Isle of Man chief minister's gaslighting remark 'unacceptable'
A Tynwald committee has called for the Isle of Man's chief minister to withdraw remarks that accused the former health minister of "gaslighting".Alfred Cannan said Lawrie Hooper's resignation speech on 15 October was a "fabrication" of facts and accused him of "gaslighting" the Council of Ministers and the public over Manx Care's funding.The full response was delivered by Cannan a day later in Tynwald, while Hooper was away on parliamentary business.The Tynwald Standards and Members' Interests Committee found the chief minister's remarks were "unacceptable" and he had delivered "a public attack on Mr Hooper's character".
In Hooper's resignation statement in October, he said: "I cannot in good conscience continue to serve a chief minister who has set out to both publicly and privately undermine my ability to do the job that is required."He added that he believed Cannan had an "ultimate aim to try and privatise our health service". On 16 October, when Hooper was not present, Cannan responded: "That statement on privatisation was of course a fabrication. "It is a falsehood and a slur on the Council of Ministers."Cannan also accused Hooper of gaslighting the Council of Ministers and the public by stating the island's health service was underfunded.
Hooper reported the remarks to the Tynwald Standards and Members' Interests Committee. It reviewed the comments made during the October Tynwald sitting, as well as the later House of Keys meeting on 29 October when members debated a motion of no confidence in the chief minister, which ultimately failed.During the discussion several members criticised referred to Cannan's remarks about Hooper. In response Cannan said "where I have fallen short, I am sorry".In its report the committee said: "Accusations of lying are unacceptable."It concluded Cannan's language had been "unacceptable" and "it is not acceptable parliamentary practice for one member to characterise what another member has said as fabrication, falsehood or gaslighting".The committee called for the chief minister to formally withdraw his remarks in May's Tynwald sitting. It has also recommended training for all members "in the principles of parliamentary language and debate".
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
03-06-2025
- BBC News
Hundreds of Isle of Man patients affected by NHS data error
More than 430 patients on the Isle of Man have been subject to a data error resulting in their home addresses being changed to UK ones, Manx Care has said. The island's healthcare provider said NHS England had incorrectly recorded temporary UK residences as permanent addresses for island residents who were receiving treatment there. A spokeswoman said that so far about 446 patients had been affected, with further cases likely to be confirmed as "awareness increases".She said Manx Care was "actively collaborating" with UK healthcare bodies and integrated care boards to "improve how address changes are managed, particularly for patients moving between the Isle of Man and the UK". NHS systems on the Isle of Man and in the UK work independently, but data is shared when address changes are made. The Manx Care spokeswoman said: "In some cases the UK system assumed a permanent relocation rather than a temporary visit."This led to "unintended updates to patient records", she added. Missed appointments Manx Care said it was contacting GP practices to verify permanent addresses to all of those affected by the error and had reiterated "the importance of not replacing records" to UK health the health body has urged anyone who has been treated in the UK and expected correspondence from Manx Care, to get in touch with their GP practice to "review your records".Potential impacts on care could mean people miss or have delayed invitations for routine screenings or appointments at Noble's Hospital. Manx Care said that despite the error, patients would not lose their places at their Manx GP healthcare body apologised for "any confusion or disruption" and said people's "health and peace of mind [were] top priorities". Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
BBC News
30-05-2025
- BBC News
Isle of Man learning disability care reform needed, review finds
The normalisation of restrictive practices and and mismatch of accommodation were among issues identified in a review of care for adults with learning findings have been published in an independent review by specialists Cordis Bright into the residential care services provided on the Isle of review was commissioned by Manx Care after a number of safeguarding concerns were raised in the autumn of executive Teresa Cope said the report identified "significant areas for improvement" but the organisation was "fully committed to supporting adults with learning disabilities". In the wake of the review the organisation would "work with partners across the system to build a strategy for the future", she report found that in some cases people cared for in residential homes faced restrictive measures such as lack of access to the kitchen because other residents risked hurting themselves if if allowed to use the facilities, for example by drinking from a kettle. 'Inappropriate workarounds' In a limited number of cases residents who could not safely spend time together were sometimes restricted to their own rooms to avoid contact, the review said. It also found restrictive practices put in place for extended periods of time to maintain the safety of residents were were often in response to staffing key challenge identified was that people were placed into one of the 17 residential homes based on availability rather than suitability. This, the review said, meant that there were people who were living together whose support needs were "very different".That could lead to those with high needs contending with people who are more able than them, and those with lower needs may be placed under "undue restrictions", the review homes had also been "poorly maintained or had become shabby", with some having issues such as persistent damp or leaks, or needing repairs, the review some cases, "inappropriate workarounds" became the norm, the review said, with one home still without from the report included ensuring greater variety of options for support, and reducing the current "over reliance on residential care", better engagement with family members, and a property strategy to improve accommodation options. Another key recommendation was the creation of a workforce strategy to address issues of low morale, ensure appropriate training and meet the need for a greater variety of care, the review added. Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
BBC News
28-05-2025
- BBC News
Isle of man ministers to hold roadshow to gather public views
Government ministers are set to face the public in a series of regional meetings starting next events, featuring members of the Isle of Man Council of Ministers, will be held at state-run secondary schools in Ramsey, Castletown, Douglas and Peel from 30 June to 3 Listening to You roadshow follows a series of similar workshops held in April Minister Alfred Cannan said it was "crucial" for ministers to "meet and engage with the public on issues that impact everyday lives". He said there was "real value in making sure politicians are accessible to the public" and the conversations meant ministers could understand any "concerns and priorities at first hand".The meetings would help government ministers make "informed decisions" that reflect the needs of the population, he said. The meetings are set to include a welcome and speech by the chief minister, followed by time for one-to-one conversations with ministers before politicians answer questions from the said it was "crucial" for politicians to listen to the public but was "equally important for the public to meet ministers to ask questions and receive a reply in the moment, in person". He said the sessions were designed to "foster transparency and trust in government" and would allow government's wider aims to be shared "to ensure that policies are aligned with the interests of people in the Isle of Man". 'Meaningful conversations' Encouraged young people to join the events he said: "By participating, you can be part of meaningful conversations and help to influence the decisions that shape our community."The meetings will be held on consecutive nights starting at Ramsey Grammar School in Ramsey on 30 June, followed by Ballakermeen High School in Douglas, Castle Rushen High School in Castletown and ending at Queen Elizabeth II High School in Peel on 3 July. Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
