No operational air monitors in KZN, confirms EDTEA
In a startling revelation on July 1, the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Economic Development, Tourism and Environmental Affairs (EDTEA) confirmed that all six of the province's air quality (AQ) monitoring stations – including the one at the iLembe Auditorium in KwaDukuza – are offline.
The disclosure came in response to formal parliamentary questions submitted by the Democratic Alliance (DA), raising serious concerns about public health and environmental governance.
EDTEA said the stations have been non-functional for an extended period due to a lack of funding. According to the DA, this leaves communities exposed to unmonitored air pollution.
Even more troubling, the department also admitted it has not conducted any studies or assessments on the health impacts of poor air quality on residents.
The DA condemned this as a 'gross dereliction of duty,' accusing successive administrations of allowing the monitoring system to collapse.
Neither EDTEA nor the iLembe District Municipality provided comment.
'Without data, there can be no accountability, and without accountability, communities will continue to suffer needlessly,' said DA KZN spokesperson on environmental affairs, Hannah Lidgett.
According to EDTEA, only three of the six monitoring stations – including iLembe – are scheduled for repair in the 2025/26 financial year. The remaining three will not be addressed until 2026/27.
The department has pointed to its newly approved Air Quality Management Plan as a framework for future health impact assessments. However, the DA argues the timeline is too slow and the damage already done is immeasurable.
The Dolphin Coast Residents and Ratepayers Association (Docrra) has gone further, describing the failure as a breach of citizens' Constitutional rights.
Docrra environmental subcommittee chairperson Brian Pottinger said the association had previously alerted iLembe to the situation.
'We pointed out to iLembe that the non-functioning AQ monitors breach citizens' Constitutional rights. They say they are waiting for funds,' said Pottinger.
'That is why we support private initiatives like Communities Against Pollution, which monitor air quality to identify sources of pollution and bring them to the authorities' attention. We have sponsored two monitors and approved two more.'
Stay in the loop with The North Coast Courier on Facebook, X, Instagram & YouTube for the latest news.
Mobile users can join our WhatsApp Broadcast Service here or if you're on desktop, scan the QR code below.
At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
4 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
The price of going viral – when political activism becomes very expensive
In an age where a single WhatsApp message can mobilise protesters and a Facebook post can shape public opinion about workplace disputes, the traditional boundaries between political activism and trade union representation are blurring in ways that would have been unimaginable a generation ago. The recent labour court judgment in Boomerang Fruits (Pty) Ltd v Umkhonto weSizwe and Others offers a stark reminder that these boundaries exist for good reasons and that crossing them can have serious legal consequences – particularly when amplified through digital platforms that can transform minor workplace grievances into viral political campaigns. From payroll error to digital political theatre The case began with a seemingly mundane payroll error. Agricultural workers at a fruit farm in Elgin in the Western Cape were underpaid overtime wages ranging from R120 to R176 per person – hardly the stuff of revolutionary politics. Yet within days, this minor administrative mistake had escalated into a full-blown industrial dispute involving police escorts, highway blockades, criminal charges and a sophisticated digital media campaign that branded the employer across multiple online platforms as racist and colonial. The transformation was breathtakingly swift. What might once have taken weeks of careful union organisation now unfolded in real time across social media networks. The Umkhonto weSizwe party (MK) didn't simply insert itself into the dispute – it digitally amplified it, using Facebook posts, press releases and WhatsApp groups to craft a narrative that reached far beyond the farm gates of the Western Cape. The digital disruption of industrial relations The involvement of the MK party demonstrates how political parties have learned to exploit the digital revolution in ways that fundamentally challenge traditional industrial relations. When employees contacted the party for assistance, the MK party didn't simply offer advice or direct workers to appropriate legal channels. Instead, it created a parallel digital infrastructure that bypassed established negotiation mechanisms entirely. The party's WhatsApp communications coordinated meetings with management, its Facebook posts generated public sympathy for workers, and its press releases shaped media coverage – all while maintaining the pretence of merely providing 'advisory' support. This digital orchestration allowed the MK party to function as a shadow trade union while avoiding the legal responsibilities that formal representation would entail. Judge Robert Lagrange's judgment methodically dissected this digital strategy, concluding that the MK party had 'consistently assumed the role of the representative of the strikers' while simultaneously 'launching a media attack on Boomerang, portraying it in villainous terms'. The court recognised that in the digital age, representation isn't just about formal negotiations – it's about controlling the narrative that shapes public perception and influences the balance of power. The legal principle at stake is both simple and profound, but its application has become infinitely more complex in the digital era. South Africa's industrial relations system was designed for an analogue world where disputes unfolded in board rooms and on factory floors, not on social media platforms where every statement can be screenshot, shared and weaponised. The social media amplification effect The court's analysis of the MK party's digital campaign reveals how social media has fundamentally altered the dynamics of labour disputes. Traditional negotiation assumes a degree of privacy that allows parties to make concessions without losing face publicly. Digital platforms destroy this privacy, creating performative pressures that make compromise virtually impossible. The MK party's Facebook posts describing the company as a 'colonial nest' and 'active site of colonial exploitation' weren't just political rhetoric – they were strategic digital content designed to generate shares, comments and viral engagement. The party understood that in the attention economy, inflammatory language performs better than nuanced analysis. The result was a digital firestorm that bore little resemblance to the original overtime payment dispute. WhatsApp democracy and workplace organising Perhaps most significantly, the case highlights how WhatsApp has become a significant organising tool for both legitimate trade union activity and political interference. The MK party's use of WhatsApp groups to coordinate with workers, arrange meetings and distribute talking points created an informal, but highly effective communication network that traditional employers and unions struggle to understand or counter. This 'WhatsApp democracy' operates outside formal industrial relations structures, creating new possibilities for worker organisation, but also new vulnerabilities to political manipulation. The platform's end-to-end encryption makes it nearly impossible for employers to understand how disputes are being coordinated, while its group messaging functionality allows political parties to influence large numbers of workers simultaneously. The judgment also reveals how digital platforms have created expectations of real-time transparency that clash with the traditionally private nature of labour negotiations. The MK party's social media strategy assumed that followers expected constant updates, behind-the-scenes content and immediate responses to developments. This digital transparency imperative makes the patient, confidential work of genuine dispute resolution nearly impossible. When every negotiation session can be livestreamed, every concession can be immediately scrutinised by online audiences, and every statement can be taken out of context and shared widely, the incentives shift dramatically towards performative confrontation rather than problem-solving. Political parties, with their natural understanding of digital engagement, are far better positioned to exploit these dynamics than traditional trade unions or employers. Digital accountability and legal consequences Judge Lagrange's decision to confirm the interdict against the MK party represents one of the first serious judicial attempts to grapple with how digital platforms are reshaping labour relations. The court recognised that social media posts and WhatsApp messages aren't just commentary – they constitute active participation in labour disputes with real legal consequences. The costs order against the MK party is particularly significant in the digital context. By requiring the party to pay the employer's legal costs, the court has established that viral social media campaigns carry financial risks. This digital accountability principle could fundamentally alter how political parties approach online labour activism. The broader implications extend far beyond this single case. Digital platforms don't just amplify existing power dynamics – they create entirely new ones. Political parties that master social media engagement can mobilise workers more effectively than traditional trade unions, but they lack the institutional knowledge and legal obligations that make genuine representation possible. The result is what might be called 'algorithm activism' – political engagement optimised for digital metrics rather than real-world outcomes. The MK party's campaign generated thousands of shares and comments, but it ultimately prolonged the dispute and harmed the workers it claimed to represent. The digital medium had become the message, drowning out the substance of legitimate workplace grievances. Towards digital industrial relations As South Africa grapples with persistent inequality and workplace exploitation, the intersection of digital technology and labour relations will only become more complex. The Boomerang Fruits case provides a crucial precedent for how courts might approach political parties that use social media to blur the lines between advocacy and representation. The challenge ahead is developing industrial relations frameworks that can harness the democratising potential of digital platforms while preventing their exploitation by political opportunists. This will require new forms of digital literacy among trade unionists, employers and judges, as well as clearer legal guidelines about what constitutes impermissible political interference in the social media age. The labour court's firm stance in this case demonstrates that legal principles can adapt to technological change, but only if we remain vigilant about protecting the institutional boundaries that make effective labour relations possible.
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Top 10 stories of the day: US trade deal talks 'complex'
Here's your daily news update for Monday, 4 August 2025: An easy-to-read selection of our top stories. News today includes trade, industry and competition Minister Parks Tau has outlined the challenges South Africa faced during negotiations with the United States (US), as the country prepares to respond to the looming 30% tariff on its exports. Meanwhile, former president and MK party leader Jacob Zuma has demanded the resignation of President Cyril Ramaphosa for 'repeatedly violating his oath of office', giving him until 10am on Friday to do so, or he will take action against him. Furthermore, South African television personality Dlamini accused Podcast and Chill presenters of hate speech and harassment. Weather tomorrow: 4 August 2025 Light snowfall is expected in parts of the Eastern Cape, while damaging waves and very cold weather threaten to disrupt beachfront activities between parts of the Northern and Western Cape. Full weather forecast here. Stay up to date with The Citizen – More News, Your Way. US tariffs: Here's why talks over trade deal have been 'complex' Trade, industry and competition Minister Parks Tau has outlined the challenges South Africa faced during negotiations with the United States (US), as the country prepares to respond to the looming 30% tariff on its exports. The tariffs are scheduled to take effect on Friday after South Africa did not reach a trade agreement with the US before President Donald Trump's deadline. Trade minister Parks Tau and international relations minister Ronald Lamola briefing reporters on the US trade negotiations. Picture: Supplied Trump had delayed the implementation of the tariffs for 90 days in April to allow time for negotiations. CONTINUE READING: US tariffs: Here's why talks over trade deal have been 'complex' Motorists could become targets of aggressive revenue collection operations by JMPD, says DA The DA in Gauteng has accused the City of Johannesburg of using Johannesburg Metropolitan Police Department (JMPD) officers to collect revenue for the struggling municipality. The party says it has been reliably informed that JMPD officers have been told to collect R7000 in fines daily. A JMPD officer directs traffic. Picture: The Citizen/Nigel Sibanda The officers also have the option of working overtime to help them reach the target. CONTINUE READING: Motorists could become targets of aggressive revenue collection operations by JMPD, says DA Zuma demands Ramaphosa resign by Friday, or else… Former president and MK party leader Jacob Zuma has demanded the resignation of President Cyril Ramaphosa for 'repeatedly violating his oath of office', giving him until 10am on Friday to do so, or he will take action against him. Zuma and the MK party are still reeling from their Constitutional Court loss, which dismissed their urgent application to invalidate Ramaphosa's decision to place Minister of Police Senzo Mchunu on a leave of absence, appoint Wits law professor Firoz Cachalia as acting police minister and establish a commission of inquiry. President Cyril Ramaphosa and former president Jacob Zuma. Picture: The Witness However, Zuma is not happy and has now written to Ramaphosa through his attorneys, demanding answers to questions related to Mchunu and Cachalia. CONTINUE READING: Zuma demands Ramaphosa resign by Friday, or else… Are there any safe cars left on SA roads? NCC issues another vehicle recall Week after week, the National Consumer Commission (NCC) has issued a product recall of certain car models due to issues that can lead to serious injury. The latest recall is of a Lexus LX600 due to an issue that can greatly increase the risk of an accident, especially at higher speeds. The NCC is a body that protects consumers by ensuring that businesses comply with consumer protection laws and treat customers fairly. Picture: iStock The Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 safeguards consumers from hazards and ensures their well-being and safety by governing product recalls. The NCC can order a recall if a product is deemed unsafe or poses a potential risk to the public. CONTINUE READING: Are there any safe cars left on SA roads? NCC issues another vehicle recall Minnie Dlamini sues MacG and Sol Phenduka for R2.5 million over podcast remarks This high-profile case puts the spotlight on gender-based discrimination in digital media and could set a landmark legal precedent. South African television personality Dlamini accused Podcast and Chill presenters of hate speech and harassment. Minnie Dlamini attends the world premiere of Disney's Mufasa: The Lion King at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood, California on December 09, 2024. Picture:for Disney In court documents submitted last week, according to Sunday World, Dlamini is seeking legal accountability, demanding R1 million for herself and an additional R1.5 million to be donated to a women's organisation. CONTINUE READING: Minnie Dlamini sues MacG and Sol Phenduka for R2.5 million over podcast remarks Here are five more stories of the day: Yesterday's News recap READ HERE: Here's how many illegal foreigners tried to enter SA | Lesufi reshuffles several heads of departments | Sibiya hits back at Mkhwanazi
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Allegations of quota-driven traffic fines raise concerns among Joburg motorists
Motorists in Johannesburg are increasingly becoming cash cows for the city, as alarming allegations emerged that Johannesburg Metropolitan Police Department (JMPD) officers are being pressured to issue a minimum of R7 000 in traffic fines per day. The Democratic Alliance (DA) has criticised the alleged quota system, denouncing it as both unethical and unlawful political interference. The party is calling on Gauteng Premier Panyaza Lesufi to urgently eliminate all revenue-driven policing targets and reinstate integrity within law enforcement. Michael Sun, DA spokesperson for Community Safety, said JMPD officers are being incentivised with overtime pay, turning law enforcement into a money-making exercise instead of focusing on public safety. 'To incentivise compliance with these targets, officers are reportedly provided with overtime payments, effectively transforming law enforcement into a commission-based revenue scheme. This pushes JMPD officers to aggressively pursue fines instead of focusing on their duties, such as bylaw enforcement, traffic management, and crime prevention.' He added that these concerning claims align with the growing trend of JMPD conducting excessive and random roadblocks at busy intersections, not for public safety, but to boost fine collection. 'Many of these operations are non-compliant with the National Road Traffic Act and SAPS Standing Orders. By reclassifying illegal roadblocks as 'roadside checks', JMPD evades crucial legal requirements, including proper authorisation by a senior officer, clear signage, adequate warning to motorists, among others,' Sun added. Responding to the allegations, JMPD spokesperson Xolani Fihla dismissed the DA's claims as false, stating: 'The JMPD would like to emphasise that our enforcement operations are conducted with the primary goal of maintaining safety and order on the city's roads.' He added that issuing citations is a normal part of an officer's duty when motorists violate traffic laws, describing it as a necessary step to curb lawlessness and encourage responsible driving. However, he firmly denied the existence of any quota system, stating: 'There is no quota that officers are expected to meet.' Fihla reiterated that the department's main priority is promoting compliance with traffic regulations to enhance road safety, not to meet any set number of fines. 'The performance of our officers is measured by their overall effectiveness in creating a safer environment for the community, and one of the ways is to issue citations, not by a predetermined target for fines. The integrity of our operations is paramount, and all actions are taken in strict accordance with the law,' he added. Political analyst Kenneth Mokgatlhe expressed concern over the alleged political interference, saying if the claims are accurate, it represents 'political interference of the highest degree.' He added, 'Corrupt politicians who have looted public funds are now trying to fix their financial mess by targeting poor motorists. The City of Johannesburg (CoJ) financial crisis is well-documented, and they are definitely looking for a shortcut to solve their financial conundrum. Remember that the treasury is on their case regarding their wasteful expenditure.' Mokgatlhe criticised Gauteng Premier Panyaza Lesufi, saying he often creates the illusion of action through noise and public spectacle rather than genuinely addressing pressing issues. 'He's all talk and no action. What happened to the poorly performing Heads of Department in his province? Instead of firing them, he simply reshuffled them. 'The ANC leaders are soft when they deal with corruption, especially when members of their factions are involved. Lesufi will not do anything regarding the deteriorating situation at CoJ because he failed to address the crisis at Emfuleni.' He added. With allegations such as these levelled against JMPD, motorists might wonder how the AARTO demerit system will be applied fairly, without putting pressure on metro police officers to meet certain traffic fine targets. The AARTO rollout is scheduled to begin in December 2025, but the points demerit system will not come into effect until 1 September 2026. This important reform aims to encourage responsible driving by assigning demerit points for traffic violations. Accumulating too many points? You could face licence suspensions or cancellations. Organisations such as OUTA (Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse) and The Automobile Association (AA) have voiced opposition to the demerit system, with OUTA stating: 'It does not address the root causes of accidents, the risk of corruption, and administrative cumbersomeness.' The Star [email protected]
