Editorial: Science Council of Japan must not become government tool
The Science Council of Japan is a representative organization of scientists dedicated to the pursuit of the truth. It must not become a government tool.
A law has been passed to turn the Science Council of Japan from a special organization operating independently of the government into a special corporate entity, effective October 2026. There remain concerns that the operational independence of the council could be threatened. It is only natural that the council and academic organizations across Japan have joined in calling for the legislation to be amended or repealed.
With the transition, a new mechanism of government oversight has been included, whereby auditors and evaluation committee members appointed by the prime minister will review the council's activity plans and operations.
If the government interferes with policy proposals or research directions, academic freedom will be shaken.
Government influence may also extend to the selection of members when the new organization is launched. Experts appointed by the prime minister will be included in the committee responsible for selecting members.
It will also become possible to dismiss members in the science council's general meetings. Manabu Sakai, the minister of state for special missions in the Cabinet Office, stated in the Diet that dismissal could occur if "specific ideologies or partisan claims are repeatedly made." If political opinions become grounds for dismissal, there is a risk of infringing on freedom of thought and belief.
In the first place, reform of the council stemmed from government intervention in personnel decisions. In 2020, a problem erupted over then Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga's refusal to appoint six people to the science council. Without explaining the reasons, the government proceeded with an organizational review as if to reproach the council for its opposition; an act that invited distrust.
The Science Council of Japan was established as a response to the fact that many scientists were coerced into cooperating with the government and military during World War II.
In 1950 and 1967, the council issued statements that it would not engage in research for war or military purposes. In 2017, it similarly expressed a cautious stance toward government-promoted research with potential military applications and has repeatedly made recommendations from an independent position.
The government's argument is that "to spend government funds, a certain level of involvement is necessary." But if the new organization panders to the government or is used to endorse government policies, questions will be raised about its very existence. Its international reputation will also suffer.
Academic freedom and its results are foundational supports for the interests of humanity. The council cannot fulfill its role as an academy providing scientific views as long as there is room for political intervention.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
6 hours ago
Return of Stink Bugs Adds to Japan's Rice Woes
Japan Data The resurgence of a major rice pest is a headache for growers in Japan. The 'rice stink bug' (inekamemushi), a brown insect about 12 to 13 millimeters long, is an avid consumer of rice. The insect sucks the nutrients out of rice plants, hindering development and blackening the grains, which can make it impossible to ship harvested rice to retailers. Grains of rice damaged by rice stink bugs. (Courtesy the Ibaraki Prefectural Agricultural Research Center) A survey of rice stink bugs was conducted by the Saitama Prefectural Pest and Disease Control Center from November 2024 to March 2025. The results confirmed overwintering of stink bugs at 100 of 172 locations in the prefecture, or 58.1%. It also found 17.1 bugs per square meter, which is 43 times higher than the 0.4 bugs per square meter noted in the survey for the previous year. An official at the center said, 'Even based on our impressions while conducting the survey, it seemed clear that the number of bugs had increased.' Interviews with prefectural governments conducted by the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries confirmed the existence of rice stink bugs in 37 prefectures in 2024. The other 10 prefectures where the bugs were not found are mainly located in northern Japan, including Hokkaidō, Aomori, and Iwate Prefectures. According to MAFF, the rice stink bug, which was considered one of the three major pests threatening rice after World War II, decreased in number sharply from around the 1960s as a result of effective pesticides and the earlier planting of rice. At one point, it was even thought that the species may have gone extinct. However, the combination of climate change and the cultivation of rice varieties with different growing periods has led to an increase in rice stink bugs in recent years. (Translated from Japanese. Banner photo: A rice stink bug feasting on a rice plant. Courtesy the Saitama Prefectural Pest and Disease Control Center.)
Yomiuri Shimbun
8 hours ago
- Yomiuri Shimbun
Japan Should Avoid Solely Relying on U.S., Engage in Global Diplomacy; Strong Ties with Like-Minded Nations is Vital
The Yomiuri Shimbun Shotaro Yachi Shotaro Yachi, former secretary general of the National Security Secretariat, said in an interview with The Yomiuri Shimbun that Japan should not rely solely on the United States, but instead increasingly reach out to build stronger ties with other like-minded nations. The following is excerpted from Yachi's remarks in an interview conducted by Yomiuri Shimbun Staff Writer Yuta Abe. *** Tariffs have been used as a tool intended to resolve trade and economic disputes since the 19th century. The international community became divided into economic blocks through the imposition of high tariffs during the period between World War I and World War II. We must deal with contemporary problems by learning lessons from those bitter experiences. Japan has constantly championed free trade. Continuing the free flow of trade will also benefit nations around the world. During negotiations with the United States over its tariff measures, adopting an approach of seeking respite [from the levies] only for Japan is not the way to go. Japan has been instrumental in the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership and the Trans-Pacific Partnership, from which the United States has pulled out. Many nations feel they could be left in a tight spot unless Japan exercises leadership in the political and economic realms. It should be possible to search for areas of cooperation between TPP member nations and the European Union. With regard to the United States, sincerely dealing with issues raised by President Donald Trump will be crucial. This means not sidestepping these issues or attempting to divert attention to other matters. Instead, Japan must face up to these issues head-on and directly explain Japan's position and circumstances. Trump likes making deals and prizes tangible benefits, so Japan will need to conduct sensible discussions grounded in reality. Take, for instance, the purchase of defense equipment from the United States. Japan should not take up this idea simply to eliminate the trade deficit. Buying such hardware from the United States during the process of strengthening Japan's defense capabilities might, in the end, become a useful bargaining chip to some extent, but our thinking must be that we purchase items Japan needs. The nation's contribution to the cost of stationing U.S. military forces in Japan is already above the international standard. In a bid to bolster Japan's defense capabilities, the government plans to increase its expenditure on security-related costs, including defense spending, to 2% of gross domestic product. Even if the nation ultimately exceeds that figure, it should not initially set out to reach 3% as a given, as some officials in the U.S. government have demanded. The United States still possesses the world's most powerful military and strongest economy. However, it is undeniable that other countries will start to catch up, and U.S. national power and international standing is declining in relative terms. The United States also might have grown tired of providing a giant market for other countries and shouldering the burden of defending those nations. As we look at the international situation, Japan should not stick to the conventional 'U.S.-centric approach' that assumed everything would be fine provided it stayed on good terms with Washington. Instead, Japan needs to start reaching out more to other nations. While the premise that the Japan-U.S. alliance remains the foundation of Japan's diplomacy remains, it is vital that Japan builds strong relations with like-minded European nations, Australia, India, members of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and countries of the Global South. This would be in line with the 'diplomacy with a global perspective' advocated by the cabinet of former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. Shotaro Yachi Yachi, 81, completed his master's degree at the University of Tokyo. He joined the Foreign Ministry in 1969 and held posts including head of the Foreign Policy Bureau and vice foreign minister before being appointed as the first secretary general of the National Security Secretariat, an entity launched in 2014 during the second administration of former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. He held that role until 2019. Yachi currently is chairman of the Fujitsu Future Studies Center think tank.
14 hours ago
Return of Stink Bugs Add to Japan's Rice Woes
Japan Data The resurgence of a major rice pest is a headache for growers in Japan. The 'rice stink bug' (inekamemushi), a brown insect about 12 to 13 millimeters long, is an avid consumer of rice. The insect sucks the nutrients out of rice plants, hindering development and blackening the grains, which can make it impossible to ship harvested rice to retailers. Grains of rice damaged by rice stink bugs. (Courtesy the Ibaraki Prefectural Agricultural Research Center) A survey of rice stink bugs was conducted by the Saitama Prefectural Pest and Disease Control Center from November 2024 to March 2025. The results confirmed overwintering of stink bugs at 100 of 172 locations in the prefecture, or 58.1%. It also found 17.1 bugs per square meter, which is 43 times higher than the 0.4 bugs per square meter noted in the survey for the previous year. An official at the center said, 'Even based on our impressions while conducting the survey, it seemed clear that the number of bugs had increased.' Interviews with prefectural governments conducted by the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries confirmed the existence of rice stink bugs in 37 prefectures in 2024. The other 10 prefectures where the bugs were not found are mainly located in northern Japan, including Hokkaidō, Aomori, and Iwate Prefectures. According to MAFF, the rice stink bug, which was considered one of the three major pests threatening rice after World War II, decreased in number sharply from around the 1960s as a result of effective pesticides and the earlier planting of rice. At one point, it was even thought that the species may have gone extinct. However, the combination of climate change and the cultivation of rice varieties with different growing periods has led to an increase in rice stink bugs in recent years. (Translated from Japanese. Banner photo: A rice stink bug feasting on a rice plant. Courtesy the Saitama Prefectural Pest and Disease Control Center.)
