Diplomatic turbulence in Benghazi won't derail EU–Libya ties
The European Union has sought to move past last week's diplomatic dispute in Benghazi, where a senior EU delegation was expelled shortly after arrival, reiterating its continued commitment to working with all relevant Libyan authorities on shared challenges — particularly irregular migration.
The delegation — which included EU Commissioner for Home Affairs and Migration Magnus Brunner and interior ministers from Italy, Greece, and Malta — was turned back upon landing at Benina Airport on Tuesday, 8 July. It had intended to hold meetings with officials in eastern Libya to discuss the recent surge in migrant crossings to Europe.
Before travelling to Benghazi, the delegation met with Prime Minister Abdulhamid Dabaiba and other members of the internationally recognised Government of National Unity (GNU) in Tripoli. Commissioner Brunner described those discussions as 'productive,' noting on social media that the visit reaffirmed a joint commitment to combat migrant smuggling and laid the foundations for broader cooperation.
However, authorities in Benghazi — aligned with Prime Minister Osama Hammad — declared Brunner persona non grata and ordered the entire delegation to leave the country. The scheduled meetings were cancelled.
EU: Incident was a 'protocol issue'
European Commission officials have described the Benghazi episode as a 'protocol issue,' while avoiding further comment on the details. A spokesperson told The Brussels Times that the EU would continue its engagement across Libya and keep communication channels open with all key stakeholders.
'We are not here to assign blame or retell events,' the spokesperson added. 'What matters is that cooperation continues where it's needed most — on migration, stability, and regional security.'
One Libya policy remains unchanged
Despite the tensions, the European Union reaffirmed its long-standing 'One Libya' policy, under which it maintains engagement with authorities throughout the country while recognising the GNU in Tripoli as the result of the UN-led political process.
A spokesperson for the European External Action Service (EEAS) said the EU's position has not changed, confirming that the bloc works with a wide range of actors to address shared priorities.
Media reports suggest that the breakdown in the Benghazi visit may have stemmed from concerns raised by EU Ambassador to Libya Nicola Orlando, who was reportedly reluctant to engage directly with senior officials from Hammad's government.
Irregular migration on the rise
The expulsion comes amid growing EU concerns over the increasing number of irregular migrants departing from Libya. According to recent data, more than 7,300 migrants have arrived in 2025 on the Greek islands of Crete and Gavdos — up from around 5,000 in 2024. Both islands lack sufficient reception facilities, prompting the issue to be raised at the recent European Council summit.
In response, the Greek government announced a temporary three-month suspension of asylum procedures for migrants arriving by sea from North Africa, particularly Libya. The European Commission has said it will review the measure once national legislation has been finalised and enters into force.
This echoes a similar move in 2020, when Greece suspended asylum claims following a border crisis with Turkey — a measure that drew criticism from rights groups and legal scholars.
Questions over EU funding and rights safeguards
The Benghazi incident has reignited debate over the EU's migration cooperation with Libya and its oversight mechanisms. A 2023 report by the European Court of Auditors (ECA) criticised the EU's €5 billion Emergency Trust Fund for Africa (EUTF) for insufficient focus on root causes of migration and inadequate monitoring of human rights conditions in recipient countries, including Libya.
The same year, a joint investigation by Lighthouse Reports revealed that Frontex, the EU's border agency, had shared the coordinates of migrant boats in distress with a vessel reportedly operated by an armed group in eastern Libya — raising serious ethical and legal concerns.
Despite these challenges, EU officials have reiterated their intention to maintain engagement with all sides in Libya, stressing the need for a comprehensive, coordinated approach to migration governance and regional security.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Libyan Express
7 hours ago
- Libyan Express
Dbeibeh attends trilateral summit in Istanbul
BY Libyan Express Aug 01, 2025 - 02:50 Libyan Prime Minister Abdul Hamid Dbeibeh A trilateral summit is taking place today, Friday, 1 August 2025, in Istanbul, bringing together Libyan Prime Minister Abdul Hamid Dbeibeh, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. The meeting, confirmed by diplomatic sources and reported by regional and international media, is expected to focus on a number of regional issues of mutual concern. The discussions are centred on economic cooperation across the Mediterranean, joint energy development—including offshore oil and gas exploration—and irregular migration, a topic of shared interest to all three governments. Efforts to coordinate infrastructure investment and enhance regional stability are also on the agenda. Libya's participation in the summit comes amid growing interest from international partners in re-engaging with the country's economic sectors, particularly energy and transport. In June 2025, Libya's National Oil Corporation signed a memorandum of understanding with Turkey's TPAO to conduct exploratory work in four maritime zones. That agreement is expected to feature in today's talks. Italy's presence at the summit follows a series of diplomatic moves aimed at strengthening ties with North African partners. Earlier this week, Prime Minister Meloni met with Tunisian President Kais Saied in Tunis. Her visit to Istanbul signals an intent to further coordinate regional efforts on migration, security, and energy. According to officials familiar with the matter, the summit seeks to build a more coherent framework for trilateral cooperation, while also reflecting a broader effort to manage shared challenges in the Mediterranean. Observers note that the outcomes of today's discussions could influence policy direction across several sectors, especially if followed by concrete implementation measures. The views expressed in Op-Ed pieces are those of the author and do not purport to reflect the opinions or views of Libyan Express. How to submit an Op-Ed: Libyan Express accepts opinion articles on a wide range of topics. Submissions may be sent to oped@ Please include 'Op-Ed' in the subject line.
Libyan Express
a day ago
- Libyan Express
Gaza faces risk of famine, UN torture rapporteur warns
Empty hands. Empty stomachs. Empty promises The United Nations Special Rapporteur on Torture, Alice Jill Edwards, has voiced deep alarm over the growing number of starvation-related deaths among Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, urging all sides to uphold their humanitarian responsibilities under international law. In a statement issued Wednesday, Edwards described the deliberate starvation of civilians as 'lethal, inhumane, and degrading,' stressing that the denial of basic necessities like food and water must end immediately. 'Denying people food, water and dignity has become a tragic hallmark of this war,' she said. 'Reports of people being shot while queuing for bread, and of widespread hunger and malnutrition, are nothing short of shocking.' Edwards warned that the risk of full-scale famine in Gaza is increasing by the day, with children, pregnant women, and the elderly especially vulnerable. She stressed that international humanitarian law obliges all parties to ensure access to essential supplies and to facilitate the safe delivery of humanitarian assistance. 'They must not obstruct or manipulate the flow of aid,' she said, adding that the effects of prolonged hunger—including malnutrition, organ failure, and death—are devastating. Beyond the physical toll, Edwards highlighted the psychological suffering endured by civilians. 'The uncertainty, the shifting rules, the militarised aid distributions—this is creating deep despair and trauma among an already exhausted population,' she said. The UN expert welcomed Israel's recent announcement of limited humanitarian pauses to allow the World Food Programme to distribute aid in Gaza over a planned three-month period. However, she stressed that such measures, while important, fall short of what is needed to protect civilians and restore hope. 'True relief will only come when there is a just and lasting peace, anchored in a political solution,' she said, renewing support for a two-state resolution to the conflict. 'No one should be forced to beg for food while supplies sit waiting to be delivered,' Edwards added. She also called for the immediate and unconditional release of all hostages, the release of arbitrarily detained Palestinians, and independent investigations into allegations of torture, mistreatment, and other potential war crimes by all sides. Edwards noted that she has raised her concerns with relevant authorities and continues to press for accountability. As part of the UN's independent special procedures, Edwards works on a voluntary basis and does not represent the official position of the UN. Her mandate is to monitor and report on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment worldwide.
Libyan Express
a day ago
- Libyan Express
El Hishri arrest marks first ICC development in Libya case
Khaled Mohamed Ali El Hishri. Photo via Reuters A coalition of international human rights organisations, including the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH), has called on all governments—particularly those involved in Libya—to fully cooperate with the International Criminal Court (ICC) following the recent arrest of a Libyan national accused of serious crimes under international law. In a joint statement sent to Libyan Express, the organisations welcomed the arrest of Khaled Mohamed Ali El Hishri, known as 'Al-Buti', by German authorities at Berlin Brandenburg Airport on 16 July 2025, based on an ICC arrest warrant. The groups praised Germany for what they described as a swift and responsible move that could mark a turning point in the ICC's long-running investigation into crimes committed in Libya. El Hishri is alleged to have held a senior position at Mitiga Prison, one of Libya's most controversial detention centres, operated by the Special Deterrence Force for Combating Terrorism and Organized Crime (commonly known as Al-Radaa), a powerful security entity affiliated with the Libyan Presidential Council. According to the ICC, El Hishri is suspected of committing or facilitating crimes against humanity and war crimes, including murder, torture, rape, and other forms of sexual violence, between 2015 and 2020. The charges relate to acts allegedly committed against detainees—both Libyans and non-Libyans—during a period marked by escalating conflict and institutional fragmentation across the country. 'This arrest offers a rare opportunity to re-energise the stalled path to accountability in Libya,' the coalition said. 'It is also a message to survivors that international justice mechanisms are still functioning, even when national courts cannot act.' This marks the first arrest under the ICC's Libya investigation that is expected to lead to formal proceedings in The Hague. The move comes more than a decade after the United Nations Security Council referred the situation in Libya to the Court through Resolution 1970 (2011), in response to widespread violence and reported abuses during the country's uprising and subsequent conflict. However, the human rights groups expressed concern over inconsistent cooperation from states. They cited the case of Osama Elmasry Njeem, another senior member of Al-Radaa, who was arrested by Italian authorities in January 2025 on similar charges related to Mitiga Prison. Instead of surrendering him to the ICC, Italy returned him to Libya, where he was reportedly received by both government figures and armed groups. The ICC is currently reviewing whether Italy violated its obligations under the Rome Statute by failing to hand over the suspect. 'Such actions undermine the credibility of international justice efforts and send the wrong message to victims and perpetrators alike,' the statement noted. The coalition urged Libyan authorities—across all regions and institutions—to meet their obligations under international law, including the arrest and surrender of individuals subject to ICC warrants. Despite repeated requests, successive governments in both eastern and western Libya have failed to fully cooperate with the ICC. The groups also drew attention to the ongoing suffering of detainees in official and unofficial detention centres across Libya, where arbitrary detention, torture, extortion, and sexual violence remain widespread. Many of these abuses, they said, are committed with near-total impunity by armed groups, state-linked forces, and local militias. They called on the ICC's Office of the Prosecutor to broaden its investigation and pursue accountability for a wider range of actors—including both Libyan and non-Libyan individuals—who have contributed to or enabled serious violations. 'For Libya to move forward, justice must apply to all, regardless of affiliation or position,' the statement concluded. 'Accountability is not only about the past—it is also about preventing future abuses and restoring trust in the rule of law.'
