Erin Patterson: Key question remaining after mushroom trial
Patterson's motivation for poisoning four in-laws with deadly mushrooms was only briefly addressed as her blockbuster trial played out in Victoria's southwest this year.
Prosecutors said they would not be putting forward a motive, explaining sometimes a killer's reasons remain only known to them, while her defence argued she had 'anti-motive', or reasons to want her victims alive.
The 50-year-old was on Monday found guilty of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder by a jury after seven days of deliberations.
She had pleaded not guilty, with her defence arguing the case was a tragic accident.
In his final remarks to the jury, Justice Christopher Beale said the prosecution does not need to prove a motive to make out the charges of murder and attempted murder.
'For some murders there may be evidence of motive, but some murders occur for no apparent reason,' he said.
'The motives for such murders may only ever be known to the offenders.'
He told the jury the prosecution had agreed there was no known reason why Patterson did what she was ultimately found guilty of.
'It's the allegations of murder and attempted murder the prosecution has to prove, nothing else,' the judge said.
'But that does not mean that the absence of the evidence of a motive to kill is irrelevant. It is a relevant consideration, which you must take into account in the accused's favour when weighing all the evidence in this case.'
Crown prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC touched on motive in her closing address, saying while the prosecution was not putting one forward; 'you don't have to know why a person does something in order to know they did it'.
Dr Rogers said the evidence in the trial shows the relationship between Patterson and her in-laws was 'not always a harmonious one'.
The prosecutor pointed to Simon's account of tension in their relationship in late 2022 over the issue of child support, with Don and Gail 'dragged unwillingly' into the conflict.
She said child protection practitioner Katrina Cripps had given evidence Patterson described Simon as 'nasty' after that conflict and their son's evidence the relationship was 'very negative'.
Dr Rogers suggested Patterson was leading a 'duplicitous life', presenting a positive face to the Patterson family while sharing her real feelings to her online friends, several of whom gave evidence.
' … the evidence shows, you might think, that the divide between the accused and her in-laws was deeper than they ever knew,' Dr Rogers said.
'She expressed her real feelings about them and the broader Patterson family to her online friends.'
Dr Rogers turned to a series of messages in December 2022 from Patterson to her online friends, where she called them a 'lost cause', mocked their religious beliefs and wrote; 'this family I swear to God'.
Patterson's barrister, Colin Mandy SC, questioned why the prosecution had focused so much on a brief period of tension in 2022 when they weren't putting forward a motive.
'They spent so much time in this trial scratching around to try and find some suggestion of … animosity in the family dynamics,' he said.
'There's no anger or aggression. There's not hatred or anything remotely approaching that.
'Not even between Simon and Erin and certainly not between Erin and Simon's parents.'
Turning to the messages Patterson sent to her online friends, Mr Mandy labelled it an 'aberration' in her relationship with the Patterson family that only spanned a few days.
'Erin made a handful of comments in the context of being hurt and frustrated about these responses she was getting from Don and Gail, in the context of her issues with Simon, and that's it,' he said.
'And you might think that venting in that way is a pretty healthy thing to do.'
The defence barrister said the prosecution's case had ignored the years of love and support shown by the family to Patterson.
'Erin Patterson had a motive to keep these people in her world so that they could keep supporting her and her children, especially her children,' he said.
'Why would she take wonderful, active, loving grandparents away from her own children?'
He further questioned why she would kill Ian and Heather, who she 'hardly knew' aside from the church community.
Mr Mandy said the evidence in the trial showed his client was a person of good character; a devoted mother of two with no prior convictions and close relationships with her in-laws, particularly Don and Gail.
He agreed motive was not one of the four elements of murder the prosecution had to provide beyond reasonable doubt, but suggested it was an important consideration on the issue of his client's intention.
'Our argument to you is that motive is very important to the proof of intention and usually fundamental to it,' he said.
'Without a motive, you're left guessing about the most important element of the offence in this trial and that's intention.'
Patterson will return to court at a later date.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Perth Now
29 minutes ago
- Perth Now
‘Large sentence' looms for triple-murderer mushroom cook
After a first night behind bars, Erin Patterson now faces the grim reality of spending the rest of her life in prison, convicted of one of Australia's most shocking murders. The 50-year-old mother of two was found guilty on Monday of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder, following a lengthy and closely watched trial. Her estranged husband's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, both 70, and his aunt, Heather Wilkinson, 66, died in hospital days after eating a beef Wellington meal laced with deadly death cap mushrooms at a family lunch in July 2023. Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, was the sole survivor, left to recover from the poisoning that shocked the nation. There was a shout of 'murderer' as Patterson was driven out of the court precinct to prison in Melbourne on Monday evening. The jury's guilty verdicts came seven days after they were sent away to deliberate and 11 weeks into the trial in the Victorian town of Morwell. Brianna Chesser, a clinical forensic psychologist and criminal lawyer, said she was not surprised by the outcome. She argued Patterson's testimony across eight days on the witness stand, as well as circumstantial evidence, likely proved critical to convincing the jury beyond reasonable doubt. 'Whenever you have any lies in a trial it is quite a difficult thing to overcome from a defence perspective,' the Associate Professor in Criminology and Justice at RMIT University told AAP. 'What came out regarding the mushrooms was almost insurmountable. 'When you've got particular searches on your phone and a dehydrator that you had and didn't have, it really speaks to the unusualness of the circumstances.' The story had captivated the world because of the method, as well as the now-convicted murderer being a woman when the vast majority of homicides were perpetrated by men, Dr Chesser said. Patterson faces a sentence of life in prison for the three murders and one attempted murder and is expected to return to court for a pre-sentence hearing later in 2025. Options for appeal were usually restricted to points of law, a 'massive' error in fact or new evidence, Dr Chesser said. 'It's going to be quite a large sentence,' she said. 'We've heard during the cross-examination and examination in chief that there are some mental health concerns for Ms Patterson. 'That may well act a mitigating factor in any sort of sentence. 'We're also dealing with someone who's a middle-aged woman who has never offended before in their life and we've got four of the most serious crimes in Victoria being committed.' Within hours of the verdict, the Supreme Court released dozens of pieces of evidence that helped prosecutors secure the convictions. They included photos showing remnants of beef Wellington leftovers as they were tested by toxicologists, after police found them inside a bin at Patterson's home. Mushroom lunch leftovers taken from Erin Patterson's home. Supplied Credit: Supplied The mushrooms inside were finely chopped. Supplied by the Court Credit: Supplied A video of Patterson discharging herself from Leongatha Hospital minutes after she had arrived was also released, while images of her at the hospital revealed a pink phone police say they never recovered. Prosecutors said this was Patterson's primary phone in 2023 and claimed she had used it to find death cap mushrooms online. - With AAP

ABC News
38 minutes ago
- ABC News
Australian police to be embedded in Fiji's Police Force under new measures
On the program today Australian Federal Police will be embedded in Fiji's Police Force as part of a new raft of measures to strengthen the Vuvale Partnership between the two countries. A historic chiefly installation is gets underway in the Lau islands in Fiji. Papua New Guinea's Prime Minister James Marape says witnesses to so-called sorcery killings will soon be prosecuted alongside perpetrators. Nuclear radiation survivors in Guam are left heartbroken after being left out of a compensation act under Donald Trump's "Big, Beautiful Bill." Monolithic statues from the remote Polynesian island of Rapa Nui pop up in museums and private collections. And Australia's Victorian Government grants cultural exemptions for the use of machetes.

The Age
an hour ago
- The Age
Brisbane news live: E-biker charged with riding dangerously, assaulting cop
Latest posts E-bike crackdown: Man charged with riding dangerously, assaulting cop By A Brisbane man has been charged with seven offences during a police crackdown on illegal e-bikes. Officers allege the 19-year-old was seen riding an illegal e-bike down Elizabeth Street in the CBD before police flagged him down. He then attempted to flee on the bike before being arrested, police said. Bodycam footage shared by Queensland Police shows the man trying to ride away. He was stopped and detained by an officer on foot shortly afterwards. A search of his belongings then allegedly uncovered a used pipe. The man was charged with seven offences including one count of dangerous operation of a vehicle, assault of a police officer, driving an uninsured vehicle and possessing dangerous drugs. He will face Brisbane Magistrates Court on August 6. 6.51am Sun all day but city to remain cool After another chilly winter's dawn, Brisbane is set for its sunniest day of the week today. But with no cloud cover, the top temperature should hover at a cool 22 degrees, with a 'feels like' temperature far lower. Clouds could return tomorrow, which will hopefully ensure more warmth is trapped during the day. Here's the seven-day outlook: 6.24am While you were sleeping Here's what's making news further afield this morning: 'Do I have to keep suffering through this?': An outburst the jury never heard would quietly define the first days of Erin Patterson's murder trial. Patterson had an interest in mushrooms, and the lonely outskirts of Gippsland were the perfect place to find an unlikely murder weapon. 'I am a psychologist,' writes Mary Hahn-Thomsen. 'I know this kind of personality – and why Erin did it.' In other news, both Coalition and Labor politicians always repeat the same line about national security – that it is the government's No.1 priority to keep Australians secure. But the female personnel of the armed forces are not guaranteed personal safety, even as they devote their professional lives to protecting ours. The Reserve Bank is expected to follow up its May rate cut with another today – just in time for US President Donald Trump to release his newest tariff plan. Former British prime minister Tony Blair's think tank worked on a post-war plan for Gaza that included a 'Trump Riviera' inspired by Dubai. 5.53am The top stories this morning Good morning, welcome to Brisbane Times' live news coverage for Tuesday, July 8. Today will be sunny with a top temperature of 22 degrees. In this morning's local headlines: Here's what we know so far about the horror attack at Darling Downs Zoo, where a woman lost her arm when she was mauled by a lion. The academy of former NRL star and 'King of the North' Johnathan Thurston is embroiled in a damaging legal battle. Now, they've turned to Kyle Sandilands' former manager for help. Star Entertainment says its negotiations with Hong Kong investors to sell its stake in the glitzy Brisbane precinct has hit a standstill, revealing an extension to the termination notice. Queensland has only one postcode featured in the latest S&P Global Ratings list of the 10 worst-performing postcodes. bestowing him with the fullback jumper, despite some calls for Reece Walsh to be parachuted back into the State of Origin fold.