Fine witnesses who mislead select committees, MP urges
According Parliament's rulebook Erskine May, the Commons has not imposed a fine in 359 years, since 1666, the year the Great Fire of London broke out.
'Of course, there is the ministerial code, there are the Nolan Principles, and there is the contempt of Parliament procedures, but there hasn't been a fine since that time,' Mr Pritchard told the Commons.
'And for members and non-members alike, what is the deterrent? What is the incentive, even, for telling the truth to this place?
'Ministers of course can be brought back to the House, correct the record, but people giving evidence to select committees? There really is a gap at the moment.
'Isn't it time we put fines on a statutory basis for members and non-members alike so that we can always be assured that people are incentivised to tell the truth, and have a deterrent should they be tempted not to tell the truth?'
A recreation of the Great Fire Of London of 1666, the same year a fine was last issued by the Commons (Hannah McKay/PA)
Commons Leader Lucy Powell said Mr Pritchard had raised a 'very, very serious issue'.
She added that there are 'many, many ways for members to hold ministers account', including by raising points of order, asking questions, and making complaints through a standards procedure.
Conservative MP Mr Pritchard later told the PA news agency: 'The current sanctions for ministers and MPs work quite well, but for non-member witnesses giving evidence to Parliament, the sanctions are weak to non-existent.
'Fines for contempt before a select committee, for example, need to be put on a statutory footing.
'This will act as both a deterrent and incentive for all public officials and external witnesses who might be tempted, on the rarest of occasions, to mislead Parliament whilst giving evidence before any of Parliament's committees.'
The Wrekin MP added: 'Currently, anyone apart from members and ministers can lie to Parliament, if they were so tempted, and get away with it.
'That is a significant gap in Parliament's powers to scrutinise.
'Other Parliaments have considerably more powers than Westminster to sanction anyone who lies to the legislature.'
New Zealand's House of Representatives is one such Parliament, where its members can agree to fine people up to 1,000 US dollars for contempt.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
4 minutes ago
- The Independent
Funding golf tournament was not attempt to ‘butter up' Trump, says Swinney
Scottish Government funding for a golf tournament at Donald Trump's Aberdeenshire course was not an attempt to 'butter up' the US president, John Swinney has said. The Government announced on Saturday, just days before the First Minister met Mr Trump, that £180,000 of public money would be spent to bring the Nexo Championship to Scotland next month. Mr Swinney said he had 'courteous' talks with Mr Trump on Tuesday morning, ahead of the official opening of a second course in Aberdeenshire. Gifts were also exchanged ahead of the meeting, with Mr Swinney giving the US president framed historic documents showing his family connections to Scotland, and a map of the Isle of Lewis. In return Mr Trump gave the First Minister an American bald eagle figurine. The leaders discussed the situation in Gaza and tariffs on Scotch whisky, which Mr Swinney said the president appeared to be willing to move on. Speaking to the PA news agency, the First Minister said the tournament funding was not to curry favour with the president. Asked if it was an effort to 'butter up' Mr Trump, he said: 'No, I think what I was trying to do is to make sure that a tournament that was coming to Scotland could be properly promoted. 'It's coming here, we've essentially intervened to secure a tournament quite late in the day.' Mr Swinney added that the Government provides cash to the Royal and Ancient Golf Club (R&A) in St Andrews. 'If the principle is good enough for the R&A, it's good enough for Trump International,' he said. Asked about his relationship with Mr Trump following his first face-to-face meetings with the leader, Mr Swinney said there had been 'very good and courteous' conversations between the two. 'I think we talked well about the issues that matter to the people of Scotland,' he said. 'He has a deep affinity with Scotland, so he's got a warmth and an empathy towards Scotland and he was interested in all the issues that I was raising about Scotland. 'So I think we had a very welcome opportunity to engage in dialogue and to build a relationship.' Asked if he believes that positive relationship will continue into the future, the First Minister said he does, adding the president ended the meeting by urging him to contact the US administration should he wish to raise any issues. 'I intend to take him up on that issue, because my job as First Minister of Scotland is to promote and protect the interests of the country and I can engage constructively with the president of the United States to do that,' Mr Swinney added. As well as a meeting early on Tuesday, the First Minister was also invited to a dinner on Monday evening at the Aberdeenshire club alongside Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer. Over a meal of langoustines and beef, the First Minister had his first face-to-face meeting with the US president – having spoken over the phone after his election win last November.
STV News
4 minutes ago
- STV News
What did Donald Trump say while in Scotland?
Donald Trump has left Scotland after a five-day working holiday. He met with political leaders and made comments about the UK-US trade deal, starvation in Gaza, and applying pressure on Vladimir Putin to end the war in Ukraine. The US President also cut the ribbon and teed off in celebration of a new 18-hole course at his Trump International Golf Links on the Menie Estate in Aberdeenshire. Here's a round-up of what he said while he was here. Getty Images Donald Trump meets with Prime Minister Keir Starmer at Turnberry. 'My mother was born in Scotland, and it's an incredible place, a beautiful place,' he told reporters as he stood on the steps of his Turnberry golf resort. Trump said he has a 'great love' for Scotland and that he wanted the country to 'thrive'. He said his mother Mary Anne MacLeod would return to her homeland 'once a year' for a visit. 'So yeah, it gives me a feeling, you know it's different, you go to another country, you have no relationship to it… but it's different when your mother was born here,' he said. The President also said he did not want to 'get involved' in British domestic politics when asked for his opinion on plans for a second referendum on Scottish independence. Trump referred to the suggestion that such a referendum could only take place once in a generation, telling reporters: 'There was a little bit of a restriction, like 50 or 75 years, before you could take another vote because, you know, a country can't go through that too much.' Speaking about the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, Trump said the children 'look very hungry'. The President has said he is 'working together' with Israel 'to try and get things straightened out' in Gaza amid warnings of severe mass starvation in the enclave. After opening his new golf course in Menie, Aberdeenshire, a reporter from the crowd asked the US President 'what will you say next to Benjamin Netanyahu', the prime minister of Israel. 'We're working together to try and get things straightened out,' Trump said. Earlier during his speech at the course, the US leader said he would fly back to the Washington to 'put out fires all over the world'. Getty Images President Donald Trump boards Air Force One bound for Scotland on July 25. Trump suggested he would reduce the 50-day deadline for Russia to agree to a ceasefire with Ukraine. The President said he was 'very disappointed' with Vladimir Putin. 'We thought we had that settled numerous times, and then President Putin goes out and starts launching rockets into some city like Kyiv and kills a lot of people in a nursing home or whatever,' Trump said. 'We're going to have to look and I'm going to reduce that 50 days that I gave him to a lesser number, because I think I already know the answer, what's going to happen.' Trump said Scotland has 'the ugliest windmills I've ever seen'. He said the 'ugly monsters' were 'destroying the beauty' of Scottish fields and waterways. 'Wind is a disaster,' Trump said, 'Wind is the most expensive form of energy. When we go to Aberdeen you'll see some of the ugliest windmills you've ever seen. 'They're the height of a 50-story building. You could take 1,000 times more energy from a hole in the ground. It's called oil and gas, and you have it in the North Sea.' Trump said he had restricted the construction of wind turbines in the United States because they 'kill all your birds', and he claimed that wind needs 'massive subsidy'. While in Scotland he also hit out at taxes on North Sea oil, saying the resource is a 'treasure chest for the United Kingdom'. 'Incentivize the drillers, fast. A vast fortune to be made for the UK, and far lower energy costs for the people,' he wrote on his Truth Social network. The President was also asked about his advice for dealing with the small boats crisis in the UK. 'If you are stopping the wrong people, my hats are off to you,' Trump said. The President said if the 'boats are loaded up with bad people, and they usually are because other countries don't send their best', then he said the UK is doing a 'fantastic' thing. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
BreakingNews.ie
4 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Donald Trump flies back to US after five-day visit to Scotland
Donald Trump has departed Scotland as his five-day visit comes to an end, with Air Force One taking off from RAF Lossiemouth in Moray. The US president concluded his trip by opening a new golf course at his resort in Menie, Aberdeenshire, on Tuesday morning. Advertisement After playing on the new course, he flew by helicopter to the RAF base. During his visit, he had earlier stayed at his other Scottish resort at Turnberry in South Ayrshire, where he enjoyed several rounds of golf. Despite the mostly private nature of the trip, he hosted Sir Keir Starmer at both resorts on Monday. EU Commission president Ursula von der Leyen also took part in a meeting with him at Turnberry on Sunday. Advertisement Mr Trump cut the ribbon to open his new course in Aberdeenshire on Tuesday morning (Jane Barlow/PA) As Mr Trump cut the ribbon on the new course in Aberdeenshire, he said he would play a quick round before returning to Washington to 'put out fires all over the world'. The US president teed off in front of an invited crowd including golfers, football stars, Scottish first minister John Swinney and Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar. Just before hitting the first ball at the New Course, the US president told those gathered on a grandstand: 'We started with a beautiful piece of land, but we made it much more beautiful.' Mr Trump added: 'I look forward to playing it today. Advertisement 'We'll play it very quickly and then I go back to DC and we put out fires all over the world. 'We did one yesterday – you know we stopped the war. We've stopped about five wars. 'That's much more important than playing golf. As much as I like it, it's much more important.' The president met first minister Mr Swinney on Monday evening at a private dinner, and the two had a more formal meeting on Tuesday ahead of the course opening. Advertisement This meeting focused on Scotch whisky tariffs and the situation in Gaza. During a lengthy media event alongside Mr Starmer on Monday, Mr Trump spoke of his 'great love' for Scotland and said he wanted to see the nation 'thrive'. A number of protests against the president's visit took place around Scotland during his time in the country. On Monday afternoon, a small number gathered in the nearby village of Balmedie in Aberdeenshire, sitting by the roadside and holding anti-Trump placards. Advertisement
