
Pool body sued by transgender player forced to crowdfund money for defence
A pool federation being sued by a transgender player it banned from women's events is crowdfunding to pay for its defence, stating the cost involved would 'possibly prove beyond our means'.
Harriet Haynes has taken the English Blackpool Pool Federation (EBPF) to court after it changed its eligibility criteria in August 2023 to stop those born male playing on its female tour and county tournaments.
The case is being heard this week at Canterbury county court, with Haynes claiming the EBPF's move amounted to discrimination that had caused her a 'loss of opportunity' and 'injured feelings'.
The EBPF launched a crowdfunding campaign to help pay for its defence on the Go Get Funding website, something that had raised more than £6,600 by Wednesday morning.
On a page entitled, 'Help us defend our female Blackball competitions from litigation', the EBPF described itself as a 'non profit' sports federation 'wholly run by volunteers'.
Stating 'the cost of defending our stance for fair play will be substantial and possibly prove beyond our means', it added of its rule change: 'We made this decision in the interests of fairness, because we believe that people who have gone through male puberty have a competitive advantage over biological women.
'As a consequence of this decision, we are being sued by the transgender player Harriet Haynes. Harriet says that the eligibility rules for the female tour are discriminatory on the grounds of gender reassignment. We say that the rules are necessary to secure fair competition and a justified means of promoting female participation in the game.
'We are disappointed that Harriet has chosen to sue an organisation made up entirely of volunteers who give up their time to promote the game of pool in England, but we stand by our decision, and we intend to defend the claim.'
The page was created by the EBPF's chairman, Paul Thomson, and secretary, Anna Goodwin, who were in court on Tuesday defending its position.
Thomson told Canterbury county court that the governing body made its decision following an 'unreal' number of complaints from players.
The court was told around 15-20 anonymous written complaints had been passed to Goodwin but Thomson said many more had been raised personally with members of the EBPF's executive committee.
He also said Haynes was not allowed to play in EBPF events purely because of 'the fact Harriet is a biological male'.
He explained: 'I think the subject was kind of taboo to a certain degree. In this day and age, you can't come out and say what you want to say, because you get called a bigot or transphobic.'
When asked by Haynes' counsel, Robin White, why he had not consulted with transgender players before changing the EBPF's rules, Thomson replied: 'What about the hundreds and hundreds of other women that it affected, am I just supposed to ignore that?
'We had loads of complaints. The amount of complaints was unreal.'
He added: 'As a pool player, I know that males are far superior than what women are at playing pool.'
Goodwin told the court the EBPF's men's category was made into an 'open section' to make it inclusive of all those born male.
She said the decision had been made 'because we didn't think it was fair on our female players', adding: 'We didn't exclude transgender people. We made a section in the open section for them to play.'
What is thought to be the first lawsuit of its kind brought by a transgender athlete in the UK could prove a landmark case in pool and beyond over rules designed to stop those born male taking part in female-only competitions.
A hearing began on Monday, the day after Haynes and Lucy Smith faced off in the Ultimate Pool Women's Pro Series Event 2 at Robin Park Leisure Centre in Wigan on Sunday.
Their match witnessed protests from demonstrators who shouted, 'He's a man and we stand stand with Lynne Pinches', and held up banners saying, 'Save women's sport', and, 'He's a man', as Haynes walked past.
Pinches is the player who forfeited a 2023 final in protest at the participation of Haynes and is part of a separate legal action against the Ultimate Pool Group and World Eightball Pool Federation over their refusal to ban transgender women from their own events.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


BBC News
04-05-2025
- BBC News
Derbyshire battle back to leave Glamorgan contest wide open
Rothesay County Championship Division Two, Sophia Gardens, Cardiff (day three)Glamorgan 431: Ingram 81 & 132-5: Ingram 64, Ul Hassan 48; Tickner 2-19Derbyshire 350 (107 overs): Reece 73*, Thomson 60; Gorvin 5-85Glamorgan (6 pts) lead Derbyshire (5 pts) by 213 runs with five second-innings wickets standingMatch scorecard Derbyshire bounced back in style against Glamorgan as the home side took a lead of 213 into the final day with five wickets Ingram made 64 and Zain Ul Hassan 48 as Glamorgan recovered from 15-3 to 132-5 to leave the game evenly Reece, batting with a runner because of a hamstring injury, top-scored with a brave 73 not out as Derbyshire avoided the follow-on comfortably to reach Thomson's 60 was a career-best as Derbyshire battled back from 162-7 despite Andy Gorvin's five-wicket haul. Resuming on 336-6, Reece and Thomson extended their eighth-wicket stand to 105 with relatively few alarms and got to within 15 of saving the new ball saw Timm van der Gugten account for Thomson, but Zak Chappell helped Reece past the target of 282 before Gorvin bowled him to claim his fifth passed 5,000 first-class runs for the visitors with a pulled six, before last man Blair Tickner swung wildly to frustrate the struggling Glamorgan attack in a first session extended by 40 minutes. Resilient Derbyshire even managed a third batting point as the last-wicket stand reached 62 before Tickner (28) was bowled by Asitha Star Wars Day, the force was with Derbyshire as they claimed three early wickets, having seen their own last three bat for a further three hours on the third high-stepping paceman Tickner and Anuj Dal swapped ends almost immediately to devastating effect with Asa Tribe, Sam Northeast and Kiran Carlson dismissed in successive Ingram's calmness and the nuggety approach of Ul Hassan saw them put together a patient partnership of struck seven fours and lofted Thomson for six but was bowled sweeping at the next ball as the tall off-spinner started to extract runs later, Chappell got one to lift on Ul Hassan to have him caught behind, and Derbyshire were back in the hunt as they delivered six maidens in a row to end the day.


Pembrokeshire Herald
28-04-2025
- Pembrokeshire Herald
Sean Bowen achieves lifelong ambition with Champion Jockey title
SEAN BOWEN has realised his boyhood dream after being crowned Champion Jockey, rounding off a remarkable season of dedication, success and resilience. The 27-year-old from Pembrokeshire clocked up an astonishing 75,000 miles over the season, with 902 rides and 180 winners to his name — a journey that ended with him making history as the first Welsh champion since Fred Winter in 1958. Earlier this year, Bowen reached 1,000 career wins, but his sights were firmly set on claiming the championship crown. 'Reaching 1,000 wins was an incredible milestone, something not many jockeys get to experience,' Bowen said. 'But becoming Champion Jockey has been my real dream for the last few years. I gave it everything after missing out last year.' Bowen's previous attempt at the title ended in heartbreak after a Boxing Day knee injury derailed his campaign while he was leading. This season, he was determined not to let history repeat itself. 'I knew I had to start fast and keep the pressure on,' he said. 'Harry Skelton pushed me hard around Christmas, but I managed to rebuild the lead. It's been relentless, but every mile, every ride, was worth it for this.' The physical and mental demands of the season were immense, but Bowen remained focused. 'It's tough, not having a day off, always chasing rides. I've kept myself fit, but it takes just as much strength mentally. I hate the idea of someone else winning on a horse I should have been riding — that keeps me moving, even if it means driving across the country in a day,' he said. Family at the heart of success Bowen paid tribute to his parents, Peter and Karen Bowen, both respected trainers, who supported his career from the very beginning. 'Mum and Dad sacrificed so much, driving thousands of miles just so we could race ponies. Seeing how hard they worked made me want to work just as hard,' he said. He also praised his partner, Harriet, for standing by him through the challenges of the racing calendar. 'Harriet has been amazing. I barely see her during the season. We're getting married in July, and I can't wait for some proper time together on our honeymoon.' Finishing on a high Bowen's final week of the season couldn't have been scripted better. He rode a remarkable five winners at Ffos Las — his home track — a career first that left him 'over the moon.' 'That five-timer was something special — in front of my family and the Welsh crowd too. It's a day I'll remember forever,' he said. He followed it up by winning the Irish Grand National aboard Haiti Couleurs, trained by Rebecca Curtis — another proud moment for Welsh racing. 'Winning the Irish Grand National was the biggest moment of my career,' Bowen said. 'To win for a Welsh trainer and beat the Irish on their turf made it even sweeter.' To put the icing on the cake, he capped off the season with victory in the Bet365 Gold Cup at Sandown, riding Resplendent Grey for trainer Olly Murphy. From childhood dreams to standing at the top of the sport, Sean Bowen's journey has come full circle — and he is not done yet.


The Sun
27-04-2025
- The Sun
Former Crucible world champion Dennis Taylor wants talks with Barry Hearn over creating incredible new snooker venue
DENNIS TAYLOR wants snooker bosses to establish a Hall of Fame where he can exhibit his 1985 Black Ball final cue and unorthodox glasses. Monday is the 40th anniversary of the moment when Taylor came from 8-0 and 9-1 down to beat the reigning champion Steve Davis 18-17, the result being settled on the last black. 2 2 The thrilling finale was watched by more than 18 million people and is still remembered and talked about four decades on. Taylor – who can still out-party men half his age – has got the world championship-winning cue at home, even though his late Westie dog did chew the end off. And he is keen for his famous upside-down specs to go somewhere special that they can be shown off for future generations. The Northern Ireland potter, 76, said: 'Somebody once wanted to buy the glasses and cue off me. But that's something I would never sell. 'It's something to hand out to the family. I don't know why our association don't make some sort of museum where we can leave memorabilia. 'If there was a Hall of Fame, I would possibly leave the cue and glasses. 'I might even suggest that. It's an idea because people have trophies that they would put in a Hall of Fame. 'We will have to see if Mr Barry Hearn might be interested.' BEST ONLINE CASINOS - TOP SITES IN THE UK Taylor and Davis, 67, have been commemorating the much-loved contest with a series of Road Show events across the UK, including one at the Crucible earlier this month. The idea is that at the end of every night, Taylor has the chance to sink the final black, and the crowds keep on coming. Celtic-daft snooker ace John Higgins aims brutal dig at Rangers after Hoops' title triumph Asked why he thinks people still talk about that special moment, Taylor said: 'I think it's the fact that nobody was beating Steve in the 80s, he was dominating the game. 'He never gave me a chance in the first session. He totally outplayed me. I was sitting in my seat all afternoon. 'The fact I had gone so far behind and then I won the last six frames in the evening with most of the frames won with one-visit. It captured the imagination. 'All of a sudden people were tuning in. They were cancelling programmes to stay with the final. 'How nearly 19 million people nearly stayed up after midnight, I'll never know. 'And it was probably more because the number of people that tell me, 'Oh we were in a club, and they kept the club open, there were probably 40 of us around the TV sets'. 'Who knows how many people actually watched that final.'