TDs call to end 'State-sanctioned cruelty' to badgers
It followed revelations by
The Journal Investigates
that
over 80% of badgers destroyed as part of the Department of Agriculture's TB eradication strategy
were free of the disease.
In a debate marking National Biodiversity Week, Jennifer Whitmore of the Social Democrats and People Before Profit's Paul Murphy both questioned the scientific basis of the killing programme and its impact on biodiversity commitments.
The Journal
/ YouTube
Speaking to Minister of State for Nature, Heritage and Biodiversity Christopher O'Sullivan, Whitmore highlighted contradictions at the heart of current policy.
'This matter is in the news at the moment. It is another instance where a species that is protected under the Wildlife Act is also being hunted or killed under that Act,' she said.
'The evidence is clear that the culling of badgers is not impacting on or reducing the incidence of bovine TB on farms.'
The TD added that while bovine TB outbreaks are having a 'devastating' effect on Irish farmers, 'we need to work with them to make sure that the solutions that are put forward are actually working'
'They are not working at the moment,' she added.
Advertisement
Social Democrats TD Jennifer Whitmore has called for an end to badger culling (File photo).
Alan Rowlette / RollingNews.ie
Alan Rowlette / RollingNews.ie / RollingNews.ie
Badger kills 'horrific'
Referencing
The Journal Investigate's
investigation, Murphy criticised the 'the ongoing slaughter of badgers by the Department of Agriculture.'
'The Department has killed more than 66,000 badgers in the past ten years. The way the badgers are killed is horrific.
'They are trapped in snares leading to internal organ damage, ruptured bladders and even disembowelment. This includes pregnant and lactating badgers, leaving their cubs to starve to death.'
The TD also referred to figures obtained by
The Journal Investigates
, which showed how more than 4,300 foxes were mistakenly snared in controversial Department of Agriculture, Food and Marine (DAFM) badger traps.
He added: 'According to opinion polls, in excess of two thirds of people in Ireland want it banned as well.
'England has promised to phase out killing badgers and replace it with a vaccination programme following scientific research that found that all the slaughter had no significant impact on bovine tuberculosis incidents in cattle.'
The Journal has contacted DAFM for comment on the TDs' remarks.
Referring to DAFM research indicating that vaccination is 'no less effective than culling', Murphy said the real cause of the country's bovine TB epidemic 'is not badgers,' but the expansion of industrial farming and larger dairy herds.
People Before Profit TD referred to the DAFM badger culling programme 'State-sponsored cruelty' (File photo).
Sasko Lazarov / RollingNews.ie
Sasko Lazarov / RollingNews.ie / RollingNews.ie
'State-sanctioned cruelty'
The People Before Profit politician also questioned the rationale behind the current culling policy.
He said: 'The Department of Agriculture admits that killing badgers is not sustainable in the long term due to its ultimate impact on badger ecology.
Related Reads
Over 80% of badgers culled in government TB programme found to be free from the disease
'It's the next worst thing to losing a family member': The toll of Ireland's bovine TB crisis
'It knows it does not work to control bovine tuberculosis.
Why on earth did it then slaughter more than 7,000 badgers last year, which was the highest number in a decade?
Concluding his statement, Murphy asked the Minister of State to if he would commit to ending the 'irrational, State-sanctioned cruelty and biodiversity destruction'.
On Wednesday,
The Journal Investigates
revealed that of the 10,301 badgers culled and tested in the last five years, 8,211 were found to be clear of mycobacterium bovis – the bacteria that causes bovine tuberculosis.
Figures obtained under Access to Information on the Environment also revealed how a total of 7,319 badgers were culled by DAFM in 2024 alone – the highest number recorded in the last 10 years.
In total, over 66,000 badgers have been destroyed since 2014, despite a 2018 government pledge to phase out the killings in favour of vaccination.
The investigation comes as Irish farmers continue to battle soaring TB rates on farms,
with many experiencing a huge financial and emotional toll
as a result.
—
Patricia Devlin is an investigative reporter with
The Journal Investigates
.
Our investigative unit is dedicated to lifting the lid on how Ireland works. This takes time and it takes resources. Find out how you can help:
Support The Journal Investigates
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
‘Families need action, not empty promises' – Cork senator criticises Fine Gael who have been in power for 13 years
In recent days, the Fine Gael TD for Cork North West John Paul O'Shea stated that all options must be looked at to make maternity leave pay better for women and families. Deputy O'Shea who is the Chair of the Oireachtas Social Protection committee said consideration must be given by the Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary to introduce a pay-related maternity benefit so those who only get the flat rate are appropriately compensated. Mr O'Shea said Ireland currently has a flat rate of €289 per week, leaving it up to employers to make up the difference. 'While the length of maternity leave in Ireland compares well with our European neighbours, clearly a change is needed to ensure Irish mothers are not at a financial disadvantage due to our flat rate system. 'By linking maternity benefit to earnings, families will be protected from financial constraints when an expectant mother is taking maternity leave. Women shouldn't have to worry about starting or growing their family for fear of a cliff-edge drop in income,' he added. Workers and self-employed individuals in the Republic of Ireland are entitled to a social welfare maternity benefit payment of €289 per week for 26 weeks. Some employers top up the entitlement. Sinn Féin senator Nicole Ryan however said families need action, not empty promises. 'Families in Cork are under enormous financial pressure with soaring housing costs, some of the highest childcare fees in the State and the rising cost of living. To then expect new mothers to survive on a flat rate maternity payment of €289 a week is simply not good enough.' Senator Ryan continued: 'It is all well and good for Deputy O'Shea to issue press releases, but Fine Gael has been in power for 13 years. If they were serious about supporting women and families, they would already have delivered a fair, pay-related maternity system. Mothers in Cork should not face a cliff-edge drop in income just for having children.' Senator Ryan said the reality is that women have been at a disadvantage from the very moment they find out they are pregnant. 'From the start of pregnancy, women are left worrying about whether their jobs will be secure, how time off will impact their career, or whether they can even afford to take their full entitlement. If they suffer an early loss, many are left without statutory protections, facing questions about employment gaps and forced to suffer in silence. This is discrimination against women for the simple fact that they are able to bring life into the world.' The Cork senator said she has personally brought forward a comprehensive Bill on early pregnancy loss, designed to give women and families the recognition, leave and protections they deserve. 'Instead of embracing it, both Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil voted to kick it down the road and delay it by a year. Do they really care about women's issues, or is it all just soundbites and empty promises?' 'Where is this so-called 'new energy' they promised in the last general election? Because for women and families, nothing has changed,' she added. 'What families need is action, not more promises,' said Senator Ryan. 'Sinn Féin will deliver proper, pay-related maternity benefit and ensure families in Cork and across Ireland get the support they deserve. It is long past time that women and families were treated with the dignity and fairness they are entitled to.'
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Carpet bomber or diplomatic hero? ‘Intellectual portrait' of Kissinger proves frustratingly lightweight
Jérémie Gallon's study of the controversial former US secretary of state is lively and provocative, but in its largely favourable view of Kissinger, it skims over uncomfortable questions Henry Kissinger had many admirers, but Michael D Higgins was not one of them. The former US secretary of state and future Irish president came face to face at a Trinity College Dublin guest lecture in 1999, Higgins asked Kissinger if he regretted his role in carpet-bombing parts of Southeast Asia during the Vietnam War, and was icily told: 'I cannot rise to the level of contrition you expect of me.' Jérémie Gallon's lively, provocative but frustratingly slight study of Kissinger claims he had precious little to apologise for. Not surprisingly, the man himself has already given it a glowing review. 'This book of yours is the most thoughtful that has ever been written about me,' he assured its author when the original French-language version was published in 2022, a year before his death aged 100. 'I believe you have truly understood me.'
Irish Examiner
10 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Irish Examiner view: Kneecap and the debate over free speech
Yesterday, Kneecap rapper Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh, better known by his stage name Mo Chara, was in court in London. He faces a terrorism charge for allegedly displaying a flag in support of Hezbollah at a gig in London last year. Kneecap have been in the spotlight for months because of their support for the Palestinian cause, and Ó hAnnaidh's latest court appearance attracted a huge amount of publicity, with hundreds present to support him as he entered Westminster magistrates' court. He is due back in court next month. The case has sparked much debate about free speech in general and the treatment of Kneecap in particular. Many pointed comparisons have been drawn between the band's treatment, for instance, and the laissez-faire attitude of the authorities in Northern Ireland recently when it came to sectarian displays around loyalist marches and bonfires. Kneecap are not the only Irish creatives facing the wrath of the British establishment, of course. It emerged this week that novelist Sally Rooney, a native of Mayo, could face arrest if she visits Britain for supporting Palestine Action, a proscribed organisation in the UK. Rooney has said she will continue to fund the organisation by using royalties from the televised versions of her books. This points up the essential absurdity of this legislation. Observers have noted that the BBC itself could be liable for prosecution if it continues to pay Rooney royalties, given she has declared her intentions to give the money to Palestine Action — yet the broadcaster would clearly be in breach of its contractual obligations if it withheld payment. The Kneecap and Sally Rooney cases can be seen as examples of judicial overreach and legislative incompetence respectively. Responding excessively to musicians' misbehaviour has been a feature of British justice going back to the Rolling Stones, while the consequences of laws enacted in haste have a far lengthier pedigree. However, it is also difficult to avoid the sense that the British establishment is focusing on Irish artists specifically here, with all that that implies. These cases will be watched very closely. Race for the Áras heats up A couple of days ago, we made the reasonable observation that the race for the Phoenix Park had not really caught fire, but then the old saw about a week being a long time in politics clicked into action. Early frontrunner Catherine Connolly has been learning what every presidential candidate learns soon enough — that throwing one's hat in the ring invites close scrutiny of one's track record. Ms Connolly's visit to Syria in 2018 has been widely publicised, for instance, as have some contradictory comments she made about our Defence Forces last weekend. Another candidate has had to do some fire fighting of his own in recent days, again, because of the focus on his past. Gareth Sheridan's emergence caught the headlines given his youth and freshness, but as recently as last weekend, he had to backtrack on how much revenue his company generates, while this newspaper has reported on fines levied on that company by the US government. Yet the real blood sport has been in Fine Gael in recent days, with the coalition partners scrambling to find an alternative to Mairead McGuinness, their fancied candidate, who dropped out of the race last week. Former minister Heather Humphreys was the warm favourite to replace McGuinness at the time of writing, though MEP Seán Kelly, another possibility, was remaining positive about his chances. Still, he appears destined for the role played by Albert Reynolds in 1997 — the runner-up forced to put on a brave face. If Humphreys succeeds, as expected, Fine Gael will have an experienced politician in the running, though her CV will surely be inspected with the same rigour as the other participants. Of course, Fianna Fáil has not yet picked someone for the race, and given its track record of success in presidential elections there will be considerable interest in its preferred candidate. Will it be an eminence grise like Bertie Ahern, a celebrity candidate out of left field, or a serving minister? Attention is well and truly focused on the race now. Child's play The schools are reopening, with all that that entails, from new stationery to battered school bags. For many readers with children of primary school age, an entirely new accessory may feature on many back-to-school shopping lists: The Labubu doll. For any readers not familiar with them, these are small furry dolls, which have been taken up by celebrities such as David Beckham and Rihanna. They are the perfect size to be attached to a schoolbag, but the manufacturers, seeing how popular they are with children and young people, are believed to be working on an even smaller model that can be hooked up to a mobile phone. Pop Mart, the Chinese company responsible for the Labubu, is doing very well — it is on track to meet its targeted revenue goal for 2025 of €2.4bn and its CEO stated recently that reaching €3.6bn should be 'quite easy'. The company's net profit has soared by approximately 400% in the last year. The bad news is that demand for the dolls is so high that harassed parents may struggle to find the genuine article — last month some dolls were recalled from a shop in Wexford amid concerns that they were not genuine, for instance. Parents who recall the fads of yesteryear may feel a little grateful that they only had to deal with the likes of the fidget spinner.
