Activist doctor opposed to puberty blocker ban now head of BMA
Dr Tom Dolphin tabled the 'emergency motion' in July last year that led to the union rejecting the findings of the Cass Review into children's gender services.
The union was later pressured by its members to backtrack to a 'neutral' stance, and announced that it would conduct its own evaluation of the Cass Review by the end of last year, though it has yet to publish anything.
Lady Cass spent more than four years on the study, which reviewed data from 113,000 children. She recommended a ban on prescribing sex hormones outside of clinical trials to children who question their gender.
The BMA's council bypassed debate to reject the Cass Review after it ran out of time to discuss the motion at the annual meeting. The union has since shunned four attempts by members to have an open debate on the review this year.
More than 1,500 doctors, the majority of them BMA members, have since signed a 'Not in Our Name' open letter to the union, criticising the 'very undemocratic' decision to reject Lady Cass's findings.
The council, which consists of 69 members, this week ousted Prof Philip Banfield, the sitting chairman, and replaced him with Dr Dolphin.
Dr Dolphin, an anaesthetic consultant who lives in London, has campaigned for Dawn Butler, the Labour MP for Brent Central and Brent South. He has been a member of BMA council since 2012 and is the chairman of his hospital trust's local negotiating committee, which represents and negotiates for doctors at employer-level.
'Trans rights are human rights'
In July 2022, he posted photos of himself getting ready for a Trans Pride march, saying: 'About to set off to let London know that trans rights are human rights!'
Fiona McAnena, the director of campaigns at human rights charity Sex Matters, said Dr Dolphin's election 'shows how gender ideology breaks previously respectable organisations'.
She told The Telegraph: 'The Cass Review is a comprehensive, evidence-based report on so-called gender medicine for children by an independent paediatrician with impeccable credentials.
'Creating doubt around it without robust evidence is irresponsible, misleading, and not in the best interests of patients.
'We've said before that the trans activist doctors at the BMA are an embarrassment to their profession. Their false assertions about biology can be disproven with primary school science.
'Giving them this level of credibility could have serious consequences for the health and well-being of vulnerable children and young adults.'
Dr Louise Irvine, a former BMA council member who co-chairs the Clinical Advisory Group on Sex and Gender, has criticised a 'culture of secrecy' around the review and said 'ideologues' had infiltrated senior positions in the union.
She said doctors were 'very angry that they were not consulted' and 'appalled by the ridiculous knee-jerk and uninformed reaction of the BMA council'.
'There has been terrible secrecy all the way along. It reflects a deeper malaise within the BMA. It is no longer a democratic organisation,' she said, adding: 'Motions relating to Cass have never been picked for debate. They are trying to avoid this, because of the ideology of a small group within the BMA that has got into quite a powerful position.'
A BMA spokesperson said: 'The BMA is a trade union and professional association with a proud history of advocating for doctors, health services and the health of the population. We are not a single-issue organisation.
'Dr Dolphin is a longstanding BMA elected member, who is widely respected by our members, underlined by his recent election as chair of council. He has been actively involved in the BMA for more than 20 years, during which time he has held multiple leadership positions and worked on a multitude of medico-political issues.
'He has sat on BMA council since 2012, and council members have now elected Dr Dolphin to lead the BMA on a huge range of issues across its wide remit as both a trade union and professional association.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
13 minutes ago
- BBC News
Mayors push for Snake Pass help amid 'deep concerns'
Three regional mayors whose areas span the Snake Pass route say they want the government to do more to help maintain it amid "deep concern" about its about the road were heard during the launch of the "Peak Partnership", a grouping of the mayors for the East Midlands, Greater Manchester and South Yorkshire who plan to lobby the government on key issues affecting the Peak County Council which is responsible for the road, which links Manchester and Sheffield, has warned it cannot afford to keep repairing government previously said it was "not responsible" for funding the road. funding was announced in July for works along the route, part of a government tranche of cash for road improvements. Snake Pass is regarded as one of the most scenic driving roads in the UK, and is used by about 30,000 vehicles a it is also considered one of the "most high-risk" roads in England due to a series of steep bends, twists and blind data submitted to the Department for Transport (DfT) states that, between 2018 and 2023, there were five fatalities along with 62 serious and 102 "slight" is often the subject of roadworks and closes regularly due to difficult weather or landslips, making it dangerous to drive along. "We're starting that conversation", East Midlands mayor Claire Ward said when asked at a launch event for the partnership in Buxton whether the mayors would be appealing for specific regular funding for the route. "We have to solve this problem, it can't carry on like this," she said."We recognise that [the route] is a big responsibility on Derbyshire County Council." Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham said that "there's a conversation to be had about managing these roads in a different way"."Snake be considered key national infrastructure."Burnham said there was no comparable situation elsewhere in the country where key infrastructure between two major cities was maintained by a local council as opposed to a body like National Highways."It's actually unfair to [Derbyshire County Council] with the budgets that they've got, the pressure on road budgets that we all know, the pothole challenges that we know, to leave them struggling with key national infrastructure," he said. South Yorkshire mayor Oliver Coppard said the Peak District was "held back" by transport and connectivity issues "every single day"."I am deeply worried about the future of the Snake Pass," he said. "It's great we've had investment there but we need to be even more ambitious." The mayors said the idea to join forces in a formal grouping was initially sparked by concerns about Snake Burnham said it was also hoped the partnership would address the issue of the Peak District being "overlooked" by Whitehall for decades in terms of its transport needs, and boosting connectivity will be a key continuation of a scheme allowing for free bus travel for young people living in the High Peak area commuting into Greater Manchester was cited as a key area of collaboration. The Bee Network extending further into the High Peak area is also seen as something that could bring "substantial benefits" to local residents. The mayors will also hope to address tourism issues that regularly plague the Peak District, though all three mayors said they would oppose a charging scheme that the leader of Derbyshire County Council said he would be open said proposals for a new rail to link to connect beauty spots in the region in Buxton were being explored as one solution to address congestion problems. Jon Pearce, the Labour member for High Peak in Derbyshire, who previously suggested that High Peak should be incorporated into the Greater Manchester region, said the new mayoral partnership represented a "step change" that addressed his concerns."This Peak Partnership is the best possible outcome we could've had," he said."My argument was we're on the edge of we've been forgotten about. This in on my constituency. This is massive for us." A Department for Transport spokesperson said: "We are already investing £7.6m to help Derbyshire County Council deliver vital safety upgrades on the A57 Snake Pass, helping save lives and improve journeys, and have also provided the new East Midlands Combined County Authority with a significant boost in highways funding – over £75m this year to share on roads across the region."
The Independent
14 minutes ago
- The Independent
Tories deliberately trying to fuel hatred against asylum seekers, Yousaf says
The former first minister of Scotland has accused the Tories of 'deliberately trying to fuel hatred' against asylum seekers by presenting them as a threat to women and children. Humza Yousaf said politicians like Robert Jenrick were 'reviving the old colonial lie that people from the east are somehow dangerous savages'. Mr Jenrick, the shadow justice secretary, has said he supports 'every peaceful protest outside an asylum hotel' and later attended one in Epping, where an asylum seeker was charged with sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl. Demonstrations against asylum seekers staying in hotels have sprung up across the UK, including in Scotland, with those attending claiming they are making their communities less safe. Mr Jenrick, who previously ran for the Tory leadership, said small boat crossings in the English Channel amounted to a 'national security emergency', adding: 'The truth is that mass, uncontrolled immigration has been fuelling crime and made women and girls less safe. ' In a video posted to social media, Mr Yousaf hit back at the Tory claims, saying it was 'predatory men' who posed a danger to women, rather than people from any one group, such as asylum seekers. He said: 'As a father of three girls, let me tell you that it's not asylum seekers I'm worried about when it comes to my daughter's safety – it's men, predatory men, who come in every colour, every religion, are from every background. 'Of course, those who do commit heinous crimes against women, be they asylum seekers or those who have lived in the UK for 10 generations, they should and must feel the full force of the law. 'But when you purposely single out asylum seekers, as the Tories are doing, you're not interested in protecting women, you're deliberately trying to fuel hatred. 'You're reviving the old colonial lie that people from the east are somehow dangerous savages.' The former SNP leader said such rhetoric has turned 'fear into mobs who are ready to set fire to hotels housing asylum seekers', in reference to a riot in Rotherham last year in which a man who attempted to set fire to an asylum hotel. 'It leads to bricks through windows,' he added. 'It leads to fire bombs aimed at vulnerable families who've already fled war and persecution. 'And here's the truth, violence against women is committed by men from every walk of life. 'Blaming asylum seekers doesn't make women safer, it just makes society more divided, more suspicious, more willing to turn on the most vulnerable. 'What the Tories are doing isn't about women's safety, it's about stoking fear. It's the oldest populist trick in the book, let's make sure we don't fall.'
Telegraph
15 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Labour poised to take control of Gupta's UK steel factories
The Government is poised to take over operations at Britain's third largest steelworks, aiming to save 1,500 jobs at Sanjeev Gupta's Rotherham-based factory. The High Court heard on Wednesday that the Government's official receiver is ready to step in as administrator if Mr Gupta is unable to finalise a rescue deal involving £75m from US giant BlackRock. 'The official receiver is prepared, should SSUK [Speciality Steel UK] enter into compulsory liquidation, to take control of SSUK's affairs,' the Department for Business and Trade said in a letter to Mr Gupta's creditors. The letter said the Government had held discussions with SSUK but had not been negotiating any taxpayer financial assistance to either Mr Gupta or any potential buyer of the company. The Government said it was also not discussing putting SSUK under state ownership. That 'would be the subject of formal ministerial decision, and no such decisions have been made'. The submission comes as creditors of SSUK seek to shut down the company in order to claim their debts. Mr Gupta is looking to avoid his company falling into the hands of the official receiver by in effect liquidating the company himself and using his fresh BlackRock funding for what the court was 'a management buyout'. In a court hearing, Judge Sally Barber said she could not decide on the spot whether to wind up SSUK – in effect putting the company under potential government management – or to let Mr Gupta go ahead with his plan. The judge said she needed more information on what would happen, saying she could not decide 'on a completely blind basis' having not seen a draft application from the official receiver. The matter is likely to return to court in the coming days, piling pressure on the Government to be more explicit about its plans for the cash-strapped plant.
