in transcript numbers when an HEG is expressed than when an LEG is expressed. While an LEG in one cell might express one transcript, in another cell it might express 30, so this is a range of 30x. But for HEGs, a 30x range is highly unlikely. In the new study, the researchers analysed over 300 P. aeruginosa strains for all the transcripts that they made from their genes. They found that although the glpD gene was an HEG, the variation in its transcript counts P. aeruginosa cells made was way more than for the other HEGs. The finding hinted that the glpD gene might be an HEG in some cells and an LEG in others. To explore this possibility, the team fused the DNA segment that regulated the expression of the glpD gene with a gene that makes the green fluorescent protein (GFP). Whenever the glpD gene was expressed, the cell would also make the GFP protein, which glows under light. This way, the researchers had a small, green light-bulb that lit up when the glpD gene was expressed. The team also used a more short-lived variant of GFP to make the signal more accurately reflect the gene's real-time expression. The fickle gene Only a small fraction of cells with the fusion gene lit up and maintained their 'on' state over an extended period of time. More interestingly, when a cell that had already lit up divided into two, one of the daughter cells also lit up but the other didn't. In some lineages, the team found that the 'on' ability was passed down to up to five generations. In lineages that descended from a single cell that didn't light up, i.e. was 'off', about 5-6% of the daughter cells randomly switched to 'on'. And in half of these cases, the 'on' state was short-lived. In the other half, it persisted as if the cell had descended from an 'on' ancestor. Finally, more cells were 'on' when glycerol was present. This was expected since P. aeruginosa bacteria use the glpD gene to make use of glycerol. The moth larva test The larvae of the greater wax moth (Galleria mellonella) are parasites of honeycombs. Scientists use the larvae as a model to study how bacterial infections develop and spread. In the new study as well, the researchers infected greater wax moth larvae with P. aeruginosa bacteria — but before they did, they removed the glpD gene first. The researchers found that these P. aeruginosa bacteria had a significantly reduced ability to kill the larvae compared to bacteria containing the intact gene. This was a sign that the expression of the glpD gene was associated with the bacteria's ability to infect. The researchers hypothesised that the interaction of P. aeruginosa with the cells in the bodies of the mammals (including humans) it infects might also be associated with higher glpD expression. To test this, the team cultured mouse immune cells and infected them with P. aeruginosa bacteria containing the GFP fusion gene. Team members found that the bacteria that came in contact with macrophage cells of the mouse immune system fluoresced more brightly, meaning glpD was being expressed more. Playing it safe The variability in the expression levels of the glpD expression was evident even in small clusters of around 10-50 cells. Given that cells that produced more glpD transcripts were better at setting infections in motion suggested that an infection can be initiated by even a small group. As the researchers wrote in their paper, 'varying levels of glpD expression … might be a strategy … for the success of P. aeruginosa as an opportunistic pathogen'. Axiomatically, a drug targeting this variation could prevent P. aeruginosa from being the scourge it currently is in hospitals. D.P. Kasbekar is a retired scientist.
Indian Express
3 hours ago
- Indian Express
2 dozen Indians among 650 experts picked to write next IPCC report
More than two dozen Indian scientists and researchers are in the list of over 650 experts chosen to write the seventh assessment report of Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which is expected to be published in 2029. The IPCC assessment reports, or ARs, are the most comprehensive contemporary scientific understanding of the planet's climate system, the changes it is undergoing, and the impact it is having on the Earth and its inhabitants. These reports are produced in a five to seven years cycle and represent the state of knowledge of the climate system at that time. The different parts of the sixth assessment report, or AR6, were released between 2021 and 2023. Like previous reports, the AR7 would comprise three working groups, each producing a report of its own — Working Group I on the physical science basis of climate change, Working Group II on impacts, adaptation and vulnerability, and Working Group III on mitigation of climate change. There are nine Indian scientists and researchers in Working Group I and III and eight Working Group II. Three scientists from Pune-based Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology, which hosts a Centre for Climate Change Research, are part of the group, the highest among Indian institutions. The Indian Institute of Science, Bengaluru, and the Indian Institute for Human Settlements (IIHS), have two people each in the list. Several of these have contributed to previous assessment reports as well. A few Indians are working in other countries. A similar number of Indians, in the range of 20-30, have been part of the earlier assessment reports. The contributors to the assessment reports are initially nominated by country governments, which can propose as many names as they like.
NDTV
4 hours ago
- NDTV
Conch Shell Blowing Shows Promise In Treating Sleep Apnea
A new study suggests that blowing a conch shell daily may help improve sleep for those with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). The research, published as a randomized controlled trial, explored how playing wind instruments can support better breathing during sleep. OSA is a common condition affecting nearly one billion adults worldwide, marked by repeated pauses in breathing while sleeping. In the study, 30 individuals with moderate OSA were divided into two groups. One group practiced a traditional Indian breathing exercise called shankh, which involves blowing into a conch shell like a trumpet. The other group performed deep, slow nasal breathing exercises. Researchers observed that participants in the conch-blowing group showed significant improvements in sleep quality and reported feeling more refreshed upon waking, compared to the deep breathing group. The study was led by Dr Krishna K Sharma from the Eternal Heart Care Centre and Research Institute in Jaipur, India. He said: "The standard treatment for OSA is a continuous positive airway pressure machine, or CPAP, which keeps the patient's airway open by blowing air through a facemask throughout the night. While effective, many patients find it uncomfortable and struggle to use it consistently. "In my clinical practice, several patients reported feeling more rested and experiencing fewer symptoms after regularly practising shankh blowing - a traditional yogic breathing exercise involving exhaling through a conch shell. These observations led us to design a scientific study to rigorously test whether this simple, ancient practice could serve as a meaningful therapy for people with OSA." The findings indicate that conch-blowing exercises may strengthen respiratory muscles and keep airways clearer during sleep, offering a non-invasive method to manage sleep apnea symptoms.
